• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

The Chosen

Mike B

Well-Known Member
I've watched the first four seasons of this show, and now the fifth and final season has
begin.

No doubt some others here have watched it, as well. I'd appreciate your thoughts on
the show, and how you feel about the message it sends.
 

Ascetic X

Well-Known Member
I've watched the first four seasons of this show, and now the fifth and final season has
begin.

No doubt some others here have watched it, as well. I'd appreciate your thoughts on
the show, and how you feel about the message it sends.
It is a horrible travesty.

The Chosen distorts the gospels by adding ridiculous fictional events, that are sometimes crude, perverse, and unseemly.

A vast majority of the show's dialogue, character arcs, and backstories are fictionalized rather than pulled directly from Scripture. By adding fictional details to "fill in the gaps" can lead viewers—especially children and people unfamiliar with the gospels—to mistake these human inventions for actual biblical accounts.

The show heavily humanizes Jesus and the disciples, depicting Christ as exhausted, uncertain, seeking support from His mother Mary, joking, practicing sermons, or needing advice from others (such as Matthew). Critics argue this diminishes His divinity and majesty.


1. Jesus saying, "I am the law of Moses."

In the gospels, Jesus never said this.


2. Jesus supposedly transgresses (i.e. sins).


3. The writers have Jesus saying, “Some things even I cannot do.”

In The Chosen, Jesus jokes in Season 2 that there are things he cannot do, such as turning a poor dancer into a good one. This fictional, casual, lighthearted moment, in response to Simon's request, is not in keeping with the true personality of Jesus.

We should not imagine Jesus as being a comedian who makes fun of people.


4. Jesus practices His sermons, welcomes advice, and worries about how the audience will react.


5. Mary Magdalene says she first saw Jesus in a tavern, then goes on to say, "He put his hand on mine", adding, "which is not what it sounds like". She recommends that John leave that part out of his book, so people don't get confused... just another way The Chosen creates questions and doubts.


6. Adding questionable things into the storylines (Mary being a prostitute, Simon becoming a spy for the Romans, Roman undercover agent sent to spy on Jesus and his followers, peter’s wife miscarries and is cold and hateful towards her husband, Jesus will raise Jairus’s daughter from the dead, yet he will not raise Peter’s unborn child from the dead.)


7. The feeding of the 5000 is portrayed wrong. The Bible says Jesus went up to a mountain, and taught His disciples. The Chosen has him on a plain, teaching the big group.


8. Focusing on feelings and the heart (Jesus asking Nicodemus, "what does your heart tell you?")

Remember, the Bible says, "the heart is deceptively wicked".

Later in the series, Jesus says, "Soon it'll all be about the heart”. The Chosen distorts the gospel with such mystical new age teachings.


9. Nicodemus kneels at Jesus’ feet and Jesus stops him, telling Nicodemus he doesn't need to worship Him. But Jesus is God and He deserves worship.


10. In the portrayal of the story of the men who bring the paralytic to Jesus, The Chosen has "Tamar" (who is a fictional, made-up character in the series) leading the way, and it’s made clear this is all her idea.

Mary Magdalene reproves Simon when he attempts to stop them from coming through the roof (which would not have been her place in that culture).

Instead of Jesus affirming the faith of the men who brought the man for healing, The Chosen's Jesus commends the faith of the women instead. That’s not being faithful to Scripture, that’s pushing an agenda.


11. Jesus refusing to heal Little James (This contradicts the Scripture that says Jesus healed all who came to Him.)


12. Throughout the series, disciples are running around with notepads and writing down hearsay that will become their supposed Biblical books.

In one case, a woman runs by crying, "He healed me!"

Matthew, in desperation, calls her saying, "Healed you of what?"

The show attempts to deny the inspiration of Scripture, portraying the gospels as common books comprised of hearsay.


13. According to The Chosen, John 21:25 came from Mary Magdalene and not John himself. In their rewritten gospel, The Chosen Mary Magdalene plays an oddly feministic role for that time period.


