Remaining Roman Catholic

[Earth Wind and Fire]

Years ago I was a Baptist. I suspect I believed closely to what yo


I'm going to hazard a guess that you visited a WELS church? They even consider the LCMS heretical.

Yes sir! I guess everyone has their own viewpoint ( a view from a point) as to what is heretical.

 

[steaver]

Just so you know, I am not here to defend Catholic Doctrines. I have my own conserns with their approach, posturing, structures of worship etc.

But to be fair, they do teach Christ and Him crucified... and I further believe that there are people in that church who are saved.... just as there are people in other Eucharistic/ Sacramental churches (Lutherans, Methodist, Anglican, Presbyterian, Reformed) who are saved —But are in error.

I can work with that Steve... I can look for some level of commonality but if I insult them, if I disown them as being
A lesser being & not being worthy of the Kingdom, then I’ve made enemies.

I have never made personal insults to anyone. They do get offended and feel insulted when their doctrines are said to be false. As you can see, the Catholic biblical stance that they have the say on biblical doctrine as being based on Luke 10 is so far out of context it is ridiculous. Yet they still repeat it bc they blindly follow the RCC.

 

[Wesley Briggman]

Years ago I was a Baptist. I suspect I believed closely to what yo


I'm going to hazard a guess that you visited a WELS church? They even consider the LCMS heretical.

Whether or not it was a WELS or LCMS church, they are teaching error.

The Lutheran doctrine teaches consubstantiation.

 

[Walter]

Whether or not it was a WELS or LCMS church, they are teaching error.

The Lutheran doctrine teaches consubstantiation.

Whether or not it was a WELS or LCMS church, they are teaching error.

The Lutheran doctrine teaches consubstantiation.

Many Lutherans would object to the term 'consubstantiation' as not adequately reflecting their beliefs, but all would accept the belief in the Real Presence. So do I and so did the Early Church.

 

[Wesley Briggman]

OK... the syringe baby baptism story. 2) find something written in Catholic archives supporting that type of medical procedure used to baptize an embryo

http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02258b.htm

" In like manner they consider as probably valid the baptism of an infant in its mother's womb, provided the water, by means of an instrument, would actually flow upon the child. Such baptism is, however, later to be repeated conditionally, if the child survives its birth (Lehmkuhl, n. 61)."


"...while baptism can be bestowed upon infants immediately after they are born, and in case of necessity even in their mother's womb."

I chose to believe the most practical "instrument" refereed to above to be a syringe. Both men I referred to in my previous post said the baptismal kit in the Catholic hospital contained a syringe to be used in the baptismal process.

I have no motive to lie about what I heard and what is documented in other sources.

 

[Rippon]

tad amount

It's tantamount.

Kunundrums
It's conundrums.

 

[Adonia]

http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02258b.htm

" In like manner they consider as probably valid the baptism of an infant in its mother's womb, provided the water, by means of an instrument, would actually flow upon the child. Such baptism is, however, later to be repeated conditionally, if the child survives its birth (Lehmkuhl, n. 61)."


"...while baptism can be bestowed upon infants immediately after they are born, and in case of necessity even in their mother's womb."

I chose to believe the most practical "instrument" refereed to above to be a syringe. Both men I referred to in my previous post said the baptismal kit in the Catholic hospital contained a syringe to be used in the baptismal process.

I have no motive to lie about what I heard and what is documented in other sources.

I clicked on the address but it won't take me there, so I then went to the address bar and the 404 error came up and said not found.

 

[Wesley Briggman]

I clicked on the address but it won't take me there, so I then went to the address bar and the 404 error came up and said not found.

Thanks for letting me know. Once you are on this site, do a find on "womb" to locate the quoted text.

CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: Baptism

 

[Adonia]

Thanks for letting me know. Once you are on this site, do a find on "womb" to locate the quoted text.

CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: Baptism

Okay, I found it. Seems to me that this is a theological exercise - it probably never has happened ever and I have never heard of such thing myself.

 

[Squire Robertsson]

This thread is closed.

Six Hour Warning
This thread will be closed sometime after 6:30 PM Pacific.