• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Seventh Day Adv.

Berean

Member
Site Supporter
Recently saw an Advent preacher on the web and had a sound message which made me ask the question; other then holding Ellen Whites Writtings in too high esteem. Are they doctrinally sound?
 

Salty

20,000 Posts Club
Administrator
Recently saw an Advent preacher on the web and had a sound message which made me ask the question; other then holding Ellen Whites Writtings in too high esteem. Are they doctrinally sound?

Well, they believe in Wholistic human nature, which includesthe unconscious state of the dead.

The wicked will not suffer eternal torment in hell, but instead will be permanently destroyed.

Here is the list of 28 adventist Fundamentals Beliefs

There founding can be traced back to the prediction of William Miller who stated the Lord would return on 22 Oct, 1844. Though many returned to their previous churches, the remainder continued with the 7DA.
 

Berean

Member
Site Supporter
Well, they believe in Wholistic human nature, which includesthe unconscious state of the dead.

The wicked will not suffer eternal torment in hell, but instead will be permanently destroyed.

Here is the list of 28 adventist Fundamentals Beliefs

There founding can be traced back to the prediction of William Miller who stated the Lord would return on 22 Oct, 1844. Though many returned to their previous churches, the remainder continued with the 7DA.
Thanks Salty
 

steaver

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Recently saw an Advent preacher on the web and had a sound message which made me ask the question; other then holding Ellen Whites Writtings in too high esteem. Are they doctrinally sound?

Actually, they hold her writings as the word of God.

Are they doctrinally sound? Eh, yes and no. On Jesus Christ as Messiah and God, they are right on. On faith alone, not so much. They have an attitude, even if it is not written in any statement of faith of theirs, that if a person has been shown the truth about Sunday worship, or pork eating, etc, and they still continue to do these things, they will not be saved. If you speak with them they will dance around on this, but if you speak with one of them who knows their faith well, you will see the attitude reveal itself. And this is a direct cause of believing in a false prophet, EGW, who has led them down this road of errors. Once you have accepted her as a prophet, you have no choice but to obey her teaching, otherwise, you disobey God.
 

Salty

20,000 Posts Club
Administrator
... that if a person has been shown the truth about Sunday worship, or pork eating, etc, and they still continue to do these things, they will not be saved. ... but if you speak with one of them who knows their faith well, you will see the attitude reveal itself. ... .


Was not aware of that - thanks for the info.

FTR, I did have an Air Force Chaplain who was 7DA.
 

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Actually, they hold her writings as the word of God.

Are they doctrinally sound? Eh, yes and no. On Jesus Christ as Messiah and God, they are right on. On faith alone, not so much. They have an attitude, even if it is not written in any statement of faith of theirs, that if a person has been shown the truth about Sunday worship, or pork eating, etc, and they still continue to do these things, they will not be saved. If you speak with them they will dance around on this, but if you speak with one of them who knows their faith well, you will see the attitude reveal itself. And this is a direct cause of believing in a false prophet, EGW, who has led them down this road of errors. Once you have accepted her as a prophet, you have no choice but to obey her teaching, otherwise, you disobey God.

they have a false prophetess, they hold to soul sleep/destruction of wicked/hold to mark of the beast being Sunday worship, and held that one is saved by grace of god, but need to observe sat worship, hold to SDA beliefs etc, and that God will inveestigate your life after death to see if made it in or not by your devotion totheir cause!

So another Christian Cult, much like Mormons....
 

Eliyahu

Active Member
Site Supporter
Soul Sleep is different from Soul Extinction.

Soul Sleep has been believed by William Tyndale, Martin Luther, Most Anabaptists like Hubmeyer, Hans Denk, etc.

IN the Bible there are plenty of verses supporting this. At the end in the Revelation it says the souls take rest.

Souls would not rest if they praise or pray wholeheartedly.

Wonder how the most baptists reject Soul Sleep since Anabaptists believed it.


Except the Leaven of Ellen White, SDA do not deserve to be called Cult.

In fact many of the wrong prediction by Ellen White was learned from a Baptist Pastor William Miller.

