• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Financial Transparency?

Kai

Well-Known Member
Suppose members of a local church started having concerns about how church funds were being allocated, specifically towards things like mission giving and other charitable programs for the community.

Since churches in the United States are generally exempt from filing Form 990 with the IRS, they aren’t required to publicly disclose detailed financial information.

So when, if ever, is it appropriate for a person who gives regularly to ask the leadership to see a record of how their financial contributions are being used?

And perhaps more importantly, how should that person respond if the leaders simply refuse to provide that information without a good reason?

I’d be interested in hearing how others would approach this, both biblically and practically.
 

Ascetic X

Well-Known Member
At a Baptist church I attended years ago, only one person collected, counted, and took to the bank all the tithes and offerings.

I do not think this is a good policy.

At secular companies, generally two or more people work together on this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kai

Kai

Well-Known Member
At a Baptist church I attended years ago, only one person collected, counted, and took to the bank all the tithes and offerings.

I do not think this is a good policy.

At secular companies, generally two or more people work together on this.

There absolutely needs to be oversight, supported by an open-book policy.

If a longstanding member started having concerns that their offerings may not be allocated towards the appropriate causes, I think they have the right to approach the leadership and ask them to take a look at the books.

If they outright refuse, offering no explanation beyond “it’s none of your business,” it may be reasonable to suspect they have something to hide.

The question, then, is whether that’s a good reason to leave and look for another church.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Suppose members of a local church started having concerns about how church funds were being allocated, specifically towards things like mission giving and other charitable programs for the community.

Since churches in the United States are generally exempt from filing Form 990 with the IRS, they aren’t required to publicly disclose detailed financial information.

So when, if ever, is it appropriate for a person who gives regularly to ask the leadership to see a record of how their financial contributions are being used?

And perhaps more importantly, how should that person respond if the leaders simply refuse to provide that information without a good reason?

I’d be interested in hearing how others would approach this, both biblically and practically.
I have asked for our budget at a fairly large church, but most churches where I have been a member handed them out (what was spent the previous year and the new budget).

If I asked and it was withheld and this could not be resolvedI would most likely find another church. I believe the leadership is accountable to the congregation.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
There absolutely needs to be oversight, supported by an open-book policy.

If a longstanding member started having concerns that their offerings may not be allocated towards the appropriate causes, I think they have the right to approach the leadership and ask them to take a look at the books.

If they outright refuse, offering no explanation beyond “it’s none of your business,” it may be reasonable to suspect they have something to hide.

The question, then, is whether that’s a good reason to leave and look for another church.
I would add...not only for long standing members. It would be a good idea to look at the budget and how things are allocated before joining a church.

There are too many "top heavy" churches out there. I would want to know a perspective church was being a good steward of its resources before joining.

This may also prevent hard feelings down the road.
 

David Lamb

Well-Known Member
Suppose members of a local church started having concerns about how church funds were being allocated, specifically towards things like mission giving and other charitable programs for the community.

Since churches in the United States are generally exempt from filing Form 990 with the IRS, they aren’t required to publicly disclose detailed financial information.

So when, if ever, is it appropriate for a person who gives regularly to ask the leadership to see a record of how their financial contributions are being used?

And perhaps more importantly, how should that person respond if the leaders simply refuse to provide that information without a good reason?

I’d be interested in hearing how others would approach this, both biblically and practically.
All the churches of which I have been a member have held regular meetings of the members, at which financial accounts are presented. It is made quite clear at such meetings how church money is being used, including missionary giving. There is opportunity for any member to question the financial report.
 
Last edited:

Kai

Well-Known Member
It would be a good idea to look at the budget and how things are allocated before joining a church.

I agree. I’m not sure I’d know the best way to approach that, either.

In the past, I’ve emailed churches I was considering joining to ask the staff for a statement of faith if one wasn’t available on their website, or to clarify their position on specific doctrinal issues.

I suppose one could ask to be sent a copy of their financial records upfront, though I understand they might be hesitant to share them with someone they don’t even know.
 
Last edited:

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
I agree. I’m not sure I’d know the best way to approach that, either.

In the past, I’ve emailed churches I was considering joining to ask the staff for a statement of faith if one wasn’t available on their website, or to clarify their position on specific doctrinal issues.

I suppose one could ask to be sent a copy of their financial records upfront, though I understand they might be hesitant to share them with someone they don’t even know.
I remember we had business meetings regularly.

Two of my pastors always emphasized members needed to attend because going through the budget, helping make decisions, approving how the resources are allocated, etc. is a congregational responsibility.

Their thought was that the pastor is sn "overseer" when it comes to discipling the church but Gos speaks through the congregation for direction and in keeping the pastor (overseer) accountable.

Every business meeting the budget was handed out, updated throughout the year. We had quarterly business meetings.
 

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
I agree. I’m not sure I’d know the best way to approach that, either.

In the past, I’ve emailed churches I was considering joining to ask the staff for a statement of faith if one wasn’t available on their website, or to clarify their position on specific doctrinal issues.

I suppose one could ask to be sent a copy of their financial records upfront, though I understand they might be hesitant to share them with someone they don’t even know.
If you have that much interest to know about the church, I would say that you would probably have visited a few times before the potential of grilling them like you were from the FBI or the IRS.
In the case of being new in town or potentially moving into the area, I don’t think it would be a very strange question so long as the money was not the main focus. It would be as much a red flag for the church to have some strangers want to pour over their books as it may feel for the potential member to feel like they are hiding something.

A bit of understanding can go a long way.
 

Kai

Well-Known Member
If you have that much interest to know about the church, I would say that you would probably have visited a few times before the potential of grilling them like you were from the FBI or the IRS.

I think you’ve hit the nail on the head.

Visit a few times and get to know the leaders, and only after you’ve decided to make the church your home, then it would be appropriate to bring that up.

Well said.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
I think you’ve hit the nail on the head.

Visit a few times and get to know the leaders, and only after you’ve decided to make the church your home, then it would be appropriate to bring that up.

Well said.
Or...attend a business meeting. You would not have a voice but you would see how involved the members are with the church.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kai

JohnDB

Member
Most EVERY church I've attended has had quarterly business meetings where copies of the budget were handed out and discussed and approved by the congregation members that cared enough to attend those meetings.
New business proposals were brought forward at these times too....like new windows needed somewhere, new playground equipment or new choir robes or whatever was needed outside of regular budgetary expenses.
Or if a new local charity needed money for whatever and came to us....it would be discussed and brought out for a vote.

Now in all of this the senior leadership of the church has the bully pulpit on all of this. They get to bring items up for congregation approval or completely ignore them.

A usually quiet pew warmer type member gets zero input normally in these matters....

However, if they are transparent like this....nothing to see or care about in most cases.

If they are NOT TRANSPARENT like the above.....there is usually something to be concerned about.

Churches are the number one target for embezzlement....just saying.
More money is embezzled from churches than any other organizations.
..
 
Top