• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

The Chosen

JohnDB

Member
John, abortion is pure evil...you'll get no argument about that.

"The truth of Simon being a silphium dealer" So, now you've decided it is absolute truth.

In your mind, you have presumed, accused, tried and convicted this man of a heinous crime,
and have now built an entire narrative around that erroneous assumption.

Not so much as a shred of evidence. None.

As a brother in Christ, I would urge you to stop, and prayerfully reconsider how you view
your fellow man.

The idea that Simon was a silphium dealer is not truth, it is speculation.

Selling abortion drugs is terrible, fetuses are murdered, but some of the Pharisees and other religious leaders were directly opposing Christ and were called children of the devil by Jesus.

Simon of Cyrene, on the other hand, performed a noble service in carrying the cross for Jesus. It was forced on him, but Simon of Cyrene may have been chosen because Simon was sympathetic to Jesus and felt He was being unjustly condemned. There is no way to confirm this.

He is venerated as a saint in the Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, Oriental Orthodox, and Eastern Catholic traditions. According to a community consensus on Reddit, he pre-dates formal canonization processes and is honored through ancient church tradition. He is recognized as the patron saint of passers-by, burden-bearers, laborers, and volunteers.

The author of Mark likely knew Alexander and Rufus, and the inclusion of their names may suggest that they were also known to the audience and held some standing in the Christian community at Rome.

Mark 15:21 casts Simon's sons as children of an eyewitness who could affirm their father's testimony, stymieing attempts to cast the passion narrative as a literary invention. It has also been suggested that the Rufus (Greek: Ῥοῦφος, Rhouphos) mentioned by Paul in Romans 16:13 is the son of Simon of Cyrene.

Some also link Simon himself with the "men of Cyrene" who preached the Gospel to the Hellenized Jews (Greek: Ἑλληνισταί) in Acts11:20.


Simon's sin still does not equate to Judas's....or unbelief.

Even the worst King of Israel who killed every Priest and burned every Torah scroll was forgiven. And I've never said that Simon went unforgiven....he very well might have been. I do not know....
And despite Catholic Church tradition....which is always suspect....I'm going to hold to what I know....its a logical deduction from the evidence given. No different from Stephan becoming the first martyr of the Hellenistic Jews that had been tossed out of Italy for the crime of being a believing Jew....but still too Greek to be considered a real Jew by his fellow Israelites.

Not every last thing is going to be included in scripture....all the "of course" and what was considered "obvious" truths are not written. Just like the world's largest outdoor orgy was at Caesarea Phillipi at the Pan Temple...Where Jesus taught the famous "Keys of the kingdom" lesson (AKA Peter's Confession of Christ)
Obvious, blatant truths were not repeated or written. It was considered redundant writing and wasteful.

Unbelief is the worst sin....its equivalent to the Blasphemy of the Holy Spirit....
Everything else is something else.
 

Ascetic X

Well-Known Member
Simon's sin still does not equate to Judas's....or unbelief.
What sin did Simon commit?

You are carried away with your own opinions based on speculation.

Unbelief is the worst sin....its equivalent to the Blasphemy of the Holy Spirit....
Everything else is something else.
Unbelief is not equivalent to blasphemy of the Holy Spirit.

Unbelief can be forgiven.

Blasphemy of the Holy Spirit cannot.
 

Foxmeister

Well-Known Member
I have a friend who loves the show....
He knows I can't stand it....

I get it.

Doesn't mean that I don't hate what it does to some of the "whispers" of scripture that hold so much meaning.....

Currently I'm wondering what they are going to do with Simon of Cyrene. (The siphium dealer)

If you don't know....silphium WAS a combination aphrodisiac and effective abortifacient. Essentially the famous "abortion herb" and on the Via de la rosa that spot is at the herb market at the prime spot.
And the soldiers picked him because he was the abortion seller. He, and others just like him, made it possible for the soldiers wives to cheat on them at home.
Nowhere in the Bible is silphium mentioned in the Bible. This is one reason that The Chosen is a travesty.
 

