• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

The Spiritual Life of Infants

Anthony Pritchard

Well-Known Member
hat does the dirt have to do with Adam’s behavior?
If he hadn’t sinned, he would be perfectly whole and still made of the dirt.
This is a new one for me. I’ve heard the devil made me do it. I’d never before heard the ground made me do it.
Adam’s flesh was not cursed or corrupt before sin. Dirt isn’t the reason for sin.

I have to admit Ben, your comment gave me a chuckle.

For years I've heard:

"The devil made me do it."

This may be the first time I've encountered:

"The ground made me do it."
 

Martin Marprelate

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I am not inserting an age of accountability into Romans 7.

I am reading the words that are already there:

"I was alive without the law once: but when the commandment came, sin revived, and I died."

You say I am adding words to the text, yet I have merely quoted the text and asked what it means.
I think you'll find you are. Paul does not mention childhood or infancy; he mentions a time when he was alive without the law. You have assumed that he means when he was an infant, but the text nowhere states that - and by nowhere, I mean nowhere in the whole Bible.
Paul does not say, "I thought I was alive."

He does not say, "I discovered I was dead."

He says he was alive, the commandment came, sin revived, and he died.

Ephesians 2:3 must be true, but Romans 7:9 must also be true. Appealing to Ephesians 2 does not explain Paul's sequence in Romans 7.

My question remains the same:

If Paul was spiritually dead from conception onward, what does "and I died" mean?
In 15 minutes I am off to take a church service, and I have a busy week with meetings and a talk to give on William Tyndale. There is a meaning to the verse, but it will not be found by bouncing up and down on it as if it were a trampoline. You might consider verse 8: 'For without the law, sin is dead.' What does that mean?
I will try to post something during the coming week, and perhaps together we can discover exactly what Paul means.
 

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
I think you'll find you are. Paul does not mention childhood or infancy; he mentions a time when he was alive without the law. You have assumed that he means when he was an infant, but the text nowhere states that - and by nowhere, I mean nowhere in the whole Bible.

In 15 minutes I am off to take a church service, and I have a busy week with meetings and a talk to give on William Tyndale. There is a meaning to the verse, but it will not be found by bouncing up and down on it as if it were a trampoline. You might consider verse 8: 'For without the law, sin is dead.' What does that mean?
I will try to post something during the coming week, and perhaps together we can discover exactly what Paul means.
Well, the alternative is that Paul lost his salvation.
At what point was Paul alive and and then sin revived and he died?
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
The OP misunderstands Rom 7:9. Paul was not saying that he was spiritually alive then died spiritually and then was made spiritually alive again.

Infants are not born spiritually alive (although they are without sin until they sin). Adam was not created spiritually alive (although he was upright and sinless until he sinned).

There are two categories of life in the Bible. These are "flesh" and "spirit". "Flesh" is temporary. All flesh will die, will not inherit God's kingdom. Spiritual life it everlasting. One who is spiritually alive can never die spirituality (Jesus IS this Life).

@Van is absolutely correctabput Paul's meaning in the verse.

Paul did not explain that Gentiles who were not under the Law were spiritually alive. If this were true then the Law was nor a benefit to the Jews (killing men spiritually).

The topic of infants is debatable as the Bible gives no detailed explanation (and why would it as the Bible is not here to answer all of our questions).


I believe that infants are like Adam prior to his sin. Adam was made fleah rather than spirit (1 Cor). He was upright, sinless, before he sinned (obviously). Then he sinned and came under condemnation. All flesh will perish and not inherit the kingdom of God.

Infants are without sin. They are not condemned for sinning but they are flesh. I believe that God saves them. But this is based on the nature of God rather than actual passages. It is opinion.
 

Dave G

Well-Known Member
Dave, which of the infants discussed in this thread have "used deceit" with their tongues, have "feet swift to shed blood," or have consciously lived with "no fear of God before their eyes"?
All of us.
Just because an infant is not old enough to fully understand and "sin with gusto", in no way absolves them of being born sinners with Adam's stain upon them.

According to God's word, they sin as soon as they are born, and they know that they're doing it.
Romans 3 describes accountable sinners actively practicing sin.
Anthony, it describes all of us, infant to elderly...
The Lord there is making no distinction.
All of us sin, and much of the time we don't even know to what extent we're really doing it. In fact, this is demonstrated when the Lord tells rebellious Israel, through His prophet Jeremiah:

" Can the Ethiopian change his skin, or the leopard his spots? [then] may ye also do good, that are accustomed to do evil." ( Jeremiah 13:23 ) <---- We are so accustomed to doing evil, that we don't even realize how bad it is, from God's point of view.

