• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Exactly what is a Fundamental?

Salty

20,000 Posts Club
Administrator
In another thread - this statment was made:
"If you are a Fundamental Baptist ... They hold to some Calvinistic doctrines but are not a Reformed

So exactly what is a Fundamental?

What must they believe ? What would he NOT ever believe?

(examples, Communion, Eternal Security, Evolution, KJO, Membership in a denomination, Santa Clause, ect
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
In another thread - this statment was made:
"If you are a Fundamental Baptist ... They hold to some Calvinistic doctrines but are not a Reformed

So exactly what is a Fundamental?

What must they believe ? What would he NOT ever believe?

(examples, Communion, Eternal Security, Evolution, KJO, Membership in a denomination, Santa Clause, ect
IBF churches I have visited (which have only been a few) were fairly the same as most SBC churches in main doctrines. The difference (again, from the ones I experienced) is they were very legalistic and KJVO.

They were a lot like the Pharisees in that they created rules in order to enforce principles commanded in Scripture.

One was like a cult. Gave me the creeps.

Another was very good, apart from the Pharisee part. And it was evident God was working through that church.


And if you don't believe in Santa he will not come (which will reinforce your disbelief). :Biggrin
 

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
In another thread - this statment was made:
"If you are a Fundamental Baptist ... They hold to some Calvinistic doctrines but are not a Reformed

So exactly what is a Fundamental?

What must they believe ? What would he NOT ever believe?

(examples, Communion, Eternal Security, Evolution, KJO, Membership in a denomination, Santa Clause, ect
By the original definition of fundamentalist, you don’t need to be a Baptist. A fundamentalist in the past has included many different denominations. In the early 1900s the Bible Institute of Los Angeles put out a series of articles in 12 volumes titled “The Fundamentals.” The preface is as follows.

PREFACE


In 1909 God moved two Christian laymen to set aside a large sum of money for issuing twelve volumes that would set forth the fundamentals of the Christian faith, and which were to be sent free to ministers of the gospel, missionaries, Sunday School superintendents, and others engaged in aggressive Christian work throughout the English speaking world. A committee of men who were known to be sound in the faith was chosen to have the oversight of the publication of these volumes. Rev. Dr. A. C. Dixon was the first Executive Secretary of the Committee, and upon his departure for England Rev. Dr. Louis Meyer was appointed to take his place. Upon the death of Dr. Meyer the work of the Executive Secretary devolved upon me. We were able to bring out these twelve volumes according to the original plan. Some of the volumes were sent to 300,000 ministers and missionaries and other workers in different parts of the world. On the completion of the twelve volumes as originally planned the work was continued through The King's Business, published at 536 South Hope St., Los Angeles, California. Although a larger number of volumes were issued than there were names on our mailing list, at last the stock became exhausted, but appeals for them kept coming in from different parts of the world. As the fund was no longer available for this purpose, the Bible Institute of Los Angeles, to whom the plates were turned over when the Committee closed its work, have decided to bring out the various articles that appeared in The Fundamentals in four volumes at the cheapest price possible. All the articles that appeared in The Fundamentals, with the exception of a very few that did not seem to be in exact keeping with the original purpose of The Fundamentals, will be published in this series.


R. A. TORREY

The most popular additions of “The Fundamentals” come in four volumes.
Topics include higher criticism; the mosaic authorship of the Pentateuch; fallacies of the higher criticism; science, and the Christian faith; the recent testimony of archaeology to the Scriptures; three peculiarities of the Pentateuch which are incompatible with the Graf-Wellhausen theories of its composition, early narratives of Genesis; the inspiration of the Bible – definition, extent, and proof; is there a God?; The deity of Christ; the Virgin birth of Christ; the God-Man.

And the list goes on. That’s not even half of them. In the greater part, it was an answer to a higher criticism, which was popular in the early 1900s and late 1800s.
A fundamentalist is just somebody who believes the Bible for what it says. Someone who engages in higher criticism is not a fundamentalist.

That is the term historically. That’s not how it gets used today. But that is how it should be used.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
By the original definition of fundamentalist, you don’t need to be a Baptist. A fundamentalist in the past has included many different denominations. In the early 1900s the Bible Institute of Los Angeles put out a series of articles in 12 volumes titled “The Fundamentals.” The preface is as follows.



