PART 2
My Comment: You said: “You have not demonstrated that faith causes justification”.
I think you misunderstood what I was saying. I was talking about Calvin’s causes. I was assuming you believed the same thing - that faith causes justification.
In my original list of Calvin’s causes, I listed at the bottom (post #91):
Material Cause - Imputed Righteousness (Christ’s Righteousness that’s in Christ only)
I know you put down “Christ and His obedience” as the material Cause but then Calvin says “through which he acquired righteousness for us.” Couldn’t that mean “Christ’s imputed righteousness”? I was guessing and that’s why I put it at the bottom. If you added that on to the material cause, wouldn’t that be what you are looking for that we receive = imputed righteousness?
We don’t believe Faith is a cause of justification (see above). To us, Faith does not cause or merit justification. To us, Christ caused justification and merited everything from full regeneration through forensic justification for us. To us, Faith (Act of Faith) merits the reward (Heb 11:6). Faith does not cause the reward either and that’s why we say the act of faith merits the reward.
I think the rest of you statements I answered above.
My Comment: Using your logic, nowhere does it say the effectual call saves you. Again, baptism is not the efficient cause.
If you look at my last post (#89) where I list the five catholic causes of justification, baptism is the “instrumental cause” and NOT the “efficient cause”. Maybe you didn’t mean to say that. I do use Titus 3:5 to prove baptism because the “washing” or “laver” points to the “instrumental cause” of baptism. (Also 1 Pet 3:21 - Baptism now saves you…) It doesn’t say the “effectual call” saves you.
My Comment: Eph 2:5 = Baptism (Eph 2:5 = cross reference to Col 2:12-13 = uses the term “baptism”). Baptism is the instrumental cause.
My Comment: In my last post, in the next sentence, I said that was probably what you meant.
My Comment: I don’t think I should have used this verse because faith after a christian commits a mortal sin doesn’t cause him to lose his faith, he loses charity. So his faith is not dead. Aquinas says the virtue of faith can exist apart from charity (STh., I-II q.65 a.4).
My Comment: Ok. But faith is still a cause. You said it wasn’t. I moved this to the beginning and answered it.
Again, to us, Faith is not a cause of justification. It’s an effect of regeneration and, to us, when it is in an act, merits the reward (Heb 11:6).I answered this above but I think Christ’s imputed righteousness is in Calvin’s causes. I think Calvin listed it as the material cause? I listed that one below Calvin’s other five causes because I wasn’t sure if I was right. I guess it would have to be there. There are five or six causes. Nothing wrong with that.
My Comment: Calling precedes Justification (Rom 8:30). There is only one calling listed under Rom 8:30. God calls in different ways. Calling is drawing. If a man is in church, God is calling him. Actually, God had to be calling him before he got to church to move him willingly to go to church. This is aided by actual grace (prevenient grace). You are not saved by it but you are being prepared by it. Trent also called these graces “preparatory graces” or ”stimulating” graces (Council of Trent, Session VI, Ch V & VI (Denz 797-798).
You have not demonstrated that faith causes justification. You have only repeated that faith has an instrumental role.
There is a difference between receiving or apprehending something and causing that thing to exist.
Romans 5:9 says we are justified by Christ's blood, and verse 10 says we were reconciled to God by the death of His Son. Christ actually accomplished redemption. Faith does not go back and complete the work of the Cross.
That is why I distinguish the Legal, Vital, and Practical Phases: Christ accomplished the Legal work; the Spirit gives life; the regenerated sinner believes. Faith is necessary as the Practical response, but it is not the cause of Christ's Legal accomplishment.
My Comment: You said: “You have not demonstrated that faith causes justification”.
I think you misunderstood what I was saying. I was talking about Calvin’s causes. I was assuming you believed the same thing - that faith causes justification.
