• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

The Systematic Theology of John Brown of Haddington

Zaatar71

Well-Known Member
II. God, by a continued work of providence, upholds and governs all things which he created.

1. As he is infinitely more perfect than they, and hath brought them into existence, he hath an undoubted right, and all-sufficient fitness, to uphold and govern them. Having infinite knowledge to discern all their qualities and connections,
—infinite wisdom to conduct them to their proper ends,
—infinite power to uphold and manage them, notwithstanding all their strength, mischievousness, jarring passions, instincts, or immediate aims,— infinite holiness and equity to prevent culpable partiality or impropriety in his conduct
,—infinite patience to bear with offenders, while it can be for his glory and their good,
—and omnipresence, rendering him equally near to each of them, he cannot but be infinitely fit for this work.

2. His own perfections require him to uphold and govern all his creatures. His independency requires him to hold all things in perpetual and immediate dependence on himself. His wisdom requires him to make all his creatures answer the ends for which he formed them. His goodness requires him never to forsake the work of his hands. Even his equity forbids, that they should be brought into being, and then left to shift for themselves.

3. Their very nature obliges them to a constant dependence on God. They cannot subsist a moment without new support from his infinite power, wisdom, and goodness. And having formed them to be receivers from, not givers to him, his providence must supply them according to their necessities, as far as his own glory, the chief end of their creation, can permit.

4. The regular motions of the heavenly bodies,
—the regular ebbing and flowing of the sea,
—the regular returns of day and night, summer and winter, seedtime and harvest,
—the periodical retirements of many animals to places suitable to the season, their sagacity in defending or 178 providing for themselves, and in forming their lodgings, hatching or nourishing their young,
—the near approaches of those animals which are useful to mankind, and retirement of hurtful ones into woods and deserts, deep or distant places of the sea;
—the multiplication of the more useful animals, while noxious ones, which are naturally more prolific, are not suffered to abound;
—the astonishing variety observable in animals, vegetables, and other things, seemingly similar;
—the amazing diversification of men's faces, voices, tempers, and forms of writing, taken as connected with the order and safety promoted by it;—the constant proportion of men and women answerable to their circumstances;—the frequent counterplotting of man's most sagacious projects, and defeating his most forcible and promising attempts;—the many miraculous counteractions of the ordinary laws of nature;—and a thousand other like actions, irrefragably manifest a Divine Providence managing the world.

5. The exact correspondence of thousands, I had almost said of every event, relative to persons, families, or nations, and especially relative to Christ and his church, with the predictions of Scripture, plainly demonstrate, that God, the predicter, hath the upholding and government of all things in his own hand.

6. The Scriptures no less plainly declare that God, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, by the agency of his own will, upholds and governs all his creatures, John 5:17; Heb 1:3; Col 1:17; Job 33:4; Ps 104:30; Dan 4:34-35; Rom 11:36; Eph 1:11; Rev 4:11; Isa 41:4; Isa 45:5-6; Isa 46:4,10-13; Job 37:6; Job 12:9; Job 38-41; Ps 8-9; Ps 19:1-6; Ps 48; Ps 65-66; Ps 68; Ps 78; Ps 103-107; Ps 114; Ps 135-136; Ps 145-148; Ezek 9; Ezek 20; etc.
 

