• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Who is Hebrews 6 actually speaking about then?

David Lamb

Well-Known Member
James is about works, (so is Hebrews) and Paul said a person who is circumsized, a Jew of the first century, is required to do the whole law, which is works plus grace/faith.
James and Hebrews contradict what Paul says about grace by faith alone in his epistles ... so how can we have them as part of our doctrine? as far as we (Bible Believing Baptists) we cannot.
That is the consensus Of the Bible believing baptists I am aware of. I am just repeating what I have been taught over the last 50 years by KJV only Baptist pastors.. It is definately not just my opinion.
All people disregarding who the books are written to and in what dispensations are going to have serious theological chaos. Which is what we see all around us.
Hebrews does not contradict on the matter of the law. It says that salvation is not by the law. For example:

NKJV Heb 10:1 For the law, having a shadow of the good things to come, and not the very image of the things, can never with these same sacrifices, which they offer continually year by year, make those who approach perfect.

Heb 10:8 Previously saying, "SACRIFICE AND OFFERING, BURNT OFFERINGS, AND OFFERINGS FOR SIN YOU DID NOT DESIRE, NOR HAD PLEASURE IN THEM" (which are offered according to the law),
Heb 10:9 then He said, "BEHOLD, I HAVE COME TO DO YOUR WILL, O GOD." He takes away the first that He may establish the second.
Heb 10:10 By that will we have been sanctified through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all.
 

Silverhair

Well-Known Member
1) Thank you for your careful effort to actually address my view!

2) The reason is I believe "heavenly gift" equals "the gospel revelation" whereas "heavenly calling" equals "being transferred spiritually into Christ's spiritual body.

3) But you are correct, the lexicon I checked to see if your finding was correct did not, as you correctly stated, include the meaning of "to pass from one state to another." However G2821, the noun in Hebrews 3:1, is a shorter version of G2564, which does include that meaning.

4) You were wrong to say the lexicon did not include "to pass from one state to another" for 1 Corinthians 1:9 and 1 Peter 2:9, in ;which G2564, rather than G2821, is used.
Van I would suggest that you have actually gotten the understanding of "heavenly gift" and "heavenly calling" reversed.

All are called by God through various means up to and including the gospel message. This is His heavenly calling to mankind. Those that have responded to the call have received the heavenly gift of salvation.

While called G2564 is found in both 1Co 1:9 & 2Pe 2:9 and they in a sense support your view that it means transfer from Adam into Christ. The main understanding is that one is invited to trust in Christ in order to gain that transfer into Christ.

G2564 Metaphorically, to call or invite to anything, e.g., of Jesus, to call to repentance, exhort (Mat_9:13; implied in Mar_2:17); of God (1Co_1:9; 2Th_2:14; 1Ti_6:12; 1Pe_2:9; 1Pe_5:10; Rev_19:9). WordStudy Dictionary

But in any case they do not support your view that “heavenly calling” means transfer into Christ.
 

Lewis HB

New Member
Ben, we cannot be fruit inspectors. Also, untaught people reading James assume that salvation is by faith plus works. That is why we cannot consider James, Hebrew etal as doctrine. They were not written to or for us.
 

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Van I would suggest that you have actually gotten the understanding of "heavenly gift" and "heavenly calling" reversed.

All are called by God through various means up to and including the gospel message. This is His heavenly calling to mankind. Those that have responded to the call have received the heavenly gift of salvation.

While called G2564 is found in both 1Co 1:9 & 2Pe 2:9 and they in a sense support your view that it means transfer from Adam into Christ. The main understanding is that one is invited to trust in Christ in order to gain that transfer into Christ.

G2564 Metaphorically, to call or invite to anything, e.g., of Jesus, to call to repentance, exhort (Mat_9:13; implied in Mar_2:17); of God (1Co_1:9; 2Th_2:14; 1Ti_6:12; 1Pe_2:9; 1Pe_5:10; Rev_19:9). WordStudy Dictionary

But in any case they do not support your view that “heavenly calling” means transfer into Christ.
1) We it seems likely one of us has it reversed. :)

2) God has invited many through various means, including the gospel, and this is indeed a "heavenly" invitation.