On another point:

" But the scripture hath concluded all under sin, that the promise by faith of Jesus Christ might be given to them that believe." ( Galatians 3:22 ).

Do you see it yet?
The language, in "legal terms", is right there.
Again, He's concluded all under sin, that He might save them that believe:
Let's see something else that He has to say:

" Verily, verily, I say unto you, He that heareth my word, and believeth on him that sent me, hath everlasting life, and shall not come into condemnation; but is passed from death unto life." ( John 5:24 ).

What can be clearly understood from the above?
That anyone outside of this process, from God's point of view, does not have everlasting life and shall come into condemnation, and have not passed from death to life.
My point to those reading this?

Be glad that you have believed on Christ, because the alternative is told to us in no uncertain terms... right in His word.
 
Last edited:

Dave G

Well-Known Member
@Anthony Pritchard

The Scriptures spell out one fact that most professing Christians seem to overlook ( and that sinful men themselves will certainly champion by saying "I'm not that bad!" ):

All of us actively practice sin....from birth to death we reject God and His ways, apart from being born again and apart from salvation through Jesus Christ and the indwelling of the Holy Spirit.
The Lord makes it clear to His people exactly what He has rescued them from...

Themselves, which is why He is willing to show His wrath and to make His power known.
He hates sinners, not just the sins that they commit ( Psalm 5:5, Psalm 11:5 ).
It is His holiness and hatred of sins and sinners that has caused Him to enlarge Hell, and to cast them into the Lake of Fire.
Do you not see this? I do.

I thought that by giving you some of what God has to say on the matter, it would cause you to re-visit His word and take all of it into account;
Apparently it has not, and apparently you seem fixed on defending what the Scriptures do not teach, that "God makes exceptions" when it comes to His judgement of anyone.

My friend, in the end, the saved are judged according to what Jesus did for them;
The lost ( infants, the young, the middle-aged, elderly, etc. ) are judged according to their works ( Revelation 20 ).
I'm sorry sir, but where the Bible speaks, I speak. Where it's silent, I won't go.
But in this case?

It's not silent, and it definitely does not provide for anything outside of belief and repentance on the part of anyone if they are to be forgiven of their sins and to be found among His elect.



That said, I will make this my last reply in the thread and wish all who read this, well.
May God bless you all in your studies... and be prepared to have popular teachings and oft-repeated beliefs challenged and put to the test the more that you do.
 
Last edited:

Anthony Pritchard

Well-Known Member
I will try to post something during the coming week, and perhaps together we can discover exactly what Paul means.
Paul meant exactly what Paul said, or rather, God meant exactly what God had Paul say.

So let us begin with what was actually said before we begin discussing what it might have meant.

You are correct that Paul does not mention infancy or childhood in Romans 7:9. Paul describes a sequence of events:

"I was alive without the law once: but when the commandment came, sin revived, and I died."

The burden is not on me to prove that Paul was speaking of infancy. The burden is on all of us to explain the sequence Paul gives.

Notice that I am not adding words to the text. In fact, I am resisting the addition of words.

Paul does not say:

"I thought I was alive."

Nor does he say:

"I discovered I was dead."

Nor does he say:

"I realized I had always been spiritually dead."

Nor does he say:

"I merely became aware of my condition."

He says:

"I was alive."

Then:

"The commandment came."

Then:

"Sin revived."

Then:

"I died."

The interpretation must account for every element in Paul's sequence.

Appealing to Ephesians 2:3 by itself does not solve the difficulty. Ephesians 2:3 must be true, but Romans 7:9 must also be true. The question remains: if Paul was spiritually dead in exactly the same sense from conception onward, what event is being described by the words, "and I died"?

You also draw attention to verse 8:

"For without the law sin was dead."


I agree that this verse deserves careful consideration. However, it strengthens rather than weakens the point.

Paul presents a parallel sequence:

Without the law, sin is dead.

When the commandment comes, sin revives.

Likewise:

Paul was alive.

Then the commandment came.

Then sin revived.

Then he died.

The language of revival necessarily carries a condition different from the one that followed. Whatever interpretation is adopted must explain why Paul chose the words "alive," "revived," and "died," rather than language describing awareness, realization, or discovery.

The discussion has to begin with what Paul actually says, not with what our theological systems require him to have meant.

If Paul meant, "I only thought I was alive," then he was fully capable of saying so.