SDA MAY BE ONE OF A FEW Protestant group struggling against RCC strongly. Their singing hymn songs are quite classical.
 

steaver

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
SDA MAY BE ONE OF A FEW Protestant group struggling against RCC strongly.

Don't know if cult fits, but definitely legalistic fits the bill. Interestingly, both the SDA and the RCC reject faith alone, so they hold a major doctrine in unity.
 

Eliyahu

Active Member
Site Supporter
Don't know if cult fits, but definitely legalistic fits the bill. Interestingly, both the SDA and the RCC reject faith alone, so they hold a major doctrine in unity.

I reject the Theory of Ellen White, but believe there were many Sabbathkeepers before SDA.

In some senses Messianic Jews today are the Legalists. But we can confirm that many of them are bornagain believers.

Even in Acts 21:20 we find many Believers of Early Church were legalists.

Also, many Bible verses are mistranslating the verses in NT. For example

Eph 2:15, what was destroyed was not the Law, but the Enmity.
Also, in Col 2:14 many misunderstand the Law was destroyed, but the Letter of Accusation against us was destroyed.

Many translations are misleading today about Romans and 1 Tim1:8-10, Galatians etc.

So, as long as SDA keeps the Holy Spirit, I wouldn't categorize them as cult.
 

evangelist-7

New Member

Can you imagine a Baptist askin' if some group is doctrinally sound?
WOW! ... I guess it's possible ... Yup, I just read it.
Just proves ... anything's possible!

.
 

Thomas Helwys

New Member
Don't know if cult fits, but definitely legalistic fits the bill. Interestingly, both the SDA and the RCC reject faith alone, so they hold a major doctrine in unity.

Yes, isn't that ironic, since they are mortal enemies. They are both about in the same boat -- not quite cult, not quite orthodox.
 

rstrats

Member
Site Supporter
re: "Interestingly, both the SDA and the RCC reject faith alone..."


As it seems does the book of James.
 

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Soul Sleep is different from Soul Extinction.

Soul Sleep has been believed by William Tyndale, Martin Luther, Most Anabaptists like Hubmeyer, Hans Denk, etc.

IN the Bible there are plenty of verses supporting this. At the end in the Revelation it says the souls take rest.

Souls would not rest if they praise or pray wholeheartedly.

Wonder how the most baptists reject Soul Sleep since Anabaptists believed it.


Except the Leaven of Ellen White, SDA do not deserve to be called Cult.

In fact many of the wrong prediction by Ellen White was learned from a Baptist Pastor William Miller.

SDA MAY BE ONE OF A FEW Protestant group struggling against RCC strongly. Their singing hymn songs are quite classical.

Don't think luther/Calvin any of them holding to orthodox faith held to 'soul sleep!"

they held to absent from the body, present with the Lord!

And SDA denies that we are saved by gave alone, thru faith alone, as MUST hold to their sabbath views, hold to prophetess White, and hold to good works needed to avoid investigative judgement of God!

So meets the test for a bible cult, as do mormons/JW!
 

Gerhard Ebersoehn

Active Member
Site Supporter
Yes, isn't that ironic, since they are mortal enemies. They are both about in the same boat -- not quite cult, not quite orthodox.

Mortal enemies?!

You must be joking.

The SDAs are in cahoots with RCism on many things and on most important issues.

What is most tragic is that the Sabbath of the LORD GOD is ALWAYS seen and treated as the Day of Worship-Rest of the Seventh-day Adventist 'church', virtually as belonging to them ... exclusively! Which is EXACTLY WHAT BOTH THE SDAs and the RCs WANT and mutually APPROVED AND AGREED UPON.

Also on the BASIS for the Seventh Day Sabbath's 'remembrance', namely: THE LAW, THE LAW, THE LAW AND NEVER BUT NEVER FOR ITS CHRISTIAN REASON-FOR-BEING, namely: the Resurrection from the dead of Jesus Christ, "ON THE SABBATH DAY".

What a pity!

Thus it will stay the status quo until Christ comes again.
 
Top