3) Hebrews 3:1 NASB: Therefore, holy brothers and sisters, partakers of a heavenly calling, consider the Apostle and High Priest of our confession: Jesus;

​
Brothers are being addressed, who share the high Priest of Jesus, so born anew believers are in view, not invitees. ​

4) In Hebrews 6:4 we see people, not designated brothers, have tasted the heavenly gift. Note, not partakers of the heavenly gift, rather they only tasted it, but the people have been made partakers of the Holy Spirit. So we can certainly say they are partakers of the invitation, the gospel good news, the work product of the Holy Spirit.

5) Yes, the main meaning of the word translated "called" in 1 Cor 1:9 and 1 Peter 2:9 is "invited" but the word is used in scripture for two other meanings, to be designated or named, and to pass from one state (unsaved in Adam) to another state (saved in Christ).
 

Paleouss

Active Member
Site Supporter
Greetings Silverhair, I hope your weekend is a blessed one.
You are misusing the text. Only those that have shared in the Holy Spirit are saved. The Holy Spirit will convict all but does not indwell all.

The text says share in the Holy Spirit it does not say share in the Holy Spirits work. That is the error you bring into the text.

The text refers to “those who have once” what?

1] been enlightened

2] have tasted of the heavenly gift

3] have been made partakers of the Holy Spirit,

4] have tasted the good word of God

5] and the powers of the age to come

6] and then have fallen away

7] it is impossible to renew them again to repentance

These words obviously refer to those that have been saved that is unless you think the unsaved can fall away from a faith they never had. Or can be renewed to a faith they never had.
You make an interesting distinction between sharing in the Holy Spirit and sharing in the Holy Spirit's work, yet notice that you are the one importing the word "indwell". Hebrews 6:4 never says they were indwelt by the Holy Spirit. It says they were metochous (companions or sharers) of the Holy Spirit.

In the New Testament, metochos means being a companion or participant alongside others (such as Luke 5:7 for fishing partners). Anyone who joined the Christian assembly, in the early church, became a direct participant in the Spirit's corporate presence, teaching, and miraculous distributions (Hebrews 2:4). Scripture gives us clear examples like King Saul (1 Samuel 10:10) and Balaam (Numbers 24:2) who genuinely shared in the Spirit's power and prophecy without ever possessing saving faith. Being a companion in the Spirit's work and presence in the congregation is not the same thing as indwelling regeneration.

Second, look closely at your final question about point #7. You asked if the unsaved "can be renewed to a faith they never had." However, Hebrews 6:6 does not say "renew them again to faith" or "renew them again to salvation." It says "renew them again to repentance." This is importing words that are not in the text.

Just five verses earlier in Hebrews 6:1, the author defines "repentance from dead works" as the elementary starting threshold of turning away from old religious works toward the gospel. An enlightened hearer can turn from dead works, taste the goodness of God's word, and share in the Spirit's convicting presence in the church (verses 4 and 5) without yet reaching rooted saving faith. If they then reject Christ and crucify Him afresh (verse 6), they cannot be brought back to that starting point of repentance again.

The bible is clear that one is saved or not saved. There is not almost saved as you seem to think. What we see in Mar 4:5-8 is speaking of people that have been saved but as we see the 2nd and 3rd type will fall away from their faith. That is not what we see in Heb 3 and 6.
Again, let me clarify your mischaracterization of my position. I agree completely that a person is either saved or not saved, and I have never claimed there is an "almost saved" category. My point is simply that an unsaved person can experience real gospel illumination, conviction, and shallow, temporary assent without yet crossing into saving faith.

That is precisely why John 2:23-25 is so important, which your reply skipped over, btw. In John 2:23, many "believed in His name" when they saw His signs, yet Jesus refused to entrust Himself to them. Those people were not saved and then lost, nor were they "almost saved"; they were unsaved people whose shallow, sign-based assent fell short of true saving faith.

I called your view a "stepped view of salvation." as that is what you have presented. You claim that babes in the faith are not really saved but have to wait until they are mature to receive the promise.