14. The Chosen's John the Baptist is arrogant, disrespectful, and always questioning Jesus.


15. The Chosen's John the Baptist tells Jesus he is planning on marching into Herod's palace to tell him off, and then adds, "My followers will love it."

This isn’t what happened! In the Bible, John stated, "I must decrease", so why does The Chosen portray him as arrogant?

In one scene, Jesus says he is not ready to get into specifics, and in a flippant voice John the Baptist responds, “You appear to not be ready to get into the specifics on a lot of things”.

In a previous discussion, Jesus speaks to John the Baptist regarding incest and adultery, saying, "I understand it is against the law of Moses, but I am here for bigger purposes than breaking rules".

This gives the impression from “Jesus” that John, who is about to confront Herod, is uninspired and even foolhardy—and that “Jesus” doesn’t care about the Ten Commandments.

While John the Baptist disrespects Christ, Peter disrespects John the Baptist, calling him "Creepy John".

In the show, Peter and his brother describe John the Baptist, saying, “Behold the Lamb of God which taketh away the sin of the world”—and do so in a way that destroys the beautiful solemnity of that moment. Peter's brother begins, “He said ‘behold’...” and Peter interjects, “I am eating a bug”. This lame, sacrilegious attempt at humor ridicules John's recognition of Jesus as the Messiah and undermines the whole message—including Christ’s divinity.

In the show, Peter comes up to Jesus and says he will go with Him to the ends of the earth, a reference to Luke 22:33. Biblically speaking, this was a monumental point in the conversion of Peter.

But in The Chosen, this moment is destroyed when “Jesus” responds, “I hope so Simon, but I seem to remember there was a problem... something about Andrew's feet.”

This is disgusting. Peter had an unconverted heart that would make it impossible for him to keep his promise to Christ, yet viewers of The Chosen will never know how Jesus reveals the truth to him.

The show subtly distorts the Bible, belittles Christ, and is a subtle error of a most disturbing nature.

16. In The Chosen, season 4 Thomas is betrothed to a woman named Ramah. A Roman soldier stabs her, killing her.

Jesus looks at Thomas, who was pleading with Jesus to heal her wound, and Jesus says “She really loved you!” Jesus does not heal Ramah, because he states "it is not her time.”
  • At many points in the Gospel, we’re told that Jesus healed “all” or “every” sick person that he encountered [e.g. Matthew 4:24, Matthew 8:16-17, Matthew 14:36; Mark 6:56; Luke 6:19].
  • The Bible specifically mentions Jesus raising the dead [e.g. Mark 5:21-43; Luke 7:11-17; John 11].
  • When the Bible explicitly describes Jesus not doing miracles, it is in response to unbelief [e.g. Matthew 5:38].
  • The Bible does not mention Jesus withholding miracles due to timing.
  • Therefore, the decision to have Jesus refuse to heal Ramah in Episode 3 is biblically inaccurate.


17. In Season 4, Episode 5 of The Chosen, Mother Mary washes Jesus' hair in a tender, intimate scene highlighting his humanity and their mother-son bond. Amidst rising frustrations and the burdens of his ministry, this absurd fictional moment makes Jesus look like He needs to confide in his mother, which is not biblical or likely. Mary did not seem to understand His mission, and once thought He was out of touch with reality.

Mark 3:21

When his family heard about this, they went to take charge of him, for they said, “He is out of his mind.”

Jesus went off to lonely secluded places to confide in His Father when Jesus needed support or comfort.


18. In the show, many Biblical characters are depicted as drunks.

The first encounter with Nathanael portrays him as a drunkard and a failed architect (Nathanael is just one of the misrepresented biblical characters). Circumstances prompt him to drown out his failure in the pub, a common backdrop in the series.

Why would the show present Nathanael in such a light when Jesus Himself declared, “Behold an Israelite indeed, in whom is no guile”? This show would lead us to believe that these things are compatible with Christianity.



