• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Age of Accountability

Status
Not open for further replies.

JohnDB

Member
Growth is a sure indicator of life. I think it’s safe to assume that we shouldn’t be killing what God is forming into people.
Part of the process of IVF is creating viable embryos before implanting them.
These embryos can be tested for a variety of things before implanting. Genetic testing can tell you exactly the diseases and physical traits the child will have before implanting...

But usually a bunch of embryos are made before selecting one to implant....then the remainder are either stored or discarded. (Usually stored and available for "adoption") but still tested And CGI photos show the appearance of the children in the catalog you order one out of.
 

Anthony Pritchard

Well-Known Member
So at what point before birth does an embryo become a baby?

Babies are not like Melchizedek (without beginning or end)

Scripture teaches that God knows the child in the womb (Psalm 139:13-16; Jeremiah 1:5). Scripture presents the unborn as a human life known by God.

From a biological standpoint, the same human being exists from conception onward. The DNA present in the embryo is the same DNA that will be present in the child, the adult, and the elderly person. What changes is development, not identity.

An embryo has not reached that point.

An infant has not reached that point.

Many young children have not reached that point.

The issue is not what we call them. The issue is whether the condition described in Scripture has been reached.
 

JohnDB

Member
Snowflake Babies were not conceived in a traditional sense....they were created by a third party in a petri dish in a lab with materials taken from individuals who may or may not even know or have even met each other.
That's how impersonal Snowflake babies are created.
This isn't a moment of attraction and an illicit action. Not that much emotion went into this.

There's issues with "life begins at conception" because this now extends into the Snowflake babies realm..

God knows the future just as well as the past and the present....no surprise party for Him. Your next breath is not at God's acquiescence but active support.

When it comes to babies....we see and believe in their potential as adults. Not anything they have done as a baby because babies don't really do anything beyond eat, sleep, and dirty their diapers.
 

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
Snowflake Babies were not conceived in a traditional sense....they were created by a third party in a petri dish in a lab with materials taken from individuals who may or may not even know or have even met each other.
That's how impersonal Snowflake babies are created.
This isn't a moment of attraction and an illicit action. Not that much emotion went into this.

There's issues with "life begins at conception" because this now extends into the Snowflake babies realm..

God knows the future just as well as the past and the present....no surprise party for Him. Your next breath is not at God's acquiescence but active support.

When it comes to babies....we see and believe in their potential as adults. Not anything they have done as a baby because babies don't really do anything beyond eat, sleep, and dirty their diapers.
If God gives a baby life, I would not want to be in the place where it is myself deciding that it isn’t life. There isn’t any life in this world that doesn’t come from God. By Him all things consist.
 

Anthony Pritchard

Well-Known Member
Snowflake Babies were not conceived in a traditional sense....
I do not see how IVF changes the issue.

An IVF child is still a human child.

The child develops into an infant, a child, an adult, and an elderly person just as any other child does.

The circumstances of conception do not change the nature of the person conceived.

The question under discussion is not how the child was conceived.

The question is whether the condition described in Scripture has been reached.

Has the individual come to the knowledge of good and evil?

Has the point described in Romans 7:9 been reached?

Those questions remain the same whether conception occurred naturally or through IVF.
 

JohnDB

Member
I do not see how IVF changes the issue.

An IVF child is still a human child.

The child develops into an infant, a child, an adult, and an elderly person just as any other child does.

The circumstances of conception do not change the nature of the person conceived.

The question under discussion is not how the child was conceived.

The question is whether the condition described in Scripture has been reached.

Has the individual come to the knowledge of good and evil?

Has the point described in Romans 7:9 been reached?

Those questions remain the same whether conception occurred naturally or through IVF.
And @Ben1445 ...



Scripture says "the soul who sins dies".

So, are you saying that the petri dish embryo qualifies as a baby, a complete soul?

There are many who would say that this embryo has not even lived yet.

I'm not saying you are right or wrong for i do not know definitively....
But I am interested in how you came to the conclusion that you are making. If its just an arbitrary assignment....then ok...but don't expect a lot of agreement. If you have a thought out reasoning for it? OK...people can subscribe.

Because then, if we have a power outage causing mass murder (if embryos are not kept frozen they will degrade and become not viable if not implanted. )
Pulling the plug on a deep freeze medical freezer or the destruction of unwanted snowflake babies is murder.

