Silverhair
Well-Known Member
Greetings Paleouss. It has been a while since we interacted. God has been good to me and mine. I hope He has been as gracious to you?Greetings Silverhair. Long time since we last interacted. I hope your days have been blessed with peace and hope in our Lord Jesus Christ.
First thoughts about your objection. Hebrews 3:1 isn't the immediate, local context of the verses 6:4-6...HOWEVER, when doing a proper exegesis of the text, the context of the book in which the passage appears should be considered after the immediate, local context.
Points about your offered verse, 3:1 to establish who Paul is speaking to in Hebrew 6:4-6.
1. Paul clearly tells us who he is talking to in Hebrew 5:11-6:20, there is no confusion. He is talking to "Babes" who apparently are sluggish and still need milk. Babes he says should be mature and teachers by now (mature is the goal).
2. Let's do a closed-text analysis of Hebrews 3:1. I say closed-text to avoid error from you or I inserting our theology upon it, thereby possibly missing God's intended meaning.
3. Hebrews 3:1 says, "a heavenly calling" (ESV, NASB), "the heavenly calling" (KJV, NKJV). I'm sure we both agree that in a closed-text analysis it clearly doesn't say "salvation".
4. The Greek word is klēseōs in Heb 3:1. Since you used Thayer's, I'll do the same (although they are all the same here). The meaning that fits right into the context of 3:1 and also the context of 6:4-6 is, according to Thayer; "a call, invitation".
Regarding point #4. Now a Calvinist would certainly object to any receiving an "invitation" that are not already elected. However, what I know of your position...this is not beyond the position you already hold. In other words, people do receive invitations by the Holy Spirit when they hear the gospel.
5. Hebrews 3:14 is within the context that was started in 3:1 and 3:1 means partakers in an "invitation". Then we can take that knowledge into 3:14. Let's break Hebews 3:14 down.
(Heb 3:14 NKJV) – 14 For we have become partakers of Christ if we hold the beginning of our confidence steadfast to the end,
The key words are "if" and "to the end". Now, since we already did an exegesis of Hebrews 6 and found that the "goal" or "end" in which the author speaks is being "mature". Lets look at Hebrews 3 and its context and see if we see the very same thing.
Right after Hebrews 3:14 uses the conditional "if", it ends with "to the end"... there is a comma.... and it says....
(Heb 3:15 NKJV) – 15 while it is said: "Today, if you will hear His voice, Do not harden your hearts as in the rebellion."
The author is using this v15 as an example of what he is saying in 3:14. This verse, 3:15 appears to be in line with Hebrews 3:1's understanding of invitation. If you hear his voice, do not harden your hearts.
A. You have been enlightened by the invitation of the gospel through the Holy Spirit.
B. You can become partakers of Christ, and receive the promise...
C. ... IF ...
D. You are steadfast to the end (the end being maturity, rooted, established, to abide).
E. You have heard his voice, you Babes, do not harden your hearts but continue into the rooted maturity in Christ (the vine).
Peace to you brother
It was not actually an objection but a question as it seemed to me that you had not taken "partakers of a heavenly calling," into consideration in your comments.
As you rightly said Heb 3:1 is not the immediate context of Heb 6:4-6 but it does give us insight as to the mind of the author of those words.
What do we know from Heb 3:1 as it relates to Heb 6:4-6
1] Those being spoken to are believers in Christ Jesus. In 3:1 they are called "holy brethren" and those in 6:4 they are called "partakers of the Holy Spirit"
2] We see in both cases that there is a warning about falling back to their prior religious position. 3:6 "if we hold fast our confidence" 6:6 "and then have fallen away"
In regard to the word calling G2821 klēseōs in Heb 3:1. Yes it is an invitation but we see that they have responded to the invitation and become partakers G3353 metochos according to Thayer's Unabridged Greek:
1. sharing in, partaking of, with the genitive of the thing (Winer's Grammar, ֗ 30, 8 a.): Heb_3:1; Heb_6:4; Heb_12:8; τοῦ Χριστοῦ, of his mind, and of the salvation procured by him, Heb_3:14; cf. Bleek at the passage.
The invitation was given and some have responded in faith and thus are called “holy brethren” Heb 3:1
As you stated post those in Heb 5:11-6:20 were “babes” who apparently are sluggish and still need milk. As we see from Heb 3:1 and Heb 6:4 they are “partakers” of a heavenly calling, of the Holy Spirit. They have accepted the invitation but have not grown and are actually in fear of falling back to their previous religious views.
Looking at Heb 3:14-15 we see that those that have trusted in “become partakers of Christ” Heb 3:1 are being warned to take care lest they fall. Heb 3:12. “Take care, brethren, that there not be in any one of you an evil, unbelieving heart that falls away from the living God.” So the warning in Heb 3:14 ““and ”...if we hold fast the beginning of our assurance firm until the end” and in Heb 6:6 “...and then have fallen away” are real.
So what we see in Hebrews is the author speaking to those Jews that have trusted in Christ Jesus for their salvation but are in danger of returning to their previous religion due to the persecution.
What are we told about the people in Hebrews.
1] have once been enlightened
2] have tasted the heavenly gift
3] have shared in the Holy Spirit
4] have tasted the goodness of the word of God
5] the powers of the coming age
This is speaking of people that have been saved that is unless you think the unsaved "have shared in the Holy Spirit".
But what are we told of them
6] then have fallen away
You cannot fall away from a position that you do not hold. They have rejected the only means of their salvation.
They cannot
7] be restored to repentance
Why, because they are now willing to condemn / crucify Christ just as had been done at Golgotha.
They have experienced the greatest of what God has to offer, and yet, have turned away.