• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

A pastor's income ?

annsni

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
It's usually easy to misjudge a person's income. A few years ago, it as time to replace my wife's car. I nearly got her a three year old Mercedes, which was in pristine condition. But sinçe she's a private school teacher, she was concerned about parents thinking the school made too much money. So instead of paying $20,000 for the Mercedes, I ended up paying $25,000 for something else. I had to pay an extra 5k just to avoid someone's fingerwagging.

Also, we should not punish a pastor for making wise monetary decisions. My cousin's church hired a new youth pastor (they're a 3000 person congregation that needed a fulltime youth pastor). The youth pastor's wife was a cardiac surgeon, who made a good income. On top of that, he had made some very wise financial investments when he was younger, which allowed him to buy a bigger house than average. He lived in a nice house with a pool, and frequently had youth ministry events there. It would have been incorrect to presume he was being unjustly enriched by his employment at the church.

We happen to live in one of the better areas of the town we live in (Oh, you live there? Those are NICE houses.) when we purchased it after my husband sold his business almost 18 years ago and paid it off just before he went into the ministry. We also have a 42 foot sailboat and belong to a yacht club - but the boat also was paid off before he went into ministry and my ILs pay for us to be in the club so we can have someplace to keep our boat. So while it may look like we have a lot, we are blessed with what we have but certainly don't live extravagantly.
 

Spear

New Member
Also, we should not punish a pastor for making wise monetary decisions. My cousin's church hired a new youth pastor (they're a 3000 person congregation that needed a fulltime youth pastor). The youth pastor's wife was a cardiac surgeon, who made a good income. On top of that, he had made some very wise financial investments when he was younger, which allowed him to buy a bigger house than average. He lived in a nice house with a pool, and frequently had youth ministry events there. It would have been incorrect to presume he was being unjustly enriched by his employment at the church.

I agree ! What would you call " unjustly enriched ", or " justly enriched " ?
I'm asking you : is there a " level ", some kind of " scale " where the amount of money a pastor earns byt his pastoral activity, should matter, or no ? Can we simply say, that a pastor that would preach in a very rich church could/should earn 200000 US $ a year ?
 

Johnv

New Member
Being justly enriched is doing an honest day's work and getting an honest day's pay. Doesn't matter if it's a pastor, CEO, doctor, lawyer, trash hauler, bucther, baker, or candlestick maker.
 

Jim1999

<img src =/Jim1999.jpg>
"A labourer is worthy of his hire..." Thus saith the scripture. A pastor should be paid sufficiently to keep bread on his table and clothes on his back and a roof overhead and maintain his witness before the world. The compensation does not have to relate to the size of his church, or bigger church, bigger income.

Further, my personal wealth does not enter into that equation. I did not choose ministry for the pay cheque or lack of, but rather to satisfy the calling of God to preach the word.

Cheers,

Jim
 

Spear

New Member
I totally agree ! The pastors must have enough for them and their family, so that they can be fully dedicated to their ministry !
 

annsni

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
What makes ministry really hard is when the pastor's family is struggling to get by while the congregants enjoy the fruits of their labors. The congregation expects way more from the pastor than he is compensated for - and unfortunately he's having to split his heart and mind between the ministry and having to pay the bills. That's not right IMO.
 

FriendofSpurgeon

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Also, we should not punish a pastor for making wise monetary decisions. My cousin's church hired a new youth pastor (they're a 3000 person congregation that needed a fulltime youth pastor). The youth pastor's wife was a cardiac surgeon, who made a good income. On top of that, he had made some very wise financial investments when he was younger, which allowed him to buy a bigger house than average. He lived in a nice house with a pool, and frequently had youth ministry events there. It would have been incorrect to presume he was being unjustly enriched by his employment at the church.

Happens on this coast too. Our school's chaplain's wife is a neurosurgeon.
 

FriendofSpurgeon

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I agree ! What would you call " unjustly enriched ", or " justly enriched " ?
I'm asking you : is there a " level ", some kind of " scale " where the amount of money a pastor earns byt his pastoral activity, should matter, or no ? Can we simply say, that a pastor that would preach in a very rich church could/should earn 200000 US $ a year ?

Speaking on a purely selfish manner... growing up as a PK, I sure wished that there was some type of level or scale that dad would have earned.
 

FriendofSpurgeon

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I agree ! What would you call " unjustly enriched ", or " justly enriched " ?
I'm asking you : is there a " level ", some kind of " scale " where the amount of money a pastor earns byt his pastoral activity, should matter, or no ? Can we simply say, that a pastor that would preach in a very rich church could/should earn 200000 US $ a year ?

