• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Faith # 7

LaGrange

Active Member
PART 2

You have not demonstrated that faith causes justification. You have only repeated that faith has an instrumental role.

There is a difference between receiving or apprehending something and causing that thing to exist.

Romans 5:9 says we are justified by Christ's blood, and verse 10 says we were reconciled to God by the death of His Son. Christ actually accomplished redemption. Faith does not go back and complete the work of the Cross.

That is why I distinguish the Legal, Vital, and Practical Phases: Christ accomplished the Legal work; the Spirit gives life; the regenerated sinner believes. Faith is necessary as the Practical response, but it is not the cause of Christ's Legal accomplishment.

My Comment: You said: “You have not demonstrated that faith causes justification”.

I think you misunderstood what I was saying. I was talking about Calvin’s causes. I was assuming you believed the same thing - that faith causes justification.

In my original list of Calvin’s causes, I listed at the bottom (post #91):
Material Cause - Imputed Righteousness (Christ’s Righteousness that’s in Christ only)

I know you put down “Christ and His obedience” as the material Cause but then Calvin says “through which he acquired righteousness for us.” Couldn’t that mean “Christ’s imputed righteousness”? I was guessing and that’s why I put it at the bottom. If you added that on to the material cause, wouldn’t that be what you are looking for that we receive = imputed righteousness?

We don’t believe Faith is a cause of justification (see above). To us, Faith does not cause or merit justification. To us, Christ caused justification and merited everything from full regeneration through forensic justification for us. To us, Faith (Act of Faith) merits the reward (Heb 11:6). Faith does not cause the reward either and that’s why we say the act of faith merits the reward.

I think the rest of you statements I answered above.

You are assuming that Titus 3:5 teaches water baptism simply because Paul uses the language of washing.

The passage says God saved us according to His mercy, “by the washing of regeneration, and renewing of the Holy Ghost.” Paul identifies God's mercy and the renewing work of the Spirit. He does not identify water baptism as the efficient cause of regeneration.

My Comment: Using your logic, nowhere does it say the effectual call saves you. Again, baptism is not the efficient cause.

If you look at my last post (#89) where I list the five catholic causes of justification, baptism is the “instrumental cause” and NOT the “efficient cause”. Maybe you didn’t mean to say that. I do use Titus 3:5 to prove baptism because the “washing” or “laver” points to the “instrumental cause” of baptism. (Also 1 Pet 3:21 - Baptism now saves you…) It doesn’t say the “effectual call” saves you.

Ephesians 2:4–5 makes the point even clearer: God, rich in mercy, quickened us when we were dead in sins. God gives life to the dead. That is the work of divine mercy.


My Comment: Eph 2:5 = Baptism (Eph 2:5 = cross reference to Col 2:12-13 = uses the term “baptism”). Baptism is the instrumental cause.

I am not arguing that a believer's subjective comfort never fluctuates. Assurance can certainly weaken through sin. But that does not change the objective ground of his acceptance with God.


My Comment: In my last post, in the next sentence, I said that was probably what you meant.

James 2:19 says even devils believe there is one God and tremble. James is exposing empty profession without the fruits of spiritual life. He is not teaching that a regenerate person loses charity through mortal sin while retaining a saving faith.


My Comment: I don’t think I should have used this verse because faith after a christian commits a mortal sin doesn’t cause him to lose his faith, he loses charity. So his faith is not dead. Aquinas says the virtue of faith can exist apart from charity (STh., I-II q.65 a.4).

Faith does not create Christ's righteousness or make His blood effective. Faith apprehends and rests upon what Christ has accomplished.


My Comment: Ok. But faith is still a cause. You said it wasn’t. I moved this to the beginning and answered it.

Again, to us, Faith is not a cause of justification. It’s an effect of regeneration and, to us, when it is in an act, merits the reward (Heb 11:6).I answered this above but I think Christ’s imputed righteousness is in Calvin’s causes. I think Calvin listed it as the material cause? I listed that one below Calvin’s other five causes because I wasn’t sure if I was right. I guess it would have to be there. There are five or six causes. Nothing wrong with that.

You are confusing outward circumstances and common operations of grace with regeneration.

An unregenerate person might attend church because of upbringing, conscience, religious fear, family influence, habit, or social relationships. Church attendance does not prove that someone has received a preparatory spiritual disposition toward God.

I am not denying God's providence, restraint of sin, or the outward call of the Gospel. I am distinguishing those things from the inward impartation of spiritual life.

My Comment: Calling precedes Justification (Rom 8:30). There is only one calling listed under Rom 8:30. God calls in different ways. Calling is drawing. If a man is in church, God is calling him. Actually, God had to be calling him before he got to church to move him willingly to go to church. This is aided by actual grace (prevenient grace). You are not saved by it but you are being prepared by it. Trent also called these graces “preparatory graces” or ”stimulating” graces (Council of Trent, Session VI, Ch V & VI (Denz 797-798).
 

LaGrange

Active Member
PART 3

Romans 8:7 says the carnal mind is enmity against God and “is not subject to the law of God, neither indeed can be.” First Corinthians 2:14 says the natural man does not receive the things of the Spirit of God and cannot know them because they are spiritually discerned.

You cannot simply insert a developing spiritual disposition into those passages and call it prevenient grace. You must establish that doctrine from Scripture.


My Comment: I answered this at the very end of post #91. This is about preparation AFTER justification in the period you call sanctification. Preparation occurs both before the effectual call and after. Rom 8 is after you become a Christian. If you look at the catholic view under the thread “The Golden Chain…” and look at the catholic view flowchart, you will see we call this period the “justification process” rather than the “sanctification process”*. Preparation by God takes place there too. This is preparation for election to glory.

* Sanctification is not one of the steps listed in Rom 8:30

Consider the passages you supplied:

  • Amos 4:12 is a warning of judgment, not a teaching about preparatory grace.
  • 1 Samuel 7:3 calls Israel to return to the Lord; it does not explain the origin of spiritual ability.
  • Lamentations 5:21 actually asks God, “Turn thou us unto thee, O LORD, and we shall be turned.”
  • Zechariah 1:3 is a call to repentance and a promise of God's favor, not proof of an independently supplied human ability.
  • Ephesians 2:10 says God prepared good works for His people to walk in, not that He prepares unregenerate sinners to regenerate themselves.
  • Romans 9:23 speaks of God preparing vessels of mercy unto glory.
These passages do not establish the doctrine of prevenient grace in the sense you are using it.


My Comment: Whether it’s a nation or an individual it doesn’t matter. These verses show how God uses prevenience grace.

Amos 4:12 - Yes, God is warning that He may punish them. Prevenient Grace draws us. God is always drawing us. Aquinas says there are different kinds of drawing and one kind of drawing is “withdrawing”. One place he speaks about this is in Rom 9:17-18. When a nation or man habitually wants to sin, God sometimes withdraws His grace and “permits” the man or nation to sin for awhile. God then punishes them for that sin. Scholastic theology teaches that grace prevents sin but it does not prevent free Will. It establishes free Will. We can still choose to sin. So if we choose to sin, God honors that and withdraws His grace. By punishing them He is preparing them for repentance. So the punishment is a preparation. Punishment in this world is always medicinal.