The most popular additions of “The Fundamentals” come in four volumes.
Topics include higher criticism; the mosaic authorship of the Pentateuch; fallacies of the higher criticism; science, and the Christian faith; the recent testimony of archaeology to the Scriptures; three peculiarities of the Pentateuch which are incompatible with the Graf-Wellhausen theories of its composition, early narratives of Genesis; the inspiration of the Bible – definition, extent, and proof; is there a God?; The deity of Christ; the Virgin birth of Christ; the God-Man.

And the list goes on. That’s not even half of them. In the greater part, it was an answer to a higher criticism, which was popular in the early 1900s and late 1800s.
A fundamentalist is just somebody who believes the Bible for what it says. Someone who engages in higher criticism is not a fundamentalist.

That is the term historically. That’s not how it gets used today. But that is how it should be used.
Yes. I remember when the SBC churches were fundamentalists.

But the identifier "fundamental" stopped meaning biblical fundamentals of the faith and started being associated with legalism and, to speak plainly, with hate.

Today "fundamental" means following a set of trafitions and is seen most often being expressed negatively towards any Christian that does not share those traditions.

For example, often "fundamental baptist" is associated with BJU. This university comdemned interracial dating and marriages until 2000. Why? Racist tradition. True fundamental churches ditched "fumdamental" long before 2000 because of this type of thing.

I do not believe "fundamental" will ever mean "biblical fundamentals of the faith" again. The word is too tarnished. It has meant tradition, racism, KJVOism, and legalism for too long (outside of IFB churches).

I do not mean all IFB churches are that way. But the ones that stand out in our communities are the bad ones (hopefully the minority) and, as is common, the bad ones give the whole a bad name.
 

timf

Active Member
Today "fundamental" means following a set of trafitions and is seen most often being expressed negatively towards any Christian that does not share those traditions.
One can understand how at the beginning of the 20th century the influence through the large increase in colleges at the end of the 19th century of secular ideas of Marxism, Darwinism, and Freud eroding the faith of many.

That there would be a defensive reaction might be seen as similar to the desire to defend the faith with creeds or other declarations to assert what is true. There can be a problem with this defensive posture as it can impose limitations on the defender.

Here is a brief article that touches on this;

Bunker Christianity

There have been historical times of opposition and even persecution where Christians have responded defensively. The term “fundamentalism” comes from a series of booklets called the Fundamentals written 100 years ago in response to the rising tide of secularism seen with Darwin, Freud, and Marx enthusiastically taken up in colleges as an alternative to Christianity.

Hymns like “Onward Christian Soldiers” often resonate with a desire for a militant engagement with the world that can foster either a defensive ossification or alternatively a prideful bellicosity. However, Christians are rather called to be prepared to give a reason for the hope that is within them.

Christians under siege can react to perceived threat with fear and anger which weakens faith in their Savior and a strengthens of faith in themselves (the flesh). This usually happens when walking in truth and humility seems uncertain and being “right” seems a more concrete position. Being “right” usually means adherence to doctrines, rituals, traditions, and practices of men. Walking in truth usually means a humble surrender to the work of the Holy Spirit and unreserved trust in Jesus.

Being “right” may manifest in creeds, organizational systems, crusades, seminaries, and even inquisitions. Walking in truth often seems to engender a passivity that may lead anywhere from being ignored to being burned alive. Adversity usually exposes the limitations of being “right”. A person may cling to a particular bible translation, an achievement such as having made Jesus Lord of his life or baptism, a tradition such as generations of denominational faithfulness, or faithful adherence to a practice such as Sabbath or dietary observances, however, ultimately being “right" elevates self and walking in truth brings us closer to him who is truth.

Christians who have sought the comfort of security in a defensive position often find themselves contending with other Christians over various elements of doctrine, bible versions, prayer formats, color of choir robes, or any deviation from what has been defined as “right”. Often sermons from this vantage point carry the theme of how bad everyone else is and how good we are.

Christianity was always intended to be transcendent to the world, not promoting it, entangled with it, or in the case of “bunker" Christianity even sniping at it. There is a book hundreds of years old called, “The Practice of the Presence of God” by a Brother Lawrence. Brother Lawrence could not often be called “right”, but what he shows is a simple and complete faith in God. In a way, his various errors are useful in demonstrating by contrast how little faith depends on intellectual achievement, meticulous practice, or getting things exactly “right”.

