• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Extremely strict colleges...your thoughts?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Luke2427

Active Member
Disagree - The army does encourage individuality,and self thinking, yet we must work as a team, which means at time, we must obey lawful orders for the good of the unit. From the day you join the Army, when there are two or more troops, one is always in charge - ie the ranking individual is responsible; even if he is a Private.

Likewise, a Christian college student is taught to think for himself. No more of - but my pastor says this - rather, how do you interpret the scripture.
eg - is the TV of the Devil or a blessing? Yes, there are times the TV can be a blessing, yet if it is a stumbling block to a new Christian, we need to be mature enough to do without a certain program. As I said before, this takes dedication and commitment.

The army does not encourage individuality. Everyone is expected to dress alike, to stand alike, to march in step, to be in the same place, to clean their gun the exact same way, to be similar in physique, and wear the same haircut, get up at the same time, go to bed at the same time, follow the exact same creed, and do nothing except what they are told.

You cannot know the definition of individuality if you think that the army encourages it.

And these colleges in question do not encourage young people to think for themselves. They encourage them to think like whichever IFB hero the college is fashioned after.
 

Luke2427

Active Member
You know, I've been thinking about this and am wondering about something. According to you, the numbers who come out okay from a strict college are "many thousands," but those who are ruined are "many more" than "many thousands." How do you come by these figures? What are the exact statistics? Who did the survey? Or is this simply your completely unsupported opinion?

I want to be clear. When I said "thousands" I meant over a very long period of time. I do not think strict fundy IFB colleges are graduating thousands of people regularly. But I am sure that in the last 6 or 7 decades there have been thousands.

SBC colleges and seminaries no doubt do graduate thousands a year. I think it is pie in the sky to compare the IFB's with the SBC' on how many they graduate.

Nonetheless, it is, as I stated, an educated opinion of mine having attended one of these types of colleges, observed what kind of workers it produced, and having observed "fundamentalists" all over the Southeastern US for the past thirty years (this is an authority that you can not claim, if I understand your situation correctly, right?)

There will be no stats, I'm sure. But we do have the ability to inductively reason.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Salty

20,000 Posts Club
Administrator
The army does not encourage individuality. Everyone is expected to dress alike, to stand alike, ...

Were you ever in the military - I would say no.
Basic Tng might be the way you stated, but after that, there is lot of individuality. In fact after Basic you attend AIT - Advance INDIVIDUAL Training!
And no - everyone does not have the same haircut, go to bed at the same time, ect...
Yes, we work as a team, but the Army does teach us to think independetnly...

I agree that a few ultra IFB schools may be reproducing their great leader, but I would say they are in the minority.
 

Luke2427

Active Member
Were you ever in the military - I would say no.
Basic Tng might be the way you stated, but after that, there is lot of individuality. In fact after Basic you attend AIT - Advance INDIVIDUAL Training!
And no - everyone does not have the same haircut, go to bed at the same time, ect...
Yes, we work as a team, but the Army does teach us to think independetnly...

I agree that a few ultra IFB schools may be reproducing their great leader, but I would say they are in the minority.

I said boot camp. The strict colleges are not to be compared to everything that goes on the army. Sure there is individuality SOMEWHERE in the army. That would be a pointless analogy. Strict colleges are NOT like the EVERYTHING that is the army. They are like boot camp and boot camp stifles individuality. It breaks down the individual to make him a part of a whole. When it's all said and done those boys standing there at graduation are little automatons. But this is a good thing for the army. It is a very bad thing for men of God.

This is what these silly little fundy colleges do with their suffocating and ridiculous rules.

They tell students when to go to bed and when to get up and what to wear and what to listen to and how to think and what to believe, etc... I cannot see how anyone would be for sending a strong willed, free thinking, on fire for God young man to one of these institution to have his every talent and personality trait wiped away and be turned into a little automaton carbon copy of the staff. These places are only good for those of weak, bland personality types. If you can't tell, I don't like these "institutions".

BTW, I do like your signature. It would be funny were it not so true, right?
 
Last edited by a moderator:

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I want to be clear. When I said "thousands" I meant over a very long period of time. I do not think strict fundy IFB colleges are graduating thousands of people regularly. But I am sure that in the last 6 or 7 decades there have been thousands.