Zaatar71

Well-Known Member
In this work of providence God upholds and governs all his creatures, and all their actions, Heb 1:3; Rom 11:36; Eph 1:11, Col 1:17; Isa 46:10; Rev 4:11.
1. All irrational creatures—animate or inanimate, great or small, Neh 9:6; Ps 36:6; Ps 104:19-21; Dan 4:35; Job 37
—41; Ps 8; Ps 104-107; Ps 136; Ps 145-148; Hos 2:18,21-22; Ezek 34:25; Matt 6:28-33; Matt 10:28-31; Exod 8:16-17; Exod 10:12; Deut 28:28; Joel 2:20,25.
Hence stars and rivers fought as his troops, in destroying Jabin's army, Judg 5:20-21; frogs, flies, and lice, plagued the Egyptian oppressors of his people, Exod 8-10; serpents punished the murmuring Israelites, Num 21; hornets drove out the wicked Canaanites, Exod 23:28;
mice plagued the profane and murderous Philistines, 1 Sam 5:5; bears and lions executed his vengeance on the profane scoffers of Bethel, the disobedient prophets, and idolatrous Samaritans, 2 Kings 2:24; 2 Kings 17:25; 1 Kings 13:24; 1 Kings 20:36;
unclean ravens provided pure food for his favorite, Elijah, 1 Kings 17:6; pity to cattle partly moved him to dry up the waters of the flood, and to spare the city of Nineveh, Gen 8:1; 1 John 4:11. 2. All reasonable creatures
,—holy angels, Ps 103:18 21; Ps 104:4; Heb 1:14.
—fallen angels, Luke 22:31-32; 1 Kings 22:21 23. Job 1:12; Job 2:6; Ps 78:49; Matt 8:28-32; Matt 12:27-28; Matt 4:24-25; Rev 2:10; Rev 12:7; Rev 13:7; Rev 20:2,7-10;
—men, and all their members, are written in this book of providential care, Exod 32:32; Ps 69:28; Ps 139:16; Ps 33:13-15; Prov 8:15-16; Prov 16:1,9; Prov 21:1; Dan 2:21-22,44,47; Dan 4:35; Job 12:10; Acts 17:28.
He governed the fate of Jacob, a very mild man, and his offspring, Gen 28:13-15; of Ishmael and Esau, very wild men, and theirs, Gen 16:12; Gen 25:16,23;
—the concerns of Jesus Christ, God-man, and his church, which is his body, Isa 42:1-7; Isa 50:4; Isa 49:1-12; Isa 53; Rom 8:28-39; 1 Cor 3:21-22; 2 Cor 4:17; Heb 13:5.
—By his providence he managed the haughty and obstinate Egyptians, Exod 1-14; Exod 18:11; the oppressed and dispirited Israelites, Gen 15:13 18; the proud and atheistical Syrians, 1 Kings 19:15; the powerful and furious Assyrians, Chaldeans, Persians, Greeks, and Romans, Isa 10; Isa 30; Isa 33; Isa 37; Jer 25:1; Jer 51; Dan 2-11; Zech 6; the savage Tartars and Turks, Ezek 38-39; Rev 7-9; Rev 20; the crafty, wicked Papists, Dan 7; Dan 11:36-43; Rev 9-19;—nay, the whole earth, Isa 24; Ps 22:27-31.
—His providence extends to men's birth, Job 10:3,8 12; Job 33:4; Ps 139:14-16; Ps 22:10; Ps 71:6;
—their manner of life, Gen 15:13; Gen 16:12; Deut 30:9,19-20; Deut 32:10; Job 12:10; Ps 56:8; Ps 139:2; Ps 116:9,12; Ps 71:17-18; Prov 22:2; Prov 16:9; Isa 46:3-4; Matt 10:29-30; and their death, Job 14:5; John 7:4; Ps 39:5; 1 Sam 26:10; Jer 34:4-5; Jer 22:19; Jer 36:30. 3. All the actions or motions of his creatures, Isa 45:6-7; Lam 3:38; Amos 3:2,6-7.—

1. All natural motions of inanimate, or actions of animate creatures, Ps 74:16-17; Ps 136:8-9; Ps 104; Gen 8:21-22; Isa 55:9-10; Jer 31:35-36; Matt 5:46; Job 37-41.
Hence plants fixed between a fruitful and barren soil direct all their roots toward the former,
—and fishes and fowls, at stated seasons, travel and station themselves to their own or mankind's advantage:—
2. All preternatural motions. By his influence the waters overflowed the earth, and after they had drowned the ungodly inhabitants, were dried up, Gen 6-8;
—Sodom was destroyed by fire and brimstone, Gen 19:24;
—Egypt was plagued, and the Red Sea and Jordan divided, Exod 7-14; Ps 75:14-15; Ps 89:10; Ps 78:12 14; Ps 77:14-20; Ps 114; Ps 136; Ps 135; Ps 105-106; Ps 78; Josh 3-4; 2 Kings 2.
— manna and quails were rained about the Hebrew camp, and water brought from flinty rocks, Exod 16-17; Num 11; Num 20; Ps 78:15-28;
—the earth swallowed up Korah and his companions, Num 16;
—the thunders roared and lightnings flashed at Sinai, Exod 19-20; Exod 24:16-17;
—the sun and moon stood still, Josh 10:12-13; Hab 3:11;
—the sun went backward ten degrees, Isa 38:8;
—a drought of forty-two months scorched the land of Israel, 1 Kings 17-18; James 5:17;
—ravens, which feed on carrion, regularly provided Elijah with clean flesh, 1 Kings 17:6;
—a whale swallowed up Jonah, and after three days landed him in a proper place, Jon 1:17; Jon 2:10;
—an outrageous fiery furnace burnt the bonds of Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego, while it did not singe their clothes or hair, Dan 3:19-37;
— hungry lions attended Daniel a whole night, without hurting him in the least, but furiously devoured his accusers, Dan 6:22-24.—

3. All accidental motions, as the slipping of an axe-head,—falling of a lot,— or fixing of a random arrow in the joint of a coat of mail, etc. Exod 21:13; Deut 19:5; Prov 16:33; 1 Kings 22:17,28,34; Ezek 21:19-27; Jer 51:16; Ps 147:15-18; Matt 10:29; Gen 22:8,13.—

