Chemnitz said:
DHK, by your own words you make God out to be a liar
The idea that God cannot do something is a purely human notion. There is a big difference between "cannot" and "does not." God is capable of doing all things. God does not lie because he has chosen not to and in his perfection he succeeds where we men fail.
I don't make God to be a liar; if anyone does you do.
God cannot lie. The Bible states it to be so. He is not capable of lying. This is not a human notion. What you have done is taken a statement that Christ has said and taken it out of its context. The statement must be qualified as most statements are.
God cannot do those things that are against His nature. I never thought that I would see the day that I would be debating a doctrine so basic in theology as this with you.
God is just. He cannot do those things which are unjust.
God is holy. He cannot do those things which are unholy.
God is love. He cannot do those things which are unloving. etc., etc.
God cannot do that which is against his nature
Neither does God ever go against His Word.
His Word is yea and yea; and nay and nay.
He is not a man that he should lie; neither the son of man that he should repent... (Num.23:19)
You have taken a verse out of context and seemingly built your own doctrine/religion around it. The atheists would love you for it. "Can God create a rock so great that he cannot lift?"
[quoteWhere in Romans 6 does it ever give any hint that Paul is talking figuratively? If you are going to claim a symbolic meaning you are going to have to prove it.[/quote]
Romans 6:3-6 Know ye not, that so many of us as were baptized into Jesus Christ were baptized into his death?
--Literal or figurative?
I was baptized in or into water. The medium was water, not Christ.
The answer--figurative.
4 Therefore we are buried with him by baptism into death: that like as Christ was raised up from the dead by the glory of the Father, even so we also should walk in newness of life.
--Literal or Figurative?
Was Christ buried with me in the water? I didn't see him there.
There is a word in that statement,
like as which denotes a similie. A similie means that the expression is figurative.
ASChrist was raised up from the dead...
EVEN SO we also shall walk in newness of life. Is if literal or figurative? The evidence overwhelmingly points to figurative.
5 For if we have been planted together in the likeness of his death, we shall be also in the likeness of his resurrection:
--Literal or Figurative?
Was I actually planted? Was Christ with me when it happened. When something is planted it takes time to grow. If that were the case I would be dead. But it doesn't say that. It says
in the likeness of his death.
It is another figurative expression. It doesn't say that I am dead, but rather that I am in the likeness of his death and shall be in the likeness of his resurrection. Nothing here is literal. It is figurative. It is full of similies, and figurative speech that shows how symbolic baptism is.
6 Knowing this, that our old man is crucified with him, that the body of sin might be destroyed, that henceforth we should not serve sin.
--If this was literally true I would be literally dead and buried six feet under. But my body and all of its millions of cells are alive. It is not destroyed. It is a picture of what happens at salvation that is pictured in baptism.
In response, to your snide remarks no I do not get a warm fuzzy or any of the other things you mention. I do not base my faith on something as flimsy and fallilbe as human emotions or reason. My faith is created and based upon the objective promises of God.
Good, because baptism is simply a command by Jesus to the believer. The only feeling that you ought to get is the feeling of getting wet. There is no grace imparted.
Now back to the text at hand if God does not lie and all things are possible for God then Romans 6 must be understood as a description of the work God is doing in Baptism, because to claim any other is to make God a liar.
Only if you read into Scripture that which is not there. Read it objectively. Read it in its context. Realize that even the very word "baptidzo" means immerse. There is a picture there. It is purely symbolic.
DHK