1 Sam 7:3 - the verse says God commands “turn to me” which cannot be done except by Prevenient Grace. Then God says if you prepare your hearts (aided by prevenient grace), then “He will deliver you”.

Lam 5:21 - how do they ask God to turn to them? By the aid of prevenient grace. Our conversion to God is preceded by the help of God.

Zech 1:3 - man can move by his will (turn to God) with the aid of grace. This grace precedes his will. Remember: prevenient grace is present before, during (at the point of) and after you become a Christian (full regeneration)

Eph 2:10 - grace prepares us to do good works (this is AFTER we become a Christian)

Rom 9:23 - this is preparation for election to glory AFTER you are a Christian during the sanctification process = the potter and the clay continues (It’s on my flowchart).

I agree that believers obey. The question is whether their obedience is an independent contribution that determines whether God's saving purpose succeeds.

Philippians 2:13 says:

“For it is God which worketh in you both to will and to do of his good pleasure.”

God works not merely to make obedience possible, but both to will and to do. That is the difference between grace that merely assists the human will and grace that renews the will so that the believer willingly obeys.

My Comment: The believer’s obedience is never a total independent contribution. There is always Prevenient grace present to assist the Will to prepare and to believe.

God worketh in YOU both to Will (frees the Will) and to do (believe). This can be applied before, during and after you become a Christian.

Here it is at baptism when you become a Christian at the effectual call:

God worketh in YOU both to Will (gives you the ability to Will freely by charity) and to do [Act of Faith = willingly come (turn) to Christ and away (turn) from sin].

If you look at the catholic view in the thread: The Golden Chain…”, look in the notes section and you will see what we call the “Order of Justification”. You will see two actual graces (Prevenient graces) I say are in tandem. The first one perfects the Will (operative) and the second one moves the Will (and we move ourselves = belief) toward Christ and away from sin (cooperative). This is Phil 2:13.
 

LaGrange

Active Member
POST #94 PART 1

This interpretation reverses the point of the passage.

Lazarus was not lying in the tomb alive, waiting for a preparatory process. He had been dead four days. Martha even said:

“Lord, by this time he stinketh: for he hath been dead four days.” (John 11:39)

Jesus then cried, “Lazarus, come forth” (v. 43), and Lazarus came forth.

You have inserted stages into the account that John never gives us. Where does John say Lazarus first sat up, then stood, exercised faith, and received life through a sacrament of penance? He says none of those things.

My Comment: My view doesn’t reverse the view of the passage. He had been dead for four days and chances are great that he was lying down. When Jesus called him, at that point, I’m sure he was still lying down. So when Jesus called him while he was lying down, he “heard” the Lord’s “Call”. Hearing is not enough to be fully regenerated. You must hear, see and walk. He was not healed until he came out. Notice: Jesus didn’t enter the tomb, He called Lazarus. In order for Lazarus to come out, he had to hear, see and walk. This is the Act of Faith. When he willingly came to Christ, his sins (bandages) were removed.

The grave clothes were removed after Lazarus came forth. They did not give him life. The account demonstrates Christ's authority over death, not baptismal regeneration or sacramental penance.


My Comment: The whole process gave him life. When Christ called him, if he did not obey and come out, his sins would not have been removed. Removal of the sins was an effect of the sacrament of penance because Christ forgave his sins.

Again, you are turning details of a historical account into sacramental symbols without showing that John intended them that way.

John records that Mary and Martha sent for Jesus, that the stone was removed, and that Jesus prayed to the Father. But he never says these things represent preparatory grace, the church imparting life, or Martha's faith being applied to Lazarus.

Jesus explains His public prayer in John 11:40–42: it was so those standing by might believe that the Father had sent Him. Your allegorical interpretation goes beyond what the text says.


My Comment: I want to make two final points on the raising of Lazarus:

1. Allegorical - My interpretation is an allegorical interpretation but your interpretation is allegorical too. You probably don’t think of it that way because you are so use to using it as an example to prove monergism and to prove there is no preparation. Nowhere in John 11 does Jesus say that His intention was to teach monergism. If you think about it, all it says is that Jesus raised Lazarus from the dead. That’s it. It doesn’t say anything about preparation or monergism.

2. Hearing & Faith - If you interpret this raising of Lazarus as an example to prove monergism, then you would have to agree that Lazarus didn’t need to hear (internally or externally) or need to have Faith either. It doesn’t mention either one. It doesn’t mention preparation, hearing or Faith.

You are assuming the very point you need to prove.

Ephesians 2:4–5 says God, because of His mercy and love, quickened us together with Christ when we were dead in sins. God is the subject; the spiritually dead are the recipients.

Colossians 2:12 says we are risen with Christ “through the faith of the operation of God, who hath raised him from the dead.” Paul identifies God's operation as the power behind this resurrection.


My Comment: Yes, it’s God’s power behind the resurrection. And by believing in it we share in it and by the first part of the verse ties it to baptism: “Buried with him in baptism: in whom also you are risen again…” As a Aquinas says, “Baptism is the sacrament of faith” (STh., III q.66 a.1 ad 1).

The passage connects baptism with union with Christ, but it does not establish that water baptism is the efficient cause of regeneration.

My Comment: Water Baptism is the instrumental cause and not the efficient cause. God’s mercy is the efficient cause.

Water Baptism is shown in Rom 5:5: And hope confoundeth not: because the charity of God is poured forth IN our hearts, by the Holy Ghost who is given to us.

The Holy Ghost dwells in our hearts by Charity (STh., I-II q.68 a.5).

“Poured” = infused - see Titus 3:6 Whom he hath poured forth upon us abundantly, through Jesus Christ our Saviour:
Rom 5:5 - Poured IN our hearts means that it “Inheres” (Inheres seen here: also 2 Pet 1:4 - Partaker of the divine nature).

This shows that the “washing” in Titus 3:5 and “pouring” (Titus 3:6) which I connected with Col 2:12, is this “pouring” (infused) IN of the Holy Ghost (Rom 5:5). This is the pouring IN of the water. John 19:34 says “ But one of the soldiers with a spear opened his side: and immediately there came out blood and WATER.” The power of baptismal regeneration is signified by the “Water” that flowed from Christ’s side, however, at baptism, the pouring IN is sanctifying Grace [Charity (G26)]. By the way, the vessel has to be fully prepared before it will hold the water.
 

LaGrange

Active Member
POST #94 PART 2

You are confusing Paul's description of the flesh with his exhortation to believers who are no longer in the flesh.

Romans 8:7–8 says the carnal mind is enmity against God, is not subject to God's law, and cannot please God. Then verse 9 says:

“But ye are not in the flesh, but in the Spirit, if so be that the Spirit of God dwell in you.”

Paul contrasts those in the flesh with those in whom the Spirit dwells. He does not describe the natural man as gradually developing a spiritual disposition through prevenient grace.

My Comment: Why would Paul tell believers about this contrast? It’s because they can still act according to the flesh. Just because you are a Christian doesn’t mean you quit sinning or that it doesn’t matter. It matters. We must persevere. Is perseverance a result or period or is it a virtue? The “natural man” is simply defining human nature (the clay in Rom 9:21). Human nature has an inclination to sin so Paul was warning them. You can lose your inheritance (ex: Eph 5:5, 1 Cor 6:11, Heb 12:16-17).

