• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Exactly what is a Fundamental?

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
As a former missionary, I disagree with the notion that the SBC method is better.
I would not expect you to find another's practice better.

I can explain how the SBC churches I have been a member of does missions.

First, the SBC is made up of independent baptist churches that participate in giving to the cooperative program (a program to consolidate funds in order to support missions). SBC and IFB churches are not denominational using the normal definition as there are no organization above these churches that prescribes doctrine or exercises authority over the individual congregation. But both are denominations in a very broad use of the term (a set of common beliefs).

We have SBC sent missionaries speak at our church, we get to know them, we pray for them, etc. But they are not a part of pur congregation like those we send out from our church.

Our churches send out missionaries. Our churches participate in local missions. So does IFB churches. But SBC churches also contribute to the Cooperative Program with the intent of pooling resources for missions in addition to the missions of the individual churches.


I do not see one as better than the other. I can see how both has its advantages. Having sister congregations help when your church cannot is a blessing.

The missionaries we send out (apart from the SBC sent missionaries) are supported by the church or by raising support themselves (often both)

I prefer local church sent missionaries because the congregation has a relationship with them beforehand, know them, and are involved with sending them beyond providing resources.
 

Armchair Apologist

Well-Known Member
I would not expect you to find another's practice better.

I can explain how the SBC churches I have been a member of does missions.

First, the SBC is made up of independent baptist churches that participate in giving to the cooperative program (a program to consolidate funds in order to support missions). SBC and IFB churches are not denominational using the normal definition as there are no organization above these churches that prescribes doctrine or exercises authority over the individual congregation. But both are denominations in a very broad use of the term (a set of common beliefs).

We have SBC sent missionaries speak at our church, we get to know them, we pray for them, etc. But they are not a part of pur congregation like those we send out from our church.

Our churches send out missionaries. Our churches participate in local missions. So does IFB churches. But SBC churches also contribute to the Cooperative Program with the intent of pooling resources for missions in addition to the missions of the individual churches.


I do not see one as better than the other. I can see how both has its advantages. Having sister congregations help when your church cannot is a blessing.

The missionaries we send out (apart from the SBC sent missionaries) are supported by the church or by raising support themselves (often both)

I prefer local church sent missionaries because the congregation has a relationship with them beforehand, know them, and are involved with sending them beyond providing resources.
With the SBC cooperative programs, you have resources at the ready which will get you out to the missions field much quicker so this is a definite advantage. The disadvantage is that individual congregations give into such cooperative funds and have little to no knowledge of who receives these funds and where they are going. They are also disconnected from these individual missionaries and are therefore unable to specifically pray for them or whatever.

IFBs have to go on deputation and it will take time to go out and raise your support from individual churches but the missionary is also meeting with and getting to know the pastors, leaders, and members of the churches who will be supporting them and in many cases, they may regard them as being "extended Church family" who will read your prayer letters, will pray for you, and so forth. There are a few other downsides such as if a church decides to drop you, it will directly affect your actual support and may place you in a hardship situation.
 

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I would not expect you to find another's practice better.

I can explain how the SBC churches I have been a member of does missions.

First, the SBC is made up of independent baptist churches that participate in giving to the cooperative program (a program to consolidate funds in order to support missions). SBC and IFB churches are not denominational using the normal definition as there are no organization above these churches that prescribes doctrine or exercises authority over the individual congregation. But both are denominations in a very broad use of the term (a set of common beliefs).

We have SBC sent missionaries speak at our church, we get to know them, we pray for them, etc. But they are not a part of pur congregation like those we send out from our church.

Our churches send out missionaries. Our churches participate in local missions. So does IFB churches. But SBC churches also contribute to the Cooperative Program with the intent of pooling resources for missions in addition to the missions of the individual churches.


I do not see one as better than the other. I can see how both has its advantages. Having sister congregations help when your church cannot is a blessing.

The missionaries we send out (apart from the SBC sent missionaries) are supported by the church or by raising support themselves (often both)

I prefer local church sent missionaries because the congregation has a relationship with them beforehand, know them, and are involved with sending them beyond providing resources.
No offense, but you really did not have to tell me how the SBC does missions: went to language school with the SBC men, 33 years on the field, have preached a Lottie Moon offering in an SBC church, currently teaching two missions classes in our college and two classes in our seminary, etc. etc.

And I remain convinced that deputation is the best way to support missionaries. I did it myself, and have advised many of our young missionaries (6 on deputation from our church).
 

Salty

20,000 Posts Club
Administrator
As a former missionary,....
I fully understand your thinking of IB missionaries - (I have been invovled with several IB churches over the years - and that system.
However, I wonder how many missionary candidates never made it to the field because they were not able to raise the support.

