To an extent, I certainly agree. What Ash Wednesday and a lot of the church calendar have become is nothing more than empty ritual. In my opinion, that stems from an initial error, whereby a human "priest" can absolve one from sin, take confession, administer "sacraments" that offer God's grace (as if it is a commodity), etc., and otherwise "speak for" the believers who are part of the mass.
But, that being said, I can find no wrong in the individual believer taking 40 days before Resurrection Day to contemplate the Cross, and yes -- absoultely -- the RESURRECTION! If that includes some form of fast, then we are yet in keeping with the Scriptures, OT and NT, for fasting is one of the disciplines of the Christian life -- not to "gain grace" but for our own purposes to reflect, meditate on Christ, and also on our own circumstances that caused His crucifixion, for He died in our stead.
So, while I disavow the "religious" nature of the ceremony for the congregation, I do not disavow the contemplative and reflective nature of the actual practice for the individual believer.
Agreed... I like Charles Colsons "Enough Sermon"
...don't blame the liberals. Don't blame the homosexual lobby or the media.
"WE are at fault. We—collectively and individually—have chased after every idol the world has to offer. We have tried so hard to be relevant that we’ve become almost completely irrelevant. We offer no other way, there is nothing distinctive about us.
"We have not been what Jesus called us to be: Salt and light. We have blended in with the world so well that we are practically invisible...
"Enough of self-absorption.
Enough of going to church for self-validation—because it makes us feel good; enough of buying into the “Jesus and me” brand of Christianity that we evangelicals are especially susceptible to.
Enough of living exactly like our non-believing neighbors, glued to electronics, engaging in promiscuity and infidelity, spending beyond our means.
Enough of ignoring the suffering of the poor. Enough of being ashamed of the truth claims of the Gospel. It’s time to repent..."