Yes, believers must mortify sin. Romans 8:13 says they do so “through the Spirit.” Their activity is real, but it is dependent upon the Spirit's power.


My Comment: We agree. It’s through the Spirit because Rom 8 it is AFTER you become a Christian. Why though? If you are one of the elect, don’t Calvinists believe that you can never commit serious sin ever again? Can an elect person commit adultery or steal? You will probably say that he can’t or won’t. If a man thinks he is one of the elect and way later in life falls into serious sin, does this mean he was wrong about his election? He guessed wrong. It that it? I say this only because this is why we must continue to prepare with God’s Grace. Mortification is part of perseverance. Perseverance is part of preparation. Also, confessing sin is too. That spiritual power comes through the instrumental cause of the sacrament of Penance (aka Confession). Jesus instituted it here (John 20:19-23). Without it we don’t go to heaven (1 Cor 6:9-10, Gal 5:4, Eph 5:5).

Likewise, Romans 8:17 teaches that believers suffer with Christ and shall be glorified with Him. It does not make glorification dependent upon an independent human contribution.


My Comment: When you say “independent human contribution” you never mention grace. You are arguing against something we don’t believe or teach. I have said many times that preparation does not save - baptism does. Preparation is for living the faith after you become a Christian. All these things done during preparation, after we are a Christian, with God’s Grace, help prevent us from falling away. During preparation, after you are a Christian, is also where we merit more rewards with our Faith in this life and the next (Heb 11).

Read Romans 8:29–30. Paul presents God's unbroken purpose: those He foreknew, predestinated, called, and justified, He also glorified. The final outcome does not rest upon a human will that grace merely assists.

My Comment: We agree. The final outcome is when God elects us to glorification. There are steps there in Rom 8:29-30 for a reason. You are elected to each one when God sees fit - after He prepares you. During this preparation is where you can resist.

You are replacing Paul's actual description with an interpretation that does not fit the context.

Paul says:

“But the natural man receiveth not the things of the Spirit of God: for they are foolishness unto him: neither can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned.”

The Greek word translated “natural” is psychikos. Paul contrasts the natural person with the spiritual person. His point is not merely that someone puts worldly things first. He says the natural man cannot receive or know the things of the Spirit.

A Christian can certainly behave carnally. In 1 Corinthians 3:1 Paul calls the Corinthians carnal and babes in Christ. But that does not make them the same as the natural man in 1 Corinthians 2:14. Jude 19 also describes natural or sensual people as “having not the Spirit.”


My Comment: I disagree. Aquinas doesn’t divide it so it applies to a Christian man too (STh., II-II q.46 a.2 resp). You are dividing something that shouldn’t be divided.

1 Cor 3:1 and 1 Cor 2:14 It’s saying the same thing because it can be the same person even AFTER you are a Christian. You can have that dullness in judgement. It’s a disposition. So, you are always subject to being the carnal man like Paul says. In his letter, he’s addressing the Corinthian church.

Here is the fundamental issue, Lagrange:

You speak of grace, but repeatedly make it a preparatory assistance that must be cooperated with before God can bring about the saving result.

I believe something different. God gives life. God renews the heart. God works in His people both to will and to do. Consequently, they believe, repent, obey, and persevere.

I am not denying the believer's activity. I am denying that his activity is the independent originating cause of spiritual life or the determining factor that makes Christ's redemption effective.

The question is not whether the believer believes, repents, obeys, and perseveres. The question is whether these things originate in God's effectual work or in a human will that grace merely prepares and assists.

My Comment: We never would say “ a believer’s activity is the independent originating cause of spiritual life or the determining factor that makes Christ's redemption effective” because we believe grace always must be there.

The central problem between us is this:

Even at the point of the effectual call, and we say at baptism, WITH GOD’S GRACE, something in man must move “willingly” inside himself to turn to God and away from sin. Otherwise, at the effectual call,

God is moving Himself to believe in (turn to) Himself and turning away from sin.

Think about that. I know it’s absurd but that’s what you are promoting theologically. This is the logical conclusion of the “God does it all” mentality. This is how you see “Necessary Works” after regeneration too. “Necessary” is a philosophical and theological term which means “necessity”. This means you have one choice. That means “God does it all” meaning, really, without a true willingness coming from you. He just does it through you. It’s not a true willingness. Also, this means that if you sin, after becoming a Christian, this work (sin) is God’s fault because he didn’t give you the grace to avoid it.

Calvinism is so afraid of Pelagianism that it goes too far the other way in error. The Catholic Church condemned Pelagianism in 418ad at the Council of Carthage , and other condemnations around that time, and Semi-Pelagianism in 529ad at the Council of Orange. Even knowing this, Turretin and Calvin knew there was an Act of Faith. This Act of Faith was something man did with God’s irresistible grace. Turretin said that man comes to God willingly but, in my opinion, it’s not a true free Will. You and more modern Calvinists seem to even deny that. You want to say “Act of God” today. Here’s a couple of questions:

At the point of the effectual call:
Does man have to come to Christ?
Does man have to come “willingly”?

We know Christ comes to man. That seems to be all modern-day Calvinists want to think about.
 

LaGrange

Active Member
POST #95 PART 1

Lagrange said:

Look closely at the contradiction you just wrote: you admit "Total inability, yes, due to original sin," yet in the same breath you claim "we are not totally depraved" because we have a conscience and natural virtues!


My Comment: Inability doesn’t mean you are totally corrupt. That’s a metaphor. It simply means we cannot reach God by natural means. That would be pelagianism. We need grace. The first graces we receive is Prevenient Grace. We are called internally by that grace.

Not totally corrupt

I’ve heard Calvinists talk about depravity. They traditionally made total depravity sound like you can’t do anything right or do anything with the right motive (Rom 14:23). That attitude has to be changed. God created each of us. That alone should tell you something. He gave us a conscience and the virtues. The conscience is what guided man before the law of Moses. God intervened sometimes. The natural law became corrupt when societies began being formed. When the population grew. They developed national laws together from the natural law to govern them. THAT IS WHAT BECAME CORRUPT. Not our individual consciences that we were born with. The punishment was the Flood and the Dispersement after the Tower of Babel. They received the Law of Faith and Circumcision through Abraham. Eventually they received the Law of God through the Law of Moses, in part, to help keep correct the natural law. Each person was still required to follow their natural consciences especially if you were a gentile and not part of the Israelites.

You misunderstand Total Depravity. Total depravity does not mean fallen men have no natural conscience (Romans 2:15) or cannot perform outward civic kindnesses. It means every faculty of the soul—mind, will, affections, and conscience—is corrupted by sin and void of spiritual life (Titus 1:15). A natural conscience accuses and excuses a sinner under the law; it never produces spiritual love for God or prepares a corpse for heaven.

My Comment: And thus enters Prevenient Grace first.

You completely invert Romans 9. Calling Romans 9 a chapter about "human preparation" turns Paul's entire argument upside down! In Romans 9:11–18, Paul explicitly excludes all human willing, running, and preparing: "So then it is not of him that willeth, nor of him that runneth, but of God that sheweth mercy" (v. 16). Esau and Jacob did zero preparation in the womb before God unconditionally elected Jacob in the Eternal Phase (Romans 9:11–13).


