• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Exactly what is a Fundamental?

Salty

20,000 Posts Club
Administrator
Keep saying that, and loudly, especially in the presence of your Southern Baptist DOM and other denominational operatives.
I do! There was one SBC leader I used to joke with about him working at Bapt HQ. And he would have a fit about it since he would remind me that the SBC is not HQ over any independent Bapt church affiliated with the SBC!!!
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Until you find a source for these figures, I consider them to be way out of proportion. Go back and look at the figures I gave in post# 19 from a reputable source, hired to do an actual survey. I wrote:

"There are more missionaries sent out by IFB churches than by SBC churches by far. Paul Chappell commissioned a survey and published the results in his 2009 book with Clayton Reed, Church Still Works. At that time, there were 4,878 IFB foreign missionaries (1 for every 2.8 churches), compared to 3,893 sent out by the IMB (1 for every 11.4 churches)."
It does not matter what you accept, John. Lets use your 2009 source for your denomination.

You state in the 2000's there were 4,878 IFB foreign missionaries (I do not know the exact year as you did not provide it BUT the book was published in 2009 so I assume we are talking about 2008 data).

2006 the SBC had 8,064 missiomaries (5,122 foreign, 2,942 North America)

2007 the SBC had 10,400 missionaries(5,250 foreign, 5,150 North America)

2008 the SBC had 10,525 missionaries (5,444 foreign, 5,081 North America)

2009 the SBC had 9,049 missionaries (5,600 foreign, 3,449 North America)

Note - the SBC classifies Canada under NAMB (not IMB, not foreign missions).

Note - This number EXCLUDES missiomaries sent out by individual SBC churches.

Source -the IMB and NAMB historical data (on their websites)


What you need to explain is how the SBC having 5,444 foreign missionaries (excluding Canada) is less than yoyr denomination having 3,893 foreign missionaries (less if you are counting Canada.


How does your denomination track the number of congregations and missionaries?
 

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
It does not matter what you accept, John. Lets use your 2009 source for your denomination.

You state in the 2000's there were 4,878 IFB foreign missionaries (I do not know the exact year as you did not provide it BUT the book was published in 2009 so I assume we are talking about 2008 data).

2006 the SBC had 8,064 missiomaries (5,122 foreign, 2,942 North America)

2007 the SBC had 10,400 missionaries(5,250 foreign, 5,150 North America)

2008 the SBC had 10,525 missionaries (5,444 foreign, 5,081 North America)

2009 the SBC had 9,049 missionaries (5,600 foreign, 3,449 North America)

Note - the SBC classifies Canada under NAMB (not IMB, not foreign missions).

Note - This number EXCLUDES missiomaries sent out by individual SBC churches.

Source -the IMB and NAMB historical data (on their websites)


What you need to explain is how the SBC having 5,444 foreign missionaries (excluding Canada) is less than yoyr denomination having 3,893 foreign missionaries (less if you are counting Canada.


How does your denomination track the number of congregations and missionaries?
Again, what is your source? I gave a perfectly legitimate, scholarly source.

Here is an official SBC source that says the SBC only has 3,522 foreign missionaries, far less than you are saying: Fast Facts - SBC.net.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Another note -

It is not an honest assessment to compare IMB missionaries to IFB missionaries as the IMB only accounts for missionaries sent through the IMB.

I can tell you, for example, thar the many (perhaps most) of SBC missionaries sent are not through the IMB.

I have lived in two states over the past decade. Both sent missionaries through local baptist associations (not SBC associations). Both sent missionaries directly supported by their churches (and through gaining support).


The IMB is a great evangelism program. But it is not an easy program for those called into the ministry because of how it uses its resources (fully funding rather than partially funding).

Most of our missionaries raise support through local churches and Christian businesses. We use programs like Reliant as a tool.

So @John of Japan saying his denomination has more missionaries than the IMB (that 3,893 more than 5,444) is meaningless because it is only counting IMB missionaries.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Again, what is your source? I gave a perfectly legitimate, scholarly source.

Here is an official SBC source that says the SBC only has 3,522 foreign missionaries, far less than you are saying: Fast Facts - SBC.net.
It was the SBC IMB site for 2008. Their is a historical data section.

1. You are only counting IMB missionaries (those sent by the Convention - NOT those sent by SBC churches apart from

Most SBC churches send out missionaries. Most of these are not sent through the Convention.

2. Where are you getting the data for your denomination (not the book but the actual data collected by the denomination)?

I ask because we don't report missionaries sent from our churces to the Convention. Only those using IMB support are counted.
 

