• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Confederate battle flag angers many at California high school!?

carpro

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Personally, I am not offended by the flying of the Confederate standard. However, I do not like it. To me, it does not symbolize racism, but rebellion and disunification (according to spell check, that's not a real word).

I understand the origins, and how it stood for state's rights and freedom. But today the meaning has changed. You'll often see it displayed alongside the phrase, "The south will rise again". This is nothing but a (nonintentional - wow, another "non word") malcontent viewpoint on the union of the states. It's meant as a statement of pride, but if we look at what's actually being said, it promotes secession and discontent.

So, while I am not offended by it, I don't like it.

Sent from my QTAQZ3 using Tapatalk

They can't change the future if they don't understand the past, and even worse, hide from it because it "offends" them.
 

Jedi Knight

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
And using your logic they would now have to get rid of the GOP as they are the party that now embraces racism and continually attempts to disenfranchise African American voters.
Do you show such bigotry buy not addressing ALL Americans with a hyphenated start or just excluding them?
 

Salty

20,000 Posts Club
Administrator
and if the CSA flag is to be banned - then lets ban all flags other than the US Flag.
The homosexual flag offends me -
The African flag offends me.
The (fill in the blank)......
 

TCassidy

Late-Administator Emeritus
Administrator
The flag in South Carolina, like so many other Confederate Standards, was likely raised in opposition to Civil Rights and desegregation during the 6os.

I don't think the US flag with 50 stars was ever hoisted in support of the things listed..
kkk flag.jpg kkk flag2.jpg
 

carpro

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
What difference does it make? It was raised "in opposition to Civil Rights and desegregation."

Curious. Looks kinda old. Why so defensive?

And what "was raised "in opposition to Civil Rights and desegregation."?

The flag of the United States? So what?
 
Last edited:

Alcott

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
It was the battle flag of an army fighting the United States Army. If that's not showing a lack of unity, I'm not sure what would be required to meet the standard.7

A.d what other flags and symbols have represented an army fighting against the United states? The Mexican flag, the designs on the flag of new Mexico, the war bonnets of the plains tribes, the clinched fist with " burn, baby, burn!" Are you against all enmity, or just white enmity?
 

righteousdude2

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Seems I touched a raw nerve showing the logical conclusion of your logic.

I'll bet you have very few friends because of an over exaggerated ego, fed by your own observations?

Show your facts, or apologize for reaching so deeply into your bag of non facts, that from your fingertips to your shoulder, you smell like the pig slop those lies were buried deep down in. It's time to back up.your claims, boy, or face peer pressure for lying in order to sound "liberal!"
 

Crabtownboy

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I'll bet you have very few friends because of an over exaggerated ego, fed by your own observations?

I have friends who are smart enough not to make such illogical comments as you made and I responded to. They are also smart enough not to resort to sophomoric comments and will enter into a reasoned discussion when opinions differ.

Show your facts, or apologize for reaching so deeply into your bag of non facts, that from your fingertips to your shoulder, you smell like the pig slop those lies were buried deep down in. It's time to back up.your claims, boy, or face peer pressure for lying in order to sound "liberal!"

How do you show facts for the illogical comment someone else made. If you do not like the logical conclusion of your illogical comment then think through what you say before making silly comments.
 

TCassidy

Late-Administator Emeritus
Administrator
So what? Did you bother to read the thread? Did you notice the claim "I don't think the US flag with 50 stars was ever hoisted in support of the things listed." (IE: in opposition to Civil Rights and desegregation)

The pictures are obviously from the 1960s. The 50th star was added in 1960.
 

StefanM

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
A.d what other flags and symbols have represented an army fighting against the United states? The Mexican flag, the designs on the flag of new Mexico, the war bonnets of the plains tribes, the clinched fist with " burn, baby, burn!" Are you against all enmity, or just white enmity?

Just white enmity, apparently. /sarcasm

Just because I think the Confederate flag should be consigned to its proper place as an historical relic doesn't mean I think it is the only divisive symbol.

I do think it has special significance, though, as it represents a secessionist movement (rebellion) by part of the nation against the rest of the nation.
 

TCassidy

Late-Administator Emeritus
Administrator
Secession is not rebellion. If a state can join the Union, it can leave the Union. The basis of our government is still "Government of the people, by the people, and for the people."

If the people of a state vote to leave the Union, it is tyranny (forcing a government on people which they don't want) and slavery (compelling taxation of their labor to support a government they don't want) to force them to stay.

It is time we owned our country's history. Slavery was a real issue from 1776 through 1865. Own it!

Slavery was already on the decline and would have died out on its own by the 1880s/1890s. The antebellum south was an unsustainable economic and social construct doomed to failure from its very inception. (Similar to the landed gentry of Great Britain.) Neither could survive the progressive ascendancy of a democratic government.

The cause of the civil war was economic, not sociological. It was about money. War is always about money. If you want to find the actual cause of the civil war follow the money.
 

Revmitchell

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Money, slavery and territory are all aspects of what drives war. The civil war was started after the southern states succeeded because Lincoln tried to maintain federal control over forts in southern states such as SC. Once he tried to resupply that fort the southern states responded by attack and the war was on. Had there been on resupply of the forts it is likely there would have been no war. It was all about control over southern states. Slavery was one of several issues that the states succeeded over but control over southern land is what caused the first gun fire.

So the idea that somehow this was rebellion from a few southerners "from the rest of the country" is just wrong.
 

Squire Robertsson

Administrator
Administrator
As I wrote earlier, the Confederate battle flag does not represent California's history or culture except as the flag of the enemy. California was not a part of the Confederacy nor was it a border state. Through, the California Column it was an active combatant on the Union side. San Francisco's Union Square got its name from the Union rallies held in the space.

This is not true of other parts of the country.
 
Top