• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Handel's Messiah

Dr. Bob

Administrator
Administrator
For years I was taught a story that always sounded so super-human as to be questionable. Wonder if others have "drunk the kool-aid" on this as well -

Handel began composing the Messiah on August 22 in his little house on Brook Street in London. He grew so absorbed in the work that he rarely left his room, hardly stopping to eat. Within six days part one was complete. In nine days more he had finished part two, and in another six, part three. The orchestration was completed in another two days. In all 260 pages of manuscript were filled in the remarkable short time of 24 days. Handel never left his house for those three weeks.

Last Sunday I heard a duetto da camera in the Italian tradition established late in the seventeenth century by Scarlatti. Bawdy Italian poetry (No, I do not want to trust you, blind Love, cruel Beauty; you lie too much - forgive my rough translation) didn't seem like Handel.

But the melody was unmistakable - "For Unto Us a Child is Born". Got me searching and found that Handel's "miraculous" writing of the Messiah was a fascinating case of self-borrowing, involving much re-composition besides re-texting in a different language and re-scoring on a grand scale.

From these earlier works of Handel we see original versions of pieces later modified and inserted into the Oratorio we love. These were all written in the year BEFORE the Messiah and only revised for his "new" work.
  • “For unto us a child is born” from inner theme of No, di Voi non vo' fidarmi


  • [*]“His yoke is easy” from Quel fior che all’alba ride


    [*]“O Death, where is thy sting?” from Se tu non lasci amore"
    [*]“And He shall purify” from Quel fior che all’alba ride


    [*]"Hallelujah” chorus from the
    motif for So per prova

    [*]“All we like sheep have gone astray” from the outer movements of No, di Voi non vo' fidarmi

    (These are the six I've seen so far; there are more)
Will continue to research this but a lot of the texts are in Italian and German. Grrrr.

That Handel was a great composer and the Messiah one of my personal favorites is not questioned. But that he just "locked himself in a room and came up with 53 unique pieces of music" might be a tad hyperbolic.
 

ktn4eg

New Member
Such practices as you mentioned were common among composers of the Baroque era, and Handel was no exception.

I've been told that composers of that day and age actually considered such borrowings as a compliment.

No telling what Messiah would have sounded like had he attempted to compose such a work in this age of licensing agreements, royalty fees and copywrite infringement laws--especially due to the fact that Handel was facing the threat of being placed in a debtors prison at the time he composed that oratorio.
 

Tom Butler

New Member
And, I'm sure many are aware that in many parts of the world, when the Hallelujah Chorus is sung, the audience stands.

This tradition is said to have started with the London performance of The Messiah, with King George II part of the audience. Then the Hallelujah Chorus began, the King rose to his feet. Of course, when the King stands, no one sits, so audience and orchestra all rose and stood until the end of the section.

No one is certain why the king stood, but there's plenty of speculation.

(From Wikipedia)

He was so moved by the performance that he rose to
his feet.
  • Out of tribute to the composer.
  • As was and is the custom, one stands in the presence of royalty as a sign of respect. The Hallelujah chorus clearly places Christ as the King of Kings. In standing, King George II accepts that he too is subject to Lord of Lords.
  • He arrived late to the performance, and the crowd rose when he finally made an appearance.
  • His gout acted up at that precise moment and he rose to relieve the discomfort.
  • After an hour of musical performance, he needed to stretch his legs.
  • He mistook the first few notes in the chorus for the national anthem and stood out of respect.
 

Zenas

Active Member
Very interesting, Dr. Bob. I rarely read through the posts on this board without learning something. Thanks for sharing. :wavey:
 

jaigner

Active Member
That Handel was a great composer and the Messiah one of my personal favorites is not questioned. But that he just "locked himself in a room and came up with 53 unique pieces of music" might be a tad hyperbolic.

Great post. As a singer, music teacher and conductor, I have a great interest in this.

I agree that it might be "hyperbolic," but it was mostly melody that was borrowed, and a lot of them were from early art songs, which would have only been accompanied by harpsichord. To borrow pieces of melody is one thing, but to harmonize and orchestrate like he did is the brunt of the work.
 

Gina B

Active Member
I wanted it to be read!! Will move it in a couple days.

Neat post, my daughter will be interested in it.

A couple years ago I had the pleasure of joining in singing it downtown at the annual Christmas tree lighting, that was pretty neat!

It's by no means a favorite of mine, but it's fun to see other people enjoy it.
 

Bro. Curtis

<img src =/curtis.gif>
Site Supporter
I guess Frank Zappa would be as close to a contemporary American "Handel". Frank borrowed from his work all the time. Bach would enter improv contests as a young man and use what he came up with in future works.(Probably had some ideas stolen, as well).

This is interesting, it is still a great piece of music. I performed in in a huge choir, singing the bass part, when I was a young man. I agree with Jaigner, the bulk of the work is the orchestration, but I had no idea about the early work of Handel.

Thanx, Doc.
 
Top