If Paul meant, "I only discovered that I had always been dead," he was fully capable of saying so.

Instead, under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, he wrote:

"I was alive without the law once: but when the commandment came, sin revived, and I died."

Before we discuss what Paul meant, we must first account for what Paul said.
 

Anthony Pritchard

Well-Known Member
At what point is sin dead?
You ask, "At what point is sin dead?"

Paul appears to answer that question himself:

"For without the law sin was dead" (Romans 7:8).

Then, in the very next verse:

"I was alive without the law once: but when the commandment came, sin revived, and I died."

Notice that Paul links these statements together.

Without the law:

Sin was dead.

Paul was alive.

Then the commandment came:

Sin revived.

Paul died.

Therefore, if the question is, "At what point is sin dead?" the corresponding question must be, "At what point was Paul alive?"

The same passage that says sin was dead also says Paul was alive.

The same event that caused sin to revive also caused Paul to die.

The sequence is inseparable.


If "sin was dead" does not mean sin was nonexistent, then "I was alive" cannot simply be dismissed as meaningless either. Both phrases must be interpreted consistently and according to the argument Paul is making.

The question remains:

If Paul was spiritually dead in exactly the same sense from conception onward, what changed when the commandment came?

Paul's answer is:

"Sin revived, and I died."
 

Anthony Pritchard

Well-Known Member
All of us.
This objection has already been addressed multiple times in this thread, and the replies continue to repeat assertions that have already been answered.

At some point, discussion becomes circular rather than productive.

I have adequately explained my position and responded to the relevant scriptural arguments. Readers can evaluate the exchange and draw their own conclusions.

Not every objection requires an endless series of replies, and this particular line of discussion has reached that point.

Therefore, I will not be responding further to this specific objection.
 

Ascetic X

Well-Known Member
All of us.
Just because an infant is not old enough to fully understand and "sin with gusto", in no way absolves them of being born sinners with Adam's stain upon them.

According to God's word, they sin as soon as they are born, and they know that they're doing it.

You grossly misrepresent fetuses, babies, and children as being deliberate sinners who willfully and knowingly rebel against God, before they even know about God or morality.

In your view, abortion would be just getting rid of a sinner.

But Jesus had a very different view of children. If children are such vile sinners, why did Jesus command us to be like children or we will not make it to heaven?


Matthew 18:3

and said, “Verily I say unto you, unless ye be converted and become as little children, ye shall not enter into the Kingdom of Heaven.
 

Martin Marprelate

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
You ask, "At what point is sin dead?"

Paul appears to answer that question himself:

"For without the law sin was dead" (Romans 7:8).

Then, in the very next verse:

"I was alive without the law once: but when the commandment came, sin revived, and I died."
So sin was alive at one point, then dead, and then it came back to life? Is this just in Paul's life or in everyone's life? Hmm. Maybe thinking about the earlier chapters of Romans, including 5:12-14, will help.
With great respect, I think these things are much deeper than you are allowing for. As I wrote above, I'd like to take a little time to prepare an answer and not just to 'shoot from the hip.' So forgive me if I don't reply again for a while, while I consider these things.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
@Anthony Pritchard

You are focusing on one verse. Read Romans. You will find you made a slight error by applying Romans 7:9 to spiritually dying. Remember these chapter abd verse divisions were made by men to make referencing easier.

NOW...to be fair...arguments can be made for this supporting an age of accountability (but has to be applied not just to the Law). But there is no biblical support for a human being dying spiritually.
 

Anthony Pritchard

Well-Known Member
So sin was alive at one point, then dead, and then it came back to life? Is this just in Paul's life or in everyone's life? Hmm.
Paul is not teaching that sin literally died and then came back to life, any more than he is teaching that sin is a living person.

Throughout Romans, sin is personified. Sin deceives. Sin reigns. Sin kills.

The issue is not whether sin exists.

The issue is imputation.

IMPU'TED, participle passive - Charged to the account of. (Noah Webster)

Romans 5:13 states:

"For until the law sin was in the world: but sin is not imputed when there is no law."

Notice that sin was present, yet not imputed. It was not charged to a person's account.

Therefore, the presence of sin and the imputation of sin are not identical concepts.

We are conceived in sin. On that point there is no disagreement.

The question is when sin is imputed. When it is charged to our account.

When Paul writes, "without the law sin was dead," he is not teaching that sin ceased to exist. Romans 5:13 explicitly states that sin was in the world. The issue is not the presence of sin, but the imputation of sin.