My Comment: I know it turns it upside down for you but not for me. God does the preparation and we do either the obeying or resisting. It’s the potter and the clay.

Revelation 3:20 and James 4:8 are addressed to believers, not unregenerate corpses. Revelation 3:20 is spoken to the church at Laodicea, and James 4:8 is written to "my beloved brethren" (James 1:16)—people already quickened in the Vital Phase who are being called to obedience in the Practical Phase. Neither verse teaches "prevenient grace" given to unregenerate sinners.


My Comment: You really should look at my flowchart. You’ll see preparation before and AFTER you are regenerated. This is the practical phase here, I guess.

  1. Practical Phase. Neither verse teaches "prevenient grace" given to unregenerate sinners.

I do not build my faith on Augustine or any fallible church father; Scripture alone is our final authority. Yet even here, you misread Augustine! Notice he says God anticipates us "that we may be healed"—referring to God's sovereign Vital Phase quickening (healing the dead soul first), followed by subsequent grace in the Practical Phase ("that being healed we may grow healthy and strong"). Augustine was arguing against Pelagian human preparation, not supporting Trent's sacramental ladder!


My Comment: I know you don’t. Your final authority is your own interpretation of the Bible.

We don’t misread Augustine. “Anticipates us” means “prevents us” (Ps 59:10) which is Prevenient Grace.

Assuming John 3:5 means water baptism is pure circular reasoning. Jesus was rebuking Nicodemus, a master of Israel, for not knowing Old Testament Scripture (John 3:10). Where does the Old Testament speak of being born of water and the Spirit? In Ezekiel 36:25–27:

"Then will I sprinkle clean water upon you, and ye shall be clean... A new heart also will I give you, and a new spirit will I put within you."

Water in John 3:5 is the Old Testament symbol of the cleansing Word and Spirit of God (Ephesians 5:26; Titus 3:5)—not a Christian water ceremony that hadn't even been instituted yet! And as for Acts 2:38, the Greek preposition eis ("for" the remission of sins) regularly means "because of" or "with reference to" (just as in Matthew 12:41, where Nineveh repented eis—"at" or because of—the preaching of Jonah). Peter was commanding convicted sinners to repent and be baptized on the basis of the remission of sins Christ had already secured in the Legal Phase.


My Comment: As it says in 1 Cor 10:6,11, Col 2:17, this OT quote (Ezek 36:25-27) is a prophecy or prefigurement of water baptism; not full regeneration out of the blue. It doesn’t say this is the effectual call either.

Look at what your own explanation of 1 Peter 3:21 just proved: you admit a candidate must already possess "faith and a true repentance" and "a good conscience" before coming to water baptism!

My Comment: You skipped the first part of the verse: “Whereunto baptism, being of the like form, now saveth you…” We must come with the dispositions of faith and true repentance BEFORE baptism (entering in the ark = the church) and your sins removed (washed away by the waters of the flood). A disposition of Faith and repentance is different from the virtue of faith and repentance. A disposition in the Will has not been perfected by Charity into a virtue, which doesn’t occur until baptism. By the way, when Peter mentions something in the second half of a verse, that doesn’t mean it didn’t occur first or before the first half.

Where did that faith, repentance, and clean conscience come from? According to Scripture, faith is the fruit of the Spirit (Galatians 5:22), repentance is granted by God (2 Timothy 2:25), and a clean heart is a sovereign creation of God in the Vital Phase (Psalm 51:10; 1 John 5:1). If a person already has living faith, true repentance, and a good conscience before touching the water, he is ALREADY regenerated! Water baptism in the Practical Phase is the outward pledge and confession of a soul already made alive—not the cause of his new birth.

My Comment: NO. I understand what you are saying. It doesn’t say “living Faith” in those verses. Repentance is a disposition; not a fruit. It says “examination” of a good conscience. This is also a disposition. 1 Pet 3:20 says Noah “Prepared” the ark before souls entered it, likewise, this preparation is figurative of these dispositions. THEN you enter the ark by baptism. Fruits don’t occur until after regeneration. Faith and other virtues in a work, through charity, produce fruit.
 

LaGrange

Active Member
POST #95 PART 2
Lagrange said:

Paul was a bishop and his main office was to teach but he could baptize (Matt 28:19). It was usually the office of the priest or deacon to baptize (1 Cor 1:17) I see what the main problem is with baptism. You think pouring water is all that is happening. There are five causes and all 5 of these causes happen simultaneously at baptism... [Council of Trent, Session VI, Ch VII, Denz 799 (1528)]
Think about the absurdity of what you just said about Paul in 1 Corinthians 1:17: "For Christ sent me not to baptize, but to preach the gospel."

If water baptism were truly the Instrumental Cause through which God regenerates and justifies sinners, then Paul would literally be saying, "Christ sent me not to regenerate or justify anyone, but merely to preach!" Every apostle and evangelist in the New Testament would have prioritized water baptism above preaching if baptism were the instrument of justification. Instead, Paul thanked God he baptized almost none of the Corinthians (1 Corinthians 1:14) because the Gospel itself is the power of God unto salvation (Romans 1:16)—calling out those whom the Spirit quickens in the Vital Phase.

My Comment: No. I don’t consider it an absurdity at all. Your logic doesn’t hold. It’s a great thought though. It’s easy to baptize but hard to keep the unity of Faith through the office of teaching. For example, look at all the Protestant denominations. So it may seem backwards but it’s not. Also, if you don’t preach or teach the gospel, there’s no one to prepare for baptism.

As for the Council of Trent, quoting Trent's Aristotelian causes only exposes how far Rome has departed from the Gospel. Trent explicitly anathematizes anyone who believes we are justified by Christ's imputed righteousness alone without inherent "sanctifying grace" infused through sacraments. Yet Romans 4:5–6 declares that God "justifieth the ungodly" and "imputeth righteousness without works." Justification is a legal declaration in heaven's court (Phase II: The Legal Phase), not an internal infusion of grace poured into the soul via a priest's water ritual.

My Comment: It’s because of your definition of imputed righteousness. Your definition of “Imputed righteousness” is really “no righteousness”. I don’t think you are saved by “no righteousness”. If the righteousness is in Christ and not in you, then you don’t have it! It’s not in you anymore than in the non-elect. The best term for impute is “confer”. That means you really have it. It Inheres. The grace you receive at baptism Inheres, that is, it’s in you, you possess it and it’s your inheritance (Rom 8:17). We see the following verses as all related to the grace received at baptism as our inheritance (2 Pet 1:4, Heb 2:14, Eph 1:14, 2 Cor 1:22). We inherit original sin from Adam & Eve (Rom 5:12-21) (STh., I-II q.81 a.1). That means sin is really in us. Do you agree with that? Or is sin imputed? Likewise, we inherit grace from the second Adam, Jesus Christ (Eph 5:5, 1 Cor 6:10) and it’s really in us.

Look at that admission: "God decides when we are prepared and then elects us to justification through baptism."
That directly overthrows Ephesians 1:4, which declares that God "hath chosen us in him before the foundation of the world"—not after observing how well we cooperated with "actual grace" prior to water baptism!