Satan has always had success getting humans to try to take control of things. When driven into a defensive posture, we often become vulnerable to this temptation by thinking we are contending for the faith by attacking other Christians or fighting their error. Christians are called to exhort, encourage, even admonish but most of all to love other Christians. When under attack or even put to death, our God is not so weak as to need us to fight the world or each other.
 

Ascetic X

Well-Known Member
There is a book hundreds of years old called, “The Practice of the Presence of God” by a Brother Lawrence. Brother Lawrence could not often be called “right”, but what he shows is a simple and complete faith in God. In a way, his various errors are useful in demonstrating by contrast how little faith depends on intellectual achievement, meticulous practice, or getting things exactly “right”.
….. When under attack or even put to death, our God is not so weak as to need us to fight the world or each other.
I am curious as to what you consider wrong in The Practice of the Presence of God.

We actually do fight the world system, we vigorously combat the spiritual forces in the world.

Ephesians 6:12

For we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world, against spiritual wickedness in high places.
 

timf

Active Member
I am curious as to what you consider wrong in The Practice of the Presence of God.
Brother Lawrence says that even if he was in hell, he would sing praises to God. While an laudable sentiment, it might not be sound doctrine. His background was Roman Catholic although I am not sure to what extent he was aware of or followed all the doctrine.
 

Ascetic X

Well-Known Member
Brother Lawrence says that even if he was in hell, he would sing praises to God. While a laudable sentiment, it might not be sound doctrine. His background was Roman Catholic although I am not sure to what extent he was aware of or followed all the doctrine.
I see nothing wrong with Brother Lawrence saying if he was in hell, he would sing praises to God.

We should praise God no matter where we may be.

Apostle Paul goes even farther. Is this sound doctrine?

Romans 9:3

For I could wish that I myself were accursed from Christ for the sake of my brethren, my kinsmen according to the flesh,
 

Armchair Apologist

Well-Known Member
Essential doctrines:

1. Inspiration of the scriptures
2. Virgin Birth and deity of Christ
3. Substitutionary atonement
4. Bodily resurrection
5. Literal second coming
6. Total depravity (original sin, fall of Adam, Etc.)
7. Authenticity and validity of miracles

A fundamentalist will stand for, fight for, and defend these essential doctrines and will separate themselves from anyone who denies these doctrines.

This is historic fundamentalism.
 

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Essential doctrines:

1. Inspiration of the scriptures
2. Virgin Birth and deity of Christ
3. Substitutionary atonement
4. Bodily resurrection
5. Literal second coming
6. Total depravity (original sin, fall of Adam, Etc.)
7. Authenticity and validity of miracles

A fundamentalist will stand for, fight for, and defend these essential doctrines and will separate themselves from anyone who denies these doctrines.

This is historic fundamentalism.
Well said. The last two points are not usually mentioned as fundamentals of the faith, but I understand your inclusion of them.

And you are completely correct that a fundamentalist will defend the fundamentals. The movement is not just a matter of believing in the fundamentals. All born again Christians should accept those doctrines.
 

Armchair Apologist

Well-Known Member
Well said. The last two points are not usually mentioned as fundamentals of the faith, but I understand your inclusion of them.
I try to be as careful and precise regarding #6 regarding total depravity and original sin otherwise people come out with their guns loaded and start arguing about Calvinism or whatever.

Fact of the matter is that Adam's fall is the very reason for God's plan of redemption of which the scriptures address from Genesis to Revelation. Do away with the fall and the gospel completely loses its relevance!
And you are completely correct that a fundamentalist will defend the fundamentals. The movement is not just a matter of believing in the fundamentals. All born again Christians should accept those doctrines.
I believe it is important to draw a clear line between Historic Fundamentalism and what I often call "Hysteric Funny-Mental-ism!" Historic fundamentalism is what I have described. Hysteric funny-mental-ism throws that all aside and starts arguing over musical styles, dress and grooming standards, going to the "Movie House, dancing, the wicked liquor industry, Bible versions, and so forth! Such are so loud with their nonsense that this is all the world sees regarding "Fundamental Christianity" and completely sidetracks us from focusing on where the real fight needs to be!
 