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Another note -

It is not an honest assessment to compare IMB missionaries to IFB missionaries as the IMB only accounts for missionaries sent through the IMB.

I can tell you, for example, thar the many (perhaps most) of SBC missionaries sent are not through the IMB.

I have lived in two states over the past decade. Both sent missionaries through local baptist associations (not SBC associations). Both sent missionaries directly supported by their churches (and through gaining support).


The IMB is a great evangelism program. But it is not an easy program for those called into the ministry because of how it uses its resources (fully funding rather than partially funding).

Most of our missionaries raise support through local churches and Christian businesses. We use programs like Reliant as a tool.

So @John of Japan saying his denomination has more missionaries than the IMB (that 3,893 more than 5,444) is meaningless because it is only counting IMB missionaries.
So now I'm accused of dishonesty.

And by the way, IFB folk do not have a denomination.
 

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
It was the SBC IMB site for 2008. Their is a historical data section.
Wrong. There is a 2023 archive on the site.
1. You are only counting IMB missionaries (those sent by the Convention - NOT those sent by SBC churches apart from

Most SBC churches send out missionaries. Most of these are not sent through the Convention.

2. Where are you getting the data for your denomination (not the book but the actual data collected by the denomination)?

I ask because we don't report missionaries sent from our churces to the Convention. Only those using IMB support are counted.
I believe I'm done here. You appear to be making up figures.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
@John of Japan

I have a question about data collection.

We know how many missionaries are sent out from the SBC (the Comvention, the NAMB, IMB, WMU, etc).

But I do not know how to account for the missionaries that are sent by SBC independent churches as these are not sent by the SBC (the Confrence).


How does your denomination account for the number of IFB churches within the denomination and the missionaries they send out?
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
So now I'm accused of dishonesty.

And by the way, IFB folk do not have a denomination.
No. I am saying the assessment in the book you referenced is not anyone's assessmemt

IFB is a denomination in the same way the SBC churches are a denomination. Both are independent baptist churches. Both have no organization above the local church.

That was the definition I was using (different churches of the same kind).


You mentioned an accountability system for data (you stated knowledge of the number of IFB churches as well as the number of missionaries sent out combined, coming up with a ratio per church).

To what entiry does IFB church report their existence ans missiomaries sent?
 

JohnDB

Member
I do! There was one SBC leader I used to joke with about him working at Bapt HQ. And he would have a fit about it since he would remind me that the SBC is not HQ over any independent Bapt church affiliated with the SBC!!!
Yeah....
Its a convention. We convene because we agree.
And there's not much we have to agree upon. However of late the list seems to have grown.
We have tossed out several churches a few years back. Now money alone is NOT a reason to get tossed from the convention. Churches have been members for decades and never kicked in a penny.....

BUT

If you promote doctrines outside the historical norms. (Homosexual priests and/or women senior pastors) While passing judgement on those who do not support those ideals, trying to gain support for your theologies as being a standard, and never kicking a dime into the IMB or Cooperative Program....you get tossed out on your ear. Which I was unhappy about even though I disagreed with their principles...they tossed them for doctrinal issues instead of the most basic reason of causing dissent amongst the convention.

SBC, by definition are undefinable....and if you can define them....then they aren't SBC anymore.

I'm currently miffed about Key Doctrine #274.
We have NEVER Had any key doctrines before, never needed a numbering system, and not wanting to endorse or even have a key doctrine of any sort.

That kinda stuff gets us all sorts of bent out of shape because we do NOT want to be defined by men.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Wrong. There is a 2023 archive on the site.

I believe I'm done here. You appear to be making up figures.
Like I stated before, it does not matter what you believe.

For those who do care - go to the site. @John of Japan is mistaking.

IMB report (June 10-11 2008)

The IMB had "5,300 missionary personnel working with people groups in 184 countries.
In 1997 when new strategic directions shifted our focus from countries to people groups, we were working with only 338 ethno-linguistic people groups. Today IMB personnel are currently engaging more than 1,100 people groups. This past year strategies were initiated among a
hundred new unreached people groups who are now hearing the gospel for the first time."


@John of Japan

I realize we may make mistakes in referencing data. I realize we can make errors in jumping to conclusions and making assumptions.

While I do not expect an apology, this does not mean you do not owe one. I would not just "make up data".

I gave my sources. All anybody had to do is look for the data.

Here is a screenshot I just took (using my phone now) -
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20261119_154246_Chrome.jpg
    Screenshot_20261119_154246_Chrome.jpg
    300 KB · Views: 0
Top