There are intermediate positions that one may occupy.
Trying to make an alternative to a pagan celebration is a good thing. That's why churches sometimes hold graduation parties for their high school youth on the same night as the get-drunk-and-fornicate party the other seniors are attending.
Historically, though, the attempt to Christianize pagan holidays hasn't fared too well. It's hard to sanitize paganism. Bringing in the fertility cult and giving the symbols new interpretations pretty much winds up just confusing everybody until onlookers, and some members, cannot tell the difference between the church and the world.
American Christianity might start drifiting that way if we aren't careful.
I'm just sayin' . . .
Trying to make an alternative to a pagan celebration is a good thing. That's why churches sometimes hold graduation parties for their high school youth on the same night as the get-drunk-and-fornicate party the other seniors are attending.
Historically, though, the attempt to Christianize pagan holidays hasn't fared too well. It's hard to sanitize paganism. Bringing in the fertility cult and giving the symbols new interpretations pretty much winds up just confusing everybody until onlookers, and some members, cannot tell the difference between the church and the world.
American Christianity might start drifiting that way if we aren't careful.
I'm just sayin' . . .