• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Willful Ignorance?

michelle

New Member
Peace and love to you all in Jesus Christ our Lord and Saviour!

--------------------------------------------------
Ed quoted:

This I say, therefore, and testify in the Lord, that you should
no longer walk as the rest of the Gentiles walk,
in the futility of their mind,
--------------------------------------------------

Pay close attention to "in the futility of their mind". This is exactly what the modern scholars, and those responsible for the underlying text of the modern versions relied upon. Amen to your showing this scripture, for it shows the fallicy of one who puts their trust in anything other than the Lord and his words of truth.

love in Jesus Christ our Lord and Saviour,
michelle
 

Phillip

<b>Moderator</b>
Originally posted by Charles Meadows:
Grannygumbo:

"Till a year ago, I'd never so much as heard of a KJVo or Ruckmanism, or Gail, or Greek/Hebrew, etc, etc, etc...all I EVER had on hand(or cared to, for there was no reason to have anything else), was my Bible...not called the KING JAMES, just HOLY BIBLE."

No one would fault you for that position. It's a fine stance, and an internally consistent one. But there are those (not me!) who have on hand the NIV, NASB, NKJV and have grown to love its verbage - the HOLY BIBLE. If you (which I'm not saying you have) choose to denigrate their bible then you're attacking them. Remember this is a debate forum! ;) If you state an opinion then you're likely to have to defend it. You don't have to make any excuses for what you believe (as you well know) but on this forum you know you're probably going to get asked to PROVE IT!
This is actually a very good description of what is happening.

I understand Granny's reasoning, because I know many Christians who have accepted "THEIR BIBLE" as "THE BIBLE" and there is nothing wrong with that. There isn't anybody on this board (I don't imagine) that does not believe Granny is a good Christian. That is not the point.

However, it is when people from the KJVo group start saying that MY Bible is NOT the Word of God, then I start having a problem and I will speak out against such an attack.

I also think there is a misunderstanding of exactly what the word "ignorant" means. When we were kids, we might use "ignorant" as a slang word for "stupid". The TRUE meaning of the word "ignorant" is simply stated as a lack of knwoledge in a particular subject. When I say that I am ignorant of Biblical Hebrew, it does not make me any less smart than other people or even scholars. I may not be as smart in THEIR subject matter, but they may be just as "ignorant" in the fields that I work.

Everybody is "ignorant" to different issues. Do not take offense when someone calls you ignorant because all they are saying is that you are ignorant to the subject matter being discussed or, more simply put, you do not know very much about THAT particular subject.

If a person is "ignorant" to Biblical history and history of translation, it does not make them a good Christian or a bad Christian. It simply means they have not been educated in that particular subject.

In a way, I think scholars have hurt themselves because there are both good scholars and bad scholars. People rant and rave about scholars who believe in evolution. Then they turn around and ask a less educated person to believe them when they say I know more about Biblical history than you because I am a Biblical scholar.

I am not trying to point fingers at ANYBODY. Personally, I do not believe in the KJVo position, but in some cases, such as Granny and Michelle, I understand their frustration and maybe the use of the word "ignorance" is commonplace in our level of thinking, it is a personal insult to their way of thinking.

All I am trying to do here is bring this to a level of conversation where we can talk without emotions clouding the issues and I think maybe "walling in ignorance" is a little bit much. As Christians, let us explain our views in love and attempt to show the truth.

I do see one thing that is a definite problem. Members of the KJVo group do tend to skip over long posts containing a lot of information. Maybe we need to stick to one single question at a time until we receive a satisfactory answer for that question. I have tried to do that with some questions and they are ignored. Why, possibly because there is no answer to that question. Possibly, it goes against the "faith" wall built up by the KJVo groups. If you will notice, when you ask a Mormon missionary about a conflict in their belief, what is their answer? Usually it is the same answer you get from the KJVo crowd: "Who came up with that information? or Where did you get that information?" Then instead of answering the question they will discredit the source with a simple. Oh, yeah, It came from "White" (for example), yeah, he doesn't know squat about the KJV. He's a liar. etc. etc.

I am just rambling here a bit, but I think if we can stick specifically to questions, then it will be difficult for our KJVo group to provide answers and maybe they will start seeing the truth. I just, personally, don't think that they understand OUR use of the word "ignorance" and maybe for the sake of peace and trying to obtain the reasons they believe what they do, it is a negative.

Just some opinion here. What do you expect from an "ignoramous like me". :D
 
S

sharpSword

Guest
Phillip "All I am trying to do here is bring this to a level of conversation where we can talk without emotions clouding the issues "

Oh Phillip I am dying here.... ROFL
laugh.gif
laugh.gif
thumbs.gif


Can you say Passion movie without OPINION and FEELINGS and WARM AND FUZZY FEELINGS...? Rofl..