Also - you mentioned the ratio of missionaries per church - but for IB churches - how many fully support one missionary / what % of a missionary do they support. In addition, if a church falls short of its support - how often have they not sent full support - or not sent any at all. In addition, when a church closes - the missionary looses that support - and if he is overseas - kinda hard to make up that loss.

Granted - both systems have advantages and disadvantages. Regardless, lets give all our missionaries at least our prayer support.
 

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
With the SBC cooperative programs, you have resources at the ready which will get you out to the missions field much quicker so this is a definite advantage. The disadvantage is that individual congregations give into such cooperative funds and have little to no knowledge of who receives these funds and where they are going. They are also disconnected from these individual missionaries and are therefore unable to specifically pray for them or whatever.
I was jealous of the SBC method wherein I did not have to raise support, look for a house on the field, etc. Then I experienced the IFB method: deputation, missionaries helping each other on the field rather than the home office deciding things, etc. etc. When the denominational headquarters handles such things, the dependence on faith in God's provision sometimes falls by the wayside.
IFBs have to go on deputation and it will take time to go out and raise your support from individual churches but the missionary is also meeting with and getting to know the pastors, leaders, and members of the churches who will be supporting them and in many cases, they may regard them as being "extended Church family" who will read your prayer letters, will pray for you, and so forth. There are a few other downsides such as if a church decides to drop you, it will directly affect your actual support and may place you in a hardship situation.
I do admit the downside of being dropped, etc. But I'm still in favor of the "faith missions" method. This is the missiological name for the deputation method pioneered by Hudson Taylor and other non-Baptists.
 

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I fully understand your thinking of IB missionaries - (I have been invovled with several IB churches over the years - and that system.
However, I wonder how many missionary candidates never made it to the field because they were not able to raise the support.
There is a percentage, but the missionaries who were on deputation to Japan with me and didn't complete deputation actually should never have started. Deputation showed up their lacks: one couldn't handle money, a couple decided they were too old, etc.
Also - you mentioned the ratio of missionaries per church - but for IB churches - how many fully support one missionary / what % of a missionary do they support. In addition, if a church falls short of its support - how often have they not sent full support - or not sent any at all. In addition, when a church closes - the missionary looses that support - and if he is overseas - kinda hard to make up that loss.
I am quite glad my home church never supported me fully. (I think it was $200/month at the end.) Follow the money. Where there is full support or sizeable support from one source, often there is assumed authority. A fellow worker in Japan was supported by one church at $500/month, but that church demanded a receipt for every expenditure, including down to a candy bar!
Granted - both systems have advantages and disadvantages. Regardless, lets give all our missionaries at least our prayer support.
Amen.
 
Last edited:

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
No offense, but you really did not have to tell me how the SBC does missions: went to language school with the SBC men, 33 years on the field, have preached a Lottie Moon offering in an SBC church, currently teaching two missions classes in our college and two classes in our seminary, etc. etc.

And I remain convinced that deputation is the best way to support missionaries. I did it myself, and have advised many of our young missionaries (6 on deputation from our church).
Sure.

It depends on what you mean. The Convention or the churches that participate in the Convention.

The Southern Baptist Convention


The SBC accepts donations from churches for cooperative missions (the Cooperative Program). A church must affirm the SBC Faith & Message and contribute to the Cooperative Program to be a member of the Convention. The SBC does not have a minimum amount (it is a donation determined by each independent church). This supports:

The International Missions Board (IMB) sends missionaries and relief teams throughout the world. They send and sipport missionaries and plant churches. Their focus is foreign missionaries.

The North American Mission Board (NAMB) sends missionaries, plants churches, and outreach services (meeting physical needs) within North America. This includes the Send Network which is designed to provide financial support to church plants and missionary support.

State Convention
Then you have State conventions. They support local and foreign missions. They are not under the authority of the SBC and how they support sending missionaries varies by State.

Our State convention is a resource not only to keep connected with IMB and NAMB missiomaries but also to support missions snd help meet the needs of churches within the State.

Independent Churches
Every SBC is sn independent baptist church
All give to the Vooperative Program but to varying degrees. Some focus on sending missionaries within America and give to the SBC to participate in foreign missions. Others send their own foreign missions, or partner with neighboring churches (often not SBC churches) to support missionaries from their community.

Each church is an independent baptist church, so there are many ways local churches support missions. I cannot give one answer here.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
With the SBC cooperative programs, you have resources at the ready which will get you out to the missions field much quicker so this is a definite advantage. The disadvantage is that individual congregations give into such cooperative funds and have little to no knowledge of who receives these funds and where they are going. They are also disconnected from these individual missionaries and are therefore unable to specifically pray for them or whatever.
Another good thing about the SBC model is the support beyond financial.

IMB and NAMB missionaries keep in touch with and visit several SBC churches to keep them updated. Often these are churches in the area they are from.

