• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

The Chosen

JohnDB

Member
Yes, you have indeed, and as a result I've learned more about the people and customs in the time of our Lord.

But, it is still, at best, nothing but circumstantial evidence that the man sold abortion drugs.
If ONLY what you said was true....
If only.

It just isnt...
And you still have a boatload of things to provide to show what I'm saying is wrong.

I've provided LOTS of proof that you choose to dismiss but still refuse to provide evidence to the contrary....
Are you or the others a shill for planned parenthood or something?
 

Ascetic X

Well-Known Member
You have dismissed all of these facts without even a second's hesitation. Are we to begin using scissors on scripture now when someone explains the narratives with what was once obvious facts you do not like or want to recognize?

Its uncomfortable....I get it. But the scissors you are using are making me uncomfortable.
Im not suggesting a female senior pastor or something ridiculous like that....nor have I gone beyond what scripture has said.

You just don't like the conclusions for some reason.
You have hijacked this thread which is supposed to be discussion of The Chosen.

I for one have affirmed the possibility that your speculations and guesses may have some validity.

You have zero proof. You have only relevant facts that might be applied to Simon, or might not.

Your opinion about Simon of Cyrene is not uncomfortable at all. I am opposed to abortion.

But if God wanted it to be perfectly clear that Simon was a silphium dealer, He could have removed all doubt by the gospels saying “Simon of Cyrene, a silphium dealer”. More details could have been added.

You have concocted a theory based on things outside the Bible narrative.

You seem to ignore and dismiss many relevant facts that I provided, such as how silphium was not used just for abortions.

If you feel so strongly anti-abortion, perhaps there are activities you can engage in to protest Planned Parenthood and abortion clinics in your area.

But you cannot claim your theory is irrefutable, because it is questionable by the silence in the scriptural references to Simon of Cyrene.

The most that can be stated is that it is possible he was a silphium dealer. No more can be said.

My hometown is famous for its breweries and whiskey distilling, but I do not sell alcohol.
 
Last edited:

JohnDB

Member
I for one have affirmed the possibility that your speculations and guesses may have some validity.

You have zero proof. You have only relevant facts that might be applied to Simon, or might not.

Your opinion about Simon of Cyrene is not uncomfortable at all. I am opposed to abortion.

But if God wanted it to be perfectly clear that Simon was a silphium dealer, He could have removed all doubt by the gospels saying “Simon of Cyrene, a silphium dealer”. More details could have been added.

You have concocted a theory based on things outside the Bible narrative.

You seem to ignore and dismiss many relevant facts that I provided, such as how silphium was not used just for abortions.

If you feel so strongly anti-abortion, perhaps there are activities you can engage in to protest Planned Parenthood and abortion clinics in your area.

But you cannot claim your theory is irrefutable, because it is questionable by the silence in the scriptural references to Simon of Cyrene.

The most that can be stated is that it is possible he was a silphium dealer. No more can be said.

My hometown is famous for its breweries and whiskey distilling, but I do not sell alcohol.
And you are demonstrating your error in hermeneutics....
Applying modern writing styles and customs to the Ancient Near Eastern writing and customs.

You simply Can't do it....its common enough....but stop it. Its not doing you any favors.

So....
Go back....
Do SOMETHING other than just dismiss what I've said. Because at this point thats ALL...THE COMPLETE ENTIRETY of what you have done. You gonna do the same for Sennacherub surrounding Jerusalem for immediate takeover?

Address any of the points I've made with something other than dismissal.

And I've already been successful in demonstrating how "animal fodder" was something ridiculous posted in whatever source you quoted. (I would never use that resource again for such a blunder as that)

You are still grasping at straws...desperate for me to be wrong....grab something substantial (if you can....you cant, but its still worth a shot)

There's a LOT of people who never wanted this to be known....
And currently we are fighting the fight of obscured knowledge. IOW people obscured the knowledge deliberately. Like the chapter and verse divisions in scriptures obscure the writing's natural chapter divisions to hide truths they really did not want to be obvious.
 

Mikoo

Active Member
And you are demonstrating your error in hermeneutics....
Applying modern writing styles and customs to the Ancient Near Eastern writing and customs.

You simply Can't do it....its common enough....but stop it. Its not doing you any favors.

So....
Go back....
Do SOMETHING other than just dismiss what I've said. Because at this point thats ALL...THE COMPLETE ENTIRETY of what you have done. You gonna do the same for Sennacherub surrounding Jerusalem for immediate takeover?

Address any of the points I've made with something other than dismissal.