You have mistaken the shallow, temporary assent as not being saving faith but the bible disagree with you. You said you agree with Rom 10:9 & Act 16:30-31 but nothing in those verses say that those believers cannot or will not fall away as soils 2 & 3 did in Mar 4:5-7.

Genuine, heart-level saving faith is the faith we see God respond to Eph 2:5 “...even when we were dead in our trespasses. It is by grace you have been saved!” and Eph 2:8 “For it is by grace you have been saved through faith,” It does not say your almost saved and we will wait until you mature to actually save you does it.
You are still arguing against a straw man of my position. You appear to be reading your theology into "babe" instead of letting the Hebrew text define what "babe" is. I have never said that a regenerated believer has to reach theological maturity before God justifies them. My point is that in Hebrews 5:11-6:12, the word "babe" is not describing a regenerated believer who already possesses salvation (that is your position); it is describing a hearer who is stalled in elementary exposure, dull of hearing, and standing outside the promised rest, the exact promised rest the text is telling the babes to move toward (just like Israel stood outside Canaan in Hebrews 3:19).

I have not bypassed any of Hebrews but I have not read into it what is not there either. The warning of Heb 3:12 and 19 is that those that do not believe will not enter God’s rest, will be saved. And in contrast we see that Heb 6:9 is pointing to the better things that come through salvation.
It would appear that you may now be contradicting yourself from earlier emails. You didn't write much here, so let me inquire.... You just said in the quote above that Hebrews 3:12 and 19 (you connected them to Heb 6:4-6 earlier) is a warning that if these Babes do "NOT ENTER GOD'S REST".... they "WILL BE SAVED".

You wrote in another post...
6] then have fallen away
You cannot fall away from a position that you do not hold. They have rejected the only means of their salvation.
7] they cannot be restored to repentance"
If the Babes do not reach the "promise" are they saved or not?

Further, you then wrote...
And in contrast we see that Heb 6:9 is pointing to the better things that come through salvation.
You have again brought in words that are not in the text (which we have seen a couple of times now). No translation, that I know of, says "come through salvation". The text says "things that accompany salvation" (NKJV) OR "things that belong to salvation" (ESV, NASB).

Even using your own phrasing (that is not in the text), your summary actually confirms my point. If the five experiences in Hebrews 6:4 and 6:5 already equaled being saved, then verses 4 and 5 would already describe the things that belong to or come through salvation.

Why would the author contrast verses 4 through 8 with "better things, things that belong to salvation" in verse 9 if the people in verses 4 and 5 were already saved? That contrast only makes sense because the initial enlightenment and tasting of verses 4 and 5 fall short of salvation itself, whereas verses 10 through 12 immediately define those "better things" as the enduring faith, love, and patience that actually inherit the promise.


Keep seeking God's truth as if it were hidden treasure
 

Silverhair

Well-Known Member
1) We it seems likely one of us has it reversed.
Yes I agree and from what we see in scripture that would be you .:)

All are called/invited by God’s various means [Rom 1:20 “His eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly seen”] but not all will receive the gift of salvation. [Rom 5:15 “the grace of God and the gift by the grace of the one Man, Jesus Christ”]

2) God has invited many through various means, including the gospel, and this is indeed a "heavenly" invitation.
Then we are in agreement on this Van.

3) Hebrews 3:1 NASB: Therefore, holy brothers and sisters, partakers of a heavenly calling, consider the Apostle and High Priest of our confession: Jesus;
Brothers are being addressed, who share the high Priest of Jesus, so born anew believers are in view, not invitees.
We see from the text that those that responded to the invitation, the heavenly calling, are now saved.

4) In Hebrews 6:4 we see people, not designated brothers, have tasted the heavenly gift. Note, not partakers of the heavenly gift, rather they only tasted it, but the people have been made partakers of the Holy Spirit. So we can certainly say they are partakers of the invitation, the gospel good news, the work product of the Holy Spirit.
The word tasted G1089 in Heb 6:4-5 Metaphorically, to experience, prove, partake of. With the acc. (Heb_6:5). With a gen. following, to taste of death, that is, to die (Mat_16:28; Mar_9:1; Luk_9:27; Joh_8:52; Heb_2:9). When used in this connection, it gives prominence to what is really involved in dying. In Heb_6:4, "who have tasted of the heavenly gift." It is not wise to press the distinction between the use of the gen. and acc. with this word as is often done where they occur in Heb_6:4-5.