Sorry...will try to remove emotion and just give opinion. :D
 

Phillip

<b>Moderator</b>
Originally posted by sharpSword:
Phillip "All I am trying to do here is bring this to a level of conversation where we can talk without emotions clouding the issues "

Oh Phillip I am dying here.... ROFL
laugh.gif
laugh.gif
thumbs.gif


Can you say Passion movie without OPINION and FEELINGS and WARM AND FUZZY FEELINGS...? Rofl..

Sorry...will try to remove emotion and just give opinion. :D
We don't discuss The Passion over here.


How else can I win with a statement like that?
laugh.gif
 

michelle

New Member
Peace and love to you all in Jesus Christ our Lord and Saviour!

--------------------------------------------------
Phillip quoted:

Everybody is "ignorant" to different issues. Do not take offense when someone calls you ignorant because all they are saying is that you are ignorant to the subject matter being discussed or, more simply put, you do not know very much about THAT particular subject.
--------------------------------------------------

What do you suppose God has said about wisdom? Is it wise to put all your trust and faith in God, his promises and his wisdom and his words? Or is it wise to put all your trust and faith in man and man's wisdom and words? Would God rather have us wise in his wisdom and ignorant to the world? Or would he rather we be wise in the world and ignorant to his wisdom? If the Holy Spirit has convicted my heart that those verses of scripture that have been long understood, taught, believed, preached, lived, for believers for generations, and myself, to then see them omitted in modern versions, should I then disobey and reject what the Lord has shown me? I will not, and cannot do this. I love God's truth more than anything. I think many of those standing for the modern versions, and excusing the omittions of God's preserved words, are being ignorant to what God has shown others and trying to show them.


Love in Jesus Christ our Lord and Saviour,
michelle
 

GrannyGumbo

<img src ="/Granny.gif">
From one ignoramous to another-hiya Phillip!
wave.gif
Thanks for trying to soothe my ruffled-feathers, but I assure you I am NOT offended by the term "ignorant", nor for being "labeled", tho' I did not ask to be.

I do get upset with remarks such as this: "Some folks on the Versions Forum need us to yank their chain so the light comes on . . or to hear the flushing sound..." because when that "threat" comes, usually someone gets suspended and/or banned & I am tired of losing my brethren.

Thank the Lord, thank the Lord, for a more simpler-time when the preacher used the same Bible the folks did & the teacher kept it on her desk & the pledge/devotion was given & no one asked "which one or which god". Back when it was a sin to have a baby out of wedlock & marriage was sacred; records were kept in the old family Bible & the funeral was preached from it. One Bible. One God. One faith. Courthouses(at least here) still use it & those "gideons" still give it away.
 

michelle

New Member
Peace and love to you all in Jesus Christ our Lord and Saviour!

Phillip,

Since it was brought up, I am curious to find out what your view/opinion on the movie the "Passion" is? Feel free to personally email me with your response, if you desire to answer.

love in Jesus Christ our Lord and Saviour,
michelle
 

Phillip

<b>Moderator</b>
Okay, Michelle, God has convicted my heart that my ESV is the Word of God and has blessed me greatly while reading it and studying new versions. (I'm not just saying this because you did.)

So, now where do we go for proof. Obviously, one of us is wrong, because the Holy Spirit will not tell one person one thing and the opposite to another person. God is the same forever. The Alpha and the Omega.

Tell me in one simple statement where we go next to solve this dilema?
 

Dr. Bob

Administrator
Administrator
Granny, pleased to see you visit the Coffee Shop where I said that! Why would that upset you?

No one has been suspended or banned unless they continually violate the rules of simple Christian decency. One may espouse a liberal position of "onlyism" or believe English texts that have added to the inspired Word of God and NOT fear being banned.

We have had threads on denying the Bible is inspired or the Word of God and folks dealt with the subject with Christian grace. No one got suspended.

Playing the "martyr" doesn't cut it. No one is a martyr here because they believe the KJV(whatever revision) is the Holy Bible.

[BTW, I've been reading more and posting less here on the BVT forum for fear I was "yanking chains" to much and creating more problems. Guess just reading this thread shows the "martyr mentality" is alive and well without my chiming in!
)
 

michelle

New Member
Peace and love to you all in Jesus Christ our Lord and Saviour!

--------------------------------------------------
Phillip quoted:

So, now where do we go for proof. Obviously, one of us is wrong, because the Holy Spirit will not tell one person one thing and the opposite to another person. God is the same forever. The Alpha and the Omega.

Tell me in one simple statement where we go next to solve this dilema?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Phillip,

This can easily be done. The scriptures. Please provide scriptures for your stand, as I have provided to you and others, and many others who understand what the Spirit says, have also provided. You should include scripture, that indicates that God would omitt his preserved words, and that he would not perfectly preserve them for all generations, if you desire me to take you sincerely and honestly. The scriptures are how we are to judge and discern all things. What scriptures did the Lord convict your heart of these things.