4. All free actions, which depend on men's will, Prov 16:1,9; Prov 20:24; Prov 21:1; Jer 10:23; Phil 2:13; Gen 24:7; Gen 45:5,7; Gen 50:20; Isa 46:10-11; Isa 10:5-7; Acts 4:28.—

5. All civil actions, even the management of armies in the hottest battles, Isa 10:5-7; Ps 47:9; Jer 36:19; Prov 8:15-16; Isa 10; Isa 13; Jer 46-51; Mic 2:13.—
6. All moral actions, good or evil, Isa 26:12; 1 Cor 4:7; Phil 2:13; James 1:17; 2 Cor 3:5; Exod 10:1; Deut 11:3,6; 2 Sam 12:11-12; 2 Sam 16:10; 2 Sam 24:1; 1 Kings 11:14,26; 1 Kings 22:22; Ps 81:12; Isa 6:9-10; Isa 29:14; Jer 4:10; Ezek 14:9; Ezek 20:25-26; Rom 1:24-28; Rom 9:17; Rom 11:8,32; 2 Thess 2:10-12.
—In respect of his operation about these creatures and their actions, his providence may be distinguished into his natural, miraculous, moral, and peculiar providence. God's natural dispensation of providence includes,
 

Zaatar71

Well-Known Member
1. His upholding all creatures in their existence and particular forms, and in their powers of action, motion, or passion,—and in the actions or motions themselves, Job 12:10; Heb 1:3; Col 1:17; Rev 4:11; Neh 9:6; Ps 36:5 6; Ps 145:15-16; Ps 147:8-9; Matt 6:26-30.

2. His government of them,—which includes, 1. His fixing certain laws or rules, called ordinances of heaven, covenant with day and night, or the like, according to which he ordinarily regulates his influence, Jer 31:35 36; Jer 33:25; Ps 119:90-91.

2. His cooperating with, and directing the motions of his creatures, according to these stated rules and his own purpose, Gen 8:22; Gen 9:11; Isa 10:15; Jer 10:23; Ps 74:16-17; Ps 115:3; Acts 17:28; 1 Cor 12:6; Eph 1:11; Isa 46:10-11; Dan 4:35.
—In this he applies his creatures to act,—and on such particular objects,
— and in such a manner, Isa 10:5; Ezek 21:21-23; Job 1:12; Job 2:6; Acts 1:26; Exod 21:12-13; 1 Kings 22:34; and he accurately directs them to their proper ends, Prov 19:21; Prov 16:1,9; Prov 21:1; Gen 49:10.
In his ordinary managements of providence, God allows second causes to have their full influence, and acts in, and by them agreeably to their nature as inferior agents or instruments in his hand:
—But his cooperating influence or concourse is not merely general, fixing a particular impression upon second causes, and then leaving them to move and act of their own accord; but it is particular with every particular creature, and producing every particular motion or act, in its particular form.
1. The Scripture represents God as exerting particular influences,
—in giving victories, Ps 33:16; Ps 18:43; Ps 144:1;
—in giving direction or satisfaction, Ps 13:1-5;
—in sending Joseph into Egypt, Gen 45:5,7; Gen 50:20;
—in employing the Assyrians, Chaldeans, and Persians, as his rod, axe, hammer, and host, Isa 10:5,15; Isa 13:14; Jer 51:22-23.
And sometimes his terror, falling on their enemies, procured victory or deliverance for the Jews, Judg 7:14-22; 2 Chron 14:11-14; 2 Chron 20:22-23; 2 Kings 7:6.
How absurd to imagine, that all these were owing to impressions made upon certain atoms, at the creation!

2. If God only made a general impression of whatever kind on things, at the first, all things must now be carried on by necessity of nature, independent of his will;
—and either that impression hath necessarily produced sin in angels and men; or they, in sinning, have counteracted his almighty influence impressed.
3. Such a general concourse exempts his creatures from all continued dependence upon him in their operations, while they are allowed to depend upon him in their existence, Acts 17:28; Prov 16:1,9; Prov 21:1.
—But concerning this divine cooperation, it must be observed,
1. It is not any power transmitted from God to his creatures, in order to move them; but an agency of his own will, by which he makes second causes to act, when and how he pleases.

2. The acting of God, and that of his creature upon which he acts, are not separable, or different, but he makes it to act, not by its own independent energy, but by the influence of his will.

3. No creatures are left to determine the influence of God's concourse with them, as they please, as the nature of the objects upon which the sun shines, determines his influence to melt, harden, scorch, or fructify them, etc.
—If they were thus left to determine it, his agency would be subjected to theirs, and they would do more in an action than he did;
—he could be no more the author of good than of evil; no decree could be certain of execution, or any prediction, promise, or threatening, of fulfilment.