Then:

"When the commandment came, sin revived, and I died."

Death is separation.

Paul does not say sin died.

Paul says, "I died."

The death occurs in Paul, not in sin.

The issue is not the existence of sin. The issue is the point at which sin is brought to account.

That is entirely consistent with Romans 5:13, where sin is present but not imputed when there is no law.

Paul's sequence remains unchanged:

"I was alive."

"The commandment came."

"Sin revived."

"I died."

The death is personal. It is Paul's.

Therefore the question remains:

What changed when the commandment came?

Paul does not say, "I discovered that I had always been dead."

He says:

"Sin revived, and I died."
 
Last edited:

Anthony Pritchard

Well-Known Member
@Anthony Pritchard

You are focusing on one verse. Read Romans. You will find you made a slight error by applying Romans 7:9 to spiritually dying. Remember these chapter abd verse divisions were made by men to make referencing easier.

NOW...to be fair...arguments can be made for this supporting an age of accountability (but has to be applied not just to the Law). But there is no biblical support for a human being dying spiritually.
I am not focusing on one verse. That is a mischaracterization.

I have repeatedly cited Romans 5:13 along with Romans 7:8-9.

Romans 5:13 states:

"For until the law sin was in the world: but sin is not imputed when there is no law."

Romans 7:9 states:

"I was alive without the law once: but when the commandment came, sin revived, and I died."

The presence of sin, the imputation of sin, the coming of the commandment, and Paul's statement that he died are all part of the same discussion.

You also state that there is no biblical support for a human being dying spiritually.

Yet Adam was told:

"For in the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die." (Genesis 2:17) - Another verse as I see we are counting them.

Adam did not physically die that day.

Likewise, Paul writes:

"And you hath he quickened, who were dead in trespasses and sins" (Ephesians 2:1). Yet another verse I have used, as I see we are counting them.

QUICK'ENED, participle passive - Made alive; (Noah Webster)

And:

"And you, being dead in your sins..."
(Colossians 2:13). And another I have cited.

In both passages, the people addressed were physically alive, yet Scripture describes them as dead.

Returning to Romans 7:9, Paul says:

"I was alive."

"The commandment came."

"Sin revived."

"I died."


That was not physical death, and Paul was obviously alive when he wrote Romans.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
I am not focusing on one verse. That is a mischaracterization.

I have repeatedly cited Romans 5:13 along with Romans 7:8-9.

Romans 5:13 states:

"For until the law sin was in the world: but sin is not imputed when there is no law."

Romans 7:9 states:

"I was alive without the law once: but when the commandment came, sin revived, and I died."

The presence of sin, the imputation of sin, the coming of the commandment, and Paul's statement that he died are all part of the same discussion.

You also state that there is no biblical support for a human being dying spiritually.

Yet Adam was told:

"For in the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die." (Genesis 2:17) - Another verse as I see we are counting them.

Adam did not physically die that day.

Likewise, Paul writes:

"And you hath he quickened, who were dead in trespasses and sins" (Ephesians 2:1). Yet another verse I have used, as I see we are counting them.

QUICK'ENED, participle passive - Made alive; (Noah Webster)

And:

"And you, being dead in your sins..." (Colossians 2:13). And another I have cited.

In both passages, the people addressed were physically alive, yet Scripture describes them as dead.

Returning to Romans 7:9, Paul says:

"I was alive."

"The commandment came."

"Sin revived."

"I died."


That was not physical death, and Paul was obviously alive when he wrote Romans.
You forgot that context when you interpreted - IF I understood your post correctly - the passage to mean Paul (and infants) die spiritually because of the Law.

Now...you are right about an age of accountability (the "age of innocence" being before we come to a "knowledge of good and evil", when we were "alive apart from the law").

But you are wrong that this is spiritually dying. Men do not die spiritually. Men are born flesh, conceived in sin. But innocent.

Paul speaks of two deaths - death sin produces due to the law and death that we experience to the law

What death do we experience to the law - a spiritual death or a physical death? Neither. This is not the context of Paul's words.

Once you have a knowledge of good and evil you die. Once you are born of the Spirit you die. This is not physical or spiritual death.

If you never came to a knowledge of good and evil your sin would not produce death. You would not even know you were "naked". Sin would not be imputed. Once you come to know good and evil you cease being alive and die. Once you are saved you die to the law and to sin.
 

Anthony Pritchard

Well-Known Member
You forgot that context when you interpreted - IF I understood your post correctly - the passage to mean Paul (and infants) die spiritually because of the Law.