SBC colleges and seminaries no doubt do graduate thousands a year. I think it is pie in the sky to compare the IFB's with the SBC' on how many they graduate.

Nonetheless, it is, as I stated, an educated opinion of mine having attended one of these types of colleges, observed what kind of workers it produced, and having observed "fundamentalists" all over the Southeastern US for the past thirty years (this is an authority that you can not claim, if I understand your situation correctly, right?)

There will be no stats, I'm sure. But we do have the ability to inductively reason.
So then your answer is that your statistics are strictly opinion, with no researched statistical basis, based on no scientific surveys, correct? And thus you have no way to prove your charge that more fundamentalists grads leave the movement than stay. It's pure speculation.

Concerning fundamentalist schools and their graduates, an educated guess from the size of various fundamental schools I am familiar with is that several thousand are graduated every year from fundamental schools. Some of them are larger than you apparently think. Bob Jones U. and Pensacola each have several thousand students in their student bodies. (Someone else may have accurate stats.) Maranatha, Northland, Crown and various other schools each graduate one or two hundred per year.
 

Bob Alkire

New Member
I'll restate: Faith is quite clear about their rules. Apparently, there are few, if any "surprises." You know what you're getting.

Let me ask this question--a slightly different approach: A military academy is obviously very strict. Is there a difference b/t a Faith College and West Point? Should there be? If there is a difference, what is it?

I don't see a problem as long as all is up front.

Rules to me were a part of life. By being home schooled I finished HS at 15. The college I went to send me to Hargrave Military Academy for two years. Then when I went to college we players were kept in a separate dorm, had little or no free time, you know had to practice keep grade up and stay out off trouble. In college could not leave school or less your parents or school people or coaches were leading you.

In seminary didn't have time to do much, went to school, taught in a HS and coached ball. Then came the service, which was the easiest that I had had it in my life. My parents were very strict. Study, work on the farm, work at the lumber yard one or two Friday nights out, had to be back by 9 PM.
 

Bro. James

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Washing of the brain

We are all being programmed--before birth. Paul, the apostle, said he was appointed before he was born. God's plan for His children predates the creation. He has everything under control--including the training. Moses spent 40 years in Midian--getting trained. He still had trouble following orders. There was a price to pay--he did not reach the promised land.

Zeal is a wonderful gift--if we allow God to use it for His honor and glory. As long as we try to help God fill our vessel, we will have problems following His orders. Usually we try to put our carnal ways in the vessel--we are depraved--God cannot use us like that.

We have very clear marching orders: Preach the Word; reprove, rebuke, exhort, with all longsuffering and doctrine. One need not be a Doctor of Divineness to be equipped to carry out these orders. However, a rigid discipline is in order when it comes to spiritual discernment, which leads to the basic problem: unregenerated in the ranks, including the generals.

Put on the whole armour of God. Only a complete uniform will work--that is what "perfect" means, complete, full grown, mature.

I have been in the military in peace and war.

I already knew how to chase rabbits. Some seminary was good, some not so good. I learned a lot in unofficial seminary at church. The best seminary is in the closet--praying. I have no letters or accolades. The real "well dones" are not in this world.

Selah,

Bro James
 
Last edited by a moderator:

sag38

Active Member
My family went to movies on occasion. I dated from the time I was sixteen without adult supervision. When I left home I went to bed when I wanted too, went where I wanted, and did what I wanted. And, horror of horrors, I listened to, and still do, CCM. Therefore, I would not attend a school with such rigid rules. So, it seems to reason that those who go to these schools already agree with the rules because that's the life that they would lead otherwise. Some kids are there because they have proven themselves unable to handle life on their own so mom and dad send them to a school with rigid rules for their kid's own good (hence my comment that John took exception too. No offense toward his family was intended.). Otherwise, I can think of no other good reasons to subject myself or my child to a school with a legalistic leaning atmosphere.
 

Jerome

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Students in residence halls are expected to sign out with the RA when they plan to be away overnight.

