Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!
It is a horrible travesty.I've watched the first four seasons of this show, and now the fifth and final season has
begin.
No doubt some others here have watched it, as well. I'd appreciate your thoughts on
the show, and how you feel about the message it sends.
It is a horrible travesty.
I do not think the Bible calls Simon of Cyrene a silphium dealer, but he might have been. The theory based on this possibility is interesting.I have a friend who loves the show....
He knows I can't stand it....
I get it.
Doesn't mean that I don't hate what it does to some of the "whispers" of scripture that hold so much meaning.....
Currently I'm wondering what they are going to do with Simon of Cyrene. (The siphium dealer)
If you don't know....silphium WAS a combination aphrodisiac and effective abortifacient. Essentially the famous "abortion herb" and on the Via de la rosa that spot is at the herb market at the prime spot.
And the soldiers picked him because he was the abortion seller. He, and others just like him, made it possible for the soldiers wives to cheat on them at home.
But Cyrene was the epicenter of Silphium trade...I do not think the Bible calls Simon of Cyrene a silphium dealer, but he might have been. The theory based on this possibility is interesting.
I doubt The Chosen would weave that into their narrative.
Silphium was a versatile herb. Its resin (known as laser or laserpicium) and stalks were used as a luxury food seasoning, animal feed enhancer, perfume, and multi-purpose medicine (treated for coughs, sore throats, and fevers). Ancient Mediterranean cultures (including the Greeks and Romans) widely used silphium as an effective herbal birth control and abortifacient.
Currently I'm wondering what they are going to do with Simon of Cyrene. (The siphium dealer)
And the soldiers picked him because he was the abortion seller. He, and others just like him, made it possible for the soldiers wives to cheat on them at home.
EVERY gospel that discusses him mentions where he was from.With respect, as has been addressed, your accusations are purely presumptuous, and
based solely on his place of residence.
Again, pure presumption and innuendo. It amazes me what the motivated imagination can dream up.
I was in sales in the 1980's, and lived in Van Nuys California, which was arguably the center of the
crack cocaine trade back then. I never sold crack cocaine.
I have heard this theory before, that Simon of Cyrene was an abortion-inducing herb farmer or sales rep. And yes, the Roman soldiers might have been hostile to anyone connected with the silphium trade, or who merely lived where it was grown. Forcing Simon of Cyrene to carry the cross makes a lot of sense in that imagined context.EVERY gospel that discusses him mentions where he was from.
………
These gospel accounts were written 2,000 years ago on the other side of the planet in a vastly different culture and world. There are few similarities with our modern culture. And if you haven't done deep-dive anthropology studies....you are missing out...especially if you think series like the Chosen is accurate in any fashion. The ONLY thing they get halfway correct is the clothing...
In the end, the guy is from Silphium headquarters...in the spice market....but isnt involved with silphium?
Yeah....I'm gonna say its too many coincidences to ignore.
The city gate is just around the corner...I have heard this theory before, that Simon of Cyrene was an abortion-inducing herb farmer or sales rep. And yes, the Roman soldiers might have been hostile to anyone connected with the silphium trade, or who merely lived where it was grown. Forcing Simon of Cyrene to carry the cross makes a lot of sense in that imagined context.
All it would take for certainty is for the scripture to say: “Simon of Cyrene, silphium dealer” in the text.
So we can say this is hinted at, but not explicitly stated. It is a very interesting concept and could be true, but like what Jesus wrote on the ground, we can have convincing speculation, but no hard irrefutable evidence.
Luke 23:26 notes that Simon was "coming in from the country" when Roman soldiers seized him. Some commentators take this literally to suggest he was an agricultural worker or lived on a rural estate outside Jerusalem, rather than being a wealthy international silphium merchant.
What people?The city gate is just around the corner...
Literally.
Its not a residential section.
The spice market is unique in that it is more like temporary stalls than a regular shop front with a home built as the second floor....
Also very narrow, short dead end street....a cul-de-sac.
All the streets are narrow except for the last one to the gate. (That one is wide)
In the book of Mark it lists his children's names too. Its not like the guy wasn't a resident and unknown to everyone. They knew his kids too.
