I'll cut to the chase. Lukewarm is avoiding the Eve question because it undoes his enlightened and intelligent acceptance of the possibility of creation by evolution. What, God took millions of years to make Adam so He could create Eve in an hour?
God did not need SIX 24 HOUR DAYS to make the universe, either. So I don't see your point.
The "God took... so he couldn't..." mess is silly. God could build a trillion to the trillionth power universes a million times larger than our own in a trillionth of a second without the least effort.
How much time it "took God" (whatever that means) is UTTERLY irrelevant.
The straightforward narrative describes in detail a surgical procedure through which God extracted the raw material to form Eve. Attempting to relegate the narrative to allegory requires he deny what he asserted elsewhere, that Adam and Eve were historical people, the first humans.
No one has said they are not historical people. I agree. That is a Gospel issue. There absolutely HAD to be a real man and real woman who were the absolute first of their kind from whence every human being who has ever existed has been born.
I have no problem whatsoever with the idea that Adam and Eve were special creations of God made from real dirt around 10,000 years ago.
I also don't have a problem with other possibilities that allow that there absolutely HAD to be a real man and real woman who were the absolute first of their kind from whence every human being who has ever existed has been born.
No allegory is completely without literal facts intermingled. I have no problem whatsoever with Adam and Eve being special creations of God somewhere between 6-10,000 years ago.