My Comment: Not really. God elects everyone to grace before the foundation of the world because He loves us and then He prepares graces for all of us. That’s predestination (Love- election - predestination). You are trying to make election a one-time event for only the few. Preparation from man’s point of view, is about not resisting God’s grace and being formed. You say “not after observing how well we cooperated with ‘actual Grace’ prior to water baptism!” He is not looking at what we do as works before baptism. That’s what you make is sound like. Works can’t even come in to play until baptism. The common grace period is really preparation but you just won’t admit it. The Arminians know it. There is only one call in Rom 8:30.

In God's Five Phases of Salvation, there is no uncertain "dark gap" where a sinner is half-alive, cooperating with actual grace while still under condemnation, hoping to make it to a baptismal font before dying:


My Comment: Your description of the “dark gap” is incorrect. The sinner is not half alive. We don’t believe in partial regeneration. He is being formed before birth which means he’s unformed. The forming is imperfect until birth. This forming is preparation.

The Eternal Phase: Unconditional election before time (Ephesians 1:4; Romans 9:11).


My Comment: We disagree with the Calvinist idea of unconditional election because it is tied to only some people. We would say it’s unconditional election for all men before time if you mean election to grace. It’s unconditional election for all men during the time of the calling. Then it’s conditional election to justification and glorification, each independently, according to preparation.

The Legal Phase: Full, finished justification accomplished at Calvary by Christ's blood (Romans 5:9).

My Comment: Christ’s death is the meritorious cause of justification so I guess you are saying it is then applied to the elect at the effectual call. If it is only possible to apply to “some” people and not all, then it is wrong. Christ redeemed the whole human race and not just the elect (2 Cor 5:14-15).

The Vital Phase: Sovereign, instantaneous regeneration by the Holy Spirit alone, without water or human works (John 3:8; Titus 3:5).


My Comment: We don’t teach works before baptism. Grace precedes works. It’s is not presenting the catholic understanding correctly to just say “regeneration by the Holy Spirit alone, without water” because I’ve shown you the five causes of justification and that baptism is the instrumental cause. Your quote makes it look like “water” has to save us all by itself.

The Practical Phase: Faith, repentance, and water baptism as the obedient walk of an already-regenerated child of God (Acts 8:36–37; Ephesians 2:10).


My Comment: There really is no practical phase that is necessary if you believe in unconditional election, limited atonement and necessary works. Doesn’t really matter. It’s a done deal. The thing I hear over and over again from all Protestants, and you mentioned this earlier, is their lack of assurance. You claim absolute assurance boldly in front of everybody but you are always looking for “evidence” to see if you or others are of the elect. “Evidence” of sin might prove you are not one of the elect. Always questioning yourself. Very unconvincing doctrine. When I confess my sins in the sacrament of Penance, I never think about them again. It’s miraculous. It works!

  1. The Final Phase: Bodily resurrection and eternal glorification (Romans 8:30).
Christ's blood alone justifies, the Spirit alone regenerates, and no priest, water, or preparatory gap stands between God's elect and their Savior.

My Comment: already answered many times.
 

Brightfame52

Well-Known Member


Lagrange said:
Before I say anything on the causes, and as I’ve already said in previous posts, I don’t understand the Calvinist causes or system perfectly. I am trying very hard to understand it correctly.
...
What would you put in the place of the instrumental or formal cause if it’s not Faith?
I appreciate your candid, thoughtful engagement. Since you asked directly what I put in place of the formal and instrumental causes of justification, here is the exact biblical answer—keeping it concise:
  1. In forensic justification, the "Formal Cause" is the Imputed Righteousness of Christ—NEVER human faith!
    • Even classic Reformed theologians like Francis Turretin (Institutes, Topic 16, Q. 2 & Q. 7) explicitly reject making faith the formal cause of justification (because making a human virtue the formal cause of justification is Rome's error!). Turretin teaches that the formal cause of justification—the exact thing by which God pronounces a sinner righteous—is the imputed obedience and blood of Jesus Christ alone (Romans 5:9, 19; 2 Corinthians 5:21).
    • In my Five Phases of Salvation, God's forensic act of justification was accomplished in Phase II (The Legal Phase) by Christ's blood and obedience alone, grounded in Phase I (The Eternal Phase)—without needing human faith as an instrumental cause to make God's verdict happen!
  2. What, then, is the role of Faith? Faith is the evidence and subjective receiver—not the cause of our legal justification!
    • You asked why I said "Faith apprehends and rests upon what Christ has accomplished" if I deny faith is an instrumental cause of justification. There is a clear difference between causing something to exist and receiving/enjoying something that already exists!
    • Think of a bank deposit made on your behalf while you were unaware: the deposit is already legally yours before you ever look at the receipt. Reading the receipt does not put the money in the bank—it apprehends what is already there so you can rest in it!
    • In Phase III (The Vital Phase — Regeneration), the Holy Spirit unilaterally imparts spiritual life (John 3:6–8; Ephesians 2:5), and in Phase IV (The Practical Phase — Conversion), the Gospel calls forth that Spirit-wrought faith to apprehend, seek, and rest in the justification Christ already secured at Calvary (Romans 5:1, 11; 2 Timothy 1:10—"hath brought life and immortality to light through the gospel").
Lagrange said:
This below might sound more like what you believe:
Website: Fort Wayne Primitive Baptist Church, Section: Beliefs...
In this case, Regeneration and hearing the gospel are separate. There would be no connection between the two. I have to admit that I was astounded when I read this.
That quote from the Primitive Baptist statement is very close to what I believe regarding regeneration (Phase III: The Vital Phase), with one key clarification:
  1. Regeneration (imparting spiritual life) is immediate by the Spirit without gospel instrumentality—because a dead corpse cannot hear!
    • Just as Lazarus had to be made alive by Christ's voice before he could hear, walk, or understand anything (John 11:43–44), a sinner dead in trespasses and sins (Ephesians 2:1) must be unilaterally quickened by the Holy Spirit in Phase III (The Vital Phase) before he can spiritually hear or believe the Gospel (1 Corinthians 2:14; 1 John 5:1). Consider elect infants who die in infancy: they are regenerated by the Spirit without ever hearing the preached Gospel!
  2. Yet there IS a vital connection between Regeneration and the Gospel in Phase IV (The Practical Phase — Conversion)!
    • The preached Gospel does not give dead sinners spiritual life—rather, the Gospel brings to light the life and salvation Christ already purchased, feeding, enlightening, and converting the newborn child of God so he consciously trusts Christ (2 Timothy 1:10; 1 Peter 2:2). Regeneration gives spiritual life; the Gospel brings conscious conversion and assurance!
Lagrange said:
My Opinion:
Justification is still forensic because grace does not Inhere. You are declared righteous. Christ’s righteousness is imputed. So that doesn’t change.
We would say Faith should not be a cause of justification. Faith is an effect. Faith isn’t a cause of anything. Faith is there but it is there as a virtue used to merit the reward in the act of Faith. Faith has to be there for the “Act of faith” because, through it, we must come to Christ “willingly”, but it is not the cause of anything.
Notice the fatal contradiction in those last two sentences:
  • First you say: "Christ's righteousness is imputed... Faith isn't a cause of anything."
  • Then immediately you say: "Faith is there as a virtue used to merit the reward in the act of Faith."
  • Look at Romans 4:4–5 and Romans 11:6: "Now to him that worketh is the reward not reckoned of grace, but of debt. But to him that worketh not, but believeth on him that justifieth the ungodly, his faith is counted for righteousness."
  • The moment you call faith "a virtue used to merit the reward," you have turned faith into a meritorious human work—which destroys grace and denies that Christ's righteousness alone is our sole merit before God! True saving faith renounces all human merit and rests 100% in the merit of Christ's blood and obedience alone (Philippians 3:8–9).
 