Which is why "of Cyrene" becomes more and more significant. Why list his home city as significant if he is living in Jerusalem with his family?
Then theres the whole "community pride" thing that is absolutely lost on us today. (Westernized mindset)
Silphium trade was so significant to Cyrene, the plant was stamped into their money. Which was a significant deviation from the regular coins of the Roman Empire. Meaning everyone was at least tangentially involved with the silphium trade.
Ephesus was really proud of its Diana Temple.....moreso than its tradition of having all the bankers. Which we today find odd....even though the port city's port was filling up with silt and was essentially useless for most ships... it remained a banking hub even though its port became useless. Kinda like NYC docks....mostly usused but the city was still a banking hub. (I'm hearing that taxes have driven out the banks...so I don't know what they are going to do now)
Cyrene HAD a major and significant Jewish community....(not all Jews lived in Israel) but weren't considered Hellenistic Jews.
Catching Simon coming in...meant that his shop was attended by someone...who could tend it a little longer by the soldier's reasoning.
People hate this idea of Simon being a Silphium dealer.
Why is it upsetteing? Who is them?Its very very upsetting to them. They want blatant, obvious answers....maybe a 11th Commandment "Thou shalt not commit abortion" (as if the scriptures don't already speak about God creating all life, giving children to barren mothers and etc)
So what are you 'buying'? What is the mustard seed that is too big to ignore?Personally, I see the clarity....the shock and horror of carrying the cross piece....
God, in his infinite wisdom, had Jesus's time spent on earth walking among us extremely choreographed out with a minutia of details all worked out... Jesus taught and spoke constantly with everything He did. When He chose to sleep could be a lesson and often was....from eating with the short Tax Collector Chief to taking a nap in the boat going across Lake Tiberias (almost small enough to be called a pond)
So....
Somehow during the midst of one of the defining moments of Jesus's earthly tour an average guy who has zero significance in any fashion is chosen to carry the cross piece.
I'm not buying that. I can't. That mustard seed is too big to ignore.
People who are desiring to use abortion, have used or have advocated for abortions in the past.What people
People love to justify themselves. Everyone believes they are right....ALWAYS.Why is it upsetteing? Who is them?
You really have serious issues with Metaphors, Similes and hyperbole...how is it you understand any scriptures whatsoever? How come you don't understand average American speech?So what are you 'buying'? What is the mustard seed that is too big to ignore?
What is the great truth you are trying to show us by you thinking Simon the Cyrene was a Silphium dealer?
The truth of Simon being a silphium dealer but carrying the cross piece of Jesus's crucifixion....that is symbolic of being one of the worst sinners....over and above the Pharisees, Sadducees, the Grammitons (experts in the law or scribes) or any of the others....it's obscene how horrific that position is.
The idea that Simon was a silphium dealer is not truth, it is speculation.The truth of Simon being a silphium dealer but carrying the cross piece of Jesus's crucifixion....that is symbolic of being one of the worst sinners....over and above the Pharisees, Sadducees, the Grammitons (experts in the law or scribes) or any of the others....it's obscene how horrific that position is.
And that is the problem.When this program first came out, I began watching the first episode. I watched the first episode and was disappointed. I felt the vast majority of it was nothing more than historical fiction based on little scripture. I have friends who watch this series and they think it's historically accurate.
I would have to say that one of the greatest biblical movies ever made was The Greatest Story Ever Told. I remember seeing it on Okinawa when I was in the 4th or 5th grade. I researched some facts about his movie. I read that 75%-80% were based on the Gospels, while 20%-25% consisted of historical fiction, dramatic embellishments, and composite characters. Almost all of the dialogue for Jesus were verbatim quotes from the King James Version Bible.And that is the problem.
People will have the fiction etched in their mind as truth.
I was in a men’s Bible study where we watched some of The Chosen.
After the video, we discussed it. I was disturbed when guys would talk about events that are not in scripture as though they were. I protested, but they continued to discuss fictional scenes as if they were in the gospels.