There does exist a line of reasoning concerning blood. (Blood is life and all life is God's) An embryo does not have blood cells yet. It may have DNA but no blood as of yet. It will at a point in the development process....but not as yet in the petri dish.

Others put the line of being a soul at the ability to breathe air. Successfully breathing or not....thats their particular line since God breathes life into Adam or all of us in truth....

There has to be a line.
Is a baby alive when its known to exist after implantation and beginning development? Its alive in its mother and father's hearts? If someone injures the mother and she miscarried is he/she guilty of murder?

There's a huge list of debate items in this bag.

I'm definitely not in favor of abortion....the scriptures are clear about it being a horrible thing. (Gives me shudders just thinking about the punishment for it)
But where is it Providence vx just possibility.
 
Last edited:

Martin Marprelate

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Psalm 51:5. 'Behold, I was brought forth in iniquity, and in sin my mother conceived me.'
The last part of the verse does not mean that the conception was (necessarily) sinful, but that what was conceived was a sinner.

I do not believe that there is an 'age of responsibility' with God. Most parents know that their children are sinners pretty much from day one. You don't have to say to a child, "Now then, Johnny, this is how you tell a lie. You think of something that isn't true and tell it as if it is." Or, "Well, Jane; this is how you can be selfish. You keep your toys to yourself and don't let your little brother play with them." No, children work these things out for themselves very quickly. They are sinners from even before birth, and unless God regenerates them they are hell-bound.

So what do we do? We lay our children who die in infancy in God's hands, saying, "Shall not the Judge of all the earth do right?" Of course He will! But He will do so according to His own perfect justice and not our imperfect version. A verse that may give us additional hope is 2 Samuel 12:23, though I am aware that there are differing interpretations of it.
 

JohnDB

Member
Psalm 51:5. 'Behold, I was brought forth in iniquity, and in sin my mother conceived me.'
The last part of the verse does not mean that the conception was (necessarily) sinful, but that what was conceived was a sinner.

I do not believe that there is an 'age of responsibility' with God. Most parents know that their children are sinners pretty much from day one. You don't have to say to a child, "Now then, Johnny, this is how you tell a lie. You think of something that isn't true and tell it as if it is." Or, "Well, Jane; this is how you can be selfish. You keep your toys to yourself and don't let your little brother play with them." No, children work these things out for themselves very quickly. They are sinners from even before birth, and unless God regenerates them they are hell-bound.

So what do we do? We lay our children who die in infancy in God's hands, saying, "Shall not the Judge of all the earth do right?" Of course He will! But He will do so according to His own perfect justice and not our imperfect version. A verse that may give us additional hope is 2 Samuel 12:23, though I am aware that there are differing interpretations of it.
I agree....
Paul in Romans (and what kind of Baptist are you if you cannot write a treatise on this book alone) writes about how in Adam all have sinned and fallen short.

The writer of Hebrews talks about how Christ is the second Adam.....

The law brings death but the Spirit brings life. These two things are brought together when those key scriptures are paralleled together in Exodus and in Acts concerning the "about 2,000 people" were either killed or were believing and got baptized.

Babies cannot even talk until almost 2 years old....and truly to get to that point there has been almost 3 years of progress. Long term and mid term memory doesn't start until 3 or 4 years of age.

Also...
Genesis in the "Begats" sections....
It is painfully obvious if you understand the names that the notion of "sin begets more sin"
2 sinful parents conceive and raise sinful children. Each fruit reproduces after its own kind through its seed.
This lesson was repeated quite vigorously by Noah to Ham concerning Canaan after his bout of getting drunk.
It was not so much a curse as it was a declaration of truth. Ham was going to curse his own son and not be able to do anything about it. Nothing worse for a Godly man than to condemn his own children to a life of sin instead of love.
 

Anthony Pritchard

Well-Known Member
So, are you saying that the petri dish embryo qualifies as a baby, a complete soul?

There are many who would say that this embryo has not even lived yet.

I'm not saying you are right or wrong for i do not know definitively....
You keep asking where the line should be drawn. My question is: where do you draw the line, and on what foundation?

Appeals to what "many would say" or what "others put the line at" carry no authority. Truth is not established by counting opinions.

