• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Who is Hebrews 6 actually speaking about then?

Silverhair

Well-Known Member
Greetings Silverhair. Long time since we last interacted. I hope your days have been blessed with peace and hope in our Lord Jesus Christ.

First thoughts about your objection. Hebrews 3:1 isn't the immediate, local context of the verses 6:4-6...HOWEVER, when doing a proper exegesis of the text, the context of the book in which the passage appears should be considered after the immediate, local context.

Points about your offered verse, 3:1 to establish who Paul is speaking to in Hebrew 6:4-6.
1. Paul clearly tells us who he is talking to in Hebrew 5:11-6:20, there is no confusion. He is talking to "Babes" who apparently are sluggish and still need milk. Babes he says should be mature and teachers by now (mature is the goal).

2. Let's do a closed-text analysis of Hebrews 3:1. I say closed-text to avoid error from you or I inserting our theology upon it, thereby possibly missing God's intended meaning.

3. Hebrews 3:1 says, "a heavenly calling" (ESV, NASB), "the heavenly calling" (KJV, NKJV). I'm sure we both agree that in a closed-text analysis it clearly doesn't say "salvation".

4. The Greek word is klēseōs in Heb 3:1. Since you used Thayer's, I'll do the same (although they are all the same here). The meaning that fits right into the context of 3:1 and also the context of 6:4-6 is, according to Thayer; "a call, invitation".

Regarding point #4. Now a Calvinist would certainly object to any receiving an "invitation" that are not already elected. However, what I know of your position...this is not beyond the position you already hold. In other words, people do receive invitations by the Holy Spirit when they hear the gospel.

5. Hebrews 3:14 is within the context that was started in 3:1 and 3:1 means partakers in an "invitation". Then we can take that knowledge into 3:14. Let's break Hebews 3:14 down.

(Heb 3:14 NKJV) – 14 For we have become partakers of Christ if we hold the beginning of our confidence steadfast to the end,

The key words are "if" and "to the end". Now, since we already did an exegesis of Hebrews 6 and found that the "goal" or "end" in which the author speaks is being "mature". Lets look at Hebrews 3 and its context and see if we see the very same thing.

Right after Hebrews 3:14 uses the conditional "if", it ends with "to the end"... there is a comma.... and it says....

(Heb 3:15 NKJV) – 15 while it is said: "Today, if you will hear His voice, Do not harden your hearts as in the rebellion."

The author is using this v15 as an example of what he is saying in 3:14. This verse, 3:15 appears to be in line with Hebrews 3:1's understanding of invitation. If you hear his voice, do not harden your hearts.

A. You have been enlightened by the invitation of the gospel through the Holy Spirit.
B. You can become partakers of Christ, and receive the promise...
C. ... IF ...
D. You are steadfast to the end (the end being maturity, rooted, established, to abide).
E. You have heard his voice, you Babes, do not harden your hearts but continue into the rooted maturity in Christ (the vine).



Peace to you brother
Greetings Paleouss. It has been a while since we interacted. God has been good to me and mine. I hope He has been as gracious to you?

It was not actually an objection but a question as it seemed to me that you had not taken "partakers of a heavenly calling," into consideration in your comments.

As you rightly said Heb 3:1 is not the immediate context of Heb 6:4-6 but it does give us insight as to the mind of the author of those words.

What do we know from Heb 3:1 as it relates to Heb 6:4-6

1] Those being spoken to are believers in Christ Jesus. In 3:1 they are called "holy brethren" and those in 6:4 they are called "partakers of the Holy Spirit"

2] We see in both cases that there is a warning about falling back to their prior religious position. 3:6 "if we hold fast our confidence" 6:6 "and then have fallen away"

In regard to the word calling G2821 klēseōs in Heb 3:1. Yes it is an invitation but we see that they have responded to the invitation and become partakers G3353 metochos according to Thayer's Unabridged Greek:

1. sharing in, partaking of, with the genitive of the thing (Winer's Grammar, ֗ 30, 8 a.): Heb_3:1; Heb_6:4; Heb_12:8; τοῦ Χριστοῦ, of his mind, and of the salvation procured by him, Heb_3:14; cf. Bleek at the passage.

The invitation was given and some have responded in faith and thus are called “holy brethren” Heb 3:1

As you stated post those in Heb 5:11-6:20 were “babes” who apparently are sluggish and still need milk. As we see from Heb 3:1 and Heb 6:4 they are “partakers” of a heavenly calling, of the Holy Spirit. They have accepted the invitation but have not grown and are actually in fear of falling back to their previous religious views.

Looking at Heb 3:14-15 we see that those that have trusted in “become partakers of Christ” Heb 3:1 are being warned to take care lest they fall. Heb 3:12. “Take care, brethren, that there not be in any one of you an evil, unbelieving heart that falls away from the living God.” So the warning in Heb 3:14 ““and ”...if we hold fast the beginning of our assurance firm until the end” and in Heb 6:6 “...and then have fallen away” are real.

So what we see in Hebrews is the author speaking to those Jews that have trusted in Christ Jesus for their salvation but are in danger of returning to their previous religion due to the persecution.