I found this suffocating and ridiculous legalistic rule on the website of a silly rigid little fundy school. Can anyone guess which silly and rigid little fundy school has such a suffocating and ridiculous legalistic rule?
 

glfredrick

New Member
One of the interesting points about schools (and others who adopt similar tenets) is that there is still "culture" involved. The question is, which era, and what makes that particular era more right than another era.

The rules put forth by some of the schools we have been examining seem to stem back to 1940s - 1960s American (and more particularly, southern) church practice. I can imagine a culture of neat hair cuts; dark suit, white shirt, and colored tie; music from a hymn book, played by either piano or organ; and other cultural indicators of that era.

The funny thing is that all that stuff was also once "modern" and considered "sinful" by prior generations who had their own culture. There is no such thing as a universal "Christian" culture that is dictated by Scripture, but many have tried to make it so anyway.

I can only imagine how those culturally-locked schools might respond to someone like the Apostle Paul with his torn up body, stink from walking the world, wearing robes, sandals and such, instead of suit and tie, speaking in a language unfamiliar to most at the school, and calling people to true righteousness instead of social issues that take the place of the gospel.

There is a place for colleges to set down rules of conduct for students, but not of those rules are in fact nothing more than a forced enculturation to a bygone era, and that merely for the sake of retaining something that the oldsters who run and finance those schools remain comfortable in having.

I'm sure we'll reach the world with the gospel with that understanding... :BangHead:
 

annsni

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I found this suffocating and ridiculous legalistic rule on the website of a silly rigid little fundy school. Can anyone guess which silly and rigid little fundy school has such a suffocating and ridiculous legalistic rule?

I don't know but my daughter's very liberal secular school has the same rule. :)
 

Tom Bryant

Well-Known Member
I have been in ministry for over 30 years. I have heard so many things that supposedly keep us from reaching the world with the Gospel: Traditional services, the name baptist in a church, musical styles, denominational structure and now strict rules in Bible colleges. If we would only change all these things the world will promptly fall into the lap of Jesus. :BangHead:

I went to Tennessee Temple with all their rules and want to know what they taught me that kept the world from knowing about Jesus? They told me that it was me not telling people about Jesus.
 

Jerome

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
From the OP's (mis?)characterization of Faith's rules:
You cannot travel out-of-town without the Resident Assistant's approval?

Wow. If the goal is to treat 22 year-olds like junior high students

The actual handbook says nothing about "out-of-town" travel, but does have students sign out with their RA when they are going to be absent from campus overnight.

As Ann reports, such a policy is not unusual.
And the silly little rigid school whose condescending legalistic overnight checkout policy I quoted is . . . Wheaton.
 

glfredrick

New Member
I have been in ministry for over 30 years. I have heard so many things that supposedly keep us from reaching the world with the Gospel: Traditional services, the name baptist in a church, musical styles, denominational structure and now strict rules in Bible colleges. If we would only change all these things the world will promptly fall into the lap of Jesus. :BangHead:

I went to Tennessee Temple with all their rules and want to know what they taught me that kept the world from knowing about Jesus? They told me that it was me not telling people about Jesus.

True that.

But, what happens if people come to check out your church and what they see is weirdly anachronistic, like a bad television sitcom (and that is just about what they will use to judge us before coming to Christ)?

In many polls that I have seen (I am one of the researchers for Thom Rainer's "The Unchurched Next Door" book for starters, one of the main issues that those apart from the church have is that they don't want to have to be "weird" like churchy folk. This is expressed in the main stream culture in programs like Saturday Night Live with their church lady routine, and in cartoon series like The Simpson's (and multiple, multiple, others).

Do we have to adopt a 1960s culture in order to follow Christ?

That is not what I've seen, and the church I currently serve sort of proves that point. We're one of the freakiest bunches you'll ever see, but the gospel is REAL and people that you and I might never even speak to are out doing just what you suggest above -- reaching people with the gospel.

Our average age is under 30 and we've grown from 12 to 2400+ in 10 years.

What is interesting is that no one has to adopt any particular culture to be a part of our church. We have blue-haired little old ladies that come in with their big old KJV Bible in hand, looking just like they stepped out of the 1950s, and we have hipsters in skinny jeans and hand-me-down t-shirts with purple hair and a dozen earing's sitting next to them -- all praising Jesus and getting on with His kingdom work. Weird, huh... :thumbs:
 

annsni

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
From the OP's (mis?)characterization of Faith's rules:


The actual handbook says nothing about "out-of-town" travel, but does have students sign out with their RA when they are going to be absent from campus overnight.