19. To bring God down to our level, The Chosen includes a scene where Jesus prepares a sermon and rehearses well-known passages, making them feel more human and common than inspired by His Father.

His mother interrupts him during one of these rehearsals, and you can see the frustration in his eyes.

During this same interaction with Jesus and Mary, she says, "I'm proud of you" to which this supposed Jesus replies, “Maybe wait to say that until after I’m done, in case I mess up in front of such a big crowd.”

20. One of the worst scenes is where a Roman soldier thrusts a sword into Thomas’s wife.

Jesus refuses to heal her, and simply says “She really loved you.”

That scene is a bizarre event that never happened.
 

JohnDB

Member
I have a friend who loves the show....
He knows I can't stand it....

I get it.

Doesn't mean that I don't hate what it does to some of the "whispers" of scripture that hold so much meaning.....

Currently I'm wondering what they are going to do with Simon of Cyrene. (The siphium dealer)

If you don't know....silphium WAS a combination aphrodisiac and effective abortifacient. Essentially the famous "abortion herb" and on the Via de la rosa that spot is at the herb market at the prime spot.
And the soldiers picked him because he was the abortion seller. He, and others just like him, made it possible for the soldiers wives to cheat on them at home.
 

Ascetic X

Well-Known Member
I have a friend who loves the show....
He knows I can't stand it....

I get it.

Doesn't mean that I don't hate what it does to some of the "whispers" of scripture that hold so much meaning.....

Currently I'm wondering what they are going to do with Simon of Cyrene. (The siphium dealer)

If you don't know....silphium WAS a combination aphrodisiac and effective abortifacient. Essentially the famous "abortion herb" and on the Via de la rosa that spot is at the herb market at the prime spot.
And the soldiers picked him because he was the abortion seller. He, and others just like him, made it possible for the soldiers wives to cheat on them at home.
I do not think the Bible calls Simon of Cyrene a silphium dealer, but he might have been. The theory based on this possibility is interesting.

I doubt The Chosen would weave that into their narrative.

Silphium was a versatile herb. Its resin (known as laser or laserpicium) and stalks were used as a luxury food seasoning, animal feed enhancer, perfume, and multi-purpose medicine (treated for coughs, sore throats, and fevers). Ancient Mediterranean cultures (including the Greeks and Romans) widely used silphium as an effective herbal birth control and abortifacient.
 

JohnDB

Member
I do not think the Bible calls Simon of Cyrene a silphium dealer, but he might have been. The theory based on this possibility is interesting.

I doubt The Chosen would weave that into their narrative.

Silphium was a versatile herb. Its resin (known as laser or laserpicium) and stalks were used as a luxury food seasoning, animal feed enhancer, perfume, and multi-purpose medicine (treated for coughs, sore throats, and fevers). Ancient Mediterranean cultures (including the Greeks and Romans) widely used silphium as an effective herbal birth control and abortifacient.
But Cyrene was the epicenter of Silphium trade...
It was so important that Cyrene coins had a silphium plant stamped on them. Yes, there was a Jewish community there....but if Cyrene and their chief product was not significant....why mention where Simon was from at all? Why would it be relevant if he lived in Jerusalem now?
The herb market is just around the corner from the large gate and large walkway to the crossroads....(place of the skull) golgotha.


This herb was consumed into extinction..... just like the papyrus plant was harvested into extinction.

And you gotta remember LOTS of political garbage is getting tossed into the mix anymore and has for some time. Abortion is a highly political subject. And bringing a definite answer like this from scriptures on the subject spells trouble for a LOT of people who would prefer it not be brought up.
 

Mike B

Well-Known Member
Currently I'm wondering what they are going to do with Simon of Cyrene. (The siphium dealer)

With respect, as has been addressed, your accusations are purely presumptuous, and
based solely on his place of residence.

And the soldiers picked him because he was the abortion seller. He, and others just like him, made it possible for the soldiers wives to cheat on them at home.

Again, pure presumption and innuendo. It amazes me what the motivated imagination can dream up.

