Allan said:
<snip>
One of my main points of disagreements is that in your view a person can be saved and never have placed their faith in Christ.
Again, the points to consider is that eternal salvation is entirely dependent upon the mercy of God on the sinner, not on his faith, obedience, or knowledge.
We need to be able to see the difference between eternal salvation and temporal salvation.
I would think of temporal salvation as a believer having preached the gospel of a finished redemption and have someone approach him and say he was convicted with what he heard and would like to learn more.
What should the preacher do ?
Tell this person to go home and pray about it ?
Or take this person under his wings and disciple him, in accordance with the instructions of the Lord.
If the second step is taken, and this person professing conviction is truly a regenerate child of God, then he manifests faith (if he belonged to another religion or creed he turns away from his faith on that false god to faith in the true God), repentance (which has the same fruits as faith), and obedience (perhaps he gets baptized, or keeps on attending church, and getting discipled).
But the questions are: will all preachers of the gospel reach every single human being on this planet as they live or die ? Obviously the answer is no. If the answer is no, and our belief is that there has to be active manifestation of faith before any actual redemption takes place, then the work of redemption becomes dependent on the ability of gospel preachers and missionaries to reach human beings, and it no longer rests on the finished work of Christ at the cross, and if He accomplished nothing at the cross without His work being preached, accepted, and believed in here on earth, then the Bible is not trustworthy because that Bible says He died once for
all and obtained eternal redemption for
us all . And you know what Scriptures I am referring to.
And in that same book, Hebrews, it tells us that He sat down (a figurative way of saying "rested") at the right hand of power. But what rest is there when nothing has been accomplished ?
Which is why I say "eternal redemption" is finished, whether the redeemed knows it or not, has faith on it or not, because his redemption is
for heaven and not for earth.
On the other hand, there is still a need to go and preach the gospel, because it is God's will that the Son be revealed to as many as those that limited human preachers can reach, because their limitations in their presence is no hindrance to the Holy Spirit who is everywhere, and by the time they are where they have been called to, the Holy Spirit Himself has prepared the hearts of those for whom the gospel is intended.
Another question is: are all gospel preachers preachers of the
true gospel ?
Were Roman Catholic missionaries of past centuries preachers of the true gospel ? Are Mormon missionaries preachers of the true gospel ? Are JW's preachers of the true gospel ? Are SDA's preachers of the true gospel ? Is Fred Phelps a preacher of the true gospel ? Moses David, or David Berg of the Family, was a Baptist preacher, then he founded the promiscuous "Children of God", but I understand previous to that, he was a missionary, was he a preacher of the true gospel ?
There are many other numerous examples.
What are we going to do with those whom these people reached and converted ahead of the preachers of the true gospel, conclude they are damned because of their circumstances ?
But God is above all circumstances, and He will not fail His people whom He had promised redemption to, and He did not fail when Christ went up on that cross, because He knew each and everyone of His own, after all He is the owner of the Book of Life, and those whose names were written there had their names written there BEFORE the foundation of the world, how then can He turn back on His word that "none shall be lost but the son of perdition".
allan said:
You place this person in the eternally saved but not temporally saved catagory if I remember it right (feel free to correct me cause it has been a while since we discussed this).
Again, this person was redeemed at the cross here in time, irrespective of his knowledge, faith, creed, location, or politics. God's people are scattered all over the earth, divided and separated geographically, politically, by creed and religion, tongue, circumstances. If their eternal salvation and subsequent regeneration were dependent on the limited ability of a human being to be everywhere all the time, unlike the Holy Spirit, then the Lord will have no one among the most remote tribes of this earth, and if being born a member of a remote tribe equals eternal damnation, then God is no longer just.
As it is, since the Bible tells us that God's redeemed shall come from all tongues, all nations, and all kindreds, then that can only be true if the redemption done by Christ at the cross were independent from the temporal nature of blessings brought about by obedience, faith, and repentance as a result of hearing the true gospel, and of obeying it.
allan said:
<snip>
What benifit is there eternally to temporal salvation or better what good is the temporal salvation of one compared to the eternal salvation of the one who never believed??
The problem is that we are pitting benefits against benefits, and therefore losing sight of God's glory.
The purpose of redemption is, alpha to omega, God's glory. Ephesians tells us this.
God had no obligation to save anyone, as I am sure you will agree, but TO HIS GLORY (just emphasis, not yelling) He did save many, because He is a merciful God.
Having obtained eternal redemption for His people, the purpose of gospel preaching is to (1) reveal Christ to His people. We need to see the religious and cultural context at the time when Christ sent out His apostles. There was NO NATION on earth which knew of the One True God, and of His Son Jesus Christ, yet the redemption which the Triune God authored encompassed all generations, all nations, and all kindreds (the world, if you will) where He had His people.
(2) to instruct and edify. Clearly indicated in the Scriptures.
The temporal salvation that results from obedience to the gospel, and from removing oneself from the error of his religion, brings blessings to the child of God as a natural consequence of obedience, but at the same time brings, in some cultures then as today, persecution and afflictions.
Either way, it brings glory to God, and that is the ultimate purpose, whether one experiences both eternal and timely salvation.