Now...you are right about an age of accountability (the "age of innocence" being before we come to a "knowledge of good and evil", when we were "alive apart from the law").

But you are wrong that this is spiritually dying. Men do not die spiritually. Men are born flesh, conceived in sin. But innocent.

Paul speaks of two deaths - death sin produces due to the law and death that we experience to the law

What death do we experience to the law - a spiritual death or a physical death? Neither. This is not the context of Paul's words.

Once you have a knowledge of good and evil you die. Once you are born of the Spirit you die. This is not physical or spiritual death.

If you never came to a knowledge of good and evil your sin would not produce death. You would not even know you were "naked". Sin would not be imputed. Once you come to know good and evil you cease being alive and die.
It appears we agree on several important points:

- There is an age of innocence.
- There is a time when one is alive apart from the law.
- There is a coming of the knowledge of good and evil.
- Sin is not imputed where there is no law.

That is substantial agreement.

The remaining disagreement concerns the meaning of death.

Scripture uses death in more than one sense.

Genesis 2:17 "But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it: for in the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die."

Ephesians 2:1 "And you hath he quickened, who were dead in trespasses and sins;".

QUICK'ENED, participle passive - Made alive (Noah Webster 1828).

Colossians 2:13 " And you, being dead in your sins and the uncircumcision of your flesh, hath he quickened together with him, having forgiven you all trespasses;".

Romans 6:11 "Likewise reckon ye also yourselves to be dead indeed unto sin, but alive unto God through Jesus Christ our Lord.".

Romans 7:4 "Wherefore, my brethren, ye also are become dead to the law by the body of Christ; that ye should be married to another, even to him who is raised from the dead, that we should bring forth fruit unto God.".

Colossians 3:3 "For ye are dead, and your life is hid with Christ in God.".

In each case, the person addressed is physically alive, yet Scripture speaks of death.

Death in Scripture is fundamentally separation.

Physical death is the separation of the spirit from the body.

Spiritual death is separation from God.

The second death is eternal separation from God.

Adam was told he would die in the day he ate of the forbidden fruit (Genesis 2:17). Yet he did not physically die that day. Something else occurred that day.

Likewise, the unbeliever is described as dead IN trespasses and sins (Ephesians 2:1; Colossians 2:13), though physically alive.

The believer is described as dead unto sin (Romans 6:11).

The believer is described as dead to the law (Romans 7:4).

The believer is also described as dead, dead TO sin, dead to the law, and dead, with his life hid with Christ in God. If death means separation, then the believer is spiritually separated from sin and separated from the law, while at the same time being united to Christ and alive unto God (Romans 6:11; Romans 7:4; Colossians 3:3).

Scripture repeatedly speaks of living people as dead and of dead people as alive.

In other words, Scripture repeatedly speaks of people who are physically alive yet separated, and of people who were separated but are now alive.

A man who dies physically does not cease to exist. Rather, his spirit is separated from his body.

Likewise, a person who is spiritually dead has not ceased to exist. He is separated from God.

When Adam sinned, he did not physically die that day. Yet God said he would die in that day. Adam was separated from God.

The unbeliever is described as dead, spiritually separated from God in trespasses and sins, though physically alive, that is soul, body and spirit intact.

The believer is described as alive unto God, in union with God, not spiritually separated from Him, though living in the same physical body.

The believer is also described as dead to sin, dead to the law, and dead, with his life hid with Christ in God. He is spiritually dead, that is separated from sin, the law and his life hid with Christ in God.

Scripture therefore uses death and life in relational terms, not merely biological ones.

Death is separation.
  • Adam died = separated from God.
  • The unbeliever is dead in sins = separated from God.
  • The believer is dead to sin = separated from sin.
  • The believer is dead to the law = separated from the law.
  • The believer is alive unto God = united to God.
  • The second death = eternal separation from God.
  • Life is union.
Physical death separates the spirit from the body.
Spiritual death separates man from God.
The second death is eternal separation from God.

When Scripture speaks of death, the question is not whether the person exists.

The question is: separated from what?

Therefore, Scripture itself does not limit death to physical death.

Returning to Romans 7:9, because that is the central theme of the argument:

"I was alive."
"The commandment came."
"Sin revived."
"I died."


That was not physical death, because Paul was very much alive when he wrote Romans.

Scripture consistently uses death to describe separation and changed relationship.

For that reason, I see no biblical basis for excluding spiritual death from Romans 7:9.
 
Top