FF&F
Listen, if I can disagree with most scientists on most issues, don’t think that I’m afraid to challenge this issue of definitions, especially since I have a pretty good idea where this definition bending on the part of scientists comes from to begin with. I have read what you said, plus many other discussions I have come across. Let me ask you a question. If macro-evolution was observed in the environment, and could be replicated in the laboratory, would it still be a theory? If not, what would it be?
Well that point about "theory vs law" might not be as accurate as it "could be". But the key point that things like "spontaneous generation" held by our friendly alchemists - was "a theory" and still is "a theory". However "how popular is it" (a biogenesists seem to like it by another name - I know, but if we exclude them
then how popular?).
Don't be sidetracked by the smoke. Your initial point is right on the money - by handwaiving and a little smoke the effort is made to "ignore" the blatant fact that "blue eyes vs brown eyes" is NOT the "key ingredient" for macro evolution.
Simply showing variation WITHIN a genetic pool - has no meaning at all for true evolutionism. The salient point of their argument is that "information goes INTO the system" And that the genetic pool exceeds the initial bounds - sometimes even getting to compound leaps up the chain.
In the great variation of features we see in dog breeds - we see a "demonstration" of "micro evolution" WITHIN the genetic bounds for canines.
What evolutionism needs is something BIGGER than THAT. If they had even ONE - or if they could MAKE even ONE by environmental changes "how nice" that would be.
However - only God can do that - and He did it in 6 days as God's Word says.
So the amazing thing is this - man fails at the macro evolution step AND he fails at the abiogenesis step - and STILL he trashes the Gospel AND the word of God as IF "he had proven something" about either macro evolution or abiogenesis that "disproved" God's Word?
Many Christians see that happening and wonder how anyone could believe in the integrity of God's Word and trust in the Gospel while being so easily disposed to disbelieve it.
Bob