Foxmeister

Well-Known Member
Simon's sin still does not equate to Judas's....or unbelief.

Even the worst King of Israel who killed every Priest and burned every Torah scroll was forgiven. And I've never said that Simon went unforgiven....he very well might have been. I do not know....
And despite Catholic Church tradition....which is always suspect....I'm going to hold to what I know....its a logical deduction from the evidence given. No different from Stephan becoming the first martyr of the Hellenistic Jews that had been tossed out of Italy for the crime of being a believing Jew....but still too Greek to be considered a real Jew by his fellow Israelites.

Not every last thing is going to be included in scripture....all the "of course" and what was considered "obvious" truths are not written. Just like the world's largest outdoor orgy was at Caesarea Phillipi at the Pan Temple...Where Jesus taught the famous "Keys of the kingdom" lesson (AKA Peter's Confession of Christ)
Obvious, blatant truths were not repeated or written. It was considered redundant writing and wasteful.

Unbelief is the worst sin....its equivalent to the Blasphemy of the Holy Spirit....
Everything else is something else.
Ya'll are making this sound like Simone of Cyrene who was the stranger who carried Jesus's cross is the same Simon who was a Apostle. They are not the same Simon.
 

Ascetic X

Well-Known Member
Maybe...

But then again I'm not dependent upon "Thou shalt not commit abortion" to be discovered in scriptures either to consider it an abomination.
You are judging someone the scriptures do not judge.

Nowhere in the Bible does it say Simon of Cyrene was a silphium dealer or an abortion provider. He might have been, but you are assuming he definitely was, based only on his being of Cyrene.

If you wish to condemn abortion, you do not need a verse that says “Thou shalt not commit abortion”. All you need is “Thou shalt not kill (commit murder)”.
 

JohnDB

Member
You are judging someone the scriptures do not judge.

Nowhere in the Bible does it say Simon of Cyrene was a silphium dealer or an abortion provider. He might have been, but you are assuming he definitely was, based only on his being of Cyrene.

If you wish to condemn abortion, you do not need a verse that says “Thou shalt not commit abortion”. All you need is “Thou shalt not kill (commit murder)”.
Then WHY state he and his family were from Cyrene?
And in the spice market?
And targeted by Soldiers?
And why a "non lesson " of a nobody in the most choreographed life during the peak focus of the Sacrifice?

EVERY little thing Jesus did and the action surrounding Him was choreographed well in advance by God the Father.....why was this not? (Your claim)

I'm not taking license and false accusations whatsoever. I'm taking rational, logical deductions from the information given. And see the firestorm I've already started on a "gimmee" theological principle? I'm sure Simon also sold other herbs and spices along side of the silphium. Maybe even some saffron. Who knows.....

But if he is in the spice market and from Cyrene....why is he not selling silphium?

Inquiring minds want to know.
 

JohnDB

Member
Nowhere in the Bible is silphium mentioned in the Bible. This is one reason that The Chosen is a travesty.
Silphium is not mentioned in The Chosen nor scriptures....
The part where Simon of Cyrene is coming i was wondering how they were going to handle it? They have made up all kinds of anti biblical junk stuff already....

Silphium was so important for Cyrene they stamped the plant on every coin they issued.
 

Ascetic X

Well-Known Member
Then WHY state he and his family were from Cyrene?
And in the spice market?
And targeted by Soldiers?
And why a "non lesson " of a nobody in the most choreographed life during the peak focus of the Sacrifice?

EVERY little thing Jesus did and the action surrounding Him was choreographed well in advance by God the Father.....why was this not? (Your claim)

I'm not taking license and false accusations whatsoever. I'm taking rational, logical deductions from the information given. And see the firestorm I've already started on a "gimmee" theological principle? I'm sure Simon also sold other herbs and spices along side of the silphium. Maybe even some saffron. Who knows.....

