Liberty University grad gains control over Lutheran (ELCA) congregation and its sizable assets:
York Daily Record: St. Paul Lutheran Church dissolves over power issues; fight over money ensues
York Daily Record: St. Paul Lutheran Church dissolves over power issues; fight over money ensues
St. Paul is no more, torn apart by a five-year feud that reads like a movie script.
An associate pastor was cited for grabbing a congregant by the arm. The church banned decades-long members from the property. A quiet struggle continues over money, including payments from a $2.8 million trust fund bequeathed to St. Paul by a Hess family member.
Nearly 40 former St. Paul members gathered recently to catch up over a lunch. Many express regret over hiring the Rev. Howard Edmondson in 2007. Many blame him for irreparably damaging their country, churchgoing way of life.
Under Edmondson, the church was renamed Family of God Community Church and it moved to Red Lion. According to former members, only a handful of St. Paul members followed him.
"He came into the congregation, and from the time he came in, he was basically Mr. Nice Guy," said Richard Smith, 71, a St. Paul member for about 55 years. "People loved him."
Edmondson applied to be full-time pastor, but there was one problem: He lacked the seminary credentials required by the ELCA.
"When he put his name in, he offered to do training through the Lutheran Church," said Karen Clever, great-granddaughter of David Hess. "That never materialized."
For a while, things proceeded smoothly for St. Paul under Edmondson. The changes came gradually and were not really noticeable to the casual Sunday worshipper, Clever said. . .