As Ann reports, such a policy is not unusual.
And the silly little rigid school whose condescending legalistic overnight checkout policy I quoted is . . . Wheaton.

I would HOPE any college where my child was staying would know where my child is when they should be staying at their "home". What if something happened? "What do you mean my daughter never came "home" last night?? No one cared to check into that?"

I would be livid if my child was not where they were supposed to be and no one cared to check. As I said, at my daughter's college, you need to let your RA know if you will be somewhere else overnight and you also have to let them know in advance if anyone will be staying in your room. This is Adelphi University in NY, a secular college.
 

Tom Bryant

Well-Known Member
True that.

But, what happens if people come to check out your church and what they see is weirdly anachronistic, like a bad television sitcom (and that is just about what they will use to judge us before coming to Christ)?

In many polls that I have seen (I am one of the researchers for Thom Rainer's "The Unchurched Next Door" book for starters, one of the main issues that those apart from the church have is that they don't want to have to be "weird" like churchy folk. This is expressed in the main stream culture in programs like Saturday Night Live with their church lady routine, and in cartoon series like The Simpson's (and multiple, multiple, others).

Do we have to adopt a 1960s culture in order to follow Christ?

That is not what I've seen, and the church I currently serve sort of proves that point. We're one of the freakiest bunches you'll ever see, but the gospel is REAL and people that you and I might never even speak to are out doing just what you suggest above -- reaching people with the gospel.

Our average age is under 30 and we've grown from 12 to 2400+ in 10 years.

What is interesting is that no one has to adopt any particular culture to be a part of our church. We have blue-haired little old ladies that come in with their big old KJV Bible in hand, looking just like they stepped out of the 1950s, and we have hipsters in skinny jeans and hand-me-down t-shirts with purple hair and a dozen earing's sitting next to them -- all praising Jesus and getting on with His kingdom work. Weird, huh... :thumbs:

I am thankful tou're church is doing that. But probably like you have noticed, there are churches that our hopelessly up to date in terms of everything they are doing but don't ever see people saved. The reason is they're not telling the story of Jesus. I know churches who do all hymns, all in ties and dresses and all carrying KJV who are reaching people.

I am just thinking that a church who was seriously loving people and trying to reach them with the story of Jesus would be reaching the world.

The reason we're not reaching the world is that we're not trying.
 

jaigner

Active Member
I would HOPE any college where my child was staying would know where my child is when they should be staying at their "home". What if something happened? "What do you mean my daughter never came "home" last night?? No one cared to check into that?/QUOTE]

College students are adults. Nobody calls me to check where I am. Neither did they when I was a freshman in college. Mom, Dad, friends, dorm, nobody.

Keeping the campus safe is the job of the school, to a large extent. Keeping tabs on every student is not.
 

sag38

Active Member
Many of these rules are great for "helicopter" parents who hover over everything thier child does.
 

Tom Bryant

Well-Known Member
the phrase most Christian colleges use is 'in loco parentis' meaning in the parents place. If I am paying for my children's college, then you bet I am hovering and finding out where they are spending the night and with whom.

God didn't give the colleges my children, He gave me the responsibility.
 

annsni

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I would HOPE any college where my child was staying would know where my child is when they should be staying at their "home". What if something happened? "What do you mean my daughter never came "home" last night?? No one cared to check into that?/QUOTE]

College students are adults. Nobody calls me to check where I am. Neither did they when I was a freshman in college. Mom, Dad, friends, dorm, nobody.

Keeping the campus safe is the job of the school, to a large extent. Keeping tabs on every student is not.

If I'm paying for college and expect my child to be staying where I paid for them to stay, I have every right to expect that they will keep some tabs on my kids - at least at night. Colleges are not wholly safe.

Oh - and they are not adults until they can pay their own way. I'm paying tens of thousands of dollars, I want to know where my child is. It is safety and courtesy to know that a dorm student is not staying at the dorm for any reason.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top