Texas,
when asked those who are saved are able to give a clear testimony of how they were saved. There should be no problem with asking a person if they know this for sure. I should think it should be the ONLY criterion for church membership, but it most definitely SHOULD be A criterion.
If the person lies that is between them and God. If for some reason their salvation is not clear in their own mind, than what better opportunity to help them clear it up than by having a deacon discuss it with them?
Here, I'll give you MY clear testimony. I was raised in a Christian home, and in churches where the gospel was present. When I was around 8 or 9 years of age, I realized that I had never actually personally talked with Jesus about making Him my saviour.....Im using different terminology because so many object here to things like "accepting Jesus into your heart" but that is essentially what I did. I realized I had never been born again. This was the Holy Spirit's convicting, although it was not a very emotional moment, it was really pretty calm. I stopped right then and prayed to Jesus, telling Him that I wanted Him to be MY saviour, and that I wanted Him to come into my life.
Having been raised in a Christian home already, and still being very young, there was not a huge change in my life at that point. Although there were some things that definitely were different. I was not as oversensitive about things as I had been before, and the guilt of "all my sins" was no longer hanging over my head as it had done before.
I really don't understand your objection to our way of seeing members brought in....if you are objecting to it, that is.
We have no long list of specific doctrinal issues that they must sign off on, most have no idea of their stance on these things, and will not for quite some time in their Christian life.
Yet to have no criterion at all for membership, as in salvation, is not right. Churches must be made up of a regenerated membership. We have to have some way of attempting to make sure that is true. Asking a person for their testimony is really the only way to do that.