But if he is in the spice market and from Cyrene....why is he not selling silphium?

Inquiring minds want to know.
Again, this is all your conjecture.

Nothing in the scriptures condemns Simon of Cyrene or calls him a silphium dealer. Many people of Cyrene had nothing to do with silphium.

You connect silphium only to abortion, but it had many other uses.

Ancient writers—including Hippocrates and Pliny the Elder—described silphium as a remedy for ailments ranging from coughs and sore throats to fevers and wounds, as well as a contraceptive and abortifacient. Modern scholars debate how effective or safe it actually was for abortion use.

It was used in perfumes, as an aphrodisiac, and as livestock fodder (though reported to be harmful or fatal to certain animals like camels).

If God wanted us to know Simon was a silphium dealer it would simply state “Simon of Cyrene, a silphium dealer”.

For example…

Acts 16:14

A woman named Lydia—a seller of purple cloth from the city of Thyatira, a God-fearer—was listening. The Lord opened her heart to respond to what Paul was saying.
 

JohnDB

Member
Again, this is all your conjecture.

Nothing in the scriptures condemns Simon of Cyrene or calls him a silphium dealer. Many people of Cyrene had nothing to do with silphium.

You connect silphium only to abortion, but it had many other uses.

Ancient writers—including Hippocrates and Pliny the Elder—described silphium as a remedy for ailments ranging from coughs and sore throats to fevers and wounds, as well as a contraceptive and abortifacient. Modern scholars debate how effective or safe it actually was for abortion use.

It was used in perfumes, as an aphrodisiac, and as livestock fodder (though reported to be harmful or fatal to certain animals like camels).

If God wanted us to know Simon was a silphium dealer it would simply state “Simon of Cyrene, a silphium dealer”.

For example…

Acts 16:14

A woman named Lydia—a seller of purple cloth from the city of Thyatira, a God-fearer—was listening. The Lord opened her heart to respond to what Paul was saying.
"Seller of purple cloth" was relevant too... and not a derogatory thing. Not like a silphium dealer which would be derogatory.

You don't hear about wine makers or beer brewers either in the New Testament.
 

Ascetic X

Well-Known Member
"Seller of purple cloth" was relevant too... and not a derogatory thing. Not like a silphium dealer which would be derogatory.

You don't hear about wine makers or beer brewers either in the New Testament.
Silphium is not derogatory.

You persist in focusing only on the usage of it for abortion.

You ignore the facts I presented about how silphium was a remedy for ailments ranging from coughs and sore throats to fevers and wounds, as well as a contraceptive and abortifacient. Modern scholars debate how effective or safe it actually was for abortion use.

It was used in perfumes, as an aphrodisiac, and as livestock fodder.
 

JohnDB

Member
Silphium is not derogatory.

You persist in focusing only on the usage of it for abortion.

You ignore the facts I presented about how silphium was a remedy for ailments ranging from coughs and sore throats to fevers and wounds, as well as a contraceptive and abortifacient. Modern scholars debate how effective or safe it actually was for abortion use.

It was used in perfumes, as an aphrodisiac, and as livestock fodder.
Harvested to extinction....
That doesn't suggest animal fodder.
 

JohnDB

Member
And where did you get your masters degree in agricultural science?

You have a theory that you prop up with speculation.
I do not have a degree in agricultural science. Most in my family do....even the girls. I'm a chef, electrician, route salesman with a CDL (I sold heavy stuff and drove pole trucks)

I just take scripture very seriously as if my very life depends upon it....(Because it kinda does)
Which means that a full blown hermeneutics skill is needed to completely understand what is said, why it was said in the manner it was said in. Which requires language skills beyond just vocabulary and tense for the verbs. (Exegetical commentaries) then I go to the expositional commentaries to get confused (the most commonly utilized) but then go on to history books, anthropology studies, and other studies that explain how people in the Ancient Near East (sometimes elsewhere) lived and intended to live.
I rely upon credible experts in their fields of study to make assessments. And upon extremely rare occasions I have found that the guy who majored in North American Indigenous people has an insight that the other guys somehow missed out on.