4. The agency of God's will in order of nature, not of time, must always precede that of his creature, in every motion or act, Rom 11:36. God's miraculous providence is that in which his agency surpasses, or is contrary to the influence of second causes, and stated rules of his common operation;
—as in stopping the course of the sun,
— dividing seas,
—raising dead persons,
—or giving sight to such as were born blind, etc.
—God does not exert more power in working miracles, than in common providence, but merely suspends his ordinary influence, or counteracts the natural or common influence of second causes.
—And herein no creature can be any more than a moral instrument of declaring the will of God, by some word or token, that such a miracle should be wrought.
—If we consider the infinite wisdom, power, holiness, justice, goodness, truth, and majesty of God, we may, in real miracles, expect,
 

JesusFan

Well-Known Member
Greetings brothers. Peace and hope to you in our Lord Jesus Christ.
@Van @Zaatar71 @JesusFan @JonC



It seems to me, in the attempt to make distinctions, that God knows all things knowable. I say "all things knowable" to exclude human nonsense and irrationalism. A good example of what I intend is the introductory example in every philosophy course, that of the 'imagined' married bachelor. The question usually is, could God create a married bachelor?

This imagined concept is nonsense disguised as wisdom. It is a contradiction, an error of thought passed off as something imaginable. Since by definition a bachelor is someone not married, then it is nonsense to suggest that something can be and not be at the same time.

But we dare not fall into the trap and suggest that this is something God cannot create. For it is nonsense from the very beginning of premise one. It is as if I asked, can God kjieine
e einfeienf ifnefiie (which no one should understand).

Likewise, God knows all things knowable.


This 'can God choose to not know something' is interesting. My first blush response to it would be something like what JesusFan replied.

We do know in Hebrews 8:12 it says, "and their sins and their lawless deeds I will remember no more." So there would be a sense in which God remembers no more. But is this "remembering" or is this "counting toward offense remembering". It still doesn't speak to God not knowing before the action, only to God saying He won't remember after the action.

In true compatablist fashion, I'll claim God's complete providence from atemporal eternity AND the God enabled temporal freedom to submit or reject. Neither conflicting with the other. As Genesis 50:20 suggests, both God's will and man's will seem to be done.

(Gen 50:20 NKJV) 20 "But as for you, you meant evil against me; [but] God meant it for good, in order to bring it about as [it is] this day, to save many people alive.

Peace to you brothers
God would know all possible outcomes that would have happened, per Quantum Physics for example
 

JesusFan

Well-Known Member
I would think you would like this, because it is overloaded with scriptural references

I am about the same way now, more with the biblical theology as it speaks toward our carrying out the Great Commission

My reading is more on biblical theology now. The systematics are needful to stave off heretics and cults. The biblical theology gets more to heart and life issues.
He is more into Historical theology, yet blasts away on anything to do with theology as Historically held by many Christians, as represented in Creeds/Confessions and Theologies?
 

JesusFan

Well-Known Member
On and on, the Calvinists post copy and paste immense amounts of verbiage, citing verse after verse, but signifying nothing.

God's will and desire to save all people is clearly stated in 1 Timothy 2:4, but not by way of compulsion, the false claim of Calvinism. God provided the means of salvation, Christ Jesus, and the access path for salvation, faith in Christ as credited by God. Thus, Christ died as a ransom for all, 1 Timothy 2:6, those to be saved in accordance with God's redemption plan, and those not to be saved in accordance with God's redemption plan, 2 Peter 2:1. Everyone believing in Christ, as determined by God alone, will never perish, but have everlasting life, John 3:16.

This is not rocket science.
Is it the desire and will of God that all should get saved?
 

Zaatar71

Well-Known Member
Is it the desire and will of God that all should get saved?
Before I posted this section I invited people to read and interact scripturally with the posted material with the posted material. Some may have just glanced or read some of it...there is alot to look over, but some just try and brush it off with a sentence or two, then they wonder why they cannot quite figure it out. Those who want study help, there is more than enough material here for that.
 

Zaatar71

Well-Known Member
Zaatar, it's better just to post the site you are copying.
I can guess with some confidence that nobody has read most of the material you posted.

The Systematic Theology of John Brown of Haddington [link]

John Brown of Haddington (1722-1787)
I agree in part and understand what you mean. After seeing many things that do get posted on here, I enjoy reading solid teaching, then questions and answers on the posted section. If a person is preparing a bible study for example, they can scroll down and copy and paste the section they need, and use the posted material as a core of bible study for their local assembly.

I have the hard Cover volume in my Library, but so much is packed into it, I have found that posting it online,and editing the sections a bit, is more effective as a source of bible study. When I use the hardcover at Home it is still good, but it overwhelms a bit. Thanks for your good observation.
 
Top