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I try to be as careful and precise regarding #6 regarding total depravity and original sin otherwise people come out with their guns loaded and start arguing about Calvinism or whatever.
Right. I believe in what I believe in a biblical doctrine of total depravity, but not total inability.
Fact of the matter is that Adam's fall is the very reason for God's plan of redemption of which the scriptures address from Genesis to Revelation. Do away with the fall and the gospel completely loses its relevance!
Right. So maybe the Gospel should be added to any list of fundamental doctrines.
I believe it is important to draw a clear line between Historic Fundamentalism and what I often call "Hysteric Funny-Mental-ism!" Historic fundamentalism is what I have described. Hysteric funny-mental-ism throws that all aside and starts arguing over musical styles, dress and grooming standards, going to the "Movie House, dancing, the wicked liquor industry, Bible versions, and so forth! Such are so loud with their nonsense that this is all the world sees regarding "Fundamental Christianity" and completely sidetracks us from focusing on where the real fight needs to be!
I get your point, but a biblical doctrine of personal separation was part of original fundamentalism. I could give scholarly sources on that, but don't have time right now. Here is a point from a lecture on fundamentalism I give in one class:

D. Personal separation is the position of taking a stand against the world and its temptations and traps (1 John 2:15-17).
1. The Greek word usually translated “world” in the New Testament is kosmos (κόσμος), meaning the system of the culture of the world that we see all around us.
2. As fundamentalists, by “world” we mean the activities and pleasures that are part and parcel of Satan’s culture.
3. This is a matter of personal soul liberty. Each Christian has the privilege and duty of deciding for him or herself what is spiritually damaging. Thus, standards of personal separation are not what we break fellowship with other Christians over, unless we deem their position to be damaging to us, our family, or our church, such as CCM, alcohol consumption, etc.
4. Having said that, when we are part of an institution (church, mission board, etc.), it is only right to adhere to the particular standards of that institution.
 

Armchair Apologist

Well-Known Member
Right. I believe in what I believe in a biblical doctrine of total depravity, but not total inability.
Yes, getting into such nuances is outside the scope of the historic fundamentals and is strictly an "intramural" discussion.
Right. So maybe the Gospel should be added to any list of fundamental doctrines.
I would say that each of the fundamentals I listed are laser-focused upon the gospel of Christ. Being correct in each of these fundamentals equates to the clarity of the gospel you are proclaiming.
I get your point, but a biblical doctrine of personal separation was part of original fundamentalism. I could give scholarly sources on that, but don't have time right now. Here is a point from a lecture on fundamentalism I give in one class:

D. Personal separation is the position of taking a stand against the world and its temptations and traps (1 John 2:15-17).
1. The Greek word usually translated “world” in the New Testament is kosmos (κόσμος), meaning the system of the culture of the world that we see all around us.
2. As fundamentalists, by “world” we mean the activities and pleasures that are part and parcel of Satan’s culture.
3. This is a matter of personal soul liberty. Each Christian has the privilege and duty of deciding for him or herself what is spiritually damaging. Thus, standards of personal separation are not what we break fellowship with other Christians over, unless we deem their position to be damaging to us, our family, or our church, such as CCM, alcohol consumption, etc.
4. Having said that, when we are part of an institution (church, mission board, etc.), it is only right to adhere to the particular standards of that institution.
Separation from what? Personal preferences or activities and conduct which are clearly sinful? The scriptures are clear that we are to warn those who are unruly, not to have fellowship with the unfruitful works of darkness, and so forth. Such speaks of our personal holiness and sanctification but so many are fussing over whether women ought to be wearing dresses (skirts, colouttes, etc.), and whether men ought to wear a suit and tie at all times to all church activities (aside from "work days" I would guess). Many of these are a matter of counscience and they ought to be sensitive to the Lord's leading. Problem is that far too many major on all of these external standards (checking all the "boxes") and then wonder where there are so many moral failures among those seem to be in strict adherence!

I think it is human nature to often go through the motions and justify ourselves for doing so while failing to deal with specific heart matters which may place us in grave danger!

I think we are largely in agreement here.
 
Top