5) Yes, the main meaning of the word translated "called" in 1 Cor 1:9 and 1 Peter 2:9 is "invited" but the word is used in scripture for two other meanings, to be designated or named, and to pass from one state (unsaved in Adam) to another state (saved in Christ).
And both of those verses can be read either way depending on what you are trying to convey to your listeners.
 

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Yes I agree and from what we see in scripture that would be you .:)

All are called/invited by God’s various means [Rom 1:20 “His eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly seen”] but not all will receive the gift of salvation. [Rom 5:15 “the grace of God and the gift by the grace of the one Man, Jesus Christ”]


Then we are in agreement on this Van.


We see from the text that those that responded to the invitation, the heavenly calling, are now saved.


The word tasted G1089 in Heb 6:4-5 Metaphorically, to experience, prove, partake of. With the acc. (Heb_6:5). With a gen. following, to taste of death, that is, to die (Mat_16:28; Mar_9:1; Luk_9:27; Joh_8:52; Heb_2:9). When used in this connection, it gives prominence to what is really involved in dying. In Heb_6:4, "who have tasted of the heavenly gift." It is not wise to press the distinction between the use of the gen. and acc. with this word as is often done where they occur in Heb_6:4-5.


And both of those verses can be read either way depending on what you are trying to convey to your listeners.
1) Romans 1:20 does not say nor suggest every human is invited with the gospel. Scripture does say many are invited but few are chosen.

2) Romans 5:15 does say the gift of grace from Christ "overflows" to the many, which I understand to mean the opportunity and means of salvation is offered to all who hear and understand the good news of the gospel.

3) We might agree, the heavenly calling applies only to those now saved, and not to all the unchosen invitees. I this is actually your position, I would be very surprised.

4) I was not intending to press a difference in grammatical form, but in the difference between tasted and partaken. I believe tasted refers to an initial experience, to try something to evaluate it. To have partaken refers to something embraced and accepted.

5) I disagree, only my view could possibly be right. :) On a more serious note, my view is they had tasted the heavenly gift, the opportunity for salvation, becoming partakers in the good news provided by the Holy Spirit.
 
Last edited:

Silverhair

Well-Known Member
n the New Testament, metochos means being a companion or participant alongside others (such as Luke 5:7 for fishing partners). Anyone who joined the Christian assembly, in the early church, became a direct participant in the Spirit's corporate presence, teaching, and miraculous distributions (Hebrews 2:4). Scripture gives us clear examples like King Saul (1 Samuel 10:10) and Balaam (Numbers 24:2) who genuinely shared in the Spirit's power and prophecy without ever possessing saving faith. Being a companion in the Spirit's work and presence in the congregation is not the same thing as indwelling regeneration.
I am surprised that you would reach back to the OT in support of your view. We know that the Holy Spirit never indwelt anyone in OT times as He only does that for believers.

Joh 14:17 “the Spirit of truth...for He abides with you and will be in you”

1Co 6:19 “...your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit who is in you…received from God”

1Jn 3:24 “...by this we know that He [God] remains in us: by the Spirit He has given us.”

Jas 4:5 “...the Spirit He caused to dwell in us…”

So we see the Holy Spirit does indwell those that are saved.

Second, look closely at your final question about point #7. You asked if the unsaved "can be renewed to a faith they never had." However, Hebrews 6:6 does not say "renew them again to faith" or "renew them again to salvation." It says "renew them again to repentance." This is importing words that are not in the text.
Since faith and repentance are two sides of the same coin, you will not have one without the other, it would seem you are picking at straws. If the unbeliever has never “repented” has never trusted in Christ Jesus how do you renew them to the repentance they never had?

