Originally posted by Bro. James Reed:
Then why have a preacher at all?
Why not just type up some notes and hand them out to the congregation?
It sure would save a lot of time.
Patrick, I think you will find that Primitive Baptists, liberal, conservative, or what have you, will not hold to the idea of having written sermons, notes, etc. in the pulpit. You are in a very minuscule minority on this issue.
I am in agreement with bethelassoc on this issue all the way.
Again, any man, or woman for that matter, can read a prepared sermon, but it takes a preacher, a true man of God, to preach, in the Spirit, the whole riches of God's grace.
There are far too many people out there nowadays who think they are preachers because they went to seminary and are able to write a sermon. Friends, that is not what makes a preacher. Only God can make a preacher and only the Spirit can move a man to preach.
Preacher's preached the gospel for 1800 years without the use of notes, why do so many feel that a man has to have them to preach now?
I guess it's yet another reason that we are Primitive (Old School) Baptist.
Bro. James
I don't care whether I'm in the minority - minuscule or not - or the majority on most any issue. I try not to let that be my measure of the correct position to have.
Again, what counts is that the message - what's given and what's received - be from God!
It doesn't matter whether the preaching is prepared or unprepared, whether notes are used or not, etc. but only that the message be as God desires it to be. The issue here is not substitution of written sermons for spoken sermons.
God is the source of the God's message and man is merely the oracle through which is is given. Thus a man, not of God can not, of his own accord, present His message no matter how well he prepares. The Holy Spirit moves a man to deliver His message in whatever venue He desires with or without preparation. A man does not become less moved by the Holy Spirit through preparation for a sermon. The Holy Spirit is not less prepared by man's lack of preparation.
However, given my observations - as a consumer of preaching - over many years and the awareness of man's serious limitations, I've concluded that God the Holy Sprit, more often than not, requires His more effective ministers to prepare their sermons through prayer for guideance followed by diligent study, organization, and whatever aids they might need to help them. I've heard some who were unprepared and substituted babbling, endless repetition, or theatrics for God's message because they had not done their homework.
Different messages - all being centered on the good news of salvation by grace - are needed at different times, in different places, by different people. God has His way of reaching His chosen children and is free, despite our feeble attempts to regulate and confine Him, to do as He wants through whatever means He wants.
Plenty of good preachers use notes. The obsession with "no notes" is another one of those legalistic diversions from what really matters. I don't plan to endorse such foolish platforms so long as I can wisely avoid it. Likewise, I admire a man of God who is so moved, so prepared, so experienced that he has no need of notes.
Attending a seminary, although not necessary, doesn't make a man an illegitimate preacher. Some people are so caught up in justifying the correctness of their own church's decision not to endorse seminaries that they find fault with all those who have attended one. That's wrong! Likewise, I've meet preachers who've never set foot in a seminary that knew the word of God inside out and could preach His message with great effect.
I don't believe man can create preachers but I think Biblical study - individual, group, or institutionalized - can help one chosen by God to be a preacher. The danger, of course, in any of these three remains that man's understanding be substitued for God's truths.
Patrick