• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Faith # 8

Brightfame52

Well-Known Member
Gods Power causes us to believe in Jesus, the truths of His Gospel Isa 53:1

Who hath believed our report? and to whom is the arm of the Lord revealed?

Eph 1:19

19 And what is the exceeding greatness of his power to us-ward who believe, according to the working of his mighty power,

1 Tim 3:16

16 And without controversy great is the mystery of godliness: God was manifest in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, seen of angels, preached unto the Gentiles, believed on in the world, received up into glory.[Christ being believed on in the world is a Mystery of Godliness]

1 Pet 1:21

21 Who by him do believe in God, that raised him up from the dead, and gave him glory; that your faith and hope might be in God.

Eph 1:12

12 That we should be to the praise of his glory, who first trusted in Christ.

My Synthesis :




God's Sovereign Power Causes Us to Believe the Gospel! (Isaiah 53:1, Ephesians 1:19, 1 Timothy 3:16 & 1 Peter 1:21)

Saving faith in Jesus Christ and the truths of His Gospel never originates from fallen man's natural ability. From beginning to end, God's own mighty power causes His elect to believe! Look at the plain witness of Scripture:

1. Believing the Gospel Report Requires "The Arm of the Lord Revealed" (Isaiah 53:1)

Isaiah 53:1 — "Who hath believed our report? and to whom is the arm of the LORD revealed?"
  • Notice how the Holy Spirit links believing the Gospel report directly to the revelation of the Arm of the LORD—the sovereign, omnipotent power of God! Without the Almighty Arm of the LORD exerted in Phase III (The Vital Phase — Regeneration), no fallen sinner ever believes the report (compare John 12:37–38; Romans 10:16).
2. Believing Is Produced by the Exceeding Greatness of God's Power (Ephesians 1:19)

Ephesians 1:19 — "And what is the exceeding greatness of his power to us-ward who believe, according to the working of his mighty power,"
  • Paul explicitly declares that our ongoing believing ("to us-ward who believe") operates "according to the working of his mighty power"—the exact same omnipotent resurrection power that raised Jesus Christ from the dead (Ephesians 1:20)!
3. Christ Being Believed On in the World Is a Mystery of Godliness (1 Timothy 3:16)

1 Timothy 3:16 — "And without controversy great is the mystery of godliness: God was manifest in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, seen of angels, preached unto the Gentiles, believed on in the world, received up into glory."
  • Look at what stands right alongside God being manifest in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, and received up into glory: "believed on in the world"! That fallen sinners in this hostile world ever believe on Christ is not a triumph of human free will—it is a supernatural "mystery of godliness" wrought by God Himself!
4. We Believe in God Only "By Him" — To the Praise of His Glory (1 Peter 1:21 & Ephesians 1:12)

1 Peter 1:21 — "Who by him do believe in God, that raised him up from the dead, and gave him glory; that your faith and hope might be in God."
Ephesians 1:12 — "That we should be to the praise of his glory, who first trusted in Christ."
  • Notice those two decisive words in 1 Peter 1:21: "by him"! We do not believe on our own strength—it is by Christ (on the ground of His finished blood in Phase II: The Legal Phase, applied by His Spirit in Phase III: The Vital Phase) that we believe in God in Phase IV (The Practical Phase — Conversion)!
  • And why has God ordained that our trusting in Christ comes 100% from His power? "That we should be to the praise of his glory" (Ephesians 1:12)!
The Bottom Line

If man believed by his own natural power, man would share the glory. Because the Arm of the LORD reveals Christ (Isaiah 53:1), God's mighty power produces faith (Ephesians 1:19), and we believe solely "by him" (1 Peter 1:21), all the glory belongs to God forever! 37
 

Brightfame52

Well-Known Member
Faith to believe in Christ is given by the victorious Christ to His People He won the victory for, by His Suretyship obedience for them. 1 Jn 5:4

For whatsoever is born of God overcometh the world: and this is the victory that overcometh the world, even our faith.

Plainly Faith cometh from being born of God, its fruit of the Spirit Gal 5:22. Being born of God is from the obedience of Christ and His victory, and He giveth them He died for the victory by giving them new birth 1 Cor 15:57

But thanks be to God, which giveth us the victory through our Lord Jesus Christ.