Just five verses earlier in Hebrews 6:1, the author defines "repentance from dead works" as the elementary starting threshold of turning away from old religious works toward the gospel. An enlightened hearer can turn from dead works, taste the goodness of God's word, and share in the Spirit's convicting presence in the church (verses 4 and 5) without yet reaching rooted saving faith. If they then reject Christ and crucify Him afresh (verse 6), they cannot be brought back to that starting point of repentance again.
Read what Heb 6:1 says. They have already received the elementary teachings about Christ. They were being told not to revisit the foundation of repentance from dead works, and of faith in God or instruction about baptisms, the laying on of hands, the resurrection of the dead, and eternal judgment as they had already been taught these things but rather to seek to grow to mature in their faith.

An unbeliever may well be enlightened by the gospel message, be made aware of the consequences of their sinful life, and my try to turn from their dead works and may enjoy and receive comfort from a good message but they will not share in the Holy Spirit they have not tasted of the heavenly gift, salvation. They have not repented and trusted in God for their salvation. Thus the unbeliever who has not repented or trusted in Christ cannot fall away/turn away from something he has never done.

All unbelievers and believers share in the conviction of their sins but only believers actually share in the Spirit.

Again, let me clarify your mischaracterization of my position. I agree completely that a person is either saved or not saved, and I have never claimed there is an "almost saved" category. My point is simply that an unsaved person can experience real gospel illumination, conviction, and shallow, temporary assent without yet crossing into saving faith.
I agree that the unsaved can and do experience those things but the words “who have shared in the Holy Spirit” precludes your idea that Heb 6:4-6 is speaking of unbelievers.

As to the “mischaracterization” of your position. This is why I said you seem to have the babe’s almost saved but not quite yet.

Quoting you from post #36

“2. These “Babes” were once enlightened (v4) and it is behind them (in time).

The text says nothing about "enlightened" meaning salvation, this would be an inference. In fact, it most certainly doesn’t mean salvation (imo).

3. The author gives a warning against “falling away” (v6) that is relevant to those in which he is speaking.
Again, talking to the babes in which he is specifically speaking (not the mature in Christ). ”

That is precisely why John 2:23-25 is so important, which your reply skipped over, btw. In John 2:23, many "believed in His name" when they saw His signs, yet Jesus refused to entrust Himself to them. Those people were not saved and then lost, nor were they "almost saved"; they were unsaved people whose shallow, sign-based assent fell short of true saving faith.
Did not skip it as I did not see the need to reply to it as it is self evident that these were not believers. Just as those that followed Him because He provided bread for them to eat. Joh 6:26

You are still arguing against a straw man of my position. You appear to be reading your theology into "babe" instead of letting the Hebrew text define what "babe" is. I have never said that a regenerated believer has to reach theological maturity before God justifies them. My point is that in Hebrews 5:11-6:12, the word "babe" is not describing a regenerated believer who already possesses salvation (that is your position); it is describing a hearer who is stalled in elementary exposure, dull of hearing, and standing outside the promised rest, the exact promised rest the text is telling the babes to move toward (just like Israel stood outside Canaan in Hebrews 3:19).
I have used the Hebrew text to define what “babe” means:

Heb 5:13 For everyone who partakes only of milk is unskilled in the word of righteousness, for he is a babe. NKJV

Heb 5:13 For everyone who partakes only of milk is not accustomed to the word of righteousness, for he is an infant. NASB
G3516 metaphorically, childish, untaught, unskilled opposed to the more advanced in understanding and knowledge Thayer's Unabridged Greek

These are the babes that have been saved and may have been growing in their faith but have now become dull of hearing. Due to trials/persecutions they have drawn back. As we see in Heb 5:10-6-20 the author is urging them to remember what they have trusted in and not turn back.

It would appear that you may now be contradicting yourself from earlier emails. You didn't write much here, so let me inquire.... You just said in the quote above that Hebrews 3:12 and 19 (you connected them to Heb 6:4-6 earlier) is a warning that if these Babes do "NOT ENTER GOD'S REST".... they "WILL BE SAVED".
Should have read "NOT ENTER GOD'S REST".... they "WILL NOT BE SAVED" My bad.

If the Babes do not reach the "promise" are they saved or not?
Whether babes or mature if they later reject salvation, the promise, then they will not be saved.

