Discussion with regards to Church history

[Thinkingstuff]

But not one of them contradict what the sources I provided say.



Actually, I quoted directly from Catholic sources.



You're right. I did choose to quote only the salient parts of those sources. However, each time you've accused me of taking them out of context, I've invited you to reproduce them in their entirity and explain how I took them out of context and you have repeatedly failed to do so.



I did not "ignore" them. I chose not to address them because none of the FIVE CATHOLIC SOURCES I quoted made any such disctinction.



Gee, another personal attack. Why does that not surprise me?



Then he would have the responsibility of explaining where these FIVE CATHOLIC sources got it wrong.



Actually, I did not write the CCC, the Council of Trent, the Catholic Encyclopedia, nor is Karl Keating my psuedonym.

And, with this post, I will follow the Bible's admonition to not argue with a fool.

Note. That they do contradict your position of that doctrine. Note venial and Mortal distinction is very much a part of this doctrine. Note the eternal and temporal consequences of sin are very much a part of this doctrine. You admit you did not post the full text nor did you put all things taught but one aspect with out the benefit of the whole.

Note I will not ever call you a fool eventhough I may become angry at you or frustrated because you have refussed to listen. I respect your education and qualifications but I am disappointed with you because I think if you were honest with yourself you would be better than this.

 

[JohnDeereFan]

Note I will not ever call you a fool

But you will continue to attack me an impugn my intelligence.

But, in any event, like I said, the Bible tells us not to argue with fools and I believe I should stopped trying to talk to you about two dozen posts ago.

 

[Thinkingstuff]

But you will continue to attack me an impugn my intelligence.

But, in any event, like I said, the Bible tells us not to argue with fools and I believe I should stopped trying to talk to you about two dozen posts ago.

Lets not bring up geneologies and mythologies if you think this was rough.

 

[JohnDeereFan]

Lets not bring up geneologies and mythologies if you think this was rough.

Sorry, not going to play your games.

God bless you. I'm praying for you.

 

[Thinkingstuff]

Sorry, not going to play your games.

God bless you. I'm praying for you.

I thought it was a good joke. But if you're mad at me I suggest you forgive me so as not to go to bed angry at me. Thanks for your prayers.

 

[JohnDeereFan]

But if you're mad at me I suggest you forgive me so as not to go to bed angry at me. Thanks for your prayers.

Sorry, not playing your games. God Bless you. I'm praying for you.