This victory which brings Faith, we overcome Rev 12:11

11 And they overcame[victory] him by the blood of the Lamb, and by the word of their testimony; and they loved not their lives unto the death.

This connects Faith, by which the born of God receive victory 1 Jn 5:4 with the blood of the Lamb ! He giveth us the victory/Faith !

Here is my expanded Synthesis:

Saving Faith Is the Gift of the Victorious Christ to the People He Won the Victory For! (1 John 5:4, Galatians 5:22, 1 Corinthians 15:57 & Revelation 12:11)


Faith to believe in Jesus Christ never originates from fallen man's natural free will. Saving faith is given by the victorious Christ to His elect people—the very ones for whom He won the victory by His Suretyship obedience and blood!

Look at how Scripture links Christ's victory, the New Birth, and saving faith into one unbreakable chain:
1. Saving Faith Comes From Being Born of God—It Is the Fruit of the Spirit (1 John 5:4 & Galatians 5:22)

1 John 5:4 — "For whatsoever is born of God overcometh the world: and this is the victory that overcometh the world, even our faith."
  • Plainly, faith comes from being born of God (Phase III: The Vital Phase — Regeneration), never the other way around! Notice the order: first a soul is born of God, and out of that new birth comes the victory that overcomes the world—even our faith (Phase IV: The Practical Phase — Conversion)!
  • That is why Paul lists faith explicitly as the fruit of the Spirit (Galatians 5:22: "But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, longsuffering, gentleness, goodness, faith"). Dead flesh cannot produce the fruit of the Spirit (John 3:6).
2. The New Birth and Faith Flow Directly From Christ's Victory for Those He Died For (1 Corinthians 15:57)
  • Where does this New Birth come from? From the obedience of Christ and His finished victory at Calvary (Phase II: The Legal Phase)!
  • Having conquered sin, death, and Satan on behalf of all those given to Him in Phase I (The Eternal Phase), the risen Christ bestows that victory upon every single soul for whom He died by giving them the New Birth (1 Corinthians 15:57):
    1 Corinthians 15:57 — "But thanks be to God, which giveth us the victory through our Lord Jesus Christ."
3. Faith Overcomes Because It Is Grounded in the Blood of the Lamb (Revelation 12:11)
  • Look at how Revelation 12:11 connects the overcoming victory of faith (1 John 5:4) directly to the blood of the Lamb:
    Revelation 12:11 — "And they overcame [gained the victory over] him by the blood of the Lamb, and by the word of their testimony; and they loved not their lives unto the death."
  • Notice that! The same victory by which those born of God overcome the world through faith (1 John 5:4) is explicitly grounded in the blood of the Lamb (Revelation 12:11)! Because Christ shed His blood as their Surety and won their legal victory at the cross (Phase II: The Legal Phase), He infallibly imparts the New Birth (Phase III: The Vital Phase) and gives them saving faith (Phase IV: The Practical Phase) so they share His triumph forever (Phase V: The Final Phase — Glorification)!
The Bottom Line

Man does not generate faith to make Christ's cross victorious. Jesus Christ won the victory by His Suretyship obedience and blood—and He freely gives that victory to all for whom He died by granting them the New Birth and the gift of faith (1 John 5:4; 1 Corinthians 15:57; Revelation 12:11)!


 

LaGrange

Active Member
Hi Brightfame,

First I want to thank you for laying out the causes of justification in your phase system. I’ve been studying it. I’ve also been studying you last posts you made in Faith #7. I’ve also been working on a couple of possible future threads.

Free Will

I would like to understand your view of free will a little better. With all of my comments below, I’m asking you the same thing over and over again in different ways. I am asking you to agree that the use of man’s free Will is necessary at the effectual call. Sometimes you say “we believe” in a sentence but I’m not so sure. To my knowledge, all Calvinists believe free Will is necessary but it’s just that they describe how it works in a different way from us. You don’t seem to want to say that. With high calvinists, maybe it’s different. In this post, It looks like you want to say God alone causes belief in us. I just need you to clarify that statement if you don’t mind. If you clarify it now, you don’t need to answer many of my comments below. When you do, we can then move forward.

