Originally Posted by HisWitness
The SOUL that sinneth IT(Soul) shall DIE--the punishment of the old testament for sin through adam was DEATH.
Psalm 6-4: again In DEATH(when a person dies)there is NO remembrance.
How can that be a true story when the rest of scriptures teach that the SOUL is dead and has no conscience(remembrance)in the grave ?
here again youll go against the teachings of the rest of the bible to prove 1 false assumption
Let's back up and let me ask you something to clear up where we both are coming from.
Do you believe that man was made dichotomous or trichotomous. In other words, is man body and soul/spirit being the same, or body, soul, and spirit all different?
Here is a link to an article on consiousness of the soul.
http://bible.org/seriespage/consciousness-soul-after-death
My view is that upon first look it appears the bible supports dichot, but with a closer view, there are verses where the soul and spirit can not be interchangeable. Let me just say this is a very difficult subject.
What do you think?