• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Why do Baptists Wind up in another denomination / religion ....

Salty

20,000 Posts Club
Administrator
How many folks in you church have joined a non-baptist church?
Whether it was another Evangelical Group, Catholic, non-Christian religion, ect -
Why are some leaving?

Is it we are not disciplining?
Is it they marry / shack up with a non Baptist
and the list can go in?: Chapter 2: Religious Switching and Intermarriage
 

Lodic

Well-Known Member
As one who moved around quite a bit, I've been a member of several non-Baptist churches. I joined a non-denominational Charismatic church just after I was saved. I've been a member of a couple of other non-denominational churches, different Assemblies of God churches, a Presbyterian church, and several Southern Baptist churches. For me, where I lived was a major factor. Even my current church, which I really love, is only a five-minute drive from home.

Why do some leave? I believe it's a lack of proper discipleship. This isn't just a Baptist problem, but a problem with the church overall. We aren't very good at leading people to Christ, and we are terrible at keeping them. I believe we need to put more effort into small groups where we can build relationships with our brothers and sisters in Christ. We cannot grow in isolation, so we tend to look elsewhere for spiritual food and fellowship.

Unfortunately, a lot of young Christians leave the church when the go off to college. They are especially prone to do so if they haven't been properly discipled. The more mature Christians have a duty to mentor those who are young in the Faith. As we can see, we are failing quite badly.
 

37818

Well-Known Member
I think one must come to the persuasion Baptist is not merely it's Protestant name origin. But of the original Apostolic New New Testament foundation as churches. Being in a New Testament church, this being the whole point of being Baptist.

Doctor Dick Part 2
 
Last edited:

Deacon

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
My retired friend just left our Baptistic congregation to become the preacher of a struggling Mennonite church just a block from my house (their pastor retired due to illness).
He lives near-by.
He knows many in the congregation.
He doesn’t need to be paid.
There was a opportunity and a need, he filled it.

It’s not exactly Baptist but it’s a very close relative.

Rob
 

AustinC

Well-Known Member
Radical individualism and wish dreams (read ch1 of Life Together by Diedrich Bonhoeffer on Community) are a major part of movement. People either looking for the church they have in their mind as the perfect church, or others desperately wanting community, but finding a church of radical individualists who couldn't care less about community.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Stating the obvious, some of our theology is a combination of philosophy and Scripture (systematic theology). Many younger people do not share our worldview, which can cause conflict with theologies held by their church (not necessarily conflict with Scripture). For them their church or denomination may hold a theology they view as not compatible with reality.

We saw this at the close of WW1 as many Christians abandoned millennialism.

We see this today as many younger Christians (particularly Calvinists) view Renaissance philosophy flawed and move away from the Penal Substitution Theory of Atonement.

We also see this when we have socio-economic challenges as a nation, particularly when a church or denomination is not active in caring for people.

It is normal. The church changes. Older people hate it, but they die off and the change becomes normal. Then the young becone old and it happens again. The church stands still.
 

37818

Well-Known Member
The difference between the believing there is a God and actually knowing God. John 17:3.
 

tyndale1946

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter

Try believing in TULIP in an Arminian household?... I believe Sovereign Grace TULIP, the few the Calvinist belief will be saved is turned into a multitude of Sovereign Grace as God planned not man!... Brother Glen:)

How do I live in an Arminian household?... I have a strong filter!:Biggrin
 

Piper

Active Member
Site Supporter
Actually, I was a member of a very well known and prominent Calvinist Pastor's church, one who was leading in the Reformed resurgence. And quite a few people who were in that church for a long time were leaving and going to Anglican churches. It makes no sense to me. The teaching was so clear from our pastor, and his writings were strong and prominent. I really think it is some kind of nostalgia, or personal preference for liturgy that is really strong, maybe stemming from a childhood in a liturgical church.
 

AustinC

Well-Known Member
Try believing in TULIP in an Arminian household?... I believe Sovereign Grace TULIP, the few the Calvinist belief will be saved is turned into a multitude of Sovereign Grace as God planned not man!... Brother Glen:)

How do I live in an Arminian household?... I have a strong filter!:Biggrin
Ha!
I can relate to this.
 

Marooncat79

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Radical individualism and wish dreams (read ch1 of Life Together by Diedrich Bonhoeffer on Community) are a major part of movement. People either looking for the church they have in their mind as the perfect church, or others desperately wanting community, but finding a church of radical individualists who couldn't care less about community.
Excellent book
 
Top