What are we told about the people in Hebrews.

1] have once been enlightened

2] have tasted the heavenly gift

3] have shared in the Holy Spirit

4] have tasted the goodness of the word of God

5] the powers of the coming age

This is speaking of people that have been saved that is unless you think the unsaved "have shared in the Holy Spirit".

But what are we told of them

6] then have fallen away

You cannot fall away from a position that you do not hold. They have rejected the only means of their salvation.

They cannot

7] be restored to repentance

Why, because they are now willing to condemn / crucify Christ just as had been done at Golgotha.

They have experienced the greatest of what God has to offer, and yet, have turned away.
 

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I am curious as to what you think "partakers of the Holy Spirit" means if not saved?

Heb 3:1 Therefore, holy brethren, partakers of a heavenly calling, consider Jesus, the Apostle and High Priest of our confession;

Heb 3:14 For we have become partakers of Christ, if we hold fast the beginning of our assurance firm until the end,

Thayer Definition:
1) sharing in, partaking
2) a partner (in a work, office, dignity)
Although I disagree with your apparent conclusion, this is an excellent example of a studied viewpoint!

My view is the word translates "partakers" means "sharing in" in all three verses Hebrews 3:1, Hebrews 3:14, and Hebrews 6:4.

1) Heavenly calling refers, in my view, to being transferred into Christ, just like being "called" into ... His marvelous light. See 1 Corinthians 1:9 and 1 Peter 2:9.

2) And again sharing in Christ, or Christ's shareholders indicates transfer, rather than understanding of opportunity.
 

Paleouss

Active Member
Site Supporter
Greetings Paleouss. It has been a while since we interacted. God has been good to me and mine. I hope He has been as gracious to you?
God has been very gracious to me and my family, far beyond measure. Thank you for asking.

I think I must clear something up before we go on so you know the direction I think I'm headed (if you don't already know it). If I remember correctly we had talked before and you had taken a stance of 'you can lose your salvation' and I took a stance that 'salvation can be secure'.

Being transparent in where I think my analysis is taking this... I think these verses are, along with others with them, are suggesting that reaching spiritual maturity is the taking part in the promise, it is the security that God holds you in His hands and will never let go. It was most certainly the message of Hebrews 5:11-6:20.

HOWEVER, there appears to be a transition time from enlightenment from the gospel, Christ is the light unto world, to reaching that rooted maturity (which is secure). It would seem that this "transition time" is referred to in the Bible as being a "babe", "needing milk".... further, during this being a "babe", apparently one is susceptible to falling away. I concede this to you if this is your stance.

The question that I search for at the moment is, is this transition period from Babe to Mature actually salvation? Does it warrant the categorization of the word salvation? Hebrews 5:11-6:20 would appear to state very clearly that being Mature is when one actually partakes of the promise. The Babes are told to progress to Mature so that they might also partake of the promise. So it seems clear to me that being Mature warrants being categorized as Salvation.

Invitation (enlightenment) --> Babe spiritually --> Mature spiritually

Is the stage of "Babe spiritually" salvation, that then is progressing toward security? Or is it the progression toward salvation, thereby not yet being saved? 1 Corinthians 3:1-3 equates Babes with Carnal.

If it can be properly categorized as salvation, then one can lose their salvation up until one becomes mature (the goal Heb 6 implores the Babes to reach). But once they reach the stage of being spiritually mature, they are secure in God's hand. If it cannot be properly categorized as salvation, then the being a Babe is being not yet saved...until one reaches maturity.

PS... I'll evaluate the technical part of your response at another time.

Peace to you
 

Kai

Well-Known Member
In other words, the author expected those to which he is writing to have already grown to maturity and be eating spiritual meat, BABES --> MATURE; But he is asserting that they are still BABES (and that is a problem). Therefore, the author of Hebrews 6 is speaking to members that are BABES. This truth should then dictate the flow of our understanding of what is to come.

Hi @Paleouss.

I don’t believe they were ever “babes” to begin with.

The “babes in Christ” at the church at Corinth were saved, since Paul referred to them as Christians. Therefore, “babes” can’t fall away if they have been indwelt by the Holy Spirit.

The Jewish audience that turned away from the Gospel’s teachings belong to a different category.
 
Last edited:

Paleouss

Active Member
Site Supporter
What are we told about the people in Hebrews.

1] have once been enlightened

2] have tasted the heavenly gift

3] have shared in the Holy Spirit

4] have tasted the goodness of the word of God

5] the powers of the coming age

This is speaking of people that have been saved that is unless you think the unsaved "have shared in the Holy Spirit".
Greeting again Silverhair. Thank you for the well constructed argument you just presented in your last post. You forced me to put more attention to the topic and our conversation.

The premises you present in the quote, above, don’t seem to lead to your conclusion; that is, they don’t lead to the dichotomy you present in the last sentence. Considering it, it might work against someone trying to explain away the warnings, but since I'm not a Calvinist and also am taking every word of these passages seriously, I think your last sentence/question sets up a false dichotomy.