Consider these two sources:

The 1646 Westminster Confession of Faith

Effectual Call (WCF 10.1)

“All those whom God hath predestinated unto life, and those only, He is pleased, in His appointed and accepted time, effectually to call, (Rom. 8:30, Rom. 11:7, Eph. 1:10–11) by His word and Spirit, (2 Thess. 2:13–14, 2 Cor. 3:3,6) out of that state of sin and death, in which they are by nature to grace and salvation, by Jesus Christ; (Rom. 8:2, Eph. 2:1–5, 2 Tim. 1:9–10) enlightening their minds spiritually and savingly to understand the things of God, (Acts 26:18, 1 Cor. 2:10,12, Eph. 1:17–18) taking away their heart of stone, and giving unto them an heart of flesh; (Ezek. 36:26) renewing their wills, and, by His almighty power, determining them to that which is good, (Ezek. 11:19, Phil. 2:13, Deut. 30:6, Ezek. 36:27) and effectually drawing them to Jesus Christ: (Eph. 1:19, John 6:44–45) yet so, as they come most freely, being made willing by His grace. (Cant. 1:4, Ps. 110:3, John 6:37, Rom. 6:16–18)”

Turretin, Institutes of Elenctic Theology, 15.14.16

“Hence it appears that man is not like a log and a trunk in his regeneration, as our opponents falsely charge upon us. (1) The will is the receptive (dektikon) subject of grace; this cannot be said of a trunk. (2) The Spirit does not force the will and carry it on unwillingly to conversion, but glides most sweetly into the soul (although in a wonderful and ineffable manner, still most suitably to the will) and operates by an infusion of supernatural habits by which it is freed little by little from its innate depravity, so as to become willing from unwilling and living from dead.”

My Comment: My interpretation is that this “willingness” begins with the assent (drawing up) by irresistible grace (Phase 2) to apprehend the faith. So man is moving his own free will (his willingness) also with God moving him (by His grace) and it begins before Faith and conversion. It continues afterward too.

Gods Power causes us to believe in Jesus, the truths of His Gospel Isa 53:1

Who hath believed our report? and to whom is the arm of the Lord revealed?

My Comment: You said: “Gods Power causes us to believe”

This verse isn’t about God’s power per se, it’s about Unbelief. It’s about who has received the “revelation” of His power. It’s about Christ being revealed.

Is 53:1 means:
Who hath believed our report? = who has believed the things about Christ which we have heard?
and to whom is the arm of the Lord revealed? = who has recognized or been shown Christ’s saving power?

Answer: Not many (Is 53:2-4).

This describes Unbelief. There are more than one kind of Unbelief:
1. Resisting Faith - You can have unbelief by resisting Faith by refusing to hear it or by despising it. This Unbelief is a sin.
2. Absence of Faith (Negation) - You can also have Unbelief because you have not heard the Faith or have not had the opportunity to receive it. This Unbelief is not a personal sin.
The kind of Unbelief in Is 53:1 is the kind that is a sin.

The bottom line: God’s power may cause us to believe, as a first cause, but as a second cause, man has the power to resist. If you think that is pelagian, you need to cite the source. If you “resist” what you have heard about Christ (Unbelief) then it means you really heard it. You really got it with God’s Grace. You can’t “resist” something you really didn’t get, therefore, you “resisted” God’s Grace. Calvinists deny the reprobate receive grace, resist it, and THEN are reprobated. In error, they believe they never receive any grace.

Eph 1:19

19 And what is the exceeding greatness of his power to us-ward who believe, according to the working of his mighty power,

My Comment: This is God’s operative power. This verse is describing those in the church. Those in the church (fully regenerated at Baptism) received a “pledge of their inheritance” (Eph 1:14). This is sanctifying Grace that Inheres (Inheres = inheritance = eternal life). We posses a down payment of this divine nature now, which includes eternal life (2 Pet 1:4, etc) . Then, Paul prays a prayer of thanksgiving (v16) and then, prays that this power (grace) “continues” to grow and work in the church (v17-18). This means it’s growth and work is conditional. It may not grow and work as well sometimes in the future. If it wasn’t conditional, why would Paul need to pray for them? When a Christian prays, that means things are conditional.

1 Tim 3:16

16 And without controversy great is the mystery of godliness: God was manifest in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, seen of angels, preached unto the Gentiles, believed on in the world, received up into glory.[Christ being believed on in the world is a Mystery of Godliness]

My Comment: This is the Incarnation.

