No. We are all born/conceived with a sinful nature that we inherited from our father Adam. That is why ALL die. The blood of Christ is sufficient for all and babies are included in this. They will be redeemed. They cannot be condemned for unbelief because they are unable to do so.
This is just one of the problems with the Calvinist position. You have babies going to hell because they were not "chosen".
No. You are placing words into my argument. God may have chosen them, that is His business and He doesn't really let us know who He chooses or doesn't choose. We do know that God elects people to salvation -- that is very clear in Scripture. What we do not know (before we see fruitful evidence) is whom it is that He elects. In the case of infants, we cannot see fruitful evidences for all the same reasons you are using to argue that God will bring all of them to Himself -- they cannot speak for themselves.
You seem to be coming at the gospel from an Arminian position, and that is fine. Many do. But I think that you have a bigger problem with the salvation of infants that I do coming from a more Calvinistic perspective. In the Arminian position, one must come to God with one's faith. Personal actions (which you argue children do not have) are the driving force behind salvation. You make a special case for children because they cannot be in "unbelief" but to that I would suggest that neither then can they "believe." If they cannot do one, they cannot do the other, which means that they are still hopelessly trapped in their original death-causing sin.
Perhaps at that point, God's merciful election is the more sure and gracious position, even though on its face it may seem more "out of our hands." Salvation IS out of our hands. We merely accept the free gifts given by an always good God.
As I said above, I am not immune to this argument. I have lost one son shortly after childbirth and my oldest son has just been diagnosed with PLS and likely will not be able to live out a full life. I care very deeply about what God may or may not do and I have dedicated my life to the gospel for many reasons, some of which surround my own ignorance at the time of the death of my second son earlier.
I am a North American missionary and pastor because God has called me (and my heart totally agrees!) to tell others about the good news of Jesus Christ. I do so because I am assured by God in His Word that wherever I go with the gospel people will respond. If I had to depend on man's arguments, that would be a most miserable task, but I see people who, like me, are drawn by God and who are Spirit-led into a salvific experience.
Simply saying something like, "
This is just one of the problems with the Calvinist position. You have babies going to hell because they were not "chosen." is cold-hearted and does not match the Scriptures in any way, shape, or form. Nothing could be further from the truth -- of the Calvinist position or of the Bible.