In my original list of Calvin’s causes, I listed at the bottom (post #91):
Material Cause - Imputed Righteousness (Christ’s Righteousness that’s in Christ only)
I know you put down “Christ and His obedience” as the material Cause but then Calvin says “through which he acquired righteousness for us.” Couldn’t that mean “Christ’s imputed righteousness”? I was guessing and that’s why I put it at the bottom. If you added that on to the material cause, wouldn’t that be what you are looking for that we receive = imputed righteousness?
We don’t believe Faith is a cause of justification (see above). To us, Faith does not cause or merit justification. To us, Christ caused justification and merited everything from full regeneration through forensic justification for us. To us, Faith (Act of Faith) merits the reward (Heb 11:6). Faith does not cause the reward either and that’s why we say the act of faith merits the reward.
I think the rest of you statements I answered above.
You are assuming that Titus 3:5 teaches water baptism simply because Paul uses the language of washing.
The passage says God saved us according to His mercy, “by the washing of regeneration, and renewing of the Holy Ghost.” Paul identifies God's mercy and the renewing work of the Spirit. He does not identify water baptism as the efficient cause of regeneration.
My Comment: Using your logic, nowhere does it say the effectual call saves you. Again, baptism is not the efficient cause.
If you look at my last post (#89) where I list the five catholic causes of justification, baptism is the “instrumental cause” and NOT the “efficient cause”. Maybe you didn’t mean to say that. I do use Titus 3:5 to prove baptism because the “washing” or “laver” points to the “instrumental cause” of baptism. (Also 1 Pet 3:21 - Baptism now saves you…) It doesn’t say the “effectual call” saves you.
Ephesians 2:4–5 makes the point even clearer: God, rich in mercy, quickened us when we were dead in sins. God gives life to the dead. That is the work of divine mercy.
My Comment: Eph 2:5 = Baptism (Eph 2:5 = cross reference to Col 2:12-13 = uses the term “baptism”). Baptism is the instrumental cause.
I am not arguing that a believer's subjective comfort never fluctuates. Assurance can certainly weaken through sin. But that does not change the objective ground of his acceptance with God.
My Comment: In my last post, in the next sentence, I said that was probably what you meant.
James 2:19 says even devils believe there is one God and tremble. James is exposing empty profession without the fruits of spiritual life. He is not teaching that a regenerate person loses charity through mortal sin while retaining a saving faith.
My Comment: I don’t think I should have used this verse because faith after a christian commits a mortal sin doesn’t cause him to lose his faith, he loses charity. So his faith is not dead. Aquinas says the virtue of faith can exist apart from charity (STh., I-II q.65 a.4).
Faith does not create Christ's righteousness or make His blood effective. Faith apprehends and rests upon what Christ has accomplished.
My Comment: Ok. But faith is still a cause. You said it wasn’t. I moved this to the beginning and answered it.
Again, to us, Faith is not a cause of justification. It’s an effect of regeneration and, to us, when it is in an act, merits the reward (Heb 11:6).I answered this above but I think Christ’s imputed righteousness is in Calvin’s causes. I think Calvin listed it as the material cause? I listed that one below Calvin’s other five causes because I wasn’t sure if I was right. I guess it would have to be there. There are five or six causes. Nothing wrong with that.
You are confusing outward circumstances and common operations of grace with regeneration.
An unregenerate person might attend church because of upbringing, conscience, religious fear, family influence, habit, or social relationships. Church attendance does not prove that someone has received a preparatory spiritual disposition toward God.
I am not denying God's providence, restraint of sin, or the outward call of the Gospel. I am distinguishing those things from the inward impartation of spiritual life.
My Comment: Calling precedes Justification (Rom 8:30). There is only one calling listed under Rom 8:30. God calls in different ways. Calling is drawing. If a man is in church, God is calling him. Actually, God had to be calling him before he got to church to move him willingly to go to church. This is aided by actual grace (prevenient grace). You are not saved by it but you are being prepared by it. Trent also called these graces “preparatory graces” or ”stimulating” graces (Council of Trent, Session VI, Ch V & VI (Denz 797-798).