Unconditional Election does not deny justice. This is why I say you feel God is unfair. I see in your writings this to be true. I struggled with these things. The testimony of Scripture reigns. It is biblical.
As to God taking mans works into consideration in light of eternity and salvation, what is the conclusion of God Winman, concerning those works you allude to?
God is just in punishing any for all eternity.
When God punished His Son for the sins of His people, He did so justly. It's hard to fathom this, but it is truth.
Let us never ask for justice. Grace only, and mercy.
Some Calvinists may over-emphasize one aspect over another, but such is human nature. Let's not stereotype the entire group that way. I know some, and yes on here, become obsessed and assinine with these things. We all have our "sugar-stick" as they used to say.
The word just means fair, look it up.
If all men are equally bad, then God should elect all or none to be fair. It is you that struggles with this, not me. It is Calvinism that must resort to the "potter" argument to explain away what appears to be injustice to reasonable persons. Your own God-given conscience is troubled as you admitted.
A potter does not intentionally make defective work, this is where Calvinism goes off the track. A potter will reject a defective work that cannot be fixed, but he doesn't make it defective by design.
Uncondional Election denies justice for the very fact that it does not take the man into consideration.
If the Police simply arrested people on a whim, and not according to whether they had committed a crime, would they be just?
UC is a man made doctrine that is not scriptural and denies God's own words that he will justly judge every man according to their works.