Brightfame52

Well-Known Member
Lagrange said:
I know you put down “Christ and His obedience” as the material Cause but then Calvin says “through which he acquired righteousness for us.” Couldn’t that mean “Christ’s imputed righteousness”? I was guessing and that’s why I put it at the bottom. If you added that on to the material cause, wouldn’t that be what you are looking for that we receive = imputed righteousness?

Yes—that is the exact heart of the Gospel! When Calvin says "Christ, with his obedience, through which he acquired righteousness for us" is the material cause, he means Christ's active and passive obedience imputed to His elect (Romans 5:19; 2 Corinthians 5:21).
  • In Phase II (The Legal Phase), Christ's blood and righteousness are the sole ground and matter of our justification before God's Law—100% outside of us in Christ!
  • And notice why calling faith "meriting the reward" (Hebrews 11:6) contradicts Romans 4:4–5:
    "4 Now to him that worketh is the reward not reckoned of grace, but of debt. 5 But to him that worketh not, but believeth on him that justifieth the ungodly, his faith is counted for righteousness."
  • In Hebrews 11:6, God is the "rewarder of them that diligently seek him" purely of grace—never because human faith "merits" anything! Christ alone merited every blessing of salvation for His elect (Phase II: The Legal Phase), and God-given faith (Philippians 1:29) simply receives that unmerited grace (Romans 4:16: "Therefore it is of faith, that it might be by grace").
Lagrange said:
If you look at my last post (#89) where I list the five catholic causes of justification, baptism is the “instrumental cause” and NOT the “efficient cause”. Maybe you didn’t mean to say that. I do use Titus 3:5 to prove baptism because the “washing” or “laver” points to the “instrumental cause” of baptism. (Also 1 Pet 3:21 - Baptism now saves you…) It doesn’t say the “effectual call” saves you.

Look closely at both Titus 3:5 and 1 Peter 3:21—neither passage teaches that water baptism is the instrumental cause of regeneration or justification:
  1. Titus 3:5 defines the washing right in the text: "by the washing of regeneration, and renewing of the Holy Ghost." The washing is the Spirit's internal regenerating work (Phase III: The Vital Phase — Ezekiel 36:25–27), which water baptism only symbolizes outwardly!
  2. 1 Peter 3:21 explicitly stops readers from turning water into an instrumental cause of salvation:
    "The like figure whereunto even baptism doth also now save us (not the putting away of the filth of the flesh, but the answer of a good conscience toward God,) by the resurrection of Jesus Christ:"
    • Notice Peter calls baptism "the like figure" (antitypon—a symbol/representation), explicitly excludes the physical water ("not the putting away of the filth of the flesh"), and anchors our salvation strictly in "the resurrection of Jesus Christ" (Phase II: The Legal Phase — Romans 4:25)!
  3. And Scripture explicitly says God's sovereign calling saves us—without water!
    "Who hath saved us, and called us with an holy calling, not according to our works, but according to his own purpose and grace, which was given us in Christ Jesus before the world began," (2 Timothy 1:9)
Lagrange said:
Eph 2:5 = Baptism (Eph 2:5 = cross reference to Col 2:12-13 = uses the term “baptism”). Baptism is the instrumental cause.

Read Colossians 2:11–13 in full—it explicitly defines which baptism is in view, and it is spiritual, inward circumcision made without hands, NOT water baptism!

"11 In whom also ye are circumcised with the circumcision made without hands, in putting off the body of the sins of the flesh by the circumcision of Christ: 12 Buried with him in baptism, wherein also ye are risen with him through the faith of the operation of God, who hath raised him from the dead." (Colossians 2:11–12)
Notice the phrase "made without hands" (acheiropoiētō)! Water baptism is performed with human hands by a minister; the baptism that unites us to Christ's death and resurrection in Phase II (The Legal Phase) and quickens us in Phase III (The Vital Phase) is the Spirit's inward, regenerating baptism "made without hands" (1 Corinthians 12:13)!

Lagrange said:
I don’t think I should have used this verse because faith after a christian commits a mortal sin doesn’t cause him to lose his faith, he loses charity. So his faith is not dead. Aquinas says the virtue of faith can exist apart from charity (STh., I-II q.65 a.4).

Scripture flatly contradicts Aquinas on this point!
  • Galatians 5:6: "For in Jesus Christ neither circumcision availeth any thing, nor uncircumcision; but faith which worketh by love [charity]."
  • 1 John 3:14: "We know that we have passed from death unto life, because we love the brethren. He that loveth not his brother abideth in death."
  • James 2:26: "For as the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without works is dead also."
True saving faith—imparted by the Holy Spirit in Phase III (The Vital Phase)—is a living union with Christ that always works by love (Galatians 5:6; 1 John 5:1–4). A "faith" devoid of love is not genuine saving faith temporarily missing charity; it is dead, unregenerate assent (James 2:19)! And no true child of God whom Christ justified in Phase II (The Legal Phase) and regenerated in Phase III can ever fall back into spiritual death (John 5:24; John 10:28–29; 1 John 3:9).

Lagrange said:
Calling precedes Justification (Rom 8:30). There is only one calling listed under Rom 8:30. God calls in different ways. Calling is drawing. If a man is in church, God is calling him. Actually, God had to be calling him before he got to church to move him willingly to go to church. This is aided by actual grace (prevenient grace). You are not saved by it but you are being prepared by it. Trent also called these graces “preparatory graces” or ”stimulating” graces (Council of Trent, Session VI, Ch V & VI (Denz 797-798).

Look at the exact Greek text and unbreakable chain of Romans 8:30—it destroys Trent's theory of non-saving "preparatory graces"!

"Moreover whom he did predestinate, them he also called: and whom he called, them he also justified: and whom he called, them he also glorified." (Romans 8:30)
  1. Every single person "called" in Romans 8:30 is 100% predestinated, 100% justified, and 100% glorified!
    • If "called" in Romans 8:30 meant general providence or "actual grace" given to churchgoers who later fall away and perish, then Paul's chain would break! Instead, 100% of those called in Romans 8:30 are glorified—proving this is God's sovereign, effectual call (Phase III: The Vital Phase — Regeneration) given exclusively to the predestinated elect (Phase I: The Eternal Phase)!
  2. Why does Paul list "called" before "justified" in Romans 8:30?
    • Because Phase II (The Legal Phase)—our objective justification by Christ's blood at Calvary (Romans 5:9)—already stood accomplished in Christ before we were born, and in Phase III (The Vital Phase) God's effectual call brings us out of spiritual death so that in Phase IV (The Practical Phase) we experience that justification by faith (Romans 5:1)!
    • God does not send "preparatory graces" to dead corpses asking them to prepare themselves for life; He speaks life into the dead (John 5:25; Ephesians 2:5) and brings every single chosen soul infallibly to glory!
 