I’m pretty sure I know you as an Arminian and not a Calvinist. Therefore, the notion that the Holy Spirit witnesses to the unsaved would be well within your frame of acceptance (I’m assuming). So yes, Scripture explicitly shows that unsaved hearers can experience the Holy Spirit’s illuminating and convicting work without yet being saved (John 16:8; Acts 7:51). Whenever the gospel seed is sown (Luke 8:11), the Holy Spirit shines light on the truth, convicts the conscience, and lets the hearer "taste" the goodness of God's word (Hebrews 6:4-5). Notice Hebrews 6:4-5 never calls them justified, born again, or indwelt; it says they were enlightened and tasted. Just like the rocky soil that receives the word with joy yet has no deep root (Luke 8:13), an unrooted "babe" can genuinely experience the Spirit's gospel illumination and still fall short of the "better things that accompany salvation" (Hebrews 6:9) if they refuse to press on to maturity.

I debated on how to address your technical points due to length, so I settled on presenting a few overview points.

Regarding your G3353 metochos: I concede that metochos means genuine participation. I don’t think I ever suggested they didn’t participate. The question is what did they participate in? The context of Hebrews 3 and 6 suggests they genuinely participated in the Spirit’s gospel illumination and convicting ministry (like John 16:8), just as the rocky soil genuinely participated in receiving the gospel seed with joy (Luke 8:13). Participating in the Spirit's "enlightenment" is not de facto the same as possessing indwelling salvation (regeneration). New Testament writers often address a visible congregation as "saints" or "brethren" while warning verses later that some among them may not truly be in the faith (like 2 Corinthians 13:5). This is exactly what happens in Hebrews 3:12, where the writer warns, beware lest there be in any of you "an evil heart of unbelief."

Regarding the unbelieving heart (Hebrews 3:12): The Greek noun is apistias (unbelief). This word would seem to in no way suggest a regenerated heart that then loses its salvation; it explicitly describes an unbelieving heart. Further, this "unbelieving heart" is illustrated right in Hebrews 3:19. The Israelites came out from Egypt, saw the miracles and wonders, and were enlightened by the words and leadership of Moses. Yet their unbelief kept them from entering the promise (like Hebrews 6 imploring Babes to progress toward the promise they had not yet entered). Therefore, unbelief here is being used as something that prevents someone from reaching and attaining the promise, not someone who had attained salvation and then lost it. That is why, back in Hebrews 6:9, the author contrasts those who fall away with "better things, things that accompany salvation."

As an added inquiry, If the five experiences in Hebrews 6:4-5 already equaled being saved, why does the author immediately contrast them with "better things” in verse 9? Then the author specifically defines those better things as “things that accompany salvation”? With what I have been suggesting, I think verse 9 makes total sense; verses 4-5 describe Babe’s illumination/tasting of pre-salvation, while v9 describes actual salvation…which belong to those who press on to maturity and into the promise rather than remaining unrooted Babes.


Peace to you brother
 

Silverhair

Well-Known Member
Although I disagree with your apparent conclusion, this is an excellent example of a studied viewpoint!

My view is the word translates "partakers" means "sharing in" in all three verses Hebrews 3:1, Hebrews 3:14, and Hebrews 6:4.

1) Heavenly calling refers, in my view, to being transferred into Christ, just like being "called" into ... His marvelous light. See 1 Corinthians 1:9 and 1 Peter 2:9.

2) And again sharing in Christ, or Christ's shareholders indicates transfer, rather than understanding of opportunity.

So it would seem that we agree that "partakers" means that they are sharing whether that be in Christ or of the Holy Spirit.

You refer to 1Co 1:9 and 1Pe 2:9 re called but if you look at those verses you will see that they are caled/invited to something. It is only if they respond in faith that they are then placed into Christ and indwelt by the Holy Spirit. Looking at "calling" Heb 3:1 we see the same thing, an invitation. In all cases the person has to respond.

If we used your view of called then this verse Mat 22:14 "For many are called, but few are chosen." makes no sense.
God has been very gracious to me and my family, far beyond measure. Thank you for asking.

I think I must clear something up before we go on so you know the direction I think I'm headed (if you don't already know it). If I remember correctly we had talked before and you had taken a stance of 'you can lose your salvation' and I took a stance that 'salvation can be secure'.

Being transparent in where I think my analysis is taking this... I think these verses are, along with others with them, are suggesting that reaching spiritual maturity is the taking part in the promise, it is the security that God holds you in His hands and will never let go. It was most certainly the message of Hebrews 5:11-6:20.

HOWEVER, there appears to be a transition time from enlightenment from the gospel, Christ is the light unto world, to reaching that rooted maturity (which is secure). It would seem that this "transition time" is referred to in the Bible as being a "babe", "needing milk".... further, during this being a "babe", apparently one is susceptible to falling away. I concede this to you if this is your stance.

The question that I search for at the moment is, is this transition period from Babe to Mature actually salvation? Does it warrant the categorization of the word salvation? Hebrews 5:11-6:20 would appear to state very clearly that being Mature is when one actually partakes of the promise. The Babes are told to progress to Mature so that they might also partake of the promise. So it seems clear to me that being Mature warrants being categorized as Salvation.

