I suppose if the majority ruled we would all be Catholic.
I agree with the article that higher education is not necessary on the condition “necessary” is emphasized, “higher education” refers to university, and we are speaking of the pastorate. That said, I believe higher education is greatly desired. When a pastor prepares his sermon it is good that he has vetted his interpretations and conclusions with both his peers and dissenting views. I’ve sat under great pastors who had little or no higher education, but unfortunately their interpretations and biblical consistency were not always adequate. (There’s a joke about a preacher who emphasized the italic words of scripture as he believed they were the words God intended to be emphasized…I’ve seen the “joke” in real life).
Higher education certainly doesn’t equal smarter students. Just look at me. If we are looking at seminary students, such an education may at least indicate a time of preparation and growth.
I do think peer review is necessary, but not necessary for truth.
I absolutely agree with the last statement. No one is neutral when it comes to their beliefs. We may try to be objective, which is a good thing, but we can’t hold our presuppositions completely at bay.
