I've been drifting in and out of this discussion over the time, and something just kinda hit me reading the last page today. The problem with the "marriage" is that they aren't living as married people. He's obviously not united with his wife if they are living separate lives. I don't want to go into if "married in the eyes of God" is real or not, or if they should get married in court or not. However, I think their actions do speak louder than their words in this case.