Invitation (enlightenment) --> Babe spiritually --> Mature spiritually

Is the stage of "Babe spiritually" salvation, that then is progressing toward security? Or is it the progression toward salvation, thereby not yet being saved? 1 Corinthians 3:1-3 equates Babes with Carnal.

If it can be properly categorized as salvation, then one can lose their salvation up until one becomes mature (the goal Heb 6 implores the Babes to reach). But once they reach the stage of being spiritually mature, they are secure in God's hand. If it cannot be properly categorized as salvation, then the being a Babe is being not yet saved...until one reaches maturity.

PS... I'll evaluate the technical part of your response at another time.

Peace to you


I would say we are not that far apart in our understanding of babe and mature.

I think if we look at what has been said in Heb 5:11-6:20 you will find that those that may fall away are those that are called babe's in the faith. This is not IMO a referance to how long they had trusted in Christ but rather how they had grown in their understanding of the Christian faith.

As I see it those that are called babe's are actually saved but are susceptible to being lead astray by smooths words of false teachers. 2Co 11:3 "...just as Eve was deceived by the serpent’s cunning" the immature/babes "may be led astray from your simple and pure devotion to Christ"

Those that are mature in their faith, as long as they do not become complacent lest they fall, see the error, the attempt at deseption and thus stand strong.

Even those that have not matured in their faith will still partake of the promise if they hold fast the knowledge they do have, the gospel once proclaimed to them.

Maturity is not required for salvation but continued trust in Christ Jesus is. God will not loose any that trust in Him but He will not stop anyone from walking away from Him. We do not loose our free will once we are saved.

I do have to ask. In your view how much knowledge must one have to be considered mature enough that they can be assured of their salvation?
When do they stop being a babe in Christ?

In response to your comments on 1Co 3:1-3.
Please note the final words of vs 1 "as infants in Christ". If they are in Christ they are saved even though they may still behave at times in a wordly manner. But as we know behaving in a worldly manner is not restricted to just the babes, we see it in the mature also. That is why we are to strive to grow, to become more Christ like in our behaviour
 

Silverhair

Well-Known Member
Greeting again Silverhair. Thank you for the well constructed argument you just presented in your last post. You forced me to put more attention to the topic and our conversation.

The premises you present in the quote, above, don’t seem to lead to your conclusion; that is, they don’t lead to the dichotomy you present in the last sentence. Considering it, it might work against someone trying to explain away the warnings, but since I'm not a Calvinist and also am taking every word of these passages seriously, I think your last sentence/question sets up a false dichotomy.

I’m pretty sure I know you as an Arminian and not a Calvinist. Therefore, the notion that the Holy Spirit witnesses to the unsaved would be well within your frame of acceptance (I’m assuming). So yes, Scripture explicitly shows that unsaved hearers can experience the Holy Spirit’s illuminating and convicting work without yet being saved (John 16:8; Acts 7:51). Whenever the gospel seed is sown (Luke 8:11), the Holy Spirit shines light on the truth, convicts the conscience, and lets the hearer "taste" the goodness of God's word (Hebrews 6:4-5). Notice Hebrews 6:4-5 never calls them justified, born again, or indwelt; it says they were enlightened and tasted. Just like the rocky soil that receives the word with joy yet has no deep root (Luke 8:13), an unrooted "babe" can genuinely experience the Spirit's gospel illumination and still fall short of the "better things that accompany salvation" (Hebrews 6:9) if they refuse to press on to maturity.

I debated on how to address your technical points due to length, so I settled on presenting a few overview points.

Regarding your G3353 metochos: I concede that metochos means genuine participation. I don’t think I ever suggested they didn’t participate. The question is what did they participate in? The context of Hebrews 3 and 6 suggests they genuinely participated in the Spirit’s gospel illumination and convicting ministry (like John 16:8), just as the rocky soil genuinely participated in receiving the gospel seed with joy (Luke 8:13). Participating in the Spirit's "enlightenment" is not de facto the same as possessing indwelling salvation (regeneration). New Testament writers often address a visible congregation as "saints" or "brethren" while warning verses later that some among them may not truly be in the faith (like 2 Corinthians 13:5). This is exactly what happens in Hebrews 3:12, where the writer warns, beware lest there be in any of you "an evil heart of unbelief."

Regarding the unbelieving heart (Hebrews 3:12): The Greek noun is apistias (unbelief). This word would seem to in no way suggest a regenerated heart that then loses its salvation; it explicitly describes an unbelieving heart. Further, this "unbelieving heart" is illustrated right in Hebrews 3:19. The Israelites came out from Egypt, saw the miracles and wonders, and were enlightened by the words and leadership of Moses. Yet their unbelief kept them from entering the promise (like Hebrews 6 imploring Babes to progress toward the promise they had not yet entered). Therefore, unbelief here is being used as something that prevents someone from reaching and attaining the promise, not someone who had attained salvation and then lost it. That is why, back in Hebrews 6:9, the author contrasts those who fall away with "better things, things that accompany salvation."