And I've already been successful in demonstrating how "animal fodder" was something ridiculous posted in whatever source you quoted. (I would never use that resource again for such a blunder as that)

You are still grasping at straws...desperate for me to be wrong....grab something substantial (if you can....you cant, but its still worth a shot)

There's a LOT of people who never wanted this to be known....
And currently we are fighting the fight of obscured knowledge. IOW people obscured the knowledge deliberately. Like the chapter and verse divisions in scriptures obscure the writing's natural chapter divisions to hide truths they really did not want to be obvious.
Thank you for you opinion on what God doesn't say in HIS Scriptures. So, back to the OP. What are your thoughts on the show (The Chosen), and how you feel about the message it sends.
 

JohnDB

Member
Thank you for you opinion on what God doesn't say in HIS Scriptures. So, back to the OP. What are your thoughts on the show (The Chosen), and how you feel about the message it sends.
But He does....you may not like it.... but theres a LOT more He says without directly saying it....

Example: Jesus does not say "I am God"....
But if you come to the conclusion that Jesus is not God you are in serious trouble....
S E R I O U S trouble.

And see!
The junk that the Chosen is putting out is even more problematic because Jesus is not more human than God....
Which is what this show makes Him out to be.

Jesus always had a strong sense of identity and knowledge about who He was and more importantly WHY He came.

Every last bit of action He took HE SCRIPTED AND CHOREOGRAPHED thousands of years before He arrived .
Before the foundations of the Earth were lain.
And lots of people just refuse to believe that. Nothing happened to or with Jesus by chance or happenstance. Every moment was scripted and choreographed. An infinite amount of Sovereignty, time, wisdom, power, and knowledge was behind His Israel tour.

That show makes it something a lot less.
 

Mike B

Well-Known Member
It just isnt...
And you still have a boatload of things to provide to show what I'm saying is wrong.
I've provided LOTS of proof that you choose to dismiss but still refuse to provide evidence to the contrary....
Are you or the others a shill for planned parenthood or something?

You have provided circumstantial evidence, and nothing more.

You made this claim, and can not support it. I (or anyone else) doesn't owe you squat.

Accuse those who disagree with you of heinous things. Ad hominem...the last resort
when an argument fails.

**************************************************************

I watched the first episode of the final season, and while it did follow some scripture,
they also added in legions of angels prepared to defend Jesus, and He waved them away.
Not scriptural.
 

JohnDB

Member
You have provided circumstantial evidence, and nothing more.

You made this claim, and can not support it. I (or anyone else) doesn't owe you squat.

Accuse those who disagree with you of heinous things. Ad hominem...the last resort
when an argument fails.

**************************************************************

I watched the first episode of the final season, and while it did follow some scripture,
they also added in legions of angels prepared to defend Jesus, and He waved them away.
Not scriptural.
I have supported it in numerous ways and fashions....(history, scripture, anthropology, theological, geography, topography)
No different from the many other doctrines.
I have more support for this than you do for that tiny cracker and sip cup for Communion.

You are angry....I can tell. But thats not on me, thats totally you. And if you want to refute what I've said you need to actually improve your hermeneutic skills. Not just find another preacher to parrot. You have to own your own set of skills.


No one has provided anything to prove what I've said is wrong or evil or antichrist or anything else....
The theology I've promoted is not in conflict with any other theology in SBC circles...not a single one. (By all means prove this point if you can)
The phoney claims of "circumstantial evidence" is another red herring....untrue and insulting to those who have always believed life matters.

But this is a complicated subject....its not one preached from the pulpit ....no different from what is preached about King David....they sanitize his life to make it palatable in church services too. Mixed company in small group is not gonna discuss this either.

So here's your shot....
 

Mike B

Well-Known Member
No one has provided anything to prove what I've said is wrong or evil or antichrist or anything else....
The theology I've promoted is not in conflict with any other theology in SBC circles...not a single one. (By all means prove this point if you can)
The phoney claims of "circumstantial evidence" is another red herring....untrue and insulting to those who have always believed life matters.

First off, no, I am not angry with you..not in the least. No reason I should be. Frustrated, perhaps,
that you continue to pursue this issue.

That said, you made the claim that this Simon of Cyrene was a drug dealer for a substance that
caused abortions. And yes, you have attempted to support that accusation with all manner of "history,
scripture, anthropology, theological, geography, topography", etc. Yet, there is nothing scriptural or
otherwise that confirms that this man is guilty of the charged crime.

The evidence you have presented is "circumstantial", meaning "relating to or depending on surrounding
details or conditions rather than direct proof or essential facts." This is not a "red herring", but an accurate
description of the information you have presented.

I do believe that life matters, and that truth matters. The evidence you present is somewhat compelling,
however it is still lacking sufficient proof to convict the man of the charge.
 

JohnDB

Member
First off, no, I am not angry with you..not in the least. No reason I should be. Frustrated, perhaps,
that you continue to pursue this issue.

That said, you made the claim that this Simon of Cyrene was a drug dealer for a substance that
caused abortions. And yes, you have attempted to support that accusation with all manner of "history,
scripture, anthropology, theological, geography, topography", etc. Yet, there is nothing scriptural or
otherwise that confirms that this man is guilty of the charged crime.