Scripture points to conception. Biology points to conception. At conception a new human organism exists. Everything that follows is development of the same individual. Physical development does not determine humanness.

Blood is not the line. Breathing is not the line. Viability is not the line.

A newborn is not viable on its own. A young child is not viable on its own. Dependence does not determine humanity. Viability is not a measure of what something is, but of how much assistance it requires.

You seem especially focused on IVF and frozen embryos. Even if millions of embryos are destroyed, that does not change what they are. Human loss on a large scale does not redefine humanity. If Russia bombs a maternity hospital and unborn children die, their location does not determine their humanity. Geography is irrelevant.

The question is not where the child is located, how developed the child is, or how dependent the child is. The question is: when does the individual begin to exist?

My answer is conception. Regardless of location.

If your answer is something else, then tell us precisely where you draw the line and provide a foundation for it. "Some people say" and "many would argue" are not foundations.

What I see is a series of hypothetical questions, but none of them establish that conception is the wrong line. They simply avoid establishing a different one.

Peace,

Tony
 

Anthony Pritchard

Well-Known Member
Psalm 51:5. 'Behold, I was brought forth in iniquity, and in sin my mother conceived me.'
The last part of the verse does not mean that the conception was (necessarily) sinful, but that what was conceived was a sinner.

I do not believe that there is an 'age of responsibility' with God. Most parents know that their children are sinners pretty much from day one.
God writes through Paul, "sin is not imputed when there is no law" (Romans 5:13), and "I was alive apart from the law once: but when the commandment came, sin revived, and I died" (Romans 7:9).

Children undoubtedly display the effects of a fallen nature from a very young age. The question, however, is not whether they are fallen, but whether God has yet held them accountable in the sense Paul describes.

That is why I do not see Psalm 51:5 as disproving an age or condition of accountability. It establishes man's fallen condition from conception, but it does not address when sin is imputed or when the transition described in Romans 7:9 takes place.

Peace,

Tony
 

JohnDB

Member
You keep asking where the line should be drawn. My question is: where do you draw the line, and on what foundation?

Appeals to what "many would say" or what "others put the line at" carry no authority. Truth is not established by counting opinions.

Scripture points to conception. Biology points to conception. At conception a new human organism exists. Everything that follows is development of the same individual. Physical development does not determine humanness.

Blood is not the line. Breathing is not the line. Viability is not the line.

A newborn is not viable on its own. A young child is not viable on its own. Dependence does not determine humanity. Viability is not a measure of what something is, but of how much assistance it requires.

You seem especially focused on IVF and frozen embryos. Even if millions of embryos are destroyed, that does not change what they are. Human loss on a large scale does not redefine humanity. If Russia bombs a maternity hospital and unborn children die, their location does not determine their humanity. Geography is irrelevant.

The question is not where the child is located, how developed the child is, or how dependent the child is. The question is: when does the individual begin to exist?

My answer is conception. Regardless of location.

If your answer is something else, then tell us precisely where you draw the line and provide a foundation for it. "Some people say" and "many would argue" are not foundations.

What I see is a series of hypothetical questions, but none of them establish that conception is the wrong line. They simply avoid establishing a different one.

Peace,

Tony
I understand that you are wanting to battle...

I'm not.

I simply was desiring to explore the subject.
Listen to ideas and concepts to determine the logic used behind those choices AND what I, as an average person, should choose to do or to counsel when faced with dilemmas.

I have zero opinion except that we should ALWAYS err on the side of life... and at what point that life begins and why you claim life begins at conception....

Your position is no different from the Catholic Church's position and it dovetail their position on the death penalty and usually war....there position was extremely consistent and thorough and received some admiration from me for its simplistic nature and relatable position so that no one ever really needed to ask....

We Baptists are by definition undefinable....(Just ask Herschel Hobbs)
So our theologies tend to vary from church to church and individual to individual.

You were making some well reasoned out positions that I agreed with so I thought you might be prepared to give a defense for your position beyond the arbitrary line you drew.

Sorry if I have upset you. Not my intention.


I'm just looking to discuss and to reason out the what's, how's, where's, and why's of a position. Because I still don't have one....and the process of IVF is extremely dehumanizing. Embryos listed in catalogs, conception in a petri dish with parts from literally wherever and whomever.
But for many, if it weren't for IVF they would have no children. And again, I like to err on the side of life.