As an added inquiry, If the five experiences in Hebrews 6:4-5 already equaled being saved, why does the author immediately contrast them with "better things” in verse 9? Then the author specifically defines those better things as “things that accompany salvation”? With what I have been suggesting, I think verse 9 makes total sense; verses 4-5 describe Babe’s illumination/tasting of pre-salvation, while v9 describes actual salvation…which belong to those who press on to maturity and into the promise rather than remaining unrooted Babes.


Peace to you brother


Where do you see a problem with the conclusion? Are you saying that they apply to the unsaved?

Could you expand on how you think they could be used to explain away the warnings? The author of Heb 6:4-6 obviously does not see it doing that.

Not a Calvinist but not an Arminian either asI see problems in both views. Although I do see more in the Calvinist soteriology.

Yes the gospel will bring light to the unsaved but when you look at the text is showing the result of those having heard the gospel message and responded to it in a positive way. They have trusted in Christ Jesus. That is why I said these words are speaking of people that have been saved. Those are the only ones that would have shared in the Holy Spirit.

Heb 6:4-6 does not have to use those words [justified, born again, or indwelt] as the ones used inform us of that reality. It seems that you have a stepped view of salvation. I do not see that as a biblical view. Rom 10:9 is very clear on salvation:

Rom 10:9

1] that if you confess with your mouth, “Jesus is Lord,”

2] and believe in your heart that God raised Him from the dead,

3] you will be saved.

We see the same thing in Act 16:30-31

The question “Sirs, what must I do to be saved?”

The answer “Believe in the Lord Jesus and you will be saved...”



You have used Luk 8:13 as an example of those that can genuinely experience the Spirit's gospel illumination and still fall short of the "better things that accompany salvation. I actually agree with you as that is what the text clearly says Luk 8:13 The seeds on rocky ground are those who hear the word and receive it with joy, but they have no root. They believe for a season, but in the time of testing, they fall away.

They believed in Christ Jesus for their salvation but later fell away. Perhaps they were not discipled or they just did not think trusting in Christ was worth the hassles they were getting. But in any case they chose to turn away from Him.

Actually the Israelites that came out of Egypt were enlightened by the various miracles of God but as we now see having the gospel message presented does not guarantee that the person will believe. You continue to say that babes have to progress toward the promise but that is not a biblical view. One can be a babe in Christ and they are still saved. One is either saved or they are not.

The text in Heb 6:6 is clear enough if you will just trust what it says. They will not attain the promise because they have turned away from the Christ they once trusted. The author in Heb 6:9 has written to the church that contained both those that believed and those that were in danger of falling away thus the contrast of continued trust in Christ and returning to their former religion.

The five experiences in Heb 6:4-5 do point to salvation. And as we see in vs 6 the warning “and then have fallen away” The author is in vs 9 telling those that continue to believe and even those that are in danger of falling that there are better things that accompany salvation if they continue to trust in Christ Jesus.
 

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
So it would seem that we agree that "partakers" means that they are sharing whether that be in Christ or of the Holy Spirit.

You refer to 1Co 1:9 and 1Pe 2:9 re called but if you look at those verses you will see that they are caled/invited to something. It is only if they respond in faith that they are then placed into Christ and indwelt by the Holy Spirit. Looking at "calling" Heb 3:1 we see the same thing, an invitation. In all cases the person has to respond.

If we used your view of called then this verse Mat 22:14 "For many are called, but few are chosen." makes no sense.

SNIP
No, we do not agree. we can share is the work product of the Holy Spirit, the gospel as presented by the Holy Spirit inspired NT writers. They might have been indwelt but that is just a possibility, not an explicit declaration.

And again, my view of 1 Corinthians 1:9 and 1 Peter 2:9 is these are examples where the Greek word "translated "called" actually means relocated from being in Adam and into being within Christ's spiritual body. This was to support "heavenly calling" as actually referring to our transfer into Christ.

The word translated "heavenly" refers to things residing in heaven or to things coming from heaven such as blessings. When an individual is transferred into Christ, he or she is transferred into the heavenly.
 

Lewis HB

New Member
Paul says Hebrews is written to the Jews in the desporia not to the church.
May I humbly point out that Baptist fundimental doctrine is dispensational. There are seven dispensations. That all of our doctrine is found from Romans to Philemon in this sixth dispensation/ church age. In the tribulation period the world will be back under law works plus faith, as will be the Millennium.
Great confusion comes from using statements in the books written to the Jews as Baptist Christian doctrine. In the Gospels Jesus is talking to the old testament Jews under the Law, NOT to the church!
 

Kai

Well-Known Member
Someone who is spiritually lost can still be a “partaker of the Holy Spirit” by immersing themselves in the church community and learning from Christians. This is very different from being sealed by the Holy Spirit through faith.
 

Silverhair

Well-Known Member
No, we do not agree. we can share is the work product of the Holy Spirit, the gospel as presented by the Holy Spirit inspired NT writers. They might have been indwelt but that is just a possibility, not an explicit declaration.

