Brian,
Welcome to BB. :1_grouphug: This is a good topic for many here are on your side. But let me make a few counterpoints:
1) Tozer "complains" that the emphasis in Christiainity drifts from one generation to the next. I think not. I think that men emerge who emphasize certain elements of Christianity (as Tozer has done here) and they get a following for a while. Overall, I believe that the Spirit teaches the whole counsel of God to every believer but from time to time there are some who want the religion to be more legalistic (as this whole judgment issue has become via Believer's Accountability/Millennial Exclusion).
2) Tozer has an inadequate notion of when the judgment for believers' sins takes place. Spiritually, all sin was judged at the cross. Physically, which is what Tozer and BA/ME are clearly calling for, judgment for sin takes place in this life. Do you ignore that we are "chastised," even counted among "the children of disobedience" and put to death from this life for continued "sin unto death?" In this life, "your sin will surely find you out!"
When we get the the Bema/REWARDS seat, 1Cor 3:11-15, there will be a spiritual cleansing right there on the spot. Some receive reward -- others "saved so as by fire." But this is a burning away of the wisdom, thoughts and glory that are not of God. a "deprogramming" by the flames of the truth much as the old earth must be "melted with a fervent heat" to make it fit for glory of living in God's presence -- the New Earth.
But here's a for instance of "wood, hay, and stubble" that must be burned/purged -- do you like rock music? Well, it has no place in God's presence. In the reverse of what you developed in this life -- a "seared conscience" to the wrongfulness of rock music -- your spirit and soul will be purged of any remembrance or desire or enjoyment of rock music in eternity.
3) Tozer (and y'all) have absolutely no comprehension of the judgments! The church believers are "judged"/cleansed post-rapture (pretrib) in heaven at the Bema. There is NO going from heaven to "outer darkness," "weeping and gnashing," "fiery furnace," etc. Those are all allusions to the pit/sheol. (Where, indeed, do you countenance that the believers purgation takes place??)
The judgments of Mt 25:13-46 and 13:38-52 are postrib/premil on the earth, Rev 20:4. They DO involve damnation of UNBELIEVERS to the "pit" followed 1000 years later (Rev 20:11) by the GWT.
The GWT is last. It is the resurrection of ALL UNBELIEVERS of ALL time to the "GWT" and then "second death" in the "lake of fire."
The only place I can think of where BELIEVERS are excluded from the kingdom is when they are excluded from the church fellowship and turned over to Satan, 1Cor 5:5. But scripture says, in the end, "they shall be saved so as by fire," 2Cor 3:15. This "in the end" Bema "judgment" for the church is NOT purgatory or purgation of sins -- it is purgation of the mind, emotions, and will of notions that don't belong in the presence of God -- because following that judgment, we will be in the presence of God in New Jerusalem for at least 7 years!
Please tell me where in scripture you are getting your notions of post-resurrection accountability and exclusion so we can get this resolved truthfully.
skypair