I don't think you will find a hard & fast rule. From what I have experienced, most US pastors earn less than the congregational average -- but perhaps somewhere in the average "range" -- perhaps 40%, not 50%. (From a technical standpoint, we should be talking about the median, not the mean, but never mind). Based on this criteria, most pastors are likely underpaid.

Also, this varies quite a bit here in the states since the cost of living is so different based on where you live. In some places, the average cost of a home is US$150,000 while in others it's over US$500,000. Thus, in certain areas, a salary of US$50,000 might be much more than the congregational average and in other areas, US$100,000 would be much less.
 

StefanM

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
The Christian Reformed Church posts a minimum wage for pastors.

The United Methodist Church has a similar system. It's necessary with the itinerant system. Otherwise, you'd have a complete uproar with some new appointments.
 

gb93433

Active Member
Site Supporter
I would much rather pastor a small church that sacrificially gives and is obedient than one that gives as lip service.

Anyone who has planted churches know the work it involves.
 

Matt Black

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Our CofE clergy get paid a stipend of £20k ($32k); mind you, they do get free accommodation.
 

Revmitchell

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Our CofE clergy get paid a stipend of £20k ($32k); mind you, they do get free accommodation.

On this side of the pond Pastors do not always get these free accommodations. Some do not even want them they would rather purchase their own house.
 

annsni

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
On this side of the pond Pastors do not always get these free accommodations. Some do not even want them they would rather purchase their own house.

In our church, we have one parsonage. Of the remaining 8 pastors, 7 own their own homes from before they were on staff. The last is a young married pastor who cannot afford a house at this time. I don't think he ever will with the cost of housing on Long Island. We're blessed in that we not only own our own home, but it's paid off. We're here almost 18 years and we've seen a HUGE increase in the value of our home and there's just NO way we could afford to start over. Hey - I have a hard time setting aside $1000 a month to pay our property taxes (yeah, they're over $14,000 but since we're clergy, we get a small discount).
 

Matt Black

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
On this side of the pond Pastors do not always get these free accommodations. Some do not even want them they would rather purchase their own house.
It's a double-edged sword. Since property (even with the recent housing crash) is generally the best way to gain capital appreciation, this leaves clergy in a rather exposed state when it comes to their retirement funds: they retire at 65 to suddenly find the nice big house they had is no longer theirs and they have no property of their own. A vicar friend of mine got round that problem by buying a smallish house with a mortgage whilst he was in ministry and renting it out to students; he used the rent to pay off the mortgage over 25 years and then at least he had some real estate of his own when he stopped working. Such solutions are not uncommon here.
 

Revmitchell

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
It's a double-edged sword. Since property (even with the recent housing crash) is generally the best way to gain capital appreciation, this leaves clergy in a rather exposed state when it comes to their retirement funds: they retire at 65 to suddenly find the nice big house they had is no longer theirs and they have no property of their own. A vicar friend of mine got round that problem by buying a smallish house with a mortgage whilst he was in ministry and renting it out to students; he used the rent to pay off the mortgage over 25 years and then at least he had some real estate of his own when he stopped working. Such solutions are not uncommon here.


Barring some physical or mental ailment that does not allow them to carry on what is a Pastor doing retiring at all until the Lord takes him home?
 

annsni

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Barring some physical or mental ailment that does not allow them to carry on what is a Pastor doing retiring at all until the Lord takes him home?

He is allowing someone else to take over the ministry of the church, which is a very difficult and consuming job - and allowing himself to then move on to work with younger pastors to train, encourage and instruct. I think that is a GREAT way for older pastors to allow the next generation to be able to pastor yet continue to work for the ministry.
 

Tom Bryant

Well-Known Member
Most pastors that I know now are buying houses rather than a parsonage for just that reason. This is a problem for some small churches who can't afford to pay a pastor a living wage but include the house.

On the retiring idea: It's not like he is retiring from serving the Lord. I can foresee a time (I am 58 now) that I won't be able to deal with the wear and tear of doing the pastoral ministry well on a full time basis. But I won't quit serving the Lord. I'd see myself doing interim pastoral ministry.
 

StefanM

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Most pastors that I know now are buying houses rather than a parsonage for just that reason. This is a problem for some small churches who can't afford to pay a pastor a living wage but include the house.

On the retiring idea: It's not like he is retiring from serving the Lord. I can foresee a time (I am 58 now) that I won't be able to deal with the wear and tear of doing the pastoral ministry well on a full time basis. But I won't quit serving the Lord. I'd see myself doing interim pastoral ministry.

Not to mention the reality that many ministers are forced out when churches are in search of "fresh blood."
 
Top