And again, my view of 1 Corinthians 1:9 and 1 Peter 2:9 is these are examples where the Greek word "translated "called" actually means relocated from being in Adam and into being within Christ's spiritual body. This was to support "heavenly calling" as actually referring to our transfer into Christ.

The word translated "heavenly" refers to things residing in heaven or to things coming from heaven such as blessings. When an individual is transferred into Christ, he or she is transferred into the heavenly.
You say you disagree with my view but you have said this in your post

”My view is the word translates "partakers" means "sharing in" in all three verses Hebrews 3:1, Hebrews 3:14, and Hebrews 6:4”:

Heb 3:1 holy brothers, who share in the heavenly calling, set your focus on Jesus

Heb 3:14 We have come to share in Christ if we hold firmly to the end

Heb 6:4 who have tasted the heavenly gift, who have shared in the Holy Spirit

What does the text say Van?

I said “that "partakers" means that they are sharing whether that be in Christ or of the Holy Spirit.”

Where is the disagreement Van?

I understand that is your view re 1Co 1:9 & 1Pe 2:9 but the text does not support that view. It seems that you are adding your own special meaning to the word “called”.

called G2564

Metaphorically, to call or invite to anything, e.g., of Jesus, to call to repentance, exhort (Mat_9:13; implied in Mar_2:17); of God (1Co_1:9; 2Th_2:14; 1Ti_6:12; 1Pe_2:9; 1Pe_5:10; Rev_19:9). The Complete WordStudy Dictionary

Thayer's Unabridged Greek - english Lexicon does not support your special meaning for “called”.

Where did you find the definition that you are using?

Not sure what point you are trying to say with your comment on “heavenly”.
 

Eternally Grateful

Well-Known Member
Hebrews 6 is speaking to those who returned to the law.

The law states when you fall. A sacrifice must be given to be forgiven of that sin.. Going back to the law puts Christ to open shame as it says his death was not enough.

and if we go back to the law.. we will never return to grace again.. which is the main warning.

If we fall away (if it were possible) we could never be renewed again
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kai

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
Paul says Hebrews is written to the Jews in the desporia not to the church.
May I humbly point out that Baptist fundimental doctrine is dispensational. There are seven dispensations. That all of our doctrine is found from Romans to Philemon in this sixth dispensation/ church age. In the tribulation period the world will be back under law works plus faith, as will be the Millennium.
Great confusion comes from using statements in the books written to the Jews as Baptist Christian doctrine. In the Gospels Jesus is talking to the old testament Jews under the Law, NOT to the church!
So not all Scripture is profitable for doctrine??
 

Paleouss

Active Member
Site Supporter
Where do you see a problem with the conclusion? Are you saying that they apply to the unsaved?
Greetings Silverhair. Peace and hope to you in our Lord Jesus Christ.

I might have misused the word "conclusion", it would have been better to say, "your rationale"
1] have once been enlightened

2] have tasted the heavenly gift

3] have shared in the Holy Spirit

4] have tasted the goodness of the word of God

5] the powers of the coming age

This is speaking of people that have been saved that is unless you think the unsaved "have shared in the Holy Spirit".
After point #5, you present your rationale by implying that the unsaved cannot share in the Holy Spirit's work in any way alongside the saved. That is the flaw in the biblical logic (imo), because all believers were unsaved at one time. When the Holy Spirit works through the gospel message, every hearer is initially unsaved when they are enlightened, convicted, and given a taste of God's good word (John 16:8; Hebrews 6:4-5).

From that common starting point, there are those who press forward in faith to partake in the promise (both Hebrews 3 and 6 use this language), which is a mature, secure salvation (Hebrews 6:9, 12), and there are those who shrink back and do not. Because both groups were unsaved when the Holy Spirit first enlightened them through the gospel, yes, those five descriptions apply to unsaved hearers who have shared in that initial gospel illumination. Some may fall away quickly, not reaching maturity, and others may take longer before falling away and never reaching maturity (to each his own path).

To head off a possible challenge, the Bible does give us examples of belief or faith being insufficient. The Parable of the Sower contrasts unrooted faith with rooted faith, which is equivalent to a babe not yet possessing the promise versus the mature reaching and partaking in the promise. John 2:23-25 distinguishes belief in verse 23 against Jesus' evaluation that this was a fickle, shallow belief based on miracles. This same kind of fickle, unrooted faith is what is being contrasted in Hebrews 3 and 6 between babes and the mature.

This also answers your concern about Romans 10:9, Acts 16:31, and what you called a "stepped view of salvation." I completely agree with Romans 10:9 and Acts 16:31, and I do not hold a stepped view of salvation. Rather, I am pointing out the biblical difference between shallow, temporary assent (like John 2:23 and Luke 8:13) and genuine, heart-level saving faith (Romans 10:9). I do find it an equal error to think that every human experience follows the same awakening period. Although God can most certainly bring someone to saving faith immediately, the biblical text, especially Hebrews, appears to tell us that this is not always the case.

