Originally posted by Dale:
Lets see...
I would like to add another Jackson to the list...Andrew Jackson who was one of the most constitutional presidents that I know anything about (of course I don't have detailed knowlege about all of them) Any man willing to die for the honor of his wife is a mans man in my book. Also, if you want to note women, I would say that most if not all of the great men listed here would'nt have been near the men they were without their wives and mothers.
I just don't understand how anyone can call Andrew Jackson 'constitutional'. He was so 'constitutional' that he ignored Supreme Court rulings and numerous federal treaties regarding the Native Americans, and committed atrocities that are probably on a level with Sherman (Trail of Tears, anyone?), since Sherman seems to be the greatest American war criminal, judging by a lot of the criticism I'm seeing of him in this thread.
And maybe I'm beating a dead horse, but Winston Churchill -was- an American. Congress bestowed honorary citizenship upon him.
Anyway, my favorite Americans:
1. Pres. George Washington
It says a lot when you're so revered by your countrymen that while you were in office even criticising you was looked upon as next to treason by many people. Quite possibly the most beloved American. Ever.
2. Gen. George S. Patton
He out-blitzkrieged the German Army and he said what he thought. Love him or hate him, the Germans feared him.
3. John Marshall
He lacked a formal education, but is quite possibly the finest legal mind to ever grace the bench of the Supreme Court.
4. Alexander Hamilton
He possessed a vision of making the US an industrial and commercial power. He was shrewd, conniving, and self-made. If Aaron Burr (who is possibly a candidate for -worst- American) hadn't killed him, he -might- have become president, even though it's probably unlikely since Jefferson hated him.
5. Benjamin Franklin
I'm kind of surprised he hasn't been mentioned yet. He was an international figure, respected throughout the world, at a time when the US badly needed one. He was one of the first to call for the colonies to band together.