“And without controversy great is the mystery of godliness: God was manifest in the flesh” -

Basically, this verse is saying that things were hidden until Christ’s Incarnation. Also, this is one of many cases where something that was “declared” really happened. The incarnation of Christ was “made manifest” (declared). Likewise, we are declared righteous when we really receive Christ’s righteousness (Inheres).

Manifest = Declared

5319. φανερόω phanĕrŏō, fan-er-ŏ´-o; from 5318; to render apparent (lit. or fig.):—appear, manifestly declare, (make) manifest (forth), shew (self).

1 Pet 1:21

21 Who by him do believe in God, that raised him up from the dead, and gave him glory; that your faith and hope might be in God.


My Comment: This is the Resurrection. The Redemption is shown in 1 Pet 1:18-19.

Notice: Faith and Hope are both present in believing in the resurrection (1 Pet 1:21). Charity (G25) is also present (1 Pet 1:22 - Purifying your souls in the obedience of charity). This means these three virtues continue and grow in the believer’s practice of the faith (God is not doing the believing or obeying). There are many other places in scripture where all three, in context, are close together and used together (ex: Rom 5:1-5, etc).
 

LaGrange

Active Member
Eph 1:12

12 That we should be to the praise of his glory, who first trusted in Christ.


My Comment: Hope = Trust

Faith, Hope (Rom 8:24) and Charity are all received in Phase 2 and used in Phase 3. Not just Faith. See previous verse 1 Pet 1:21-22. These are virtues, so believing is something we are doing. God is not the one doing the believing. He’s doing the moving (cooperating grace) but we’re doing the moving too, secondarily, by believing (cooperating grace).

My Synthesis :



GodM's Sovereign Power Causes Us to Believe the Gospel! (Isaiah 53:1, Ephesians 1:19, 1 Timothy 3:16 & 1 Peter 1:21)

My Comment: We know God’s power (grace) is the formal cause of justification. The question is: Does man move his own Will, along with God moving it, or is it moved by God alone? God is drawing us (John 6:44) but are we drawing ourselves too? (Phil 2:12-13, James 4:8, etc). In Phil 2:12-13, God is not doing the fearing and trembling in the working out of our salvation, therefore, in context, Phil 2:13 is both God and man working together (cooperative).

Saving faith in Jesus Christ and the truths of His Gospel never originates from fallen man's natural ability. From beginning to end, God's own mighty power causes His elect to believe! Look at the plain witness of Scripture:

My Comment: If God’s power causes us to believe and man has nothing to do with it, is man really believing? Or is God believing in Himself?

Brightfame, here’s my number one question:

At the effectual call, does man have to “willingly” come to Christ?

YES OR NO. WHY?


1. Believing the Gospel Report Requires "The Arm of the Lord Revealed" (Isaiah 53:1)


  • Notice how the Holy Spirit links believing the Gospel report directly to the revelation of the Arm of the LORD—the sovereign, omnipotent power of God! Without the Almighty Arm of the LORD exerted in Phase III (The Vital Phase — Regeneration), no fallen sinner ever believes the report (compare John 12:37–38; Romans 10:16).
2. Believing Is Produced by the Exceeding Greatness of God's Power (Ephesians 1:19)


  • Paul explicitly declares that our ongoing believing ("to us-ward who believe") operates "according to the working of his mighty power"—the exact same omnipotent resurrection power that raised Jesus Christ from the dead (Ephesians 1:20)!

My Comment: We also believe in God’s operative power

3. Christ Being Believed On in the World Is a Mystery of Godliness (1 Timothy 3:16)


  • Look at what stands right alongside God being manifest in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, and received up into glory: "believed on in the world"! That fallen sinners in this hostile world ever believe on Christ is not a triumph of human free will—it is a supernatural "mystery of godliness" wrought by God Himself!

My Comment: Is free Will necessary to come to Christ?

4. We Believe in God Only "By Him" — To the Praise of His Glory (1 Peter 1:21 & Ephesians 1:12)


  • Notice those two decisive words in 1 Peter 1:21: "by him"! We do not believe on our own strength—it is by Christ (on the ground of His finished blood in Phase II: The Legal Phase, applied by His Spirit in Phase III: The Vital Phase) that we believe in God in Phase IV (The Practical Phase — Conversion)!
  • And why has God ordained that our trusting in Christ comes 100% from His power? "That we should be to the praise of his glory" (Ephesians 1:12)!

