Hillary is a nominal Methodist, but few Methodists are Evangelicals these days and Hillary has made it clear that she is pro-choice which disqualifies her from being an Evangelical. As for Jimmy Carter, he is a religious liberal, and liberalism is considered cultic theology. He and Clinton were both Southern Baptists; Carter left the SBC on his own and Clinton was thrown out. Obama was in a blacks-only church that cursed the USA and publically criticized Evangelicals as bitter enders, etc. (check You Tube). Obama also made attacks on the truth of Scripture and thus identified himself with the cult of liberal Christianity.
So the question remains, why vote for someone who hates you and calls you a deplorable?