Poll: Should Peyton Manning retire?

No. He's a great regular season quarterback. He just stinks in the post-season. Let him play in the regular season and then use the backup in the postseason.

Or do what the Eagles did with Ron Jaworski and bring in a young QB to take over on 3rd and 4th downs.

 

He does? Are you basing this on one game, or all of his postseason games, including the Super Bowl that he won?

I hope this is sarcasm. If you're serious, this is just silly.

What are you talking about?

 

I'm talking about exactly what I said. As Jaworski got older and his mobility became an issue, Buddy Ryan would bring Cunningham in on third down on any third down that was over six or seven yards.

 

Ahh. Buddy Ryan. Gotcha.

 

If he gets a clean bill of health on his neck situation he ought to come back for another season. He should also work on strengthening his throwing arm.

 

Don't think at his age that his arm is going to get much stronger. He really never had the "gun" like a Ben or a Marino, but was the most accurate in football. I said he should have retired after the neck surgeries, but competitors like him, those that are in the upper echelon, they're just kinda wired different. When he does hang it up, he will be missed. And I'm glad I had the opportunity to watch him work his 4th quarter magic in person many times. Even if a couple times it brought me grief.

 

Tell that to Elway.

 

Peyton should etire when Peyton is ready to retire. He's the greatest QB of all time in my book. Why would he retire? None of the perceived to be better QBs got farther than he did this year.

 

He is having fun. And has made it known he has no plans to retire in 2014!