• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Is it Wrong to Pray for and Desire Real Prophecy

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I don't understand where you are going. I am talking of prophecy as recorded in scripture. Prophecy in the bible is special revelation into a particular circumstance. If it is into our circumstances, it may be a section of the bible given in prophecy or new revelation that testifies to Jesus Christ for our edification, exhortation, and consolation.
That "new revelation" is the Preaching and teaching of the scriptures, no extra revelation today!
 

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Yes He did. But it is not proper teaching to use that verse against what may be genuine prophets. Jesus didn't say the only people in the end times will be false prophets.
he did say to us thru revelation that there will be ONLY those 2 eyewitness in the end times, and that all others are bogus!
 

Particular

Well-Known Member
I don't understand where you are going. I am talking of prophecy as recorded in scripture. Prophecy in the bible is special revelation into a particular circumstance. If it is into our circumstances, it may be a section of the bible given in prophecy or new revelation that testifies to Jesus Christ for our edification, exhortation, and consolation.
Prophecy as recorded in scripture can be a brand new revelation or a forthtelling of an older revelation to the moment.
If you believe in new revelations from God, then there could be a potential adding of inspired scripture to the Canon. This is what both Muhammed and Joseph Smith claimed with their revelations.
I reject new revelations as antichrist. God has revealed to us all we need for Godly living.
However, God can use a brother or sister to speak a specific scripture to us that cuts to the heart of our hidden sin (like Nathan did with David). That is a prophetic foretelling to a specific person by ordinance and providence of God. I believe God still does this form of prophetic work today.
 

Steven Yeadon

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Prophecy as recorded in scripture can be a brand new revelation or a forthtelling of an older revelation to the moment.
If you believe in new revelations from God, then there could be a potential adding of inspired scripture to the Canon. This is what both Muhammed and Joseph Smith claimed with their revelations.
I reject new revelations as antichrist. God has revealed to us all we need for Godly living.
However, God can use a brother or sister to speak a specific scripture to us that cuts to the heart of our hidden sin (like Nathan did with David). That is a prophetic foretelling to a specific person by ordinance and providence of God. I believe God still does this form of prophetic work today.

I guess the problem with that is, where do you find that doctrine in the bible? Also 1 John exhorts us to test the spirits. Jesus says to test prophets in the Sermon on the Mount. Thus, we are commanded in the bible to test prophets, their spirits, and Deuteronomy has two tests of their message. To test it's accuracy and whether it testifies to Yahweh and Jesus Christ. After you include instruction in John.
 

Reformed1689

Well-Known Member
I guess the problem with that is, where do you find that doctrine in the bible? Also 1 John exhorts us to test the spirits. Jesus says to test prophets in the Sermon on the Mount. Thus, we are commanded in the bible to test prophets, their spirits, and Deuteronomy has two tests of their message. To test it's accuracy and whether it testifies to Yahweh and Jesus Christ. After you include instruction in John.
I mean if you want to go the Deuteronomy route we should be putting the false ones to death right?
 

Particular

Well-Known Member
I guess the problem with that is, where do you find that doctrine in the bible? Also 1 John exhorts us to test the spirits. Jesus says to test prophets in the Sermon on the Mount. Thus, we are commanded in the bible to test prophets, their spirits, and Deuteronomy has two tests of their message. To test it's accuracy and whether it testifies to Yahweh and Jesus Christ. After you include instruction in John.
Would you accept a new book being added to the Canon of the Bible by a new prophesy?
 

Marooncat79

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
That is ripped out of context. First they were asking for a sign in the heavens beyond Jesus' miracles of exorcism and healing. Second, only those with impure hearts would ask for prophecy to prove their faith.

Our first love, Yahweh, must be our first love, not the gifts. Love is also a greater gift than prophecy according to scripture.

Pentecostal and Charismatic prophecy is false prophecy. Also when I was a Charismatic Christian so called prophecy was a power trip.

