Rocks don't have logic -- as it turns out

[BobRyan]

thoran said: ↑
No, logic cannot exist according to your strawman, and that strawman was extremely stupid.

<Jumping into this conversation now>

Even atheists can figure out that rocks don't reason.. they will have to admit that rocks have no "logic" of any kind.

Atheists are stuck with rocks... (they start off with gas, dust and rocks from the accretion disc of the sun to get an Einstein)

But all the properties of Einstein had to come from that rock from which he evolved... and that rock had no such properties such as reason or even the ability to "gain" reason.

Zero times 10 trillion is still zero.

But in fact the situation for atheist is much worse than that....

Eukaryotes can't reason either... and Rocks can't even make it to Eukaryote, much less to rabbit or horse or Einstein.

What are you talking about? Rocks obey logic all the time! Newton’s laws were BASED ON the behaviour or objects like rocks.

Pretty funny... next time get a rock to explain its logic or you get a chance debate its logic with it , or program logic into its "logic circuits"... let us know.



Even atheists can figure out that rocks don't reason.. they will have to admit that rocks have no "logic" of any kind. Atheists are stuck with rocks... (they start off with gas, dust and rocks from the accretion disc of the sun to get an Einstein)

Gravity is not "logic" any more than fire is "logic".

Neither do forces "have the property of logic".

Logic
1. reasoning conducted or assessed according to strict principles of validity.
2. a system or set of principles underlying the arrangements of elements in a computer or electronic device so as to perform a specified task.

You can "program logic" into a device like a computer but only because you built "logic circuits" into it (look that up if you don't know what it is or never built one)... none of that is "built" into rocks.

God can reason and devise/create/follow/implement logic- so could Einstein to an infinitely lesser degree. By contrast - rocks don't even play in that arena.

"Everything in the universe runs on logic. ESPECIALLY rocks. Throw a rock and it hits something"

What? "runs on logic"???

"Logic" is not a form of energy.

Atheists are in more trouble than I had first suspected if you think that the rock is demonstrating logic when you throw it -- or if you think that throwing a rock demonstrates it has logic.

The point remains

If you throw enough rocks and place them in a pattern to spell a word like "Logic" then you have used some logic to make the arrangement - but the rocks did not implement any logic of their own because - they have none.