The evidence you have presented is "circumstantial", meaning "relating to or depending on surrounding
details or conditions rather than direct proof or essential facts." This is not a "red herring", but an accurate
description of the information you have presented.

I do believe that life matters, and that truth matters. The evidence you present is somewhat compelling,
however it is still lacking sufficient proof to convict the man of the charge.
WOW
Thats called denial. Its not just dismissing....its flat denial.

And you keep calling it a criminal offense. On what basis are you claiming that?

Because in the Ancient Near East, even in Jewish culture and the 613 laws of Judaism what Simon of Cyrene was doing was not a crime. And they had the strictest laws of anyone in the neighborhood.

If calling someone "a fool" would get you hauled before the Sanhidrin which would get you horsewhipped 49 minus one times but you could say they weren't thinking (empty head) and be free and clear of the Law.

This selling of Silphium as an abortifacient and aphrodisiac was one of those things that circumvented every Law of Judaism they had. So long as he did not open his market stall on Saturday....he was just fine.

And this whole time you ALL keep claiming my evidence (which are extremely substantial proofs despite your claims otherwise) is just circumstantial at best albeit somewhat compelling does NOT make YOUR CLAIMS TRUE.

Lies have a matrix.
They are flat and without details, rely upon your (the listener's) gratuitous assertions to fill in blanks and are impossible to get to the bottom of due to the huge number of mischaracterizations and false premises. Sky is the limit on lies. Embellishments conflict more and more with established truth and scriptures and even believable actions by others. But its always fun to hear, it scratches itching ears. Bad guys get punished and good guys get rewards type things.

Truth?
It is extremely limited. Its always heavily nuanced. It doesn't travel anywhere else because its unpopular. It never conflicts with other truths. Nobody wants to hear it because its always inconvenient and bruises egos. The good guys get forgotten and bad guys get license by authorities to be bad....

Which is why this subject matters as much as it does during this discussion of The Chosen.

The Chosen follows the lie matrix.
It ticks every last box on the lie matrix. The Jews succeeded in Crucifying Jesus. They suffered no earthly consequences for lying and purgery about Jesus.
 

Mike B

Well-Known Member
And this whole time you ALL keep claiming my evidence (which are extremely substantial proofs despite your claims otherwise) is just circumstantial at best albeit somewhat compelling does NOT make YOUR CLAIMS TRUE.

Haven't made any claims, John. You have.

I'm done with this pointless discussion.
 

JohnDB

Member
Haven't made any claims, John. You have.

I'm done with this pointless discussion.
And I've supported EVERY SINGLE CLAIM WITH FACTS.

I'm just surprised at all the denial and false claims made against me as I present the truth.

There are other lessons JUST LIKE THIS in scriptures...nobody argues about them except for people with a theological axe to grind....like Catholics, Presbyterian, Church of Christ, Church of God, AOC, Episcopalians, Methodists and etc...all dependant upon their unique theologies.

Nobody likes these lessons made clear with a more complete hermeneutic...
Confusion, "Grey areas" are where the Narcissists love to play and grab authority to exert control. Light and clarity are where they run and hide from....extinguish the lights and go back to grey and obscure ground.....

Studying the harmonies and disharmonies of the gospels provides more lessons. Especially as you learn the sciences that makes things clear....

Would people rather be right in front of men or would they rather know God better?

Answers are frightening....we have never progressed Spiritually from when Jesus walked. The Pharisees, Sadducees and experts in the Law are all right here....right now.
That should bring fear and trembling....but instead it brings the same reaction as it did 2,000 years ago. Jesus's sacrifice has become license to sin instead of freedom from sin.

In many ways despite the horrible pain and suffering The Coming is going to be such a relief.
 

Foxmeister

Well-Known Member
You made the claim Simone of Cyrene was a Simon of Cyrene siphium dealer, yet the Bible does not say that. You're accusation is nothing more than conjecture based on siphium was grown there. That's like saying all women who live in a town with a bordello are prostitutes.
 

Ascetic X

Well-Known Member
You made the claim Simone of Cyrene was a Simon of Cyrene siphium dealer, yet the Bible does not say that. You're accusation is nothing more than conjecture based on siphium was grown there. That's like saying all women who live in a town with a bordello are prostitutes.
He piles up conjectures and calls them facts.

If you live in a town with an Army base, that does not prove you are a soldier.

He wants to call Simon of Cyrene a sinful silphium dealer, but silphium was used for many things, not just abortion.

Silphium was used for culinary seasoning, medicine, perfume, lentil preservative, food for sheep and goats, aphrodisiac, and contraceptive.

Silphium was also applied or ingested for ailments ranging from sore throats, coughs, and fevers to toothaches, indigestion, goiters, and animal bites.

He ignores these facts that do not fit in with his theory.
 
Top