My Comment: If Regeneration and Justification occur at Phase 2, why do you even need Phases 3 and 4? Why do you need Faith and Conversion? They seem like “effects” in your version of justification. I’m sure the Arminians have asked the same question. If you are declared Righteous and justification occurs at Phase 2, it seems like it’s a done deal. The rest, in theory, could maybe occur under that sanctification process.

Question: The Raising of Lazarus
If the effectual call (is essentially Phase 2*) is Christ calling Lazarus out (John 11:43) and also Phase 2* (John 11:44) is the raising of Lazarus, where are Phases 3 and 4? Are Phases 3 and 4 just ordinances of Phases 1-2? Is Faith and Conversion an Ordinance? I’m sure the Arminians have asked that question too.

* By the way, it seems Phases 2 and 3 overlap some - ex: Eph 2:5 - so of you want to include Phase 3 with the raising of Lazarus, that’s fine)

The Bottom Line

If man believed by his own natural power, man would share the glory. Because the Arm of the LORD reveals Christ (Isaiah 53:1), God's mighty power produces faith (Ephesians 1:19), and we believe solely "by him" (1 Peter 1:21), all the glory belongs to God forever! 37

My Comment: Follow this logic in order:
Man does not believe by his own natural power
Man’s natural power is his free Will
Man moves himself naturally by his free Will*
God moves man naturally through man’s free Will*
likewise
Man moves himself supernaturally by his free Will with God’s Grace
God moves man supernaturally by man’s free Will with His grace
ie
Man moves himself (believes) by his free Will with God’s Grace
ie
Man willingly (believes) comes to Christ by God’s grace

* first and secondary causes - God moves man first and man moves himself second. This is true in the natural world and it’s true in the supernatural world.

Which propositions are wrong?


God’s Glory

We don’t share in God’s glory by our natural power but we do share in God’s glory by His supernatural power working in us. His glory is manifested in us (Rom 5:11) because we are united to him by Faith, Hope and Charity (1 Cor 1:31, 2 Cor 10:17). When our Faith worketh through Charity (Gal 5:6), it produces fruit which gives glory to God.

Rom 2:6-7 Who will render to every man according to his works. 7 To them indeed who, according to patience in good work, seek glory and honour and incorruption, eternal life:
Rom 2:6-7 means seeking glory, honor, incorruption and eternal life beginning in this world.
 