Im not here to condemn or promote....just talk.
 

Ascetic X

Well-Known Member
I agree....
Paul in Romans (and what kind of Baptist are you if you cannot write a treatise on this book alone) writes about how in Adam all have sinned and fallen short.
I do not see anyone scripture that says “we all sinned in Adam.”

That opinion would mean that a fetus or new born baby was a sinner who committed sins “in Adam” before knowing right from wrong.

To me, scripture says that we all sinned and die, because we inherit the fallen nature of Adam, thus the tendency to sin.

Note that sin is not charged against anyone’s account where there is no law to disobey. Thus, sins are not charged to a fetus or baby, who has no knowledge of any human or divine law. But the fetus or baby can die, because death is in this world, not because they “sinned in Adam”.

Death comes to everyone, because we all sinned against the laws that we know.

Adam disobeyed God, and consequently, we all become sinners by our own sins.

Romans 5:18 states — Consequently, just as one trespass resulted in condemnation for all people, so also one righteous act resulted in justification and life for all people.

The condemnation occurs, not automatically at conception, but because we all sinned. The justification and life occurs, not automatically at conception, but when we are saved, when we confess Jesus as Lord and believe God raised Him from the dead.



Romans 5:12-18

12 Therefore, just as sin entered the world through one man, and death through sin, and in this way death came to all people, because all sinned—

13 To be sure, sin was in the world before the law was given, but sin is not charged against anyone’s account where there is no law.

14 Nevertheless, death reigned from the time of Adam to the time of Moses, even over those who did not sin by breaking a command, as did Adam, who is a pattern of the one to come.

15 But the gift is not like the trespass. For if the many died by the trespass of the one man, how much more did God’s grace and the gift that came by the grace of the one man, Jesus Christ, overflow to the many!

16 Nor can the gift of God be compared with the result of one man’s sin: The judgment followed one sin and brought condemnation, but the gift followed many trespasses and brought justification.

17 For if, by the trespass of the one man, death reigned through that one man, how much more will those who receive God’s abundant provision of grace and of the gift of righteousness reign in life through the one man, Jesus Christ!

18 Consequently, just as one trespass resulted in condemnation for all people, so also one righteous act resulted in justification and life for all people.

19 For just as through the disobedience of the one man the many were made sinners, so also through the obedience of the one man the many will be made righteous.
 
Last edited:

JohnDB

Member
I do not see anyone scripture that says “we all sinned in Adam.”

That opinion would mean that a fetus or new born baby was a sinner who committed sins “in Adam” before knowing right from wrong.

To me, scripture says that we all sinned and die, because we inherit the fallen nature of Adam, thus the tendency to sin.

Note that sin is not charged against anyone’s account where there is no law to disobey. Thus, sins are not charged to a fetus or baby, who has no knowledge of any human or divine law. But the fetus or baby can die, because death is in this world, not because they “sinned in Adam”.

Death comes to everyone, because we all sinned against the laws that we know.

Adam disobeyed God, and consequently, we all become sinners by our own sins.

Romans 5:18 states — Consequently, just as one trespass resulted in condemnation for all people, so also one righteous act resulted in justification and life for all people.

The condemnation occurs, not automatically at conception, but because we all sinned. The justification and life occurs, not automatically at conception, but when we are saved, when we confess Jesus as Lord and believe God raised Him from the dead.



Romans 5:12-18

12 Therefore, just as sin entered the world through one man, and death through sin, and in this way death came to all people, because all sinned—

13 To be sure, sin was in the world before the law was given, but sin is not charged against anyone’s account where there is no law.

14 Nevertheless, death reigned from the time of Adam to the time of Moses, even over those who did not sin by breaking a command, as did Adam, who is a pattern of the one to come.

15 But the gift is not like the trespass. For if the many died by the trespass of the one man, how much more did God’s grace and the gift that came by the grace of the one man, Jesus Christ, overflow to the many!

16 Nor can the gift of God be compared with the result of one man’s sin: The judgment followed one sin and brought condemnation, but the gift followed many trespasses and brought justification.