Finally, remember to consider and not bypass Hebrews 3:12, Hebrews 3:19, and Hebrews 6:9. Hebrews 3:12 warns of an "evil heart of unbelief", Hebrews 3:19 shows that unbelief kept Israel from ever entering the promise in the first place, and Hebrews 6:9 contrasts the initial experiences of verses 4 and 5 with "better things, things that accompany salvation." As Hebrews 10:39 sums it up, we are not of those who shrink back to destruction, but of those who believe to the saving of the soul. Notice the book of Hebrews gives no indication that this "belief to the saving of the soul" means enduring until physical death; rather, in the context of Hebrews, it is specifically enduring unto rooted maturity. It would seem that Hebrews clearly establishes what it means in Hebrews 10:39.


May God bless you and yours and may His name be heard through all the world.
 

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
You say you disagree with my view but you have said this in your post

”My view is the word translates "partakers" means "sharing in" in all three verses Hebrews 3:1, Hebrews 3:14, and Hebrews 6:4”:

Heb 3:1 holy brothers, who share in the heavenly calling, set your focus on Jesus

Heb 3:14 We have come to share in Christ if we hold firmly to the end

Heb 6:4 who have tasted the heavenly gift, who have shared in the Holy Spirit

What does the text say Van?

I said “that "partakers" means that they are sharing whether that be in Christ or of the Holy Spirit.”

Where is the disagreement Van?

I understand that is your view re 1Co 1:9 & 1Pe 2:9 but the text does not support that view. It seems that you are adding your own special meaning to the word “called”.

called G2564

Metaphorically, to call or invite to anything, e.g., of Jesus, to call to repentance, exhort (Mat_9:13; implied in Mar_2:17); of God (1Co_1:9; 2Th_2:14; 1Ti_6:12; 1Pe_2:9; 1Pe_5:10; Rev_19:9). The Complete WordStudy Dictionary

Thayer's Unabridged Greek - english Lexicon does not support your special meaning for “called”.

Where did you find the definition that you are using?

Not sure what point you are trying to say with your comment on “heavenly”.
1) Thank you for your careful effort to actually address my view!

2) The reason is I believe "heavenly gift" equals "the gospel revelation" whereas "heavenly calling" equals "being transferred spiritually into Christ's spiritual body.

3) But you are correct, the lexicon I checked to see if your finding was correct did not, as you correctly stated, include the meaning of "to pass from one state to another." However G2821, the noun in Hebrews 3:1, is a shorter version of G2564, which does include that meaning.

4) You were wrong to say the lexicon did not include "to pass from one state to another" for 1 Corinthians 1:9 and 1 Peter 2:9, in ;which G2564, rather than G2821, is used.
 

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
Our doctrine is from Romans to Philemon. Paul was talking to the hebrews not to the church.
Hi Ben, the thing is Hebrews and James contridict the Pauline letters romans to philemon. That is where much of the chaos comes from. So does the four gospels where Jesus is talking to the Jews under the Law.
So it can get really confusing if you bring into church doctrine letters that are not written to the churches.

So you think Hebrews is not profitable for doctrine?
I don’t see any contradictions. You want to take Hebrews out? James is mistaken?
Salvation for the Jews is not through Christ, it’s different for them?
 

Lewis HB

New Member
James is about works, (so is Hebrews) and Paul said a person who is circumsized, a Jew of the first century, is required to do the whole law, which is works plus grace/faith.
James and Hebrews contradict what Paul says about grace by faith alone in his epistles ... so how can we have them as part of our doctrine? as far as we (Bible Believing Baptists) we cannot.
That is the consensus Of the Bible believing baptists I am aware of. I am just repeating what I have been taught over the last 50 years by KJV only Baptist pastors.. It is definately not just my opinion.
All people disregarding who the books are written to and in what dispensations are going to have serious theological chaos. Which is what we see all around us.
 

Silverhair

Well-Known Member
After point #5, you present your rationale by implying that the unsaved cannot share in the Holy Spirit's work in any way alongside the saved. That is the flaw in the biblical logic (imo), because all believers were unsaved at one time.
You are misusing the text. Only those that have shared in the Holy Spirit are saved. The Holy Spirit will convict all but does not indwell all.

The text says share in the Holy Spirit it does not say share in the Holy Spirits work. That is the error you bring into the text.

The text refers to “those who have once” what?

1] been enlightened

2] have tasted of the heavenly gift

3] have been made partakers of the Holy Spirit,

4] have tasted the good word of God

5] and the powers of the age to come

6] and then have fallen away

7] it is impossible to renew them again to repentance

These words obviously refer to those that have been saved that is unless you think the unsaved can fall away from a faith they never had. Or can be renewed to a faith they never had.

When the Holy Spirit works through the gospel message, every hearer is initially unsaved when they are enlightened, convicted, and given a taste of God's good word (John 16:8; Hebrews 6:4-5).
That is true but Heb 6:4-6 is not speaking of unbelievers is it.