You have again brought in words that are not in the text (which we have seen a couple of times now). No translation, that I know of, says "come through salvation". The text says "things that accompany salvation" (NKJV) OR "things that belong to salvation" (ESV, NASB).
So you have a problem with the word “through”. Really that is the best argument you can make?

Whether it is “accompany salvation” or “belong to salvation” it is still only through salvation.

Even using your own phrasing (that is not in the text), your summary actually confirms my point. If the five experiences in Hebrews 6:4 and 6:5 already equaled being saved, then verses 4 and 5 would already describe the things that belong to or come through salvation.
I agree as that is what they do confirm. The person, including the babe/infant of Heb 5:13, having met those conditions as laid out in vs 4 & 5 are indeed saved. That is why the warning in vs 6 “and then have fallen away, it is impossible to renew them again to repentance, since they again crucify to themselves the Son of God and put Him to open shame.”

Why would the author contrast verses 4 through 8 with "better things, things that belong to salvation" in verse 9 if the people in verses 4 and 5 were already saved? That contrast only makes sense because the initial enlightenment and tasting of verses 4 and 5 fall short of salvation itself, whereas verses 10 through 12 immediately define those "better things" as the enduring faith, love, and patience that actually inherit the promise.
Because they are the same people seen in Heb 5:11 that “have become dull of hearing.” Would you not do all you could do to dissuade people from turning away from the salvation they now have?
 

Silverhair

Well-Known Member
1) Romans 1:20 does not say nor suggest every human is invited with the gospel. Scripture does say many are invited but few are chosen.
But Rom 1:20 does say that all can know Him and are held responsible for what they do with that knowledge. Remember no one heard the gospel before Christ was risen. They heard about God and trusted in the creator.

2) Romans 5:15 does say the gift of grace from Christ "overflows" to the many, which I understand to mean the opportunity and means of salvation is offered to all who hear and understand the good news of the gospel.
As I understand it the gift of salvation comes through Christ in the OT and the NT. All can be saved by trusting in the creator who is Christ Jesus. Joh 1:3 As He said here Joh_14:6 Jesus *said to him, "I am the way, and the truth, and the life; no one comes to the Father but through Me.

3) We might agree, the heavenly calling applies only to those now saved, and not to all the unchosen invitees. I this is actually your position, I would be very surprised.
That the heavenly calling applies only to those now saved, and not to all the unchosen is a Calvinist misunderstanding of scripture.
The invitation to salvation is made to all but actual salvation is personal.

4) I was not intending to press a difference in grammatical form, but in the difference between tasted and partaken. I believe tasted refers to an initial experience, to try something to evaluate it. To have partaken refers to something embraced and accepted.
Now I could say what about the disciples that would not taste death until they see the Son of Man coming in His kingdom. But that would be ignoring context and we should not do that.

We see in Heb 6:4 that they had tasted/experienced the heavenly gift/salvation through sharing in/being indwelt by the Holy Spirit.

So I agree tasted refers to an initial experience, & partaken refers to something embraced and accepted. I am just more wordy in my comments.

5) I disagree, only my view could possibly be right. :) On a more serious note, my view is they had tasted the heavenly gift, the opportunity for salvation, becoming partakers in the good news provided by the Holy Spirit.
I agree with much of what you said Van, it is just that first sentence that needs correction.:p
 

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
Ben, we cannot be fruit inspectors. Also, untaught people reading James assume that salvation is by faith plus works. That is why we cannot consider James, Hebrew etal as doctrine. They were not written to or for us.
So you defend the KJV but don’t think that two of the books in it are for you? I see.
 

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
Ben, we cannot be fruit inspectors. Also, untaught people reading James assume that salvation is by faith plus works. That is why we cannot consider James, Hebrew etal as doctrine. They were not written to or for us.
That also doesn’t answer the question. I didn’t ask if we could be fruit inspectors.
I asked if we could have living faith without works because you think those books don’t mean anything doctrinally to us.

It’s a yes or no question. Don’t sidestep it.

And untaught/ unstudied people might read any book of the Bible incorrectly. The Mormons have been doing it with the KJV since they started. They have only recently branched out into other versions.