17 For if, by the trespass of the one man, death reigned through that one man, how much more will those who receive God’s abundant provision of grace and of the gift of righteousness reign in life through the one man, Jesus Christ!

18 Consequently, just as one trespass resulted in condemnation for all people, so also one righteous act resulted in justification and life for all people.

19 For just as through the disobedience of the one man the many were made sinners, so also through the obedience of the one man the many will be made righteous.
Now see....
Babies do not physically resurrect because they are sinless....(unlike Jesus who was sinless and was able to ressurect himself because of the sinlessness and being God).

Ergo....sinful because of Adam
and
sin begets more sin. You are going to sin because you now have a sin nature because of Adam. No escaping it. The patriarchs and the Law have a unique relationship...they somewhat created the Law before it was ever codified by their actions...because they had a personal and foundational relationship with God. We could discuss Jacob's relationship and how it evolved and its nuances for decades....but essentially Abraham's gift to Melchizedek was the institution of the tithe
And all the other activities recorded the positive ones loosely became a hard codified Law that the Israelites either followed or died by.
Before then....there were laws....they are in that Old Testament shorthand speak. (Nimrod, Peleg and others). Where so much is left out....

Until Jesus. Jesus is deemed a second Adam for a reason...because through him we can have a new life. We now don't have a license to sin but an escape from the heavenly consequences....earthly consequences are still gonna happen.

At least thats my understanding....

Sinless babies do not resurrect themselves. Snowflake babies do not regenerate.....

So....
If someone is "declared" innocent of sin and believes that God in his omnipotence is going to ressurect a sinless baby.

Where does that sinlessness begin and where does it end?
Which again goes straight into the moment that an embryo or baby becomes a soul and at what age the accountability starts....

God is a righteous judge....I have zero doubt He will choose according to His Righteousness and not mine.
I'm not sure we can truly know the answer...
 

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
And @Ben1445 ...



Scripture says "the soul who sins dies".

So, are you saying that the petri dish embryo qualifies as a baby, a complete soul?

There are many who would say that this embryo has not even lived yet.

I'm not saying you are right or wrong for i do not know definitively....
But I am interested in how you came to the conclusion that you are making. If its just an arbitrary assignment....then ok...but don't expect a lot of agreement. If you have a thought out reasoning for it? OK...people can subscribe.
I’m giving boundaries that I don’t think it wise to cross. You answer to God for you.

Because then, if we have a power outage causing mass murder (if embryos are not kept frozen they will degrade and become not viable if not implanted. )
An embryo by itself is not a person. Life begins at conception. Growth begins at conception. I can’t tell you when a soul gets a body. There are a lot of things I don’t have answers to. But I don’t think that children born as a result of this process are given souls by the doctors. I don’t think that they are soulless either. God must do something man cannot do.

Pulling the plug on a deep freeze medical freezer or the destruction of unwanted snowflake babies is murder.

There does exist a line of reasoning concerning blood. (Blood is life and all life is God's) An embryo does not have blood cells yet. It may have DNA but no blood as of yet. It will at a point in the development process....but not as yet in the petri dish.

Others put the line of being a soul at the ability to breathe air. Successfully breathing or not....thats their particular line since God breathes life into Adam or all of us in truth....

There has to be a line.
Is a baby alive when its known to exist after implantation and beginning development? Its alive in its mother and father's hearts? If someone injures the mother and she miscarried is he/she guilty of murder?

There's a huge list of debate items in this bag.

I'm definitely not in favor of abortion....the scriptures are clear about it being a horrible thing. (Gives me shudders just thinking about the punishment for it)
But where is it Providence vx just possibility.
I don’t live in this world you are in. It’s not something that I would do myself. Protecting a hospital laboratory is not a responsibility that I can take on myself or would even be allowed to take onto myself.
But if you can do something to stop the freezer hackers, by all means do it.
I know we have the internet, but I don’t take it upon myself to police the world. I told you what I think. I conduct my behavior in accordance with what I believe. I don’t expect anyone to come to me to find out what is right and wrong. I do speak up for children who can’t speak for themselves or defend themselves.

I’m not sure exactly what you want me to say.
That people do things they shouldn’t do is unfortunately, part of living in this world.
I can’t just walk up to any clinic and tell them what to do any more than I could walk up to the leader of a country and tell them how to do their job. I just don’t have that authority.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top