Brightfame52

Well-Known Member
LaGrange said:
Free Will
I would like to understand your view of free will a little better. With all of my comments below, I’m asking you the same thing over and over again in different ways. I am asking you to agree that the use of man’s free Will is necessary at the effectual call. Sometimes you say “we believe” in a sentence but I’m not so sure. To my knowledge, all Calvinists believe free Will is necessary but it’s just that they describe how it works in a different way from us. You don’t seem to want to say that. With high calvinists, maybe it’s different. In this post, It looks like you want to say God alone causes belief in us. I just need you to clarify that statement if you don’t mind. If you clarify it now, you don’t need to answer many of my comments below. When you do, we can then move forward.
...
My Comment: My interpretation is that this “willingness” begins with the assent (drawing up) by irresistible grace (Phase 2) to apprehend the faith. So man is moving his own free will (his willingness) also with God moving him (by His grace) and it begins before Faith and conversion. It continues afterward too.
  1. Here is my crystal-clear clarification—and notice where your own interpretation of WCF 10.1 and Turretin slips back into Semi-Pelagian synergism:
    • Who is the conscious subject who believes? The regenerated sinner himself ("we believe" — Galatians 2:16; Romans 10:9)! God does not believe for us—we ourselves believe with our own renewed mind and will!
    • What is the sole efficient CAUSE of that believing? God alone! Look closely at the exact causal order in both WCF 10.1 and Turretin that you yourself just quoted:
      • First (Regeneration — Phase III: The Vital Phase): The Holy Spirit acts alone (monergistically) upon a spiritually dead, unwilling sinner (Ephesians 2:1, 5), taking away the heart of stone, giving a heart of flesh (Ezekiel 36:26), and renewing his enslaved will (Philippians 2:13: "For it is God which worketh in you both to will and to do of his good pleasure"). In this initial quickening, man is 100% passive—a spiritually dead corpse does not "move his own free will" alongside God to resurrect himself!
      • Second (Conversion / Effectual Calling — Phase IV: The Practical Phase): Having been made alive and given a new, willing heart by God's omnipotent grace (Psalm 110:3: "Thy people shall be willing in the day of thy power"), the newly regenerated believer now acts willingly and freely (without external coercion) in embracing Christ by faith!
    • Where your "My Comment" goes off the rails: You claim "man is moving his own free will (his willingness) also with God moving him (by His grace) and it begins before Faith and conversion." No! Before regeneration (Phase III), fallen man's will is enslaved to sin (John 8:34; Romans 8:7–8) and has zero spiritual willingness toward God! Willingness does not begin by fallen man moving his own will—willingness is created by God's monergistic New Birth (Phase III) and then exercised by the newborn soul in faith (Phase IV)!
LaGrange said:
The bottom line: God’s power may cause us to believe, as a first cause, but as a second cause, man has the power to resist. If you think that is pelagian, you need to cite the source. If you “resist” what you have heard about Christ (Unbelief) then it means you really heard it. You really got it with God’s Grace. You can’t “resist” something you really didn’t get, therefore, you “resisted” God’s Grace. Calvinists deny the reprobate receive grace, resist it, and THEN are reprobated. In error, they believe they never receive any grace.
  1. You just contradicted the Westminster Confession of Faith 10.1 that you yourself quoted three paragraphs earlier—and taught classic Semi-Pelagianism / Arminianism!
    • Look at WCF 10.1 that you just pasted: "All those whom God hath predestinated unto life, and those only, He is pleased, in His appointed and accepted time, effectually to call..."
    • Notice that WCF 10.1 explicitly teaches Unconditional Election before time (Phase I) and Effectual Calling given ONLY to the predestinated—whereas you just claimed: "Calvinists deny the reprobate receive grace, resist it, and THEN are reprobated. In error, they believe they never receive any grace"! That is conditional election based on foreseen resistance/acceptance—condemned by Romans 9:11–18 and 2 Timothy 1:9!
    • Furthermore, your claim that "You can't 'resist' something you really didn't get, therefore, you 'resisted' God's Grace" confuses receiving the outward preaching of the Gospel (Isaiah 53:1a: "Who hath believed our report?"; Romans 10:16) with receiving the inward revelation of God's saving Arm (Isaiah 53:1b: "and to whom is the arm of the LORD revealed?")! Unregenerate men hear the outward report with their physical ears and resist it (Acts 7:51), whereas 100% of those to whom the Arm of the LORD is inwardly revealed believe (John 6:44–45)!
LaGrange said:
My Comment: This is God’s operative power. This verse is describing those in the church. Those in the church (fully regenerated at Baptism) received a “pledge of their inheritance” (Eph 1:14). This is sanctifying Grace that Inheres (Inheres = inheritance = eternal life)...
Also, this is one of many cases where something that was “declared” really happened. The incarnation of Christ was “made manifest” (declared). Likewise, we are declared righteous when we really receive Christ’s righteousness (Inheres).
  1. Look at three critical Roman Catholic / Tridentine errors you just slipped into your comments on Ephesians 1:19 and 1 Timothy 3:16:
    • First, Ephesians 1:19–20 explicitly defines "the exceeding greatness of his power to us-ward who believe" as "the working of his mighty power, Which he wrought in Christ, when he raised him from the dead"! That is resurrection power creating faith in spiritually dead sinners (Colossians 2:12: "through the faith of the operation of God"), NOT an infused substance given at water baptism! Nowhere in Ephesians 1 does Paul say anyone is "regenerated at water baptism"—we are regenerated by the Holy Spirit (John 3:5–8; Titus 3:5) and sealed with the Spirit upon believing the Gospel (Ephesians 1:13)!
    • Second, you turned forensic justification into Roman Catholic "infused righteousness" ("when we really receive Christ's righteousness (Inheres)")!
      • Read Romans 4:5–6, Romans 5:19, and 2 Corinthians 5:21: justification is NOT an inherent quality infused inside us—it is God's forensic declaration in heaven's court based on Christ's obedience imputed (credited) to our legal account (Phase II: The Legal Phase), while our own inherent righteousness in this life remains stained with sin (Isaiah 64:6; Romans 7:18–25)!
    • Third, in 1 Peter 1:21, look at the exact words: "Who BY HIM do believe in God"! Even the believer's ongoing faith and hope in God exist exclusively BY HIM (through Jesus Christ's mediatorial power and grace)—never by autonomous human free-will power!
Summary:
  • In regeneration (Phase III: The Vital Phase), God acts alone upon a dead sinner to create a new heart and renewed will (Ezekiel 36:26; Philippians 2:13).
  • In conversion (Phase IV: The Practical Phase), the newly regenerated sinner willingly and freely believes (Psalm 110:3) as the fruit of God's monergistic work—not by co-operating with God prior to regeneration, and not with a libertarian power to frustrate God's effectual call (John 6:37, 44–45)!
 

