It has been great reading all of your lists. What a blessing these songs are to our faith!
I think it looks like Charles Wesley has made a huge impact on many of our lives with "And can it be."
Here is my list:
1. And can it be
2. All that thrills my soul is Jesus
3. Come thou fount of every blessing
4. Heaven came down and Glory filled my soul
5. When I survey the wondrous cross
6. Dwelling in Beulah Land
7. My Jesus, I love Thee
8. The crimson wave
9. Constantly abiding
10. It is well with my soul
Wow! That really was difficult... I don't know if I picked my top 10 or not...pretty close I think.
Numbers 1-3 are not negotiable with me...don't even try to talk me out of them.