I was in sales in the 1980's, and lived in Van Nuys California, which was arguably the center of the
crack cocaine trade back then. I never sold crack cocaine.
 

JohnDB

Member
With respect, as has been addressed, your accusations are purely presumptuous, and
based solely on his place of residence.



Again, pure presumption and innuendo. It amazes me what the motivated imagination can dream up.

I was in sales in the 1980's, and lived in Van Nuys California, which was arguably the center of the
crack cocaine trade back then. I never sold crack cocaine.
EVERY gospel that discusses him mentions where he was from.

Now in today's writing, sure, you would have a great point...and it would not be a relevant fact.

But this is scripture where there is not one jot, tittle, or crumb of extra information written or given...ever. EVERY WORD IS PRECIOUS because of the cost of every single word written.

Ready to give up 3 months salary just to write a short book like a gospel account? Probably 6 months salary for just a copy of one. Tiny writing too....tiny for that time period because nobody had glasses.

Paper was an extremely laborious process to produce even if it was animal skins (leather) used to form a scroll. Most was papyrus....and it was still expensive. In fact parents writing letters to their children would include sheets of blank paper with their letters so they could write back.
And there existed a whole used paper market where paper was erased and made able to be used to write again on it.

Ink also wasn't cheap. Because simple charcoal and water would not survive the journey of delivery. Iron powder and other similar materials were used because it worked better. And it also was expensive.

These gospel accounts were written 2,000 years ago on the other side of the planet in a vastly different culture and world. There are few similarities with our modern culture. And if you haven't done deep-dive anthropology studies....you are missing out...especially if you think series like the Chosen is accurate in any fashion. The ONLY thing they get halfway correct is the clothing...

In the end, the guy is from Silphium headquarters...in the spice market....but isnt involved with silphium?
Yeah....I'm gonna say its too many coincidences to ignore.
 

JohnDB

Member
@Mike B I'm not really expecting to change your mind on the subject...
But I did appreciate the opportunity to more fully explain the situation.

God is the Giver/Creator of ALL life....

Some don't believe that. I get that....but don't agree with that either...
 

Kai

Well-Known Member
I watched it until I couldn't anymore.

My main issue with the show is that some parts are deliberately left open to interpretation as an appeal to audiences from all denominations.

For example, the scene in which Jesus calls Peter “the rock” is presented in such a way that could lead some to believe him established as the pope.
 
Last edited:

Ascetic X

Well-Known Member
EVERY gospel that discusses him mentions where he was from.

………

These gospel accounts were written 2,000 years ago on the other side of the planet in a vastly different culture and world. There are few similarities with our modern culture. And if you haven't done deep-dive anthropology studies....you are missing out...especially if you think series like the Chosen is accurate in any fashion. The ONLY thing they get halfway correct is the clothing...

In the end, the guy is from Silphium headquarters...in the spice market....but isnt involved with silphium?
Yeah....I'm gonna say its too many coincidences to ignore.
I have heard this theory before, that Simon of Cyrene was an abortion-inducing herb farmer or sales rep. And yes, the Roman soldiers might have been hostile to anyone connected with the silphium trade, or who merely lived where it was grown. Forcing Simon of Cyrene to carry the cross makes a lot of sense in that imagined context.

All it would take for certainty is for the scripture to say: “Simon of Cyrene, silphium dealer” in the text.

So we can say this is hinted at, but not explicitly stated. It is a very interesting concept and could be true, but like what Jesus wrote on the ground, we can have convincing speculation, but no hard irrefutable evidence.

Luke 23:26 notes that Simon was "coming in from the country" when Roman soldiers seized him. Some commentators take this literally to suggest he was an agricultural worker or lived on a rural estate outside Jerusalem, rather than being a wealthy international silphium merchant.
 

atpollard

Well-Known Member
[sigh]
Sometimes I miss being a drug trafficker in a gang … Christians are so much meaner spirited than godless criminals.
(as a criminal, only the enemy wanted to kill me)
 
Top