From that common starting point, there are those who press forward in faith to partake in the promise (both Hebrews 3 and 6 use this language), which is a mature, secure salvation (Hebrews 6:9, 12), and there are those who shrink back and do not. Because both groups were unsaved when the Holy Spirit first enlightened them through the gospel, yes, those five descriptions apply to unsaved hearers who have shared in that initial gospel illumination. Some may fall away quickly, not reaching maturity, and others may take longer before falling away and never reaching maturity (to each his own path).
You are trying to isolate one part of the text from the balance of the text as it then would show the complete error of your view. While the unsaved may be enlightened by hearing the gospel message only the saved will tasted the heavenly gift [Rom_6:23 ...the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus] or share in the Holy Spirit [Act_2:38 .. "Repent, and each of you be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ ...and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.] and so forth and they most certainly cannot fall away from a faith they never had or be restored to that same faith.

To head off a possible challenge, the Bible does give us examples of belief or faith being insufficient. The Parable of the Sower contrasts unrooted faith with rooted faith, which is equivalent to a babe not yet possessing the promise versus the mature reaching and partaking in the promise.
Yes as we see in our own time, many will hear the gospel and some will respond to the message. But as we see in Mar 4:16 Some are like the seeds sown on rocky ground. They hear the word and at once receive it with joy. Mar 4:17 But they themselves have no root, and they remain for only a season. When trouble or persecution comes because of the word, they quickly fall away.

These are those that have believed, have been saved but fall because as Christ said “When trouble or persecution comes ...they quickly fall away”




It seems that you think that one starts out almost saved [a babe in the faith] and as they mature they become more and more saved. That is not biblical.

John 2:23-25 distinguishes belief in verse 23 against Jesus' evaluation that this was a fickle, shallow belief based on miracles. This same kind of fickle, unrooted faith is what is being contrasted in Hebrews 3 and 6 between babes and the mature.
The bible is clear that one is saved or not saved. There is not almost saved as you seem to think. What we see in Mar 4:5-8 is speaking of people that have been saved but as we see the 2nd and 3rd type will fall away from their faith. That is not what we see in Heb 3 and 6.

This also answers your concern about Romans 10:9, Acts 16:31, and what you called a "stepped view of salvation." I completely agree with Romans 10:9 and Acts 16:31, and I do not hold a stepped view of salvation. Rather, I am pointing out the biblical difference between shallow, temporary assent (like John 2:23 and Luke 8:13) and genuine, heart-level saving faith (Romans 10:9). I do find it an equal error to think that every human experience follows the same awakening period. Although God can most certainly bring someone to saving faith immediately, the biblical text, especially Hebrews, appears to tell us that this is not always the case.
I called your view a "stepped view of salvation." as that is what you have presented. You claim that babes in the faith are not really saved but have to wait until they are mature to receive the promise.

You have mistaken the shallow, temporary assent as not being saving faith but the bible disagree with you. You said you agree with Rom 10:9 & Act 16:30-31 but nothing in those verses say that those believers cannot or will not fall away as soils 2 & 3 did in Mar 4:5-7.

Genuine, heart-level saving faith is the faith we see God respond to Eph 2:5 “...even when we were dead in our trespasses. It is by grace you have been saved!” and Eph 2:8 “For it is by grace you have been saved through faith,” It does not say your almost saved and we will wait until you mature to actually save you does it.

Finally, remember to consider and not bypass Hebrews 3:12, Hebrews 3:19, and Hebrews 6:9. Hebrews 3:12 warns of an "evil heart of unbelief", Hebrews 3:19 shows that unbelief kept Israel from ever entering the promise in the first place, and Hebrews 6:9 contrasts the initial experiences of verses 4 and 5 with "better things, things that accompany salvation." As Hebrews 10:39 sums it up, we are not of those who shrink back to destruction, but of those who believe to the saving of the soul. Notice the book of Hebrews gives no indication that this "belief to the saving of the soul" means enduring until physical death; rather, in the context of Hebrews, it is specifically enduring unto rooted maturity. It would seem that Hebrews clearly establishes what it means in Hebrews 10:39.
I have not bypassed any of Hebrews but I have not read into it what is not there either. The warning of Heb 3:12 and 19 is that those that do not believe will not enter God’s rest, will be saved. And in contrast we see that Heb 6:9 is pointing to the better things that come through salvation.


Those that have trusted in God for their salvation can and some do turn away for the faith that lead to their salvation. This we see in Mar 4:4-20. While all that trust in Christ Jesus are saved not all will grow. Those that do grow will do so to different levels and at different speeds. That growth is called sanctification, they grow more Christ like not to be more saved.
 

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
James is about works, (so is Hebrews) and Paul said a person who is circumsized, a Jew of the first century, is required to do the whole law, which is works plus grace/faith.
James and Hebrews contradict what Paul says about grace by faith alone in his epistles ... so how can we have them as part of our doctrine? as far as we (Bible Believing Baptists) we cannot.
That is the consensus Of the Bible believing baptists I am aware of. I am just repeating what I have been taught over the last 50 years by KJV only Baptist pastors.. It is definately not just my opinion.
All people disregarding who the books are written to and in what dispensations are going to have serious theological chaos. Which is what we see all around us.
So modern day Christians may have faith without works and have living faith?
 
Top