A SBC missionary has prayer support from many local churches and forms relationships with many congregations who are also an active part of sending and supporting them.
 

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Sure.

It depends on what you mean. The Convention or the churches that participate in the Convention.

The Southern Baptist Convention

The SBC accepts donations from churches for cooperative missions (the Cooperative Program). A church must affirm the SBC Faith & Message and contribute to the Cooperative Program to be a member of the Convention. The SBC does not have a minimum amount (it is a donation determined by each independent church). This supports:

The International Missions Board (IMB) sends missionaries and relief teams throughout the world. They send and sipport missionaries and plant churches. Their focus is foreign missionaries.

The North American Mission Board (NAMB) sends missionaries, plants churches, and outreach services (meeting physical needs) within North America. This includes the Send Network which is designed to provide financial support to church plants and missionary support.

State Convention
Then you have State conventions. They support local and foreign missions. They are not under the authority of the SBC and how they support sending missionaries varies by State.

Our State convention is a resource not only to keep connected with IMB and NAMB missiomaries but also to support missions snd help meet the needs of churches within the State.

Independent Churches
Every SBC is sn independent baptist church
All give to the Vooperative Program but to varying degrees. Some focus on sending missionaries within America and give to the SBC to participate in foreign missions. Others send their own foreign missions, or partner with neighboring churches (often not SBC churches) to support missionaries from their community.

Each church is an independent baptist church, so there are many ways local churches support missions. I cannot give one answer here.
Yes, I knew all that. You wasted your time with that post. Except for the "Vooperative Program." Maybe you could explain that to me. :rolleyes:
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Yes, I knew all that. You wasted your time with that post. Except for the "Vooperative Program." Maybe you could explain that to me. :rolleyes:
It was for others who are not members of a SBC church and are unfamiliar with the SBC missions.

I prefer deputation missionary as well. SBC churches do this on a regular basis. This is normal. This is what my son did and is doing. It has been good for him as he built relationships with many other SBC churches.
I always found the IFB program a bit hypocritical when it comes to bashing the SBC (not that you were bashing, but others have).

I do not see a problem with the SBC model because SBC missionaries still build relationships with SBC churches, they still visit and give updates on their mission, they still keep in contact with these churches (exactly as the IFB missionaries).

The SBC sends about 7000 missionaries. The IBF denomination about 1400. Granted, there are more SBC churches than IFB churches.

The plus with the SBC model is it covers both methods (both deputation and cooperation). Our main support in missions is deputation. But by giving to the Cooperative Program as well there is another avenue for missions.

Many IFB missiomaries do essentially the same thing. Their support is from several IFB churches.

The SBC program capitalizes on independent baptist churches coming together to support their missionaries so that finances will not be so great a burden. At the same time these missionaries have the support and prayers of many churches.


It would be different if, while in the field, you refused any support from any IFB churches within the denomination except your home church. That does not make sense, but it would be the distinction you are trying to make without the risk of appearing a bit hypocritical. But doing in the micro what you view as inferior in the macro is suspect.
 

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Now that Jon has explained how the SBC program works, I'll briefly explain the "faith missions" approach pioneered by Hudson Taylor of the old China Inland Mission (CIM). This is the method and program used not only by the IFB mission boards but to my knowledge by most (if not all) non-denominational missions efforts in the US. (I call the SBC method the "denominational method," since it is common to the Protestant denominations such as the United Methodists, the Presbyterian boards, etc.

The missionary has freedom to hear a call from God. If he or she does feel called, they either join a mission board or go out directly from their local church. (I don't recommend this.) The board or church is called a sending agency. Another option is the so-called "tent making" option, wherein the missionary supports themself with an occupation on the field. This has primary application to "closed" nations, and doesn't work well in unblocked nations, IMO.

The missionary candidate may or may not get training at an institution, and I highly encourage them to do so. However, the early CIM missionaries were not required to get Bible training--a huge failure by Taylor, IMO. Likewise, to the best of my knowledge the missionaries of Wycliffe are not required to get Bible training, but do get linguistic training--another huge mistake, since the Bible is a theological document, and to translate correctly requires theological knowledge. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I've read a number of biographies of Wycliffe translators that do not mention theological training.

The final step before the "faith missions" missionary leaves for the field is deputation. This is where the missionary contacts churches, sets up meetings at them, then presents his or her future mission at each, usually using slides and a testimony, and sometimes preaching. Each individual church then makes an evaluation of their own program and missions budget as to whether it can support the missionary financially or only with prayer support. (Sometimes individuals also support the missionary financially.) On deputation I took the approach of Taylor, and never mentioned support or finances to the churches. Some missionaries mention money, and that's okay.