Brightfame52

Well-Known Member
LaGrange said:
Rom 8 is after you become a Christian. If you look at the catholic view under the thread “The Golden Chain…” and look at the catholic view flowchart, you will see we call this period the “justification process” rather than the “sanctification process”*. Preparation by God takes place there too. This is preparation for election to glory.
Sanctification is not one of the steps listed in Rom 8:30
  1. You misread Romans 8:7–9! Look at Romans 8:9: "But ye are not in the flesh, but in the Spirit, if so be that the Spirit of God dwell in you. Now if any man have not the Spirit of Christ, he is none of his." Paul explicitly defines "in the flesh" (vv. 7–8) as anyone who does not have the Spirit of Christ dwelling in him—that is, an unregenerate sinner! And Paul declares that such a person "is not subject to the law of God, neither indeed can be. So then they that are in the flesh cannot please God." He cannot prepare himself for justification or election to glory because he has zero spiritual ability to please God prior to regeneration (Phase III: The Vital Phase).
  2. Furthermore, election is NOT a future prize you "prepare for" during a "justification process"—election happened BEFORE the foundation of the world!
    • Ephesians 1:4: "According as he hath chosen us in him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and without blame before him in love:"
    • 2 Thessalonians 2:13: "God hath from the beginning chosen you to salvation through sanctification of the Spirit and belief of the truth:"
    • Notice that sanctification of the Spirit (Phase III & Phase IV) is the fruit of eternal election (Phase I), never a human preparation to earn election to glory! And sanctification is already included in Romans 8:29–30 ("predestinate to be conformed to the image of his Son... glorified").
LaGrange said:
Amos 4:12 - Yes, God is warning that He may punish them. Prevenient Grace draws us. God is always drawing us. Aquinas says there are different kinds of drawing and one kind of drawing is “withdrawing”... By punishing them He is preparing them for repentance. So the punishment is a preparation. Punishment in this world is always medicinal.
  1. You are reading Thomas Aquinas into Amos 4:12, not reading what the Bible actually says!
    • Look at Amos 4:6–12: five times God says "yet have ye not returned unto me, saith the LORD," and then concludes in verse 12: "Therefore thus will I do unto thee, O Israel: and because I will do this unto thee, prepare to meet thy God, O Israel."
    • That is a judicial summons to face God's wrath in judgment—not "medicinal prevenient grace"! And claiming "punishment in this world is always medicinal" directly contradicts Romans 9:17–18, 22, where God hardened Pharaoh to show His power and endured "vessels of wrath fitted to destruction"!
  2. Look at 1 Samuel 7:3, Lamentations 5:21, and Zechariah 1:3:
    • Notice you had to insert the words "(aided by prevenient grace)" in parentheses into every single verse because none of those verses mention "prevenient grace"!
    • In Lamentations 5:21 ("Turn thou us unto thee, O LORD, and we shall be turned"), the prophet confesses that man cannot turn himself unless God turns him first—proving monergistic regeneration (Phase III: The Vital Phase), not cooperative "prevenient grace"!
LaGrange said:
God worketh in YOU both to Will (frees the Will) and to do (believe). This can be applied before, during and after you become a Christian.
Here it is at baptism when you become a Christian at the effectual call:
God worketh in YOU both to Will (gives you the ability to Will freely by charity) and to do [Act of Faith = willingly come (turn) to Christ and away (turn) from sin]... You will see two actual graces (Prevenient graces) I say are in tandem. The first one perfects the Will (operative) and the second one moves the Will (and we move ourselves = belief) toward Christ and away from sin (cooperative). This is Phil 2:13.
  1. Read Philippians 1:1 and 2:12–13 to see who "YOU" is in Philippians 2:13!
    • Paul is writing "to all the saints in Christ Jesus which are at Philippi" (Philippians 1:1)—people who are already regenerated and justified believers, NOT unregenerate sinners at water baptism!
  2. Look at the exact words of Philippians 2:13:
    "For it is God which worketh in you both to will and to do of his good pleasure."
    • Notice Paul does not say God merely "frees the will" or offers a "cooperative grace" where "we move ourselves." Paul says God Himself works in His regenerated people BOTH the willing AND the doing!
    • When God regenerates His elect in Phase III (The Vital Phase)—entirely apart from water baptism (1 Corinthians 1:17; John 3:6–8)—He gives them a brand-new heart (Ezekiel 36:26–27), and then in Phase IV (The Practical Phase) He infallibly works in them both to will and to do His good pleasure!
Summary: Scripture knows nothing of a "justification process" where unregenerate sinners cooperate with "preparatory graces" to merit election to glory. Chosen in Phase I (The Eternal Phase), justified in full by Christ's blood in Phase II (The Legal Phase), and quickened from death in Phase III (The Vital Phase), God's elect believe and obey in Phase IV (The Practical Phase) because God works in them both to will and to do!

The Roman Catholic Doctrines are Heresy !
 

Brightfame52

Well-Known Member
LaGrange said:
My view doesn’t reverse the view of the passage. He had been dead for four days and chances are great that he was lying down. When Jesus called him, at that point, I’m sure he was still lying down. So when Jesus called him while he was lying down, he “heard” the Lord’s “Call”. Hearing is not enough to be fully regenerated. You must hear, see and walk. He was not healed until he came out... When he willingly came to Christ, his sins (bandages) were removed... Removal of the sins was an effect of the sacrament of penance because Christ forgave his sins.

Look closely at the timeline of John 11:43–44—you have reversed life and movement:
  1. A dead corpse cannot hear, see, or walk until AFTER it has already been given life!
    • Lazarus had been dead for four days (John 11:39). Dead ears do not hear; dead legs do not walk.
    • When Jesus cried, "Lazarus, come forth" (v. 43), Christ's creative voice immediately imparted life to Lazarus first, and because Lazarus was now alive, he came forth (v. 44)! Lazarus did not walk out of the tomb in order to get life—he walked out because he was already alive!
  2. And notice how your allegorical scheme collapses on itself:
    • You say Lazarus's grave clothes were "sins" removed by "the sacrament of penance" after he came out. Yet Jesus never heard Lazarus confess a single sin, never assigned him penance, and never absolved him in a confessional! Jesus simply commanded the bystanders, "Loose him, and let him go" (v. 44).
    • Reading Roman Catholic penance into Lazarus's grave clothes is pure eisegesis—imposing a post-apostolic sacramental system onto a narrative that never mentions it.
LaGrange said:
  1. Allegorical - My interpretation is an allegorical interpretation but your interpretation is allegorical too... Nowhere in John 11 does Jesus say that His intention was to teach monergism...
  2. Hearing & Faith - If you interpret this raising of Lazarus as an example to prove monergism, then you would have to agree that Lazarus didn’t need to hear (internally or externally) or need to have Faith either.
  1. I am NOT making an allegory out of John 11—Jesus Himself explicitly connected physical resurrection to spiritual regeneration in John 5:25!
    "Verily, verily, I say unto you, The hour is coming, and now is, when the dead shall hear the voice of the Son of God: and they that hear shall live." (John 5:25)
    • Notice that! Jesus says "and now is"—speaking of spiritual resurrection right now in the Gospel age (Phase III: The Vital Phase — Regeneration)! Just as the physically dead in the grave (John 5:28) do not cooperate to raise themselves, the spiritually dead in sin (Ephesians 2:1, 5) do not cooperate to regenerate themselves—the voice of the Son of God gives them life!
  2. And your second point proves my exact distinction between Phase III (The Vital Phase) and Phase IV (The Practical Phase):
    • Lazarus needed zero faith to be made alive—because dead men cannot believe! Likewise, in Phase III (The Vital Phase), God unilaterally quickens dead sinners without human faith as a prerequisite (Ephesians 2:5; 1 John 5:1).
    • Once Lazarus was made alive, he heard, saw, and walked out to Christ—just as once a sinner is regenerated in Phase III, he hears the Gospel, believes, and comes to Christ in Phase IV (The Practical Phase) (John 6:45)!
LaGrange said:
Water Baptism is shown in Rom 5:5: And hope confoundeth not: because the charity of God is poured forth IN our hearts, by the Holy Ghost who is given to us... This shows that the “washing” in Titus 3:5 and “pouring” (Titus 3:6) which I connected with Col 2:12, is this “pouring” (infused) IN of the Holy Ghost (Rom 5:5). This is the pouring IN of the water... By the way, the vessel has to be fully prepared before it will hold the water.

