Originally posted by Michael Sly:
Originally posted by RhondaJoy:
[qb] really poor 80s praise and worship that sounds like limp noodles under cold maranara sauce
RhondaJoy, you've got my curiosity. Can you give me an example of what you are referring to?
Hi Michael,
Sure . . . the songs I mentioned are fine "lyrically." Unfortunately, this may raise some ire among folks on the boards, but here's my two cents anyway. As a musician, I want the chord structure and the melody to be as interesting and inspirational as the lyrics are inspiring and uplifting.
That's why I called the songs limp noodles . . . songs which immediately come to mind are "This Is The Day," (Not Bob Fits version) Gary Oliver's "Celebrate Jesus," (which actually came out in the early '90s, and in 2001 he re-arranged it with an ethnic twist -- it's MUCH more musically interesting now), "Alleluia," "Majesty," "What a Mighty God We Serve," and many others.
These were basically very short choruses with very little meat musically, and even lyrically because there were very few lyrics. Congregations would sing them 15 times, over and over.
Now the praise and worship "SONGS" are truly songs. They have verses, refrains (or choruses) and some even have bridges. Many of them come straight out of the scriptures (although let me stress that lyrically they've always been accurate, only very short). But now they have begun to use more interesting chord progressions and melody lines, thanks to folks like Don Moen, Jamie Harvill, Lincoln Brewster and Paul Baloche.
Just my humble little opinion.
[ May 29, 2002, 09:31 AM: Message edited by: RhondaJoy ]