So no one should use the Bible for doctrine because they might misunderstand what was meant?? And let me guess, you are the pope?
 

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
We see in Heb 6:4 that they had tasted/experienced the heavenly gift/salvation through sharing in/being indwelt by the Holy Spirit.
I did not see any reason to address the rest of your post, as it did not seem to address mine.

You are reading salvation into the text, where it makes no sense. You do not taste salvation, you either are saved, or you are not saved. Thus you redefine the meaning of tasted to mean embraced. Not what the word means.
 

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
2 Timothy 3:16
All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness:


That means the Old Testament, it also means Hebrews and James.
 

David Lamb

Well-Known Member
2 Timothy 3:16
All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness:


That means the Old Testament, it also means Hebrews and James.
I agree. Once we start saying that we can/should ignore certain books in Scripture because they were not addressed to us, we end up with a truncated Bible, particularly as far as the New Testament is concerned. Luke and Acts were addressed to Theophilus. All the epistles were addressed to local churches or individual Christians of the first century. So were the seven letters in Revelation.
 

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Does Romans 1:20 say everyone can "know" God? Or does it say everyone should know about God from what He has made, so everyone is without excuse. Those that do not know about God when they die might be aborted babies, or mentally challenged individuals, so "should" rather than can better captures the truth of Romans 1:20 in my opinion.
 

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Matthew 16:28 NASB
“Truly I say to you, there are some of those who are standing here who will not taste death until they see the Son of Man coming in His kingdom.”

This or similar verses were said to indicate the Greek word translated "taste" means to fully experience death. But let's take a closer look. Let's consider "may not taste {encounter} their personal death" which translates the subjunctive mood and the middle voice
 

Silverhair

Well-Known Member
I did not see any reason to address the rest of your post, as it did not seem to address mine.

You are reading salvation into the text, where it makes no sense. You do not taste salvation, you either are saved, or you are not saved. Thus you redefine the meaning of tasted to mean embraced. Not what the word means.

I answered them point for point Van you must have missed that?

I do not have to read salvation into the text as it is right there in the text.

You disagree with these words:
"We see in Heb 6:4 that they had tasted/experienced the heavenly gift/salvation through sharing in/being indwelt by the Holy Spirit." but you do not give an alternative understanding.

The point you seem to be missing is that they were saved [have become G1096 (G5679) partakers G3353 of the Holy G40 Spirit G4151] NOTE it does not say might become partakers.
Then they were warned of the danger of falling away/returning to the religion they had before.
 

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I answered them point for point Van you must have missed that?

I do not have to read salvation into the text as it is right there in the text.

You disagree with these words:
"We see in Heb 6:4 that they had tasted/experienced the heavenly gift/salvation through sharing in/being indwelt by the Holy Spirit." but you do not give an alternative understanding.

The point you seem to be missing is that they were saved [have become G1096 (G5679) partakers G3353 of the Holy G40 Spirit G4151] NOTE it does not say might become partakers.
Then they were warned of the danger of falling away/returning to the religion they had before.
I think we have reached an impasse. Certainly someone convicted of sin by the Holy Spirit has become a partaker in the Holy Spirit, but not indwelt.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kai

Silverhair

Well-Known Member
Does Romans 1:20 say everyone can "know" God? Or does it say everyone should know about God from what He has made, so everyone is without excuse. Those that do not know about God when they die might be aborted babies, or mentally challenged individuals, so "should" rather than can better captures the truth of Romans 1:20 in my opinion.

Now you are reading your own desired understanding into the text. You are also over thinking the text.

Reading Rom 1:20 in it's context would clear up your concerns.

Rom 1:18-23 is obviously written to those that can and do made free choices.

The Holy Spirit was correct when He inspired Paul to write those words.

"For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal power and Godhead, so that they are without excuse, because, although they knew God, they did not glorify Him as God, nor were thankful,..."
 

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
When I was in elementary school, I tried out our newly built cafeteria, and took a bite of "boiled green stuff." It was awful, and I ran outside and spit it out. To claim tasted means to fully embrace something is rewriting the word meaning.
 
Top