Brightfame52

Well-Known Member
LaGrange said:
My Comment: Hope = Trust
Faith, Hope (Rom 8:24) and Charity are all received in Phase 2 and used in Phase 3. Not just Faith. See previous verse 1 Pet 1:21-22. These are virtues, so believing is something we are doing. God is not the one doing the believing. He’s doing the moving (cooperating grace) but we’re doing the moving too, secondarily, by believing (cooperating grace).
...
My Comment: We know God’s power (grace) is the formal cause of justification. The question is: Does man move his own Will, along with God moving it, or is it moved by God alone? God is drawing us (John 6:44) but are we drawing ourselves too? (Phil 2:12-13, James 4:8, etc). In Phil 2:12-13, God is not doing the fearing and trembling in the working out of our salvation, therefore, in context, Phil 2:13 is both God and man working together (cooperative).
  1. Look at how Philippians 2:12–13 and John 6:44 explicitly answer your question: God's monergistic work IN us (v. 13) is the sole efficient CAUSE of our working out our salvation (v. 12)!
    • Read Philippians 2:12–13 together—and notice the crucial word "FOR" (gar — because) that connects verse 13 to verse 12:
      "12 Wherefore, my beloved, as ye have always obeyed, not as in my presence only, but now much more in my absence, work out your own salvation with fear and trembling. 13 FOR [because] it is God which worketh in you both to will and to do of his good pleasure." (Philippians 2:12–13)
    • Notice that Paul is addressing already-regenerated believers ("my beloved, as ye have always obeyed"), telling them to work out (katergazesthe — carry out to completion) the salvation God has already worked in them—and WHY can they do so? "FOR [because] it is God which worketh in you BOTH TO WILL AND TO DO of his good pleasure" (v. 13)!
    • We do NOT "draw ourselves" alongside God in John 6:44! Look at John 6:44: "No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him." A spiritually dead sinner (Ephesians 2:1) has zero ability to draw himself—God alone quickens the dead soul in Phase III (The Vital Phase — Regeneration), and then the newly quickened child of God actively believes, hopes, and loves in Phase IV (The Practical Phase — Conversion) as the fruit of God's inward work (Galatians 5:22)!
LaGrange said:
Brightfame, here’s my number one question:
At the effectual call, does man have to “willingly” come to Christ?