All of which requires weeks of dry reading of books where the author seems to love to use his $0.75 words when a nickel word would have worked just fine. But you know...some people try to make a living by their reputation of being smart....I never did...got the bad joints to go with it.

But....
I'm not a "scholar" who has made footnotes and kept a bibliography. Thats for the guys with all the letters behind their names. I'm just a working stiff....oldest GenX they make....not quite up to the level of human but I get by. All that to say; I do what is necessary to get what I want...or want to find out.

Now if you want to follow the same paths I recommend a subscription to JANES (Journal of Ancient Near East studies) and subscribe to some other REAL researching anthropologists familiar with the Ancient Near East and the Ancient Roman Empire and start there...lots of posers in that crowd too. Almost like trying to buy Natural Tahitian Saltwater Pearls....lots of fakes to wade through and NONE of them are famous.

But by ALL MEANS if you have some respectable research articles to dismiss the facts I've presented I'd love to see them.

The truth is NEVER packaged up and made pretty...its convoluted and heavily nuanced. You have made a neat, clean, dead end claim....but it resembles fiction.
I'm not going to outright claim you are wrong but I'd definitely like to see the evidence of the basis for your claim...

Being wrong happens to the best of us...
Admitting it is how we became Christians....
A person continuing to recognize that is the basis for the ever popular OSAS doctrine that is throughout the Baptist world in some fashion. Never being wrong is a psychosis....
 

Ascetic X

Well-Known Member
The truth is NEVER packaged up and made pretty...its convoluted and heavily nuanced. You have made a neat, clean, dead end claim....but it resembles fiction.
I'm not going to outright claim you are wrong but I'd definitely like to see the evidence of the basis for your claim...
Truth is simple so that a child can understand it.

You are adding your opinions and speculations to scripture.

You make claims that are not supported by biblical evidence.
 

JohnDB

Member
Truth is simple so that a child can understand it.

You are adding your opinions and speculations to scripture.

You make claims that are not supported by biblical evidence.
Oh yes....very much scriptural evidence.
Nobody says Simon's name without the "of Cyrene" as if its his last name....but he is one of two Simon...and the other was not present.

Judas "of" Iscariot is named this was to so there would not be confusion as to which Judas they were speaking of....

Cyrene's history is attested by multiple sources and the coins which all attest further to the silphium trade..
Location in Old City Jerusalem is also testifying as yo where, why, and how.

Purpose and intent....
I wrote Schroedingers cat an escape plan here....
Meaning I have zero interest in having people assume or think they can get "morning after" abortions and God is unconcerned or they are without blood guilt. These people need God's forgiveness desperately.
I also have not stretched or tortured the meaning of any words of scriptures. (How most debates on the internet start and never end).
I have provided archeological evidence, historical evidence, Location evidence, scriptural evidence, timing evidence, agricultural evidence, and anthropological evidence....

You have provided what exactly other than a charge of "You're making it up."....?

And the whole reason I would make any of this up is?
(The crickets are deafening on this one)

However, I CAN READILY believe a slew of people would want this to not be true....and just about every other conservative Christian can as well believe that many people would want this to be suppressed.

I am 100% uninterested in leading a crusade or even a small group Bible study on this subject...that is NOT one of my skills....I'm as average and unimportant as they come. Not looking to change that. YMMV .

You NEED to test what I've said....not dismiss it out of hand just because you don't like it. And you have not tested anything....just attacked me personally. Again not a winning strategy. Im both a recovering chef and electrician....I don't have feelings. They died a long time ago and my wife made me put them in a proper coffin for the mantle piece.
 
Top