Look at how you just turned the Holy Spirit Himself into water baptism—a leap that flatly contradicts Scripture:
  1. In Romans 5:5 and Titus 3:5–6, what is "poured out"? THE HOLY GHOST—not water!
    • Read Titus 3:5–6 word for word: "by the washing of regeneration, and renewing of the Holy Ghost; Which he shed [poured] on us abundantly through Jesus Christ our Saviour."
    • Read Romans 5:5 word for word: "because the love of God is shed abroad [poured out] in our hearts by the Holy Ghost which is given unto us."
    • Notice that water is never mentioned in either passage! Turning the outpouring of the Holy Spirit into a literal splash of water baptism confuses the sign (water) with the Substance (the Holy Spirit).
  2. Look at Acts 10:44–48—which completely refutes your claim that the Spirit is poured out at water baptism after the vessel prepares itself:
    "44 While Peter yet spake these words, the Holy Ghost fell on all them which heard the word... 47 Can any man forbid water, that these should not be baptized, which have received the Holy Ghost as well as we?" (Acts 10:44, 47)
    • Cornelius and his household received the Holy Ghost and saving faith BEFORE a single drop of water ever touched them!
    • And look at your closing line: "By the way, the vessel has to be fully prepared before it will hold the water." That directly contradicts Romans 9:21–23, where God—the Sovereign Potter—makes the vessel Himself out of dead clay, and Ephesians 2:1, 5, where God quickens us "even when we were dead in sins"—not when we were "prepared vessels"!
Lazarus did not walk out of the tomb to earn life, and Cornelius did not get baptized in water to receive the Holy Spirit: Christ gives life to the dead by His sovereign power alone (Phase III), and living faith follows as its guaranteed fruit (Phase IV).
 

Armchair Apologist

Well-Known Member
Ascetic X, your mocking rewrite of Christ’s preaching doesn't expose a flaw in my theology; it only exposes your complete ignorance of the purpose of God's commands and the redemptive-historical timeline of the Gospels. You are suffering from the ancient Pelagian delusion that just because God commands a sinner to do something, the sinner must automatically possess the natural free-will power to perform it.
Let's look at the raw data of the text and apply sound biblical theology to completely flatten your conditional timeline:
  1. You Completely Misunderstand Christ’s Audience and Purpose: You look at Mark 1:15—"repent ye, and believe the gospel"—and blindly assume this was a universal offer to every single human being proving universal human ability. You are dead wrong. Christ’s earthly preaching of the Kingdom was strictly and primarily restricted to the lost sheep of the house of Israel (Matthew 15:24).Furthermore, Christ knew exactly who was sitting in His audience, and He was not offering a free-will gamble to everyone. John the Baptist explicitly confronted the false religious leaders, demanding they "Bring forth therefore fruits meet for repentance" (Matthew 3:8) because he knew their natural hearts were corrupt.Christ Himself did not preach a message of potential free-will salvation to the reprobate leaders. In Matthew 23:32-33, He looked at the religious elites and commanded them: "Fill ye up then the measure of your fathers. Ye serpents, ye generation of vipers, how can ye escape the damnation of hell?" Christ did not invite them to use their willpower to get saved; He judicially commanded them to fulfill their wayward, wicked course to destruction! God’s commands to the reprobate do not prove their ability; they seal their condemnation. The saving command to repent and believe is an efficacious voice meant exclusively to arrest and gather His lost sheep, whom the Father sovereignly draws.
  2. You Completely Fled From Philippians 1:29: You didn't even attempt to touch the premier verse I put right in front of your face. Paul declares explicitly: "For unto you it is GIVEN in the behalf of Christ, not only to believe on him, but also to suffer for his sake."The Greek word for "given" here is charizomai, which means to bestow as a favor or an act of pure grace. Paul states point-blank that the actual act of believing is a gift given to the elect for the sake of Christ—because of what Christ legally accomplished at the cross 2,000 years ago! Faith is a blood-bought benefit of the covenant, legally earned by Christ and sovereignly applied to His sheep. It does not originate in the factory of your natural willpower. By claiming that unsaved people can just choose to believe on their own, you are stripping Christ of His glory and making man the author of his own faith.
  3. The Father's Drawing is Efficacious (John 6:44, 65): You claim the Father draws souls, but "each person still has to believe." You are turning the Father's drawing into a weak, conditional tug-of-war that man can easily defeat. But look at the text! Christ says, "No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him: and I will raise him up at the last day."The drawing and the final resurrection are bound together in an unbreakable chain! Everyone who is drawn is raised up. The drawing is not a vague, universal invitation; it is an efficacious, sovereign operation of grace. And why do they come? Because verse 65 says it is "given unto him of my Father." The Father doesn't just put an offer on the table and wait for your free-will permission; He crushes the heart of stone, gives a heart of flesh, and sovereignly causes His elect to walk in His statutes (Ezekiel 36:26-27). The faith is the immediate, living breath of a soul that has already been quickened by divine power.
Your system presents a defeated savior who begs dead serpents to walk, but lacks the power to actually give his sheep life unless they help him out with their free will. My Bible presents a Triune God who commands repentance externally through the Word, judicially hardens the reprobate in the sins they freely love, and sovereignly creates saving faith internally in His elect vessels of mercy by the power of the Holy Spirit. [1]
Stop trying to turn a divine command into human ability. Answer the words on the page, Ascetic X: If Christ explicitly commanded the generation of vipers to fill up the measure of their sins unto damnation (Matthew 23:32-33), how can you claim His commands prove universal free-will ability?


Sir, we likely agree on many things but such arrogance and belittling of those who disagree is completely unneccessary and counterproductive!

Arminians, provisionists, non-Calvinists, and rabid anti-Calvinists often misrepresent the Calvinist view in efforts to "Score points for their team" but Calvinists are often equally guilty with slanderous accusations of semi-pelagianism or whatever if someone does not affirm the "Five Points" to your liking or satisfaction! Please check yourself.
 
Top