When the missionary has full support from the churches according to a budget suggested by the board on consulting with missionaries on the field, they can then leave for the field. Deputation can take from one to several years. It took 3 1/2 with me because during deputation I married and rejoiced in the birth of a bouncing baby boy. So our budget went from $860/month to $1450 to $1850 before we left for Japan in 1981.

Every few years or so, the faith missions missionary will come back to the sending church and sending country for rest (Ha!) and to report their ministry to the churches and individual supporters. This is biblical. (See Acts 14:26-28.) This whole process is what I did for 36 1/2 years, including deputation. I feel so blessed by the process: God's call and leading, a wonderful mission board, up to 50 supporting churches and a number of individual supporters, etc.
 
Last edited:

Jerome

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
The SBC sends about 7000 missionaries. The IBF denomination about 1400. Granted, there are more SBC churches than IFB churches.
Where did you pull the number of Independent Fundamentalist Baptist missionaries?
 

Jerome

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
And...
Back to the topic of the opening post?
What is a Fundamental?
Salty, here are those promoted by the World's Christian Fundamentals Association (1919):

I. We believe in the Scriptures of the Old and New Testament as verbally inspired of God, and inerrant in the original writings, and that they are of supreme and final authority in faith and life.
II. We believe in one God, eternally existing in three persons, Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
III. We believe that Jesus Christ was begotten by the Holy Spirit, and born of the Virgin Mary, and is true God and true man.
IV. We believe that man was created in the image of God, that he sinned and thereby incurred not only physical death but also that spiritual death which is separation from God; and that all human beings are born with a sinful nature, and, in the case of those who reach moral responsibility, become sinners in thought, word and deed.
V. We believe that the Lord Jesus Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures as a representative and substitutionary sacrifice; and that all that believe in Him are justified on the ground of His shed blood.
VI. We believe in the resurrection of the crucified body of our Lord, in His ascension into heaven, and in His present life there for us, as High Priest and Advocate.
VII. We believe in “that blessed hope,” the personal, premillennial and imminent return of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ.
VIII. We believe that all who receive by faith the Lord Jesus Christ are born again of the Holy Spirit and thereby become children of God.
IX. We believe in the bodily resurrection of the just and the unjust, the everlasting felicity of the saved and the everlasting conscious suffering of the lost.

https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/community.35980714.pdf
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Where did you pull the number of Independent Fundamentalist Baptist missionaries?
It was based on a survey of field IFB missionaries. It is a general estimate. I did not save the survey site (because of the computer I was using). I wish I had written it down.

The SBC data was easy to find, but there is no site for the independent chuches that comprise the SBC.

So I am sure that many SBC church missionaries and IFB missionaries are in the field but unaccounted for in denominational numbers.

We have three from our church (within the US) that are not numbered as SBC missionaries because they are supported by our local churches and support they generated. And our church is a small plant (less than two years old, about 150 people).

So the numbers I reported are definitely not an accurate representation.


My intent was to show that both SBC and IFB churches are very active in the missionary field with the number of sent missionaries being strong proportional to the size of the two denominations.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Keep saying that, and loudly, especially in the presence of your Southern Baptist DOM and other denominational operatives.
I do not have to among SBC churches (we know that we are independent baptist churches who choose to donate to the Cooperative Program).

We need to say that loudly to other denominations (like the IFB and Missionary Bsptist denominations) as they cannot grasp the concept of the SBC (they cannot separate the Convention from independent baptist churches that participate in the Convention).


I think the reason that many (perhaps most) churches within the IFB denomination misunderstand the relationship between the SBC and independent baptist churches that are members of the convention is they link the relationship of the SBC to its seminaries and inter-operational processes to churches. That is a mistake.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Salty, here are those promoted by the World's Christian Fundamentals Association (1919):
Another issue is whether we define "fundamental" using the initial meaning or the contemporary meaning.

All SBC churches are "independent fundamental baptist" churches using the 1919 definition.

BUT in 2026 the meaning of "fundamental" has changed to reflect legalistically clinging to human tradition.

This may not even reflect the majority of the IFB denomination (often the few bad apples tarnish the name of the good apples).
 

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
The SBC sends about 7000 missionaries. The IBF denomination about 1400. Granted, there are more SBC churches than IFB churches.
Until you find a source for these figures, I consider them to be way out of proportion. Go back and look at the figures I gave in post# 19 from a reputable source, hired to do an actual survey. I wrote:

"There are more missionaries sent out by IFB churches than by SBC churches by far. Paul Chappell commissioned a survey and published the results in his 2009 book with Clayton Reed, Church Still Works. At that time, there were 4,878 IFB foreign missionaries (1 for every 2.8 churches), compared to 3,893 sent out by the IMB (1 for every 11.4 churches)."

Note that my source gave only overseas missionary numbers. Note also that the IFB numbers for just that are well above the SBC numbers. Also, your number of 1400 IFB missionaries is not at all accurate.
 
Last edited:
Top