Our daughter is finishing her freshman year at a Christian college. Our church doesn't do anything to help with college choices. It is assumed everyone will go to the local university. One thing to keep in mind is cost. Private will cost more, but we see a lot of value. Smaller classes (15 vs 85 here), Christian teachers with values similar to ours, not all Christian students, but the kids know who believes what, strict living standards, excellent education, mandatory chapel 3 days a week ( mandatory but loved). God is a part of every aspect of their lives, even regular classes.
We did the public shcool route, so our daughter really appreciates where she is now. Her friends here are in overcrowded classes, have made no new friends, aren't able to meet with teachers for help, are just surviving school, have teachers who go off on anti-Christian tangents that have nothing to do with the subject the class is about. This is very rampant here, and it is bothering even the non-Christians.
We get calls and texts daily, do facebook, so even though she is 9 hours away, we are kept in her life.
Kathy