Natural mans religion always seeks to deprive Christ/God of their Glory due. One way they do this is by attributing Faith Heb 11:1 unto the natural man, which is a lie. Sure man may have a natural faith, but that has absolutely nothing to do with God in Salvation. But the Faith in God that has to do with Salvation in and through Jesus Christ, who is God, comes from Christ and is part of the Glory He received from the Father when He raised Him from the dead.
My Comment: You are saying that it is taking away God’s glory if you attribute natural faith in man to the faith we receive from Jesus Christ. You quote Heb 11:1. I think you mean that the Arminians believe faith before full regeneration causes regeneration and justification and you disagree with that. We would agree with you that full regeneration precedes Faith. However, we would agree with the Arminians in that, before full regeneration, there is a kind of faith we call an intellectual faith (Rom 10:14-17). Before full regeneration, intellectual faith is developed by audibly hearing scripture preached. The Arminians are right on this hearing as being dispositive. It “prepares” us for full regeneration. This means that when you hear preaching before you are saved, God’s grace [prevenient - Ps 58:11 (Ps 59:10 KJV)] is working inside you at the same time (precedes the preaching). Sometimes it may not seem like it. They can hear with their heart! It’s just that their wills (hearts) are not perfect yet. There can be certain impediments too, such as being mentally challenged, too young, not feeling well, etc. The key is this: Their faith is not dead as calvinists believe and they are not resisting God. They are there. At least, they are not totally resisting. During this time (before full regeneration), those who are moved by the Spirit get what we would call “illuminations”. An example would be seeing something in scripture before you hear it or sort of like “reading between the lines”. The catholic view is that these help prepare us for election to justification (full regeneration) which occurs at baptism. They move the soul or stimulate our souls and develop certain required dispositions in us (ex: recognizing that we are sinners, fear of divine Justice, begin to love God, etc). These dispositions don’t have to be perfect and God decides when we are ready to be baptized through the ministry of the priest or deacon. It’s in God’s Providence when we are baptized. Baptism is an effect of predestination. Baptism is where we receive and use our Faith to willingly come to Christ (Rom 10:9-13). We depart from the Arminian view in that this intellectual faith is perfective and causes partial regeneration. We say it prepares us for full regeneration at baptism so there is a gap between the two. One doesn’t cause the other.
Lets look at 1 Pet 1:21
Who by him do believe in God, that raised him up from the dead,
and gave him[Christ] glory; that your faith and hope might be in God.
Faith and Hope in God, in the realm of Salvation, is the result of God giving Christ Glory after raising Him from the Dead.
Thats what 1 Pet 1:21 tells us. Key to understanding this is the word that:
that your faith and hope might be in God.
Its the greek Conjunction hóste and it means:
so that, therefore, so then, so as to.
hṓste (a conjunction, derived from 5613 /hōs, "as" and 5037 /té, "both-and") – wherefore (with the result that both . . . ), connecting cause to necessary effect which emphasizes the result (the combined, end-accomplishment). The result involved then is the combination of both elements in the correlation, underscoring the inevitable effect of the paired elements.
So understand that according to Peter here Faith in God is the necessary effect, the inevitable of effect of God raising up Christ from the dead and giving Him Glory !
My Comment: You quote 1 Pet 1:21 to say that “your faith and hope might be in God” comes AFTER or is received from “God, that raised him up from the dead, and gave him[Christ] glory”. I think you interpret this to mean that your faith comes after full regeneration (after the resurrection)?
Thats why Peter writes in his 2 nd epistle to these same believers 2 Pet 1:1
Simon Peter, a bondservant and apostle of Jesus Christ,
To those who have obtained like precious faith with us by the righteousness of our God and Savior Jesus Christ: 29
My Comment: I think you are saying your faith comes from the righteousness of Christ. Again, full regeneration precedes saving Faith.
I do have a couple of questions:
Since you receive Faith at full regeneration by hearing the gospel, does hearing the gospel happen “one time” and this “one time” causes Faith which causes justification? After that first time, the next time you hear preaching and receive Faith, are you in the sanctification process?
Full regeneration precedes Faith. What is Faith for then? (Since you are already regenerated). I know you will say to cause justification. It seems that if you are already fully regenerated, that would cause justification by itself?
Faith - Catholic View
I thought that since this thread is about "Faith", I would introduce the viewers to the catholic understanding of Faith.
In Scripture, the term “Faith” can be a gift, virtue or fruit (not just a gift; not just something received):
Baptism (Full Regeneration)(Rom 10:9-13)
At the point of baptism, Faith is all of these:
Belief (Gift and Virtue - mainly a virtue)
Faith as a gift - it is a gift because it is received by grace (Eph 2:8)(Baptism - Eph 2:4-5)
Faith (belief) as a theological virtue - saving Faith = believing (infused by charity) (believe - Rom 4:3, Rom 10:9)
Faith as a theological virtue that works through charity (Gal 5:6) to produce fruit - When this Faith (belief) is used in an act, it is a work (John 6:29, 1 Thess 1:3, James 2:22, etc) and produces fruit (reward - ex: life everlasting - Rom 6:22)
Faith as a fruit - Gal 5:23 - Faith is a fruit
To make an analogy
Let’s say I receive a Christmas present (Gift) and let’s say it’s a power tool. It is a gift because I received it but mainly it is something I am suppose to use (power tool = Virtue). When I work to complete a job with the power tool (virtue), I obtain a finished product (fruit or reward). So Faith is a gift, virtue and fruit.