Love in Jesus Christ our Lord and Saviour,
michelle
 

Phillip

<b>Moderator</b>
Originally posted by Dr. Bob Griffin:
[BTW, I've been reading more and posting less here on the BVT forum for fear I was "yanking chains" to much and creating more problems. Guess just reading this thread shows the "martyr mentality" is alive and well without my chiming in!
)
If Bob were kicking you off for your stance of KJVo, we MVers would be complaining that he was turning you into a martyr. :D
 

Phillip

<b>Moderator</b>
Besides, it would be awfully boring if all we had to debate with was other MVers. We have to have somebody that we can correct. :eek:
laugh.gif
laugh.gif
 

sdnesmith

New Member
Originally posted by Phillip:
All I am trying to do here is bring this to a level of conversation where we can talk without emotions clouding the issues and I think maybe "walling in ignorance" is a little bit much. As Christians, let us explain our views in love and attempt to show the truth.
"Oh East is East and West is West and never the twain shall meet" - Rudyard Kipling

"The truth" is very subjective. KJVO's are convinced that they have "the truth" as do most on the other side of the issue.

Whether you call it "willful ignorance" or "spiritual blindness" it is basically the refusal to consider another position that may be different from your own. While accepting the KJB as a good translation of the manuscripts available in the early 17th century, I also recognize the fact that most modern versions, with the obvious exception of the New World Translation from the Watchtower Society, are the products of the best textual criticism available today. Unfortunately, most churches that use KJVO reject any modern scholarship due to the corrupt influences of today's society. I believe the favorite verse is 1 Cor 1:27 to ridicule anyone educated.
 
D

dianetavegia

Guest
Actually, Granny Gumbo, the Gideons now also have the NEW King James Version. This is information off the Gideon.org website.

Plain (no Gideon Symbol) pocket-sized New Testament with Psalms and Proverbs (brown only, King James Version or New King James Version) These are just like those distributed by the Gideons, except all Gideon identification has been omitted. The special "helps" in the front and back prepared by the Gideons are included in these.
Diane
 

Phillip

<b>Moderator</b>
Originally posted by michelle:
Peace and love to you all in Jesus Christ our Lord and Saviour!

--------------------------------------------------
Phillip quoted:

So, now where do we go for proof. Obviously, one of us is wrong, because the Holy Spirit will not tell one person one thing and the opposite to another person. God is the same forever. The Alpha and the Omega.

Tell me in one simple statement where we go next to solve this dilema?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Phillip,

This can easily be done. The scriptures. Please provide scriptures for your stand, as I have provided to you and others, and many others who understand what the Spirit says, have also provided. You should include scripture, that indicates that God would omitt his preserved words, and that he would not perfectly preserve them for all generations, if you desire me to take you sincerely and honestly. The scriptures are how we are to judge and discern all things. What scriptures did the Lord convict your heart of these things.

Love in Jesus Christ our Lord and Saviour,
michelle
Actually, ALL of the scriptures, Michelle. They are the Word of God and so is the King James Version. It contains the Word of God also. It is difficult to point to any particular scripture. The Bible says in ALL Bible translations (at least most, the main stream, when I say all, please note that I do realize there are some corrupt versions out there, but they are not the main-stream (NIV, NASB, ESV, HOLMAN, etc. etc.) Yes, God says in many scriptures that He will preserve His Words. He has. You have them in the KJV and I have them in my ESV, NASB and my KJV.

Now, I think we are going to have to discuss what is meant by "words". Let me ask you another question. Do you believe the punctuation in the KJV is part of what is preserved? Just a yes or no would be fine.
 

LarryN

New Member
Please provide scriptures for your stand
Michelle, I ask you once again, why don't you provide Scriptures for your stand? The burden of proof is on you- you're the one who is making the exclusivity claim. You are the one who says that versions other than the KJV are not God's Word. You are the one who says that MV's are not the Word of God. (I don't necessarily care for the "MV" term- after all, the KJV was considered a "MV" in 1611.)

Those who know that MV's are the Word of God don't deny that the KJV is also God's Word (and is a time-honored translation which has been greatly used to God's Glory)- they just say that it is not the only acceptable translation of His Word. You're the one making the claim for exclusivity: prove it, using Scripture (without ignoring context, please). "The Holy Spirit showed me" has been the only evidence I've seen you offer up to this point; and as it's been pointed out to you already, much aberrant theology has come with such a claim as the only basis.
 

GrannyGumbo

<img src ="/Granny.gif">
Actually, Granny Gumbo, the Gideons now also have the NEW King James Version. This is information off the Gideon.org website.

"Actually, dianetavegia, I was referring to the gideons HERE in my area, as I had just stated about the Bible being used in our courts here. I was told by one of these men they would NEVER give out anything else...at least in his lifetime.
 

Lacy Evans

New Member
Originally posted by Phillip:
Besides, it would be awfully boring if all we had to debate with was other MVers. We have to have somebody that we can correct. :eek:
laugh.gif
laugh.gif
(Brother Lacy bites his tongue! Hard!)
 
Top