YES OR NO. WHY?
  1. YES—100%! At the effectual call (Phase IV: The Practical Phase — Conversion), man MUST and DOES come to Christ willingly!
    • WHY? Not because fallen man brings an independent, cooperative "free will" to the table alongside God—but because in Phase III (The Vital Phase — Regeneration), the Holy Spirit sovereignly removes his stony heart of rebellion, gives him a new heart of flesh (Ezekiel 36:26), and works in him "both to will and to do of his good pleasure" (Philippians 2:13)!
    • Look at Psalm 110:3 and John 6:44–45:
      Psalm 110:3: "Thy people shall be willing in the day of thy power..."
      John 6:45: "Every man therefore that hath heard, and hath learned of the Father, cometh unto me."
    • God does not believe for us, nor does He drag an unwilling man kicking and screaming against his desires—He regenerates the dead soul so that the newly quickened believer willingly, freely, and gladly embraces Christ!
LaGrange said:
My Comment: If Regeneration and Justification occur at Phase 2, why do you even need Phases 3 and 4? Why do you need Faith and Conversion? They seem like “effects” in your version of justification. I’m sure the Arminians have asked the same question. If you are declared Righteous and justification occurs at Phase 2, it seems like it’s a done deal. The rest, in theory, could maybe occur under that sanctification process.
Question: The Raising of Lazarus
If the effectual call (is essentially Phase 2*) is Christ calling Lazarus out (John 11:43) and also Phase 2* (John 11:44) is the raising of Lazarus, where are Phases 3 and 4?
  1. First, carefully keep the exact biblical distinction between Phase II, Phase III, and Phase IV—regeneration does NOT occur in Phase II!
    • Phase I (The Eternal Phase — Election & Covenant Suretyship): God unconditionally chooses His elect in Christ before the foundation of the world (Ephesians 1:4–5).
    • Phase II (The Legal Phase — Redemption & Objective Justification at Calvary): Jesus Christ satisfies divine justice by His blood and imputed obedience, legally justifying and reconciling His elect while they are yet ungodly enemies (Romans 5:9–10, 19; 2 Corinthians 5:19, 21).
    • Phase III (The Vital Phase — Regeneration / New Birth): Because Christ's death in Phase II legally merited life for all whom He died (Romans 5:10: "much more, being reconciled, we shall be saved by his life"; Romans 8:32), the Holy Spirit imparts spiritual life to the dead soul (Ephesians 2:5; John 3:6; Titus 3:5). In John 11:43–44, Phase III is Christ's omnipotent voice imparting life to Lazarus's dead body!
    • Phase IV (The Practical Phase — Conversion: Faith & Repentance): Once made alive in Phase III, Lazarus walks out of the tomb (John 11:44)! Faith and conversion are NOT "human conditions that buy justification"—they are the vital, God-ordained fruit and experiential apprehension by which the regenerated child of God lays hold of Christ's finished righteousness (Romans 5:1, 11), enjoys conscious peace with God, and walks in good works unto Phase V (The Final Phase — Glorification)!
    • Why are Phases III and IV necessary? Because God did not merely decree to clear His elect in heaven's court—He decreed to conform them to the image of His Son (Romans 8:29), bring them into living communion with Himself (1 John 1:3), and prepare them for glory (Ephesians 2:10)! Without the New Birth (Phase III), no man can see or enter the kingdom of God (John 3:3, 5).
LaGrange said:
My Comment: Follow this logic in order:
Man does not believe by his own natural power
Man’s natural power is his free Will
Man moves himself naturally by his free Will*
God moves man naturally through man’s free Will*
likewise
Man moves himself supernaturally by his free Will with God’s Grace
God moves man supernaturally by man’s free Will with His grace
ie
Man moves himself (believes) by his free Will with God’s Grace
ie
Man willingly (believes) comes to Christ by God’s grace
  • first and secondary causes - God moves man first and man moves himself second. This is true in the natural world and it’s true in the supernatural world.
Which propositions are wrong?
  1. Look at the exact two propositions in your chain where your logic breaks down against Scripture:
    • Proposition 1 ("Man moves himself supernaturally by his free Will with God's Grace"): Fallen man's natural will is dead in sin (Ephesians 2:1) and enslaved to sin (John 8:34; Romans 8:7–8). A natural, unregenerate will cannot move itself supernaturally! Only after God sovereignly imparts a new nature and renewed will in Phase III (The Vital Phase) does the regenerated believer willingly act in faith (Phase IV)!
    • Proposition 2 (Your Roman Catholic "Cooperative Grace" model in Romans 2:6–7 & Galatians 5:6): Notice how you closed by turning Romans 2:6–7 into meriting eternal life by works ("who, according to patience in good work, seek glory and honour and incorruption, eternal life"), and calling justification "formal cause" and "infused virtues."
      • Read Romans 3:20, 28 and Romans 4:4–6: Romans 2:6–7 states the strict standard of the Law—which nobody keeps (Romans 3:9–12, 20: "Therefore by the deeds of the law there shall no flesh be justified in his sight")!
      • The sole formal/meritorious cause of our justification is NOT infused virtues inside us—it is the imputed obedience and blood of Jesus Christ alone (Phase II: The Legal Phase — Romans 5:19; 2 Corinthians 5:21)! Our good works (Galatians 5:6; Ephesians 2:10) are the fruit of salvation, never the cause or condition of eternal life!
Summary:
  • Yes, man comes to Christ willingly at the effectual call (Phase IV)—because God first makes him alive and willing by monergistic regeneration (Phase III — Psalm 110:3; Philippians 2:13).
  • Christ's finished obedience and blood (Phase II)—not infused virtues or cooperative works—is the sole ground of our justification (Romans 5:19).
 
Top