I should explain that genuine prophecy, the infallible kind, is meant to build up the Body of Christ in the scriptures. The intent of biblical prophecy is to build up the Body or lead people to Jesus Christ. Thus, real prophecy isnt about the prophet but the good of the audience. In fact many prophets suffer greatly for their message. To tell people what they need to hear may get you disliked, hated, and even persecuted. Anyone who seeks revelation must be ready to carry a bigger cross.


1. The passage is not out of context.

2. Extra biblical revelation is not consistent w the witness of early christians. They declared the era of this ended w the death of John.

3. Why do we need extra when we dont even do what is written very well
 

Steven Yeadon

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
1. The passage is not out of context.

2. Extra biblical revelation is not consistent w the witness of early christians. They declared the era of this ended w the death of John.

3. Why do we need extra when we dont even do what is written very well


1. I disagree. I must say though that the context assumes plenty of miraculous evidence on Jesus' behalf. Jesus later references his resurrection, the sign of Jonah, which is a miracle the faith is founded on attested to by hundreds of witnesses. Lastly, the scripture you reference doesn't seem to apply to authentic, biblical prophecy.

2. This is not true. Martyrology in church history taught me that. Remember martyrs and confessors in the early church can sometimes be considered prophets. The most famous of them is Perpetua.

3. That is an odd point to me. The prophecies in Revelation to the churches are a great example of that principle not being in play. Those churches are struggling, most of them, and the words of Christ are not weighing them down further but trying to lift them up out of the mire.
 

Marooncat79

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Believe what you will. There is no Biblical basis for any of it.

If true individual prophecy exists then the Bible can mean anything someone wants it to mean

Got thrown out of a church in Brownsburg IN for this same thing. Some yahoo claimed to see “the hand of God” which is an example of where it all ends. Thankfully, the church as it existed at that time died out
 

xlsdraw

Well-Known Member
I don't think foreknowledge, which I know God sometimes gives, is necessarily prophecy
.
My grandfather and grandmother, sitting together in their home, on an evening in 1915, both saw a vision that appeared before them. The vision was of a neighbor in a casket. The next day, they were told by other neighbors, that the man had committed suicide that night. The vision, being immediately realized, and though tragic, increased my grandfather's faith in what had already been a tragedy filled life prior to that, to be able to endure an increasingly more tragic life yet ahead.

I had a dream concerning a serious illness I would have. I thought it was just a common dream. Until I started the experience of going through the illness. I experienced the Lord's intervention and His comforting to go through the experience. Everything happened exactly as it was in the dream. He went through the valley with me, and I was faith filled throughout, because of the foreknowledge I was given. Just as in the dream, the doctors were confounded by what I experienced. After being sent to several specialists, for follow up visits, they still don't understand. It's not meant for them to understand. It was meant to increase my faith.

H.E.L.P. ministrie's Scottie Drake is a member of our church. He testified of Iraqi Christians in underground churches in Iraq that had abandoned Islam. They had heard scriptures spoken to them in dreams. They had never heard scriptures before. Then they found out the scriptures they heard were words Jesus had spoken in the New Testament. Scottie Drake also fell ill and into a coma for a few weeks, 1.5 years ago. He came very close to death but the Lord restored him.

In every instance of foreknowledge, the result was bringing to faith or increasing faith.
 

Steven Yeadon

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Believe what you will. There is no Biblical basis for any of it.

If true individual prophecy exists then the Bible can mean anything someone wants it to mean

Got thrown out of a church in Brownsburg IN for this same thing. Some yahoo claimed to see “the hand of God” which is an example of where it all ends. Thankfully, the church as it existed at that time died out

I am sorry you were kicked out of a church due to a false prophet. I am dispassionately seeking the truth of scripture.

I believe you are interpreting the bible wrongly.

You ignored my church history example and pursued an unrelated argument.

You seem